Bmi of less than 16 anorexic?

Straight up, you're hovering on the edge of a very unhealthy weight.

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

Hi so I am 5'6 and weigh 96 lbs and I have been told that this is anorexia? But there are others who are truly anorexic at 85 lbs or lower, in order to gain they can eat 3000 calories. I tried eating only 1500 and I gained rapidly 4 lbs in a month, so does this mean that I should not even bother with 2500 per day?

You tried eating 1500 calories... from what? Were you eating less than that?
If the answer is yes.. then yeah, you could quite possibly have anorexia. Are you purposely restricting your calories?

And yes, you are underweight.

BTW, if you upped your calories TO 1500 calories and gained weight, that's your glycogen stores replenishing... it's not fat, and it's temporary. You should continue to increase your calories... probably about 100 calories a week until you hit your desired calorie