Calories given for exercise??

weemazo1
weemazo1 Posts: 2 Member
edited November 2024 in Food and Nutrition
Hi there I was wondering about the extra calories it gives you after you exercise....i thought the whole idea of exercising was to burn these off. How important is it to eat these?

Replies

  • diannethegeek
    diannethegeek Posts: 14,776 Member
    I like this explanation of why MFP adds them best. It explains things better than anything I could type up: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/818082/exercise-calories-again-wtf
  • theresaTerriM
    theresaTerriM Posts: 28 Member
    weemazo1 wrote: »
    Hi there I was wondering about the extra calories it gives you after you exercise....i thought the whole idea of exercising was to burn these off. How important is it to eat these?

    This should be something that is answered and then the post bumped so it's always there for anyone else to find. I have this question myself but never have seen a clear cut answer without a bunch of other numbers thrown in or calculations.

    To eat back the calories burned or not to eat back the calories burned, that is the question ~William Shakespeare (just kidding) but really, it's something that should be clearer and put right up front and not buried under a mass of other threads! :smile:
  • flippy1234
    flippy1234 Posts: 686 Member
    I don't eat them back unless I am really hungry. I don't exercise to eat more, I exercise to lose weight and stay in shape.
  • 999tigger
    999tigger Posts: 5,235 Member
    It depends which method you are using to calculate your deficit. If you are using the MFP default, then the deficit you need to create has already been calculated in based on your eating alone. It doesnt include any exercise, so if you do some you then get to eat calories back to maintain the deficit you set i.e 1lb a week. The proviso is that you need to ve sure your deficit is accuate in the first place(weigh your food) and that the burn estimates are correct i.e MFP overestimates on some exercise, uswers overestimate their own efforts, so you end up being awarded more calories than you have really burned, which if you eat them back dilutes your deficit.

    Initially eat 50% of the calories back and see if you are hungry and wheher you lose weight. Im fluid to the extent of calories I eat back and use them as a reserve. If ive had a long workout then I make sure im properly fueled ip.

    The alternative method TDEE gives you a bumber that already factors in exercise and you do not eat the calories back or that would be double counting.
  • theresaTerriM
    theresaTerriM Posts: 28 Member
    999tigger wrote: »
    It depends which method you are using to calculate your deficit. If you are using the MFP default, then the deficit you need to create has already been calculated in based on your eating alone. It doesnt include any exercise, so if you do some you then get to eat calories back to maintain the deficit you set i.e 1lb a week. The proviso is that you need to ve sure your deficit is accuate in the first place(weigh your food) and that the burn estimates are correct i.e MFP overestimates on some exercise, uswers overestimate their own efforts, so you end up being awarded more calories than you have really burned, which if you eat them back dilutes your deficit.

    Initially eat 50% of the calories back and see if you are hungry and wheher you lose weight. Im fluid to the extent of calories I eat back and use them as a reserve. If ive had a long workout then I make sure im properly fueled ip.

    The alternative method TDEE gives you a bumber that already factors in exercise and you do not eat the calories back or that would be double counting.

    Thank you!! I use the MFP default so if I burn 300 calories (I can tell they overestimate lol) then I really need to eat back 150 of them, for example.

    I would do the TDEE but I get lost in the numbers so I just have been using the MFP default. I know there's 'this factor' or 'that factor' that the number gurus love to toss in but for us simple folk that just want a simpler answer this works great. Thank you so much! :smile:
  • weemazo1
    weemazo1 Posts: 2 Member
    Thanks everyone, appreciated
This discussion has been closed.