So much woo in one place!

Nony_Mouse
Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
edited November 2024 in Food and Nutrition
This article popped up on my FB newsfeed as one of those 'you may also like...' things:

hiit-blog.dailyhiit.com/hiit-diet/diet-tips/10-diet-mistakes-seriously-slowing-metablolism/

Apparently pesticides make you fat, and all that tea I've drunk today is doing a serious boost on my metabolism.

*rollseyes*
«1

Replies

  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member
    LOL kickstart, white carbs, oh my ….

  • techgal128
    techgal128 Posts: 719 Member
    edited April 2015
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.

    Oh yeah, there are some sprinklings of truth in there, but it's like they took those and ran in some completely random direction with them. Like with the fibre. Yes, adequate fibre is good, it helps you to feel full, and keeps you regular, but raising your metabolism by 30%??

    And is the extra 70 cals in my lunch going straight to my hips, or does the metabolism boost from the tea make it okay? Or, am I totally screwed because I halted my metabolism by not having breakfast?
  • Alluminati
    Alluminati Posts: 6,208 Member
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You must counteract with lemon.
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    OdesAngel wrote: »
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You must counteract with lemon.

    Heh I'm actually surprised that wasn't in there!

    Also, 'brewed tea'. Is there some other way to make tea that doesn't involve brewing it??
  • MKEgal
    MKEgal Posts: 3,250 Member
    techgal wrote:
    I lol'ed at the water though. DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You should only drink ice-cold water, because then your body expends calories warming it to body temp.
    :innocent::wink: :smirk:
    (Which, again, is completely true, but the effect is so small that it's not worth counting.)
  • MKEgal
    MKEgal Posts: 3,250 Member
    When you eat less than you need for basic biological functioning ... your body halts your metabolism.
    Well, that's true, but not in the way they're implying.
    They're trying to tell people that if you eat less than you need _right_ _now_, your metabolism shuts down.
    That's wrong.
    When your metabolism shuts down, you die.
    If you miss a meal, you don't die (immediately).
    Miss enough meals and of course you will.

    .
    If you were to drink the equivalent of 2 martinis, you can slow your body’s fat burning ability by 73%.
    :confused: Vert da ferk?
    I doubt it slows anywhere near that much, and I doubt the slowdown lasts very long. (No time limit is mentioned.)
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    MKEgal wrote: »
    When you eat less than you need for basic biological functioning ... your body halts your metabolism.
    Well, that's true, but not in the way they're implying.
    They're trying to tell people that if you eat less than you need _right_ _now_, your metabolism shuts down.
    That's wrong.
    When your metabolism shuts down, you die.
    If you miss a meal, you don't die (immediately).
    Miss enough meals and of course you will.

    .
    If you were to drink the equivalent of 2 martinis, you can slow your body’s fat burning ability by 73%.
    :confused: Vert da ferk?
    I doubt it slows anywhere near that much, and I doubt the slowdown lasts very long. (No time limit is mentioned.)

    Yeah, that's the problem, they've taken facts and twisted them into crazy. Except the pesticide thing, that's just straight up woo.
  • lynn_glenmont
    lynn_glenmont Posts: 10,149 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    OdesAngel wrote: »
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You must counteract with lemon.

    Heh I'm actually surprised that wasn't in there!

    Also, 'brewed tea'. Is there some other way to make tea that doesn't involve brewing it??

    Sadly, there is granulated powdered mix, which may or may include some actual tea-derived product. There are restaurants that serve that for iced tea (I've never seen one try to do it for hot tea, although I suppose it's theoretically possible).
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    OdesAngel wrote: »
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You must counteract with lemon.

    Heh I'm actually surprised that wasn't in there!

    Also, 'brewed tea'. Is there some other way to make tea that doesn't involve brewing it??

    Sadly, there is granulated powdered mix, which may or may include some actual tea-derived product. There are restaurants that serve that for iced tea (I've never seen one try to do it for hot tea, although I suppose it's theoretically possible).

    This makes me sad :(. But then I also think powdered (instant) coffee is an abomination.
  • avskk
    avskk Posts: 1,787 Member
    Don't knock Lipton powdered iced tea mix, man. I love it because it boosts my metabolism by up to 40000% my grandmother got me hooked on it as a child. It's excellent if you mix it right, ice it down until it practically frosts over, and splash in some lemon.

    Um, I mean, on the topic of this post I have nothing to say because I'm too busy eating white carbs and skipping breakfast.
  • Russandol
    Russandol Posts: 71 Member
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    Russandol wrote: »
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.

    I will definitely sign on for that!

    So according to the article, today I have managed to:

    Halt my metabolism by not eating breakfast (you are all invited to my funeral)
    Yet also increased my metabolism by 63% with coffee (three cups) and tea (four cups) (the article isn't remotely clear on whether the % is cumulative, so I'm just going to assume it is)
    Eat over the magical 400 cals for both lunch and dinner (presumably that's gone straight on my butt)
    Do something wrong by eating a white bagel
    Boost my metabolism another 30% by eating 25g of fibre
    Burn an extra 20 or so cals with icy cold water
    Boosted my metabolism even more by having protein with both meals
    Vit D from sunlight - check, no alcohol - check, calcium from the milk in all that tea and coffee - check

    Either I'm going to be skinny in no time or my 'fails' cancelled out all the metabolism revving.
  • mkakids
    mkakids Posts: 1,913 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    OdesAngel wrote: »
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You must counteract with lemon.

    Heh I'm actually surprised that wasn't in there!

    Also, 'brewed tea'. Is there some other way to make tea that doesn't involve brewing it??

    Sadly, there is granulated powdered mix, which may or may include some actual tea-derived product. There are restaurants that serve that for iced tea (I've never seen one try to do it for hot tea, although I suppose it's theoretically possible).

    You ever notice how much that stuff foams when you make it?! Makes me wonder why!
  • tulips_and_tea
    tulips_and_tea Posts: 5,767 Member
    I couldn't get past the first picture. What on earth is that girl wearing? And are we to believe that if we do what the article says that we will look like her? Where do breast implants come into play on her list of dos and don'ts? (just an assumption on my part, but I'd be surprised if I was wrong)
  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Russandol wrote: »
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.

    I will definitely sign on for that!

    So according to the article, today I have managed to:

    Halt my metabolism by not eating breakfast (you are all invited to my funeral)
    Yet also increased my metabolism by 63% with coffee (three cups) and tea (four cups) (the article isn't remotely clear on whether the % is cumulative, so I'm just going to assume it is)
    Eat over the magical 400 cals for both lunch and dinner (presumably that's gone straight on my butt)
    Do something wrong by eating a white bagel
    Boost my metabolism another 30% by eating 25g of fibre
    Burn an extra 20 or so cals with icy cold water
    Boosted my metabolism even more by having protein with both meals
    Vit D from sunlight - check, no alcohol - check, calcium from the milk in all that tea and coffee - check

    Either I'm going to be skinny in no time or my 'fails' cancelled out all the metabolism revving.

    you are already dead...
  • CrabNebula
    CrabNebula Posts: 1,119 Member
    MKEgal wrote: »
    When you eat less than you need for basic biological functioning ... your body halts your metabolism.
    Well, that's true, but not in the way they're implying.
    They're trying to tell people that if you eat less than you need _right_ _now_, your metabolism shuts down.
    That's wrong.
    When your metabolism shuts down, you die.
    If you miss a meal, you don't die (immediately).
    Miss enough meals and of course you will.

    .
    If you were to drink the equivalent of 2 martinis, you can slow your body’s fat burning ability by 73%.
    :confused: Vert da ferk?
    I doubt it slows anywhere near that much, and I doubt the slowdown lasts very long. (No time limit is mentioned.)

    Sort of true. When you drink alcohol, your body prioritizes it to be metabolized first. As soon as that is taken care of, it goes back to whatever you have eaten.

  • cw106
    cw106 Posts: 952 Member
    so fakebook=woo (whatever that may be).
    fascinating.
  • techgal128
    techgal128 Posts: 719 Member
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Russandol wrote: »
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.

    I will definitely sign on for that!

    So according to the article, today I have managed to:

    Halt my metabolism by not eating breakfast (you are all invited to my funeral)
    Yet also increased my metabolism by 63% with coffee (three cups) and tea (four cups) (the article isn't remotely clear on whether the % is cumulative, so I'm just going to assume it is)
    Eat over the magical 400 cals for both lunch and dinner (presumably that's gone straight on my butt)
    Do something wrong by eating a white bagel
    Boost my metabolism another 30% by eating 25g of fibre
    Burn an extra 20 or so cals with icy cold water
    Boosted my metabolism even more by having protein with both meals
    Vit D from sunlight - check, no alcohol - check, calcium from the milk in all that tea and coffee - check

    Either I'm going to be skinny in no time or my 'fails' cancelled out all the metabolism revving.

    you are already dead...

    RIP
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Russandol wrote: »
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.

    I will definitely sign on for that!

