Only one pound in 32 days? This really blows!

krishildy
krishildy Posts: 23 Member
edited September 27 in Health and Weight Loss
I'm hoping some of you can give me some direction because I am starting to become frustrated and questioning myself and whether this is even worth the effort anymore.

While this is the first time in my life that I have become really serious about trying to become more fit, lose weight, and take better care of myself, I should say that I could never understand how people could change their habits for a few days to drop/gain a few pounds -- I have never been able to have that kind of control over my weight.

A little background info: I'm right at the obesity threshold. 185 pounds on a 5'6" frame, I'll be turning 40 in a month. Up until a month ago, I would eat anything I wanted, when I wanted to. I was 165 pounds in December of 2004, so I've been gaining an average of 4 pounds annually.

Ok, here goes. I started on MFP on April 10th, 32 days ago. I tried to count calories the best I could, and documented all of my exercises/times/calories burnt, etc. I do not have a heart rate monitor, but have been using numbers off the equipment I use at the gym or those online calorie burn calculators. I also signed up with a gym.

To keep my data simple and easy to follow, I averaged most of it out. Over the past 32 days, I went to the gym 22 days. On those 22 days, I burnt an average of 500 calories. I've been trying to eat back all my exercise calories. Over the 32 days, I averaged eating about 1640 calories total and my overage/underage averaged about 95 calories over. Since MFP has a deficit of 500 calories built in, I should still be losing some weight.

All that sweat work, all that watching what I'm eating (I am eating MUCH better than I used to, but I know I could still do even better), and I've only lost one pound. I actually lost three pounds at one point, but gained two back. No change in my measurements, either!!!! I do feel a little teeny bit more "toned," but you can't tell by looking at me, so it could all just be in my head. I am exhausted most of the days that I go to the gym.

I do not have any thyroid issues or anything else going on medically that I know of.

So..... What gives? All this work over 32 days for one lousy pound?????

Replies

  • stargazgal
    stargazgal Posts: 93 Member
    My only advice would be to only eat half of those calories back...so MFP probably gave you abotu 1200 to lose 2 lbs right? Now, stick to that 1200 cals on days you dont exercise and on days you do exercise try to eat between 1400 and 1550 (the gym machines def overestimate the calories burned). Also watch the sodium/sugar and fat intake! Hope this helps...
    ps...drink at least 10 cups of water!
    :)
  • waverly9876
    waverly9876 Posts: 605 Member
    Stick in there. It took me 3 WEEKS to lose a lb!!!!!!
  • lhurtubise
    lhurtubise Posts: 693 Member
    My only advice would be to only eat half of those calories back...so MFP probably gave you abotu 1200 to lose 2 lbs right? Now, stick to that 1200 cals on days you dont exercise and on days you do exercise try to eat between 1400 and 1550 (the gym machines def overestimate the calories burned). Also watch the sodium/sugar and fat intake! Hope this helps...
    ps...drink at least 10 cups of water!
    :)

    Totally agree! It is a great investment to get a HRM so you are not eating back too many calories. Good Luck!
  • MyaPapaya75
    MyaPapaya75 Posts: 3,143 Member
    hard to tell without seeing your diary but sodium is a big culprit and I too would suggest trying things like only eating half of your exercise calories back...but you have to stick with whatever you choose for at least 3 weeks before making more changes...also invest in a HRM..you could be over accounting your actual workout burn
  • kadye
    kadye Posts: 136 Member
    I thought I was only eating about 1600 calories/day until I got a food scale. It turned out I was closer to 2000. Once I started weighing EVERYTHING (in grams when possible) I started losing. It's so easy to underestimate intake and overestimate calories burned.
  • nickylj
    nickylj Posts: 3 Member
    I purchased a monitor to calculate my calories burned and I found that the workout programs I use always show more calories burned than my monitor does. I did 55 minutes of Zumba on my Wii and my monitor only showed 349 calories burned. I just go by that so I don't think I have more calories than I actually have. It is also useful to see how many I burned total for the day compared to food intake. Keep it up--you can do it!
  • xtinalovexo
    xtinalovexo Posts: 1,376 Member
    Stick in there. It took me 3 WEEKS to lose a lb!!!!!!

    like waverly, i also only lost about 1 or 2 lbs in an entire 2 weeks! some of us are slower to lose weight. i have been trying some different methods and i find that i was consuming WAY too much carbs and not enough fiber and protein! after i cut back of carbs, i have finally begun to lose more weight. maybe you should look closer at your food intake?

    eat more metabolism-boosting foods also.
  • muggle311
    muggle311 Posts: 14
    I would say get the heart rate monitor if you can. The machines WAY overestimate your calorie burn.
    My treadmill is off by at least 100+ calories when it says 205 I am close to burning 99 maybe 101 so that is how off they are.
    Calories does make a difference and the quality of your calories. However if you are eating back calories you did not burn well then that would make the pounds down a whole lot harder. It is nice to know and a HR monitor will tell you calories burned all day long if you leave it on. I have one and don't workout without it. Even my garmin has a chest strap.
    Keeps things more real.
    Stick to it though sometimes the scale does not show your progress.
  • eeeekie
    eeeekie Posts: 1,011 Member
    I think it would be beneficial if you opened your diary so we could get a reference.

    "I tried to count calories the best I could"

    Are you weighing/measuring everything?

    Are you going over your sodium? If you haven't added sodium to your diary you might want to turn it on and check it out.

    Are you eating ENOUGH calories? You said you're eating back some of your exercise calories...how many calories are you netting? (I know I have a hard time netting 1200 calories when I exercise and burn over 1000).

    Are you drinking enough water? How much?
  • ebert5150
    ebert5150 Posts: 135 Member
    Have you noticed any changes in your body? Maybe you're losing fat and gaining muscle weight. I've gone weeks without losing weight but have gone from a pair of pants not fitting to being able to wear them. I've decided to get away from purely weight loss related goals and focus more on fitness. I still follow the mfp calorie count but I also think about:

    1. Am I getting stronger?
    2. Have I increased my endurance in the run?
    3. Have I increased my mile speed?

    The answer to all those questions is yes and I bet you've noticed your fitness improving too despite not seeing your weight drop. Don't give up, it will come off eventually!
  • born2bskinny
    born2bskinny Posts: 8 Member
    You could try lean protiens for 2 or 3 days to kick start your diet. I started doing that on Monday and have lost 5lbs! Pure protien is definitely not good for you, but for a few days to eliminate the sugar and give yourself a kickstart isn't bad. Don't give up, you can do it!:happy:
  • phy40
    phy40 Posts: 260 Member
    Hang in there. I joined this site in March and I haven't lost a pound. I just keep trying.
  • serendipityrr
    serendipityrr Posts: 109 Member
    I thought I was only eating about 1600 calories/day until I got a food scale. It turned out I was closer to 2000. Once I started weighing EVERYTHING (in grams when possible) I started losing. It's so easy to underestimate intake and overestimate calories burned.


    This is absolutely true!!!
  • dawnkitchen
    dawnkitchen Posts: 161
    Heart rate monitor, food scale, and watch sodium (also make sure you're getting ENOUGH potassium).
    In the past four weeks, I've had only a GAIN of .8lb, but in the past 5ish weeks, I've lost 5 inches over my body. Our bodies are smart.
  • sassiebritches
    sassiebritches Posts: 1,861 Member
    I was having the same troubles, even went to the doctor. He put me on a lower carb diet plan. I eat the Atkins way, started from the beginning Induction phase. I DO NOT count calories at all. I count only the carbs. I find that I am NEVER hungry or feel deprived of anything and rarely go over 1700 cals a day. I lost 10lbs my first week and 9 lbs the next 2 months. I do not eat calories back or anything like that.....

    Not all diet plans work for everyone, I tried a few and this is the best by far.....
  • bsilence
    bsilence Posts: 2
    I would talk with your doctor too. Although you may think there is no thyroid issue, without blood work, that could definitely be the culprit. Drink your water, and hang in there because you are doing an amazing job of getting physically fit. As much as I hate to say it, turning 40 affects your metabolism too...be patient and gracious with yourself and know that you are doing an amazing thing for you and your family!!
  • sweetheart03622
    sweetheart03622 Posts: 928 Member
    I agree, open your diary so we can have a better idea of what you're eating. For me, I was losing about .4lbs/week until I switched my diet up so that I'm eating more protein and less carbs (at least 100g protein/day and less than 200g carbs/day... except this week, I have a race on Saturday lol) and the weight started dropping off a lot easier. Also, are you being honest with yourself? Those one or two nibbles on your son's leftovers or that bite of a friend's donut will add up. I think that you should try to be VERY diligent with your calories. You'll realize how quickly little things add up. Do you put cream in your coffee? Measure out a 50 calorie serving size, mix it in, and see how it tastes compared to what you normally used. I found I was typically adding 120 calories/day just in coffee creamer alone. It really pays to keep close eye on these things.
  • sassiebritches
    sassiebritches Posts: 1,861 Member
    Oh

    P.S. They say that weight loss is 80/20....80% what you eat and 20% exercise, so even without working out you should be losing if you are eating right.,..
  • cheezywino
    cheezywino Posts: 2
    Keep in mind that muscle weights more than fat so it will be likely that your scale won't change much in the beginning of a muscle building routine. Eat yogurt before a work out you burn 30% more fat during your workout. And drink lots of water no sodium beverages. You can't lose weight without drinking water that's how fat is broken down. Keep with the work outs and try to eat many small meals not less large ones even if it means splitting your meal and eating the other half 2 hrs later. you will find that your probably not even hungry by then.
    Stay with it you can do this. Don't get too obsessive on the scale but stay with the work outs.
    Good luck
    I just started MFP today being very lazy and not exercising, enjoying lots of wine and cheese has brought here. I will be doing all this too over the next few months together I hope we both lose at least 10lbs by mid June.
  • deb_rn
    deb_rn Posts: 144 Member
    I was just looking at another website to see what their recommendations were for me to lose 1 pound a week. The calorie amount was right on with MFP but they recommended more protein and less fat and carbs than MFP. So, maybe that is the problem?
  • Pangea250
    Pangea250 Posts: 965 Member
    I don't have answers. Just lots of support & ((((hugs)))). Keep in mind - I just broke through an almost 3 week plateau. So for my last 30 days, I'm probably at the same 1 lb as you.

    If the scale victory isn't happening, screw it! Laugh in it's face & find a different type of victory. Inches...endurance...clothing size...belt holes. Something.

    This is all a numbers games. Calories in & calories out. I wonder if you are overestimating your exercise calories? 500 per workout seems rather high for us beginners. Unless your workouts are kickass killers straight through?

    Maybe I'm just a wimp though.
  • elliecolorado
    elliecolorado Posts: 1,040
    The first 2 months I was on this site I lost only 5lbs. The first month I didn't eat back any of my exercise calories and I lost 3lbs. The second month I at back all or most of my exercise calories and I only lost 2 lbs. Since then I have only eaten back about 1/3-1/2 of my exercise calories and have been losing weight pretty steadily since then. Some of it could have been underestimating calories I eat or some could have been that this site tends to estimate what you burn a little bit on the high side. Sometimes it takes a little bit of experimenting to see what works for you personally.
  • JunkFoodJane
    JunkFoodJane Posts: 150 Member
    I'm in a similar boat, 3 pounds in 60-something days. But I am healthier. Yesterday I netted under 1,200 calories. That's way low for me, I usually average 1800+. But I'm not quitting. I keep giving what I'm doing a shot, then changing it a bit when I still get no results. I've received some nice compliments recently, and yesterday my whole family went out to walk the dog a mile in a 15 minute timeframe, and despite being 10" shorterthan my partner I SMOKED him. When people aren't in my way I was going as fast as 13/min a mile walking, while he was going around 20/min mile.

    I feel the burning in my legs right now from yesterday and today's exercises. I've added in 30 day shred and weights and still bupkis. But then I read it can take some people 90 days to see swifter results.


    And if I don't lose weight, I don't lose weight. I do feel the benefits.

    If I don't see anything come off in the next two weeks, I'll probably change something up again. Maybe it will take two years, but I believe it will happen and as dr Phil used to say, "that year is going to go by whether you change or not".
  • robertf57
    robertf57 Posts: 560 Member
    it is likely you are eating too many calories. MEASURE EVERYTHING that passes you lips. Cut back on your exercise calories eaten as you don't have a good estimate for them. Don't get discouraged. Keep up the good work. If you somehow can get a polar HRM, it will give you a much better estimate of your calorie burn.

    Good Luck!
  • Swimgoddess
    Swimgoddess Posts: 711 Member
    Since you belong to a gym, they can probably caliper your body fat for you so you can get a clearer picture of your maintenance calories, and from there, the number of calories to effect weight loss. MFP can only estimate. The Katch-McArdle method is far more accurate.

    1st figure out your lean body weight using your calipered %, ie: 155lbs x .26 = 40lbs, 155lbs - 40lbs = 115lbs

    2nd convert your lean body weight in lbs to kgs by dividing by 2.2, ie: 115 / 2.2 = 52.2kgs

    3rd is the Katch-McArdle formula for BMR: ie: ((52.2 x 21.6)) + 370) = Basal Metabolic Rate of 1,497 calories

    Then multiply according to activity level to get your true maintenance calories:
    Sedentary: BMR x 1.2
    Lightly Active: BMR x 1.375 (light exercise/sports 1-3 days/wk)
    Moderately Active: BMR x 1.55 (moderate exercise/sports 3-5 days/wk)
    Very Active: BMR x 1.725 (hard exercise/sports 6-7 days/wk)
    Extra Active: BMR x 1.9 (hard daily exercise/sports & physical job or 2x day training)

    Then subtract what you need to in order to create a 1750-7000 calorie deficit in a week.
  • vaidaz
    vaidaz Posts: 7
    Definitely review your food and calorie intake.

    When I started, before MFP, I was working out 3 days a week for an hours either strength training or cardio for about 3-4 weeks. Didn't loose anything. Then I started 30 day shred and went on for another 3 weeks daily. Didn't loose anything. Then I found this website and started counting calories. O boy, I was overeating! I would reach some days up to 3000 cal/day.

    Since my child was born I am constantly hungry. I can't even fall asleep if I don't have some snack right before sleep. So, to keep my calorie intake low I had to add lots of vegetables to fill my stomach and find substitutes with lower calories for my favourite foods, e.g. instead of eating 100 cal yogurt I eat 35 cal yogut. Since then I am loosing 2 lbs/week on average. In total I lost 10 lbs in a little over month.
  • brandydelight
    brandydelight Posts: 16 Member
    I am in same boat...I have a trainer, go to the gym after work everyday, walk on my breaks at work, walk on the weekends, keep track of everything I eat/drink, drink lots of water...and I am losing only half pound a week. It is making me crazy. But, I have lost over 30 inches, and my fat ratio is going down and muscle is going up. Still I am stumped. I look leaner, my clothes are loose, but I want to see that scale go down! My MD says I have no health issues causing this. I am 40, and like so many others, used to eat/drink whatever I wanted. I also have a back injury so I am a little limited to different excerises, ie; no running/jogging, and I have UC=Ulcerative Colitis so I have to be careful messing with my diet too much. I eat high fiber, high protein, low fat. Although I am frustrated, I am seeing some progress, slow but steady and I wont give up. I think my expectations were too high, afterall, I am not 25 anymore. Any ideas on how to speed this up would be welcomed. I started Dec 2010 and have lost approx 22 lbs, but its been up and down week to week.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories