Does anyone uses a waist trainer?? Someone Plus size preferably
r_wilson9
Posts: 17 Member
hey you guys I'm really thinking about getting a waist trainer!!! I've been reading the pros and cons but as anyone I'm more so on the pro side lol
0
Replies
-
Or you could just work for it instead of using a "quick fix" from a company that would happily see you out of pocket if it meant they got your money.
I can't imagine many people on this website would recommend a waist trainer.
The only thing that will make a difference is a steady caloric deficit and accurate logging mixed with an increase in exercise. Good luck!0 -
You are asking at a fitness and exercise forum if a waist trainer will make you thinner???0
-
No.0
-
Soooooo either the effects are totally temporary because you don't use it hard enough, or you run the risk of rib deformity, organ displacement, spinal issues, and breathing issues, and you're coming down on the side of pro? Wow.0
-
^Alatariel75 wrote: »Soooooo either the effects are totally temporary because you don't use it hard enough, or you run the risk of rib deformity, organ displacement, spinal issues, and breathing issues, and you're coming down on the side of pro? Wow.
This.
Just don't.
Do you think the manufacturers of waist trainers give two hoots for your wellbeing? No. They have your money. End of.
Yes I do feel strongly about this.
0 -
hey you guys I'm really thinking about getting a waist trainer!!! I've been reading the pros and cons but as anyone I'm more so on the pro side lol
You're going to have a sweaty middle and temporary results. Just figure out your deficit, eat at that, and be patient. My waist is so much trimmer than it was 48 pounds ago.0 -
You know what? A waist trainer, to me, is like filling a Ziploc bag with water, sealing it, then popping am elastic band around the middle and freezing it. When you pull it out of the freezer, is it that shape? Yes! of course!
Now leave it on the counter for a couple hours. Now is it just a Ziploc bag full of water? yes... yes it is.
You don't get to 'train' the contents of your meatbag. You want your meatbag to be smaller, reduce the contents.0 -
barbecuesauce wrote: »hey you guys I'm really thinking about getting a waist trainer!!! I've been reading the pros and cons but as anyone I'm more so on the pro side lol
You're going to have a sweaty middle and temporary results. Just figure out your deficit, eat at that, and be patient. My waist is so much trimmer than it was 48 pounds ago.
Thank you! I've been going to the gym just wanted to maybe target that area while I'm working out!
0 -
Alatariel75 wrote: »You know what? A waist trainer, to me, is like filling a Ziploc bag with water, sealing it, then popping am elastic band around the middle and freezing it. When you pull it out of the freezer, is it that shape? Yes! of course!
Now leave it on the counter for a couple hours. Now is it just a Ziploc bag full of water? yes... yes it is.
You don't get to 'train' the contents of your meatbag. You want your meatbag to be smaller, reduce the contents.
LOL @ "meatbag" :laugh:0 -
Thank you all I was considering it because when my sister let me try on hers I felt like maybe it could just work! But thanks for all the input I will continue cutting calories and going to the gym!0
-
Yay....that's the spirit!
Seriously though, in the past I have worn Spanx when I was a bit chubby and it sort of works for an evening out to smooth out the worst lumpy bits!
But waist trainers/corsets are much more aggressive....no wonder Victorian women used to faint. They even wore them through pregnancy, well into the last trimester.
0 -
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal. I "would" consider an elastic trainer because of the potential benefits in controlling hunger. Ghrelin is the hunger hormone that is secreted by the gastrointestinal track. This happens when the stomache and intestines are "not full". It appears that when your stomache empties, Ghrelin is secreted and goes to the hypothalamus where it binds and causes a signal to the brain that it is time to eat. If you apply external pressure so that the gastrointestinal tract is compressed, it could have the same effect as keeping your stomache full without keeping your stomache full. I suggest you investigate the major hormones that control hunger, satiety, and glucose homeostasis. In particular look up Ghrelin, Leptin, and Insulin using Wikipedia. Good luck!
PS. After you remove a trainer, you should practice holding in the stomache using your stomache muscles ... And perform some ab exercises to strengthen those muscles.0 -
I would like to clarify my previous post. I am a believer in caloric restriction and exercise as the way to improve your health and lose weight. Sugar and all it's forms are your enemy. Eating a low carbohydrate diet with lots of good fat is the way to improve insulin resistance. Do your own research. There are plenty of people who think eating low fat is the way to be healthy. But, there is significant new research that says eating a high fat diet is best. Check out Dr Mercola! I have noticed a lot of testimonials from vegans, vegetarians, Paleos, and Adkins diet proponents who provide annecdotal proof of their success. But then you find out they are competing in triathlons, running marathons or biking 150 miles per week. Well, probably all of us would lose weight on such a high level of physical exercise. I am 70 years old ... I walk about 5 miles every day and have lost about 30 lbs over the last year. I try to eat less than 100 grams of carbohydrates each day and I stay away from all simple sugars, trans fats, and try to eat fresh vegetables. I am not afraid of fats. And my cholesterol is excellent even though I eat eggs and bacon almost every morning. Fat doesn't make you fat. Sugar and excess calories make you fat. Good luck!0
-
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal. I "would" consider an elastic trainer because of the potential benefits in controlling hunger. Ghrelin is the hunger hormone that is secreted by the gastrointestinal track. This happens when the stomache and intestines are "not full". It appears that when your stomache empties, Ghrelin is secreted and goes to the hypothalamus where it binds and causes a signal to the brain that it is time to eat. If you apply external pressure so that the gastrointestinal tract is compressed, it could have the same effect as keeping your stomache full without keeping your stomache full. I suggest you investigate the major hormones that control hunger, satiety, and glucose homeostasis. In particular look up Ghrelin, Leptin, and Insulin using Wikipedia. Good luck!
PS. After you remove a trainer, you should practice holding in the stomache using your stomache muscles ... And perform some ab exercises to strengthen those muscles.
Thank you much, sir! Your comment sound so well thought out and so educated seems like you have some knowledge about losing weight! Again, thank you!0 -
Hi dear r_wilson9,
I see people discouraged you, but probably no one tried before criticizing…
I’ll tell you about my experience with corsets so that you can decide by yourself. I started training my waist 5 years ago when I was 22 years old, 54 kilos and 67 centimeters of waist (I’m 1,70m). I never thought it would help me to lose weight, that wasn’t my intention. I wanted to have a small waist. In two years, my weight was the same, but my waist was 58cm. So, you can see it worked a lot for me. Today I am 60 kilos and my waist is 65cm (less than when I wasn’t training my waist and were much thinner). But it’s up to you, I searched A LOT before deciding to use a corset, you MUST exercise or you are going to lose your muscle tone and should ask a doctor opinion just to be sure you can use it without problems. More, you have to wear it AT LEAST 8 hours per day or it won’t deform your ribs and must look for a corsetmaker, so that she makes a corset for YOU, with your measures. By the way, Ronc28 is right, I don’t use to be hungry when I’m wearing my corset and you are going to feel full with less food. I’m sorry if my English is not OK, but think you could understand…
0 -
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal. I "would" consider an elastic trainer because of the potential benefits in controlling hunger. Ghrelin is the hunger hormone that is secreted by the gastrointestinal track. This happens when the stomache and intestines are "not full". It appears that when your stomache empties, Ghrelin is secreted and goes to the hypothalamus where it binds and causes a signal to the brain that it is time to eat. If you apply external pressure so that the gastrointestinal tract is compressed, it could have the same effect as keeping your stomache full without keeping your stomache full. I suggest you investigate the major hormones that control hunger, satiety, and glucose homeostasis. In particular look up Ghrelin, Leptin, and Insulin using Wikipedia. Good luck!
PS. After you remove a trainer, you should practice holding in the stomache using your stomache muscles ... And perform some ab exercises to strengthen those muscles.
Thank you much, sir! Your comment sound so well thought out and so educated seems like you have some knowledge about losing weight! Again, thank you!
Just saying. Sugar in all forms is not your enemy- and low carb is not the way to win at life.0 -
I love using my weighted hula hoop to work my waist. I got mine from canyonhoops.com I can hoop and watch t.v. perfect union!-1
-
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal. I "would" consider an elastic trainer because of the potential benefits in controlling hunger. Ghrelin is the hunger hormone that is secreted by the gastrointestinal track. This happens when the stomache and intestines are "not full". It appears that when your stomache empties, Ghrelin is secreted and goes to the hypothalamus where it binds and causes a signal to the brain that it is time to eat. If you apply external pressure so that the gastrointestinal tract is compressed, it could have the same effect as keeping your stomache full without keeping your stomache full. I suggest you investigate the major hormones that control hunger, satiety, and glucose homeostasis. In particular look up Ghrelin, Leptin, and Insulin using Wikipedia. Good luck!
PS. After you remove a trainer, you should practice holding in the stomache using your stomache muscles ... And perform some ab exercises to strengthen those muscles.
Lulz. Begins post by saying all the comments are non-scientific, opinion or anecdotal then writes post using no scientific references and at the end advises the OP to use Wikipedia.
Of course this is the post the OP loves....
MFP, never change.0 -
Listen to the posters who have over 100 post at least,(1000 better). They usually know what they are talking about and not trying to sell you on something.0
-
No, I am my own waist trainer. There is no special belt, no magic pill, no special anything that is going to work, and if it does work 1. it's usually in your head and 2. the results will only be temporary. You have to put the work in to achieve the results.0
-
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal. I "would" consider an elastic trainer because of the potential benefits in controlling hunger. Ghrelin is the hunger hormone that is secreted by the gastrointestinal track. This happens when the stomache and intestines are "not full". It appears that when your stomache empties, Ghrelin is secreted and goes to the hypothalamus where it binds and causes a signal to the brain that it is time to eat. If you apply external pressure so that the gastrointestinal tract is compressed, it could have the same effect as keeping your stomache full without keeping your stomache full. I suggest you investigate the major hormones that control hunger, satiety, and glucose homeostasis. In particular look up Ghrelin, Leptin, and Insulin using Wikipedia. Good luck!
PS. After you remove a trainer, you should practice holding in the stomache using your stomache muscles ... And perform some ab exercises to strengthen those muscles.
0 -
I thought things like that were just for use for an evening, hidden under your clothes when you want to have a nice outline? Like support underwear or something? Either way it doesn't look appealing - spend your money on something more active and fun.0
-
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal. I "would" consider an elastic trainer because of the potential benefits in controlling hunger. Ghrelin is the hunger hormone that is secreted by the gastrointestinal track. This happens when the stomache and intestines are "not full". It appears that when your stomache empties, Ghrelin is secreted and goes to the hypothalamus where it binds and causes a signal to the brain that it is time to eat. If you apply external pressure so that the gastrointestinal tract is compressed, it could have the same effect as keeping your stomache full without keeping your stomache full. I suggest you investigate the major hormones that control hunger, satiety, and glucose homeostasis. In particular look up Ghrelin, Leptin, and Insulin using Wikipedia. Good luck!
PS. After you remove a trainer, you should practice holding in the stomache using your stomache muscles ... And perform some ab exercises to strengthen those muscles.
Lulz. Begins post by saying all the comments are non-scientific, opinion or anecdotal then writes post using no scientific references and at the end advises the OP to use Wikipedia.
Of course this is the post the OP loves....
MFP, never change.
So much this.0 -
Brunavilla wrote: »Hi dear r_wilson9,
I see people discouraged you, but probably no one tried before criticizing…
I’ll tell you about my experience with corsets so that you can decide by yourself. I started training my waist 5 years ago when I was 22 years old, 54 kilos and 67 centimeters of waist (I’m 1,70m). I never thought it would help me to lose weight, that wasn’t my intention. I wanted to have a small waist. In two years, my weight was the same, but my waist was 58cm. So, you can see it worked a lot for me. Today I am 60 kilos and my waist is 65cm (less than when I wasn’t training my waist and were much thinner). But it’s up to you, I searched A LOT before deciding to use a corset, you MUST exercise or you are going to lose your muscle tone and should ask a doctor opinion just to be sure you can use it without problems. More, you have to wear it AT LEAST 8 hours per day or it won’t deform your ribs and must look for a corsetmaker, so that she makes a corset for YOU, with your measures. By the way, Ronc28 is right, I don’t use to be hungry when I’m wearing my corset and you are going to feel full with less food. I’m sorry if my English is not OK, but think you could understand…
Strong first post. :noway:0 -
Alatariel75 wrote: »You know what? A waist trainer, to me, is like filling a Ziploc bag with water, sealing it, then popping am elastic band around the middle and freezing it. When you pull it out of the freezer, is it that shape? Yes! of course!
Now leave it on the counter for a couple hours. Now is it just a Ziploc bag full of water? yes... yes it is.
You don't get to 'train' the contents of your meatbag. You want your meatbag to be smaller, reduce the contents.
Loving this analogy
0 -
My foster daughter is hooked on the weight trainer corset and I find it so upsetting! From the research I've done a lot of what is said about health concerns is not proven so I don't think it's going to likely do long term damage to your body. HOWEVER it is going to cause you pain/discomfort while using it. It's going to limit the extent to which you can do exercises with proper form. And most of all it's a reinforcement of an outdated and absurd standard of what a woman should look like. I'm not a violent person but I kind of want to slap Kim Kardashian for making this a thing! We do not all need to have giant boobs, a tiny waist and a nice round butt. That's not reality for almost anyone and to expect that of yourself means you need to detox from magazines, tv etc and surround yourself with people who encourage you to love your body the way it is. If you want to improve your health move your body more and make good food choices most of the time. You are beautiful just the way you are so don't give your money to anyone who tells you you need to buy their product to be good enough. You already are.
0 -
Almost all of the above comments are non-scientific, oppinion, or anecdotal.
Scientifically, waist trainers have no impact on weight loss
Opinion, they are a waste of money if one is trying to "shape" their body
Anecdotally, I've been doing this for over 30 years and can emphatically say that a lot of people who think they know what they are talking about when it comes to fitness and nutrition, don't really know what they are talking about.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
My foster daughter is hooked on the weight trainer corset and I find it so upsetting! From the research I've done a lot of what is said about health concerns is not proven so I don't think it's going to likely do long term damage to your body. HOWEVER it is going to cause you pain/discomfort while using it. It's going to limit the extent to which you can do exercises with proper form. And most of all it's a reinforcement of an outdated and absurd standard of what a woman should look like. I'm not a violent person but I kind of want to slap Kim Kardashian for making this a thing! We do not all need to have giant boobs, a tiny waist and a nice round butt. That's not reality for almost anyone and to expect that of yourself means you need to detox from magazines, tv etc and surround yourself with people who encourage you to love your body the way it is. If you want to improve your health move your body more and make good food choices most of the time. You are beautiful just the way you are so don't give your money to anyone who tells you you need to buy their product to be good enough. You already are.
*Begins the slow clap for this whole post*
Honestly, the whole corset thing is ridiculous- just like grapefruit diets and cabbage soup diets and master cleanses. Nothing about it seems legit, and it's just giving false hope to desperate people in search of a fast solution. Healthy weight loss is not fast, it's not always convenient, and at the end of the day we all have to accept what our bodies look like. Slow is better, consistent is better, lifelong changes are better. They're hard, but they're also the only things that actually do you any good.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions