80 carbs/10 protein/10 fat ___Fruitarian diet
graywi123
Posts: 19 Member
Has anyone tried this? I just found out about this diet. I love fruit and this might work for me. Has anyone succeeded with this dietary change?
0
Replies
-
My personal experience is that it is very, very hard to mess with the macros. How do you intend to make up for what proteins and fats give you?0
-
-
Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves. They had groups in LA an San Diego, and urged it as a "lifestyle" for everyone.
My New England-dwelling self laughed my glutes off at the notion.0 -
I'm sure people have succeeded on every diet, and 80-10-10 types tend to be evangelistic, so I imagine they will be along. However, IMO cutting protein and fat so low on a reduced calorie diet is a terrible idea and results in poor nutrition. You'd do better trying to meet more traditional nutrition recommendations and filling your discretionary calories/carbs with fruit if you love fruit (but make sure to eat veggies too). Many of those who succeed on an 80-10-10 type of ratio tend to be endurance athlete types who have high calorie goals so 10% isn't nearly so low as for an average person, let alone someone on a deficit.0
-
HeySwoleSister wrote: »Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves. They had groups in LA an San Diego, and urged it as a "lifestyle" for everyone.
My New England-dwelling self laughed my glutes off at the notion.
I don't have a source atm, but yeah, there are some really crazy sects that do crap like that. I believe there is an account of a fruitarian who had a baby, didn't breastfeed it and instead fed it their stupid fruitarian diet, and the baby died.
People are morons.
*Edit: Found the source http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/1542293.stm
They were spared child cruelty jailtime because their intentions were "loving yet misguided."0 -
That much fruit would probably give me the runs, which would lead to rapid weight loss. Sounds like a solid plan to me.0
-
HeySwoleSister wrote: »Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves.
Hmm. That sounds like a cross between a fruitarian and a freegan.
Ah, what a world!0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »HeySwoleSister wrote: »Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves. They had groups in LA an San Diego, and urged it as a "lifestyle" for everyone.
My New England-dwelling self laughed my glutes off at the notion.
I don't have a source atm, but yeah, there are some really crazy sects that do crap like that. I believe there is an account of a fruitarian who had a baby, didn't breastfeed it and instead fed it their stupid fruitarian diet, and the baby died.
People are morons.
*Edit: Found the source http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/1542293.stm
They were spared child cruelty jailtime because their intentions were "loving yet misguided."
That's really upsetting. I've met a few lovingly and stubbornly misguided people in passing during my 61 long years, and I think they deserve the same penalties as anybody else.0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »HeySwoleSister wrote: »Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves.
Hmm. That sounds like a cross between a fruitarian and a freegan.
Ah, what a world!
Oh! Maybe they were freegans? IDK, it was a show about odd diet groups. There was a segment on the dumpster-divers (not actual homeless people, but hipsters who live off garbage in Brooklyn) as well. Maybe those are the freegans? Who knows. I just sat there and laughed. Where I live, the bears eat all the garbage, and 9 months out of the year the only "food" one can find overhanging public roadways is pine needles and dirty snow.0 -
I'm not sure about Fruitarian and keeping your protein/fat macros quite so low. But you may be interested in something closer to a low fat raw vegan life style.
I'm not a personal subscriber because my goals require quite a bit more protein than that. And I think the minimum fat macro should be about 35g to keep brain and hormone function. It may work for some, and might be a better idea than just fruit.0 -
As someone who is carb sensitive, I wouldn't recommend it. I did the vegan thing years ago and though I was at my smallest, I always was deficient in iron and my protein level was scary low. Not something I'd recommend. Are you active enough to where you can expend all those excess carbs (I know people will debate the carb is a carb thing but extra carbs & limited protein isn't a good thing, at least in my experience).0
-
I don't recommend this diet for two major reasons:
1) That many carbs and (if it comes from fruit) sugars is going to do horrors to your blood sugar. If you also eat at a calorie deficit, you may experience hypoglycemic symptoms: freezing limbs, irritability (like crying for no reason), and gnawing hunger.
2) You need proteins and fats in your diet to get both your essential amino acids (from protein) and essential fatty acids (from fat.) The word essential in this case means these have to come from your diet. Your body cannot produce them. At a calorie deficit, it is likely you won't be getting enough of these nutrients.*
Now, these are mostly warnings. There are people who micromanage their diet and nutrient intake enough to make this work, and some people have different needs than others. But be VERY careful. Do your homework. Get a professional involved.
* The proteins/fats don't have to come from animals, if you are leaning towards a vegan diet for ethical reasons. (Though some people medically can't be on a vegan diet longterm, and getting check ups is a good idea on any diet.)0 -
Freelee the banana girl does this whole fruit thing... claims to eat 30 bananas a day....... I tried it for 3 days...... got so sick that it took me months to recover. Others have gotten way worse than I did..... we are talking kidney problems. She claims it can cure everything..... including cancer. Other people just simply got fatter, and she just told them they were doing it wrong.
It's basically an eating disorder nothing more.0 -
As an aside, I was eating a very similar diet to this, plateaued constantly (despite no cheats and daily exercise) and my blood sugar kept crashing, and I was I so cold had to wear a jacket outside during summer... in Texas.
It took 6 months for me to lose 8lbs. And I was miserable that whole time.0 -
Here's why a bunch of misguided people are going to think this is a great diet:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/food/article-3069294/New-book-reveals-Beyonce-really-got-Met-Gala-body.html
There is no way that balance of macros could be healthy. What a crock.0 -
Here's why a bunch of misguided people are going to think this is a great diet:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/food/article-3069294/New-book-reveals-Beyonce-really-got-Met-Gala-body.html
There is no way that balance of macros could be healthy. What a crock.
Oh, no.
Should we start a pool as to when we'll see the first meeting of the "Beyonce fruit diet" and "waist cincher" threads?0 -
Didn't Beyonce do that master cleanse too?0
-
lemurcat12 wrote: »Didn't Beyonce do that master cleanse too?
I would think she most likely didn't actually do it but was paid to endorse it.0 -
HeySwoleSister wrote: »Here's why a bunch of misguided people are going to think this is a great diet:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/food/article-3069294/New-book-reveals-Beyonce-really-got-Met-Gala-body.html
There is no way that balance of macros could be healthy. What a crock.
Oh, no.
Should we start a pool as to when we'll see the first meeting of the "Beyonce fruit diet" and "waist cincher" threads?
Channel surfing last night and came across a TV ad for one of those things. Anyone seen it? Lord. That thing looks painful. Some sort of double velcro wrap thing. And, people will buy them.0 -
With that little protein, how does your body repair itself of even the damage done by daily living? How does the brain function with so little fat for processing?0
-
Here's why a bunch of misguided people are going to think this is a great diet:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/food/article-3069294/New-book-reveals-Beyonce-really-got-Met-Gala-body.html
There is no way that balance of macros could be healthy. What a crock.
Doing something like that for 22 days isn't a big deal, assuming you actually can do it. The kicker is what the average person would do for the next 22 days.0 -
No thanks. I have a job.0
-
This sounds like a job for Freelee the Banana Idiot. 10% protein? Screw that noise.0
-
pinkraynedropjacki wrote: »Freelee the banana girl does this whole fruit thing... claims to eat 30 bananas a day....... I tried it for 3 days...... got so sick that it took me months to recover. Others have gotten way worse than I did..... we are talking kidney problems. She claims it can cure everything..... including cancer. Other people just simply got fatter, and she just told them they were doing it wrong.
It's basically an eating disorder nothing more.
This. I've spent some time looking into the plan-read both Dr. Campbell and Dr. Graham books on it (Whole, and The 80/10/10 Diet). After reading both and spending time on Dr. Graham's website etc. I walked away feeling very uneasy about the whole thing-seems to be a very distorted and unhealthy woe. Now of course they preach that it's the best/healthiest way to eat but yeah-hang out at the forum on Dr. Graham's site for a while or the forum over at 30bananasaday and it's SCARY
0 -
Pretty sure they linked this diet to being a contributing factor in pancreatic cancer. The super high amounts of fructose damage the pancreas and liver. (Steve Jobs was a fruitarian and died of pancreatic cancer. Imagine that.)
There is no way a diet that high in carbs and low in protein is good for the body.0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »HeySwoleSister wrote: »Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves. They had groups in LA an San Diego, and urged it as a "lifestyle" for everyone.
My New England-dwelling self laughed my glutes off at the notion.
I don't have a source atm, but yeah, there are some really crazy sects that do crap like that. I believe there is an account of a fruitarian who had a baby, didn't breastfeed it and instead fed it their stupid fruitarian diet, and the baby died.
People are morons.
*Edit: Found the source http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/1542293.stm
They were spared child cruelty jailtime because their intentions were "loving yet misguided."
Umm can we say negligence, they were told over and over and they ignored,at some point this childs ill health became obvious and they still ignored. I would say if you want to avoid jail time then you need to agree to be sterilized. Either/or these people are too stupid to be allowed to procreate.
0 -
emmydoodles83 wrote: »Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »HeySwoleSister wrote: »Don't Fruitarians live off the fruit that grows on trees in people's yards but are on branches overhanging the sidewalk? I saw some documentary about some people that did that, and "Fruitarians" are what they called themselves. They had groups in LA an San Diego, and urged it as a "lifestyle" for everyone.
My New England-dwelling self laughed my glutes off at the notion.
I don't have a source atm, but yeah, there are some really crazy sects that do crap like that. I believe there is an account of a fruitarian who had a baby, didn't breastfeed it and instead fed it their stupid fruitarian diet, and the baby died.
People are morons.
*Edit: Found the source http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/1542293.stm
They were spared child cruelty jailtime because their intentions were "loving yet misguided."
Umm can we say negligence, they were told over and over and they ignored,at some point this childs ill health became obvious and they still ignored. I would say if you want to avoid jail time then you need to agree to be sterilized. Either/or these people are too stupid to be allowed to procreate.
My thoughts exactly. People that stupid certainly don't need to be spreading their genes around like that.0 -
Here's why a bunch of misguided people are going to think this is a great diet:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/food/article-3069294/New-book-reveals-Beyonce-really-got-Met-Gala-body.html
There is no way that balance of macros could be healthy. What a crock.
Doing something like that for 22 days isn't a big deal, assuming you actually can do it. The kicker is what the average person would do for the next 22 days.
I don't know, I would think going that low in fat and protein and that heavy in carbs would make you feel fairly badly within a few days. It would me, I know. I couldn't eat like that for 1 day. Then again, I do low-carb and I'm speaking for myself only. To each their own!0 -
Here's why a bunch of misguided people are going to think this is a great diet:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/food/article-3069294/New-book-reveals-Beyonce-really-got-Met-Gala-body.html
There is no way that balance of macros could be healthy. What a crock.
Doing something like that for 22 days isn't a big deal, assuming you actually can do it. The kicker is what the average person would do for the next 22 days.
I don't know, I would think going that low in fat and protein and that heavy in carbs would make you feel fairly badly within a few days. It would me, I know. I couldn't eat like that for 1 day. Then again, I do low-carb and I'm speaking for myself only. To each their own!
Same for me. But I was talking more along the lines of long term physical/metabolic changes. In only 22 days, you're aren't going to do irreparable damage to yourself. So there isn't a significant inherent danger to it. Then, after the 22 days are over, most people will experience some sort of rebound. After which, are they really ahead of the game?
Sorry I wasn't clear... I wasn't arguing against your post/point.0 -
I'd never heard of Fruitarian before but given how imbalanced it is I'm not surprised... I actively ignore nonsense.
Speaking of nonsense here's an actor who followed the diet for the Steve Jobs movie.
http://health.usnews.com/health-news/articles/2013/02/07/ashton-kutchers-fruitarian-diet-what-went-wrong
Ended up in hospital, rather as you'd expect.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 420 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions