Do you count tea and coffee as part of your water intake?
cocates
Posts: 360 Member
I have never counted (or considered) it part of my water intake. I read a post that suggested you could count it.
Please let me know why or why you don't count it. And yes, I've read the links on the myth of tea and coffee dehydrating and therefore shouldn't be counted.
Please let me know why or why you don't count it. And yes, I've read the links on the myth of tea and coffee dehydrating and therefore shouldn't be counted.
0
Replies
-
I didn't know there was any myth. If you think its dehydrating, then you wouldn't count it. If you think its not, then you would count it.
Personally i don't bother counting how much i drink. You've already got enough to worry about. Just drink enough to ensure that your pee is pale yellow. If its pure clear, then you are overdrinking and if its dark then you are dehydated. Its almost that simple.
0 -
I count it but aim for at least 64 oz of fluids above and beyond my coffee.0
-
Why are you tracking your water? Will counting coffee/tea change your water count a lot? Like, 5-10 cups of tea/coffee? If so, you might want to reevaluate how much tea/coffee you drink.
I think it's a slippery slope. Would you count brothy soups? Watery fruits?
Drink ample water. If you feel dehydrated, drink more. Done.
0 -
I started logging my water recently, as well as focusing on hydrating more. I do log coffee, but only decaf. I also add flavoring to my water because a practical nurse friend of mine said there's no problem with that. I actually even count frozen fruit bars as a half cup.
The research shows that liquid is liquid. I do find that checking that my urine is very light is helpful to seeing if I'm getting enough fluid.0 -
Count it - and as Patttience said keep an eye on wee colour. Don't forget to track milk etc too!0
-
I don't ever count coffee towards water intake. Whether you're drinking coffee/tea or not doesn't change the fact that you need to be drinking enough straight-up water. However, make sure to log any milk you're adding; it's so many carbs!0
-
Of course! Even jellies and broth. My elderly neighbour told me when they used to be thirsty they would have a cup of tea; to drink just plain water was not a common thing. Tea has minerals in it; it makes sense. They were all thin back then mostly, I think more active with life.
0 -
I take my weight and divide by 2 (260 pounds/2 =130) 130oz of water I must consume in a 24 hour time frame. I do count Green Tea, but not my 1 coffee a day. And as strange as it sounds i monitor the color of my urine to make sure I am not dehydrated.0
-
I count water as water. Everything else is something else, for me. If I were going to add in anything else as water, it would be tea and coffee. But that would be it. I log juice, milk, soups and other foods in the calories section.
I think the point of counting water is to encourage people to drink water, not just take in any fluid.
Some people count milk, juice, pop, soup, tomatoes, lettuce and even apples or carrots as water. If that works for them, it's great.
It's really a personal decision. It is your diary and you get to make the rules!0 -
I like to log coffee and tea as snacks (especially if I add anything to them), and I track plain water.0
-
Food has water in it and most beverages are primarily water. These all contribute to your overall hydration. The arguments that caffeinated beverages are a diuretic is kind of silly as water itself is a diuretic, meaning it causes an increased passing of urine.
I just try to shoot for a few Nalgene bottles of water each day and while I don't log any non-caloric beverage, I do count my tea and my water towards my overall hydration when I think of trying to get adequate fluids. If you're active, probably drink a little more and if you're fairly sedentary, you can probably get by with a little less.0 -
I wouldnt count tea and coffee. Water is water . coffees will dehydrate you with all the caffeine.0
-
The only reason you should be too focused on exactly how much water you're consuming is if you think you're retaining water (water weight). Is this an issue with you?0
-
Yes... I do count tea and coffee. The dehydrating effect of caffeine is negligible (according to multiple peer-reviewed scientific studies) . I see no reason to force myself to drink extra water just so I can formally tally 64 ounces of plain water in my daily food diary. I like to be properly hydrated, but I'm not going to drink so much water that I have to pee every 90 minutes. That's just silly and doesn't provide any health benefits. In fact, when I used to force myself to drink 8-10 cups of water on top my other beverages, it gave me heartburn. The gastroenterologist told me to lay off the extra water and just drink when I was thirsty. Turned out, all the extra liquid was making my stomach contents too voluminous.
Some folks feel differently - I suppose it just boils down to a personal preference. :-)0 -
I don't track my water intake - but if I did of course I would count coffee and tea - I mean it is just water with flavor. Flavor doesn't make it not be water any more.0
-
I count water as water. Anything else I drink has calories so I count them in my food intake. If you want to count your tea/coffee with your water intake, go for it, but remember to log any caloric additions like milk, cream, sugar, etc.. Do whatever you want with your diary and water glass as long as it makes sense to you.0
-
I also take notice of my urine color to help me determine if I need more water. But I do not log water. I don't log diet soda (no calories and I no longer look at sodium), and I don't log usually coffee (too few calories to make a difference in the big picture unless I'm drinking a lot, like on road trips when I'm trying to maximize time and thus driving at night while doing/seeing stuff during the day).
A few weeks ago, I was out hunting/camping in the forest. I put my pack down in the wrong way at camp and the bite valve broke and started releasing water. I didn't notice until several minutes later when most of the water was already gone. It was a mostly full 3L reservoir and that was a problem since there wasn't a good water source without hiking close to 15 miles and it was getting dark out. So I woke up the next morning thirsty. My brother was with me and shared some of his water, but we decided to take a break mid to late morning and drive back to town. I only urinated once that morning and it was very dark yellow - not a good sign. I was parked 4 miles away, and hiked past my vehicle to a different part of the woods and then back before driving into town around lunch time to get some liquid.0 -
People are too obsessed with this water thing.
Drink enough fluids (of any kind) that your pee is a yellow to light straw color. If you feel thirsty, drink. It's that easy. People have been properly hydrating themselves for centuries without formulas and measuring cups.
If your pee is clear, you are drinking more than you really need and your body is just discharging it straight out again. It is possible to drink too much water, so take care.
If your pee is dark yellow, drink more.
If it's brown, you are severely dehydrated or may have liver disease. Drink more and if it doesn't resolve in a few hours, call a doctor.
If it's red or green, seek medical attention.
If it's blue or purple, you may be an alien.
From the Cleveland Clinic - http://health.clevelandclinic.org/2013/10/what-the-color-of-your-urine-says-about-you-infographic/0 -
I wouldnt count tea and coffee. Water is water . coffees will dehydrate you with all the caffeine.
This has been thoroughly debunked many times. Yes, caffeine has a diuretic effect, but it's far outweighed by the hydrating effect of drinking 8 to 12 ounces of water with it.
You could survive perfectly well drinking nothing but coffee, though as with any extreme diet there would be ill effects other than dehydration.0 -
If coffee dehydrated you more than it hydrated, I'd be dead by now.
I don't track water, but I would count coffee/tea if I did.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.7K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.8K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 415 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.6K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions