Does drinking fizzy drinks make the tummy/stomach fatter?
jjasmelon
Posts: 101
OK, not sure if this is silly. But, a family member told me from a young age not to drink lots of fizzy drinks as it will make me have a big tummy permanently.
I don't drink it all the time but do like a diet coke from time to time... So will it cause me to gain tummy fat or not or just a myth?
I don't drink it all the time but do like a diet coke from time to time... So will it cause me to gain tummy fat or not or just a myth?
0
Replies
-
Sounds like one of those things parents tell kids to scare them into building good habits. Like don't swallow watermelon seeds, or a watermelon will grow in your belly.0
-
No, eating and drinking too many calories does.0
-
StaciMarie1974 wrote: »Sounds like one of those things parents tell kids to scare them into building good habits. Like don't swallow watermelon seeds, or a watermelon will grow in your belly.
Like swimming after eating lunch
0 -
They make me burp.0
-
Only if you had gastric bypass or something. Apparently the carbonation can expand a tummy made smaller by surgery.
I drink seltzer like everyday and have no issues0 -
I believe it's just the gasses from the fizzy drinks themselves that can cause a TEMPORARY bloating appearance, or feeling, for a short time after drinking them. Obviously, if you drink sugary fizzy drinks every day and don't account for their calories, you can become heavier. I say if you enjoy a fizzy drink from time to time, and it fits within your calorie count for the day, why not? Life's too short to deprive ourselves. This site is a wonderful tool to help us learn how to eat and be healthier. I find that for me, no food is off limits, and it's everything in moderation. Otherwise, that forbidden thing simply calls my name and calls it until I overindulge. :-)
That was a good question, by the way!0 -
This content has been removed.
-
StaciMarie1974 wrote: »Sounds like one of those things parents tell kids to scare them into building good habits. Like don't swallow watermelon seeds, or a watermelon will grow in your belly.
It's not true??? GASP
laughsssss (couldn't resist). OP NO, eating too many calories makes our tummies bigger.0 -
Actually it is true - all of the carbonation makes you bloat with gas.0
-
Similarly, a "beer belly" isn't caused by beer, it's caused by too many calories. Personally I'm not a huge beer fan, but I have a wine belly and a cookie belly and a pie belly.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Oh ccool! thanks
0 -
The fructose in HFCS (sweetener used in pop) can be put directly into fat by the liver. The fructose in pop has been shown to increase visceral fat - fat around your organs, leading to that rounded apple-shape - the inflammed liver look.
http://w.banpac.org/pdfs/sfs/2012/ssg_maersk.pdf
Subjects drinking 1 liter cola a day had more visceral fat develop than those drinking 1 liter of another beverage.
Liver fat and visceral fat (the types encouraged by soda) increase the risk of diabetes (type II), metabolic syndrome, sleep apnea, and vascular disease (heart attacks). In women, the risk of breast cancer and the need for gallbladder surgery increases as well.
Eating in a deficit, exercising, and eating whole grains, fruits and vegetables, and dairy reduces visceral fat.0 -
Interesting, i guess i will keep it as a now and then thing.The fructose in HFCS (sweetener used in pop) can be put directly into fat by the liver. The fructose in pop has been shown to increase visceral fat - fat around your organs, leading to that rounded apple-shape - the inflammed liver look.
http://w.banpac.org/pdfs/sfs/2012/ssg_maersk.pdf
Subjects drinking 1 liter cola a day had more visceral fat develop than those drinking 1 liter of another beverage.
Liver fat and visceral fat (the types encouraged by soda) increase the risk of diabetes (type II), metabolic syndrome, sleep apnea, and vascular disease (heart attacks). In women, the risk of breast cancer and the need for gallbladder surgery increases as well.
Eating in a deficit, exercising, and eating whole grains, fruits and vegetables, and dairy reduces visceral fat.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
...and be careful crossing your eyes or they will get stuck that way.
...and swallowed gum goes straight to your liver and stays there FOREVER.
...and sugar makes children hyper.
...and stepping on a crack brings dire consequences to your mother.0 -
enterdanger wrote: »Only if you had gastric bypass or something. Apparently the carbonation can expand a tummy made smaller by surgery.
I drink seltzer like everyday and have no issues
I heard that recently, I think on that 600 lb life show. The patient was cheating by having diet soda, and that caught my attention that diet soda would be "cheating", but I guess the carbonation expands the stomach temporarily so that greater quantities of food than the surgery is designed for can be eaten in one sitting.
0 -
No, heck. The diet soda expands the stomach to overfull and nothing else can be eaten. The danger is malnutrition, not over-eating.
Yes, the carbonation expands the stomach. No danger for a normal stomach that deflates and inflates like a football. Dangerous for a bariatric stomach.
But carbonation does not add to belly fat! The expansion is not permanent!0 -
That wasn't the explanation given on the show. The danger of carbonation was overeating, I think the patient either gained weight or didn't lose as expected - not from soda, but from overeating because of cheating with soda.No, heck. The diet soda expands the stomach to overfull and nothing else can be eaten. The danger is malnutrition, not over-eating.
I just heard this on a program about bypass patients, I guess it's possible the show is wrong.
0 -
Of course, I am talking about my own experience. There is a cheat where the patient eats a meal then washes it in to the bowel with any sort of liquid. I am sure soda would do that too. The patient can then eat the meal all over again.
Drinking soda would eventually stretch out the little tummy so it could take more food at a single sitting. The stomach will gradually stretch out anyways.
Which is why it was emphasized over and over to me that the surgery is a tool. The rest is up to me (you know, CICO).
0 -
Interesting, i guess i will keep it as a now and then thing.The fructose in HFCS (sweetener used in pop) can be put directly into fat by the liver. The fructose in pop has been shown to increase visceral fat - fat around your organs, leading to that rounded apple-shape - the inflammed liver look.
http://w.banpac.org/pdfs/sfs/2012/ssg_maersk.pdf
Subjects drinking 1 liter cola a day had more visceral fat develop than those drinking 1 liter of another beverage.
Liver fat and visceral fat (the types encouraged by soda) increase the risk of diabetes (type II), metabolic syndrome, sleep apnea, and vascular disease (heart attacks). In women, the risk of breast cancer and the need for gallbladder surgery increases as well.
Eating in a deficit, exercising, and eating whole grains, fruits and vegetables, and dairy reduces visceral fat.
Hey. You're asking about diet soda, yes?
There is no HFCS in diet soda. The paper is not relevant to your question.0 -
Interesting, i guess i will keep it as a now and then thing.The fructose in HFCS (sweetener used in pop) can be put directly into fat by the liver. The fructose in pop has been shown to increase visceral fat - fat around your organs, leading to that rounded apple-shape - the inflammed liver look.
http://w.banpac.org/pdfs/sfs/2012/ssg_maersk.pdf
Subjects drinking 1 liter cola a day had more visceral fat develop than those drinking 1 liter of another beverage.
Liver fat and visceral fat (the types encouraged by soda) increase the risk of diabetes (type II), metabolic syndrome, sleep apnea, and vascular disease (heart attacks). In women, the risk of breast cancer and the need for gallbladder surgery increases as well.
Eating in a deficit, exercising, and eating whole grains, fruits and vegetables, and dairy reduces visceral fat.
Hey. You're asking about diet soda, yes?
There is no HFCS in diet soda. The paper is not relevant to your question.
Sorry - missed the diet part.0 -
Oh please, not another soda is ebil thread.0
-
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Scares me0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions