Would you be ok with being stuck on an island with the above person?

Yep

I'd have to hear her sing first.

she won't be able to handle me and will escape the island.

If she can hunt yes

sure, he can use his cowbell to hypnotize animals into hunting themselves and he has a cowbell so he should know how to cook

You know it

Wouldn't it be awkward.........?

Sure...but is it just us two?

I prefer an audience... but I'm still game!

Yes, but only if you play nice.