Willpower Struggles

mcpchants
mcpchants Posts: 2 Member
edited November 13 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi All,
I'm sure i'm like many of you...Have been struggling for years to lose weight. For me, it all started when I turned 30.
I've gained about 20 lbs over the years and would love to go back to what I used to think was "fat".
My biggest problem these days is willpower and motivation. "They" all say that if you want it enough, you'll be able to achieve it. That's not my case, unfortunately. I am having a very difficult time to think positive. I am constantly thinking of food and what to eat next. How does everyone else do it?
The biggest struggle is at night...I always want more. How do I stop that constant 'want'?!
I try chewing gum or keeping myself occupied which works sometimes. But more often than not, I still want those chips or whatever else after.
I know what some say - I just have to get over it. But it would help to know how you're getting over it.
Looking forward to hearing from you!

Replies

  • sjp_511
    sjp_511 Posts: 476 Member
    For me, it is all about having routines and habits more than having willpower. Create a daily routine that has meal ands snacks scheduled. Pre-plan your meals and snacks to fit your nutrition goals. If there are certain times of day you mindlessly snack or binge, schedule something else instead. You say you graze a lot in the evening. Make that be the time of day you go to the gym or take a walk around the neighborhood.
  • girlviernes
    girlviernes Posts: 2,402 Member
    You may need to eat more during the day if you are struggling at night. Do you have a consistent and fairly hearty breakfast and lunch?

    You don't need motivation and willpower so much as you need to practice reminding yourself why you are doing this and talking back to unhelpful thinking. For example, when you think you can't do it that isn't helpful (self-fulfilling cycle), so remind yourself that you can make small changes over time and learn from slips.
  • mcpchants
    mcpchants Posts: 2 Member
    thanks guys!
    it's not that i'm not eating enough...it's all in my head.
    i'm keeping reminders around the house (quotes or images) to help me out :-)
  • jgnatca
    jgnatca Posts: 14,464 Member
    It might help to have a deep think about what you are really feeling when you want to eat more. Is it boredom? Routine? Persistent hunger pangs? The desire to sink your teeth in to something?

    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/jgnatca/view/halting-a-binge-session-715131

    With more insight in to why, you can figure out a strategy to overcome. I rarely eat in the evening now since I've substituted an old habit with a new one. Knitting, for instance. Keeps me occupied.
  • Liftng4Lis
    Liftng4Lis Posts: 15,151 Member
    Try pre-logging and include a few snacks. Helps tremendously.
  • Markguns
    Markguns Posts: 554 Member
    1. Out of sight out of mind.. Don't buy trigger foods. 2. Notes on the Fridge are good if they help you. 3. I Drink green tea, eat protein, apples. 4. Why do you want to lose weight and get in shape.... you need to focus on your motivation, what really is it. Are you doing it to please yourself or someone else? 5. Challenge yourself, set achievable goals and then celebrate them.
  • shreddedtrooper
    shreddedtrooper Posts: 107 Member
    edited February 2015
    Plan ahead etc, great advice.

    Diary is not able to be viewed but you state eating "enough"

    Some usual responses: nutritional foods first, stay within nutrional requirements and guidelines.

    I have yet to come across someone that says the volume/quantity of food is too sparse when accuractely Macro tracking.

    OP stated in her head as she is getting enough food, above provided if after review OP feels that it may actually be diet/intake. Just a consideration is all.

    Satiety.
    If one hypothetically can adjust to include all requirements in addition to guidelines, there is usually often room to fit in that cheeky snack etc which avoids the binging and constant "willpower" #thestruggleisreal
    But in my opinion, if accurately intaking then willpower simply becomes a word that has no power to sway my macros nor my choices.

    I will leave it with this famous words of Nick Cheadle.
    "Guessing as to how much protein, carbohydrates & dietary fat you're consuming means you'll ultimately be guessing as to how your results will turn out"

    Best of luck and hopefully its just "in your head" as you put it and it goes away, if not, consider some partial 2 cents :)
  • 2snakeswoman
    2snakeswoman Posts: 655 Member
    What really jolted me was getting my first high blood pressure reading. Suddenly it solidified in my mind that obesity isn't just a vanity issue, it's a health issue. I'm 61 and already have the feeling that my time is running out. I don't want that sand passing through the hourglass any faster than it has to.

    I've only been back at this for a week, and so far it hasn't been hard. I started out with 1700 calories plus whatever workout calories I earned. Now I'm at 1450 calories plus any workout calories that I earn. After 3 days, I felt ready to cut back. I used the MFP calculator to set my goal at 1 pound per week.

    And I got rid of the scales. I'm not after a particular number. I want my size 18 pants to be too big and my 1X tops to look like sacks; then I will donate them. I want to learn how to eat appropriately instead of running to the kitchen for every little emotion, from anger (stuff it back with food!), boredom, a need to celebrate - you name it and I ate it.

    I know it's hard to let go of old habits. They wouldn't become habits if they didn't work on some level. I'm trying to replace them with good habits. I enjoy coloring, so I have a few intricate, adult coloring books and a variety of colored pencils and markers. I get away from the kitchen and go do that, or sew, or take the dog for a walk if it's nice out, or do homework (I'm back in school learning a new career - medical assisting).
  • Out_of_Bubblegum
    Out_of_Bubblegum Posts: 2,220 Member
    There is nothing wrong with snacking if it fits in your calorie goals... if depriving yourself of a night snack is messing with your head, then there are somethings you can do to offset the effect it has on your weight loss:

    In the morning, Pre-log some snacks in the night to make sure they fit your daily goals... eat around those extra calories throughout the rest of the day.

    Get some low calorie snack to have handy (raw veggies as example are crunchy and can be very satisfying) for when you feel the need to munch.

    Portion out exactly a certain amount of your go-to snack food ahead of time. When the urge comes, grab that pre-portioned amount, and enjoy it slowly... When it's gone, don't go back for more.


  • kyta32
    kyta32 Posts: 670 Member
    I find getting enough fiber (27+ g/day) and protein, and some high intensity exercise daily helps with hunger pangs/cravings. You may benefit by eating more than what MFP recommends for protein, .8g/kg of bodyweight or 1 g/lb of lean body mass.

    When you chose to give in to the hunger, advise yourself you can eat as much as you want, so long as it is non-starchy vegetables, and you will probably not end up with too many extra calories. I personally generally stop with about 2 celery stalks (20-30 calories, 2 grams fiber).

    The more I avoid added sugars, the fewer cravings I have. I try not to have a lot of trigger foods in the house, or buy trigger foods in single servings (i.e. when eating out).

    Having a glass of water, then exercising/doing chores/taking a walk, or talking to a friend (distraction) may help. Exercise can suppress hunger for me, at least while I'm exercising. Drinking enough water sometimes helps with cravings.

    Sometimes you just have to live with the hunger for a while. I get cravings the day after a family celebration, during my time of month, or anytime I fall off the wagon for a bit. If I stay strong, they go away after a few days.

    I know what works for me won't necessarily work for everyone. I hope some of these suggestions work for you. Good luck :)
  • ArkMom35
    ArkMom35 Posts: 225 Member
    I totally understand. Some days a good part of my day is comprised of thinking about what I can eat and when. You have to just do your best to stay strong and keep busy. You aren't alone!
  • lthames0810
    lthames0810 Posts: 722 Member
    It is all in our heads.

    I don't have to drop what I'm doing and get something to eat just because the idea popped into my head. I know I can delay eating until it's convenient if I'm doing something fun. I should be able to delay it at any other time as well (assuming I'm not actually starving myself.)

    I tried out a type of intermittent fasting where you only eat in an eight hour window and fast the other 16 hours. I was surprised at the effect it had on my snacking. Basically, I just don't eat outside of that 8 hours...the kitchen is closed. I seem to have gotten it into my head that the "magic" happens during the fast, so I don't dare break it frivolously. Sounds stupid, and probably is, but it's working.

    Last night I came really close to blowing it. I've been stuck for a few days (seriously, how can the scale show exactly the same weight three days in a row?) and I wanted to eat some of that banana bread my mom brought over, but I stopped myself. If I just keep eating the way I'm supposed to, the weight will come off. If I eat that treat tonight, it won't. Simple as that.
  • kecmw25
    kecmw25 Posts: 2,743 Member
    Try thinking of your willpower as a muscle, the more you work it, the stronger it gets. I have 2 "trigger" times that I always think about food even if I know I'm not hungry. When I 1st get home from work and when no one else is around (doesn't matter what time of the day that is) I have been working on the getting home from work thing (planning a snack, otherwise occupying myself) and I think it is getting easier. I still need to work on the other times tho
This discussion has been closed.