    So according to the article, today I have managed to:

    Halt my metabolism by not eating breakfast (you are all invited to my funeral)
    Yet also increased my metabolism by 63% with coffee (three cups) and tea (four cups) (the article isn't remotely clear on whether the % is cumulative, so I'm just going to assume it is)
    Eat over the magical 400 cals for both lunch and dinner (presumably that's gone straight on my butt)
    Do something wrong by eating a white bagel
    Boost my metabolism another 30% by eating 25g of fibre
    Burn an extra 20 or so cals with icy cold water
    Boosted my metabolism even more by having protein with both meals
    Vit D from sunlight - check, no alcohol - check, calcium from the milk in all that tea and coffee - check

    Either I'm going to be skinny in no time or my 'fails' cancelled out all the metabolism revving.

    you are already dead...

    Yeah, but I'm thin, right?? :p
  • techgal128
    techgal128 Posts: 719 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Russandol wrote: »
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.

    I will definitely sign on for that!

    So according to the article, today I have managed to:

    Halt my metabolism by not eating breakfast (you are all invited to my funeral)
    Yet also increased my metabolism by 63% with coffee (three cups) and tea (four cups) (the article isn't remotely clear on whether the % is cumulative, so I'm just going to assume it is)
    Eat over the magical 400 cals for both lunch and dinner (presumably that's gone straight on my butt)
    Do something wrong by eating a white bagel
    Boost my metabolism another 30% by eating 25g of fibre
    Burn an extra 20 or so cals with icy cold water
    Boosted my metabolism even more by having protein with both meals
    Vit D from sunlight - check, no alcohol - check, calcium from the milk in all that tea and coffee - check

    Either I'm going to be skinny in no time or my 'fails' cancelled out all the metabolism revving.

    you are already dead...

    Yeah, but I'm thin, right?? :p

    It doesn't matter what you do with your life as long as you leave a sexy corpse.
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    techgal128 wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    ndj1979 wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Russandol wrote: »
    I'd like to invent a browser add-on that lets me deliver sucker punches to any article writer using the phrase "boost your metabolism" or variations thereof.

    I will definitely sign on for that!

    So according to the article, today I have managed to:

    Halt my metabolism by not eating breakfast (you are all invited to my funeral)
    Yet also increased my metabolism by 63% with coffee (three cups) and tea (four cups) (the article isn't remotely clear on whether the % is cumulative, so I'm just going to assume it is)
    Eat over the magical 400 cals for both lunch and dinner (presumably that's gone straight on my butt)
    Do something wrong by eating a white bagel
    Boost my metabolism another 30% by eating 25g of fibre
    Burn an extra 20 or so cals with icy cold water
    Boosted my metabolism even more by having protein with both meals
    Vit D from sunlight - check, no alcohol - check, calcium from the milk in all that tea and coffee - check

    Either I'm going to be skinny in no time or my 'fails' cancelled out all the metabolism revving.

    you are already dead...

    Yeah, but I'm thin, right?? :p

    It doesn't matter what you do with your life as long as you leave a sexy corpse.

    Gotta look good for the zombie apocalypse!!
  • PeachyCarol
    PeachyCarol Posts: 8,029 Member
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?
  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?

    Apparently we killed ourselves by not eating breakfast and therefore halting our metabolisms, therefore the rest is moot :(. I'm pretty sure calories have no effect when you're dead though, so yay!! I can eat whatever I want :D. Maybe I should have some margaritas first to help with that (yes, I am reading the hilarious 'diet mistakes thread currently).

    Also, anyone get the feeling that if they could have gotten away with adding smoking as a metabolism booster they would have?
  • jennifer_417
    jennifer_417 Posts: 12,344 Member
    OdesAngel wrote: »
    techgal128 wrote: »
    A few of them are right. Such as some people need more fiber, protein, and vitamin D in their diets. I lol'ed at the water though.

    DAMN WATER IS MAKING ME FAT.
    You must counteract with lemon.

    Don't forget the honey and cayenne!
  • PeachyCarol
    PeachyCarol Posts: 8,029 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?

    Apparently we killed ourselves by not eating breakfast and therefore halting our metabolisms, therefore the rest is moot :(. I'm pretty sure calories have no effect when you're dead though, so yay!! I can eat whatever I want :D. Maybe I should have some margaritas first to help with that (yes, I am reading the hilarious 'diet mistakes thread currently).

    Also, anyone get the feeling that if they could have gotten away with adding smoking as a metabolism booster they would have?

    I was a fat two-pack-a-day smoker. Meh. Didn't work for me! I quite AGES ago, though. There are probably people here on MFP born after I quit smoking.

  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?

    Apparently we killed ourselves by not eating breakfast and therefore halting our metabolisms, therefore the rest is moot :(. I'm pretty sure calories have no effect when you're dead though, so yay!! I can eat whatever I want :D. Maybe I should have some margaritas first to help with that (yes, I am reading the hilarious 'diet mistakes thread currently).

    Also, anyone get the feeling that if they could have gotten away with adding smoking as a metabolism booster they would have?

    I was a fat two-pack-a-day smoker. Meh. Didn't work for me! I quite AGES ago, though. There are probably people here on MFP born after I quit smoking.

    Ah, yes, but the myth that it speeds up your metabolism persists!!

    I confess to still being a smoker (obvs not because I think it keeps me thin!), BUT I have a quit plan so cunning you could stick a tail on it and call it a weasel - once I'm done with initial weight loss I'm planning to do that building muscle thing. So I'm going to quit then and put the extra cals I will inevitably consume to good use ;).
  • PeachyCarol
    PeachyCarol Posts: 8,029 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?

    Apparently we killed ourselves by not eating breakfast and therefore halting our metabolisms, therefore the rest is moot :(. I'm pretty sure calories have no effect when you're dead though, so yay!! I can eat whatever I want :D. Maybe I should have some margaritas first to help with that (yes, I am reading the hilarious 'diet mistakes thread currently).

    Also, anyone get the feeling that if they could have gotten away with adding smoking as a metabolism booster they would have?

    I was a fat two-pack-a-day smoker. Meh. Didn't work for me! I quite AGES ago, though. There are probably people here on MFP born after I quit smoking.

    Ah, yes, but the myth that it speeds up your metabolism persists!!

    I confess to still being a smoker (obvs not because I think it keeps me thin!), BUT I have a quit plan so cunning you could stick a tail on it and call it a weasel - once I'm done with initial weight loss I'm planning to do that building muscle thing. So I'm going to quit then and put the extra cals I will inevitably consume to good use ;).

    That sounds like a great strategy, actually.

  • Nony_Mouse
    Nony_Mouse Posts: 5,646 Member
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    Nony_Mouse wrote: »
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?

    Apparently we killed ourselves by not eating breakfast and therefore halting our metabolisms, therefore the rest is moot :(. I'm pretty sure calories have no effect when you're dead though, so yay!! I can eat whatever I want :D. Maybe I should have some margaritas first to help with that (yes, I am reading the hilarious 'diet mistakes thread currently).

    Also, anyone get the feeling that if they could have gotten away with adding smoking as a metabolism booster they would have?

    I was a fat two-pack-a-day smoker. Meh. Didn't work for me! I quite AGES ago, though. There are probably people here on MFP born after I quit smoking.

    Ah, yes, but the myth that it speeds up your metabolism persists!!

    I confess to still being a smoker (obvs not because I think it keeps me thin!), BUT I have a quit plan so cunning you could stick a tail on it and call it a weasel - once I'm done with initial weight loss I'm planning to do that building muscle thing. So I'm going to quit then and put the extra cals I will inevitably consume to good use ;).

    That sounds like a great strategy, actually.

    I know! I thought it was genius :)

    This reminds me of when I quit a few years ago (obviously didn't stick with it) - I did nicotine patches for the first time. It was shortly after my last round with the lovely ED that lives in my head and I was rake thin (not underweight, but way too thin for me). When I picked up the script from the pharmacy the girl started telling me they work best when you put them somewhere fatty on your body, then looked at me and said 'Oh. Um, maybe try your thigh?' :\. (this is also around the time I kicked my bathroom scales for going down instead of up, that's an interesting experience!).
  • lemurcat12
    lemurcat12 Posts: 30,886 Member
    I just saw this gem. According to it, I'm good on tea, water, fiber, and dairy, but I'm killing my metabolism by not eating until noon and not eating 400 calories a meal. I can't decide whether I should be thin and my fat is just an illusion or I should be dead.

    I also can't figure out what I should be kickstarting each day. Am I dead before my tea? It feels that way sometimes. Does this mean that my fasted workouts have no effect?

    I should have a great metabolism: I eat plenty, drink lots of (too much, sigh) coffee, greatly prefer cold water to room temperature (I also love ice), get tons of protein, plenty of iron (but no fortified cereal, which I understand from the Cheerios thread is super great or something, maybe that's a problem?), I've started taking Vit D (not for metabolism reasons), don't drink, eat tons of dairy (yeah, I know, I'm a chubby baby cow).

    Why am I not a fat burning machine?

    It has to be the pesticides. Or maybe those white carbs: I have been eating lots of cauliflower, turnips, and celeriac lately!

    I would really like to know the source for the kickstarting metaphor. When did people start saying/believing that? It's so odd.
This discussion has been closed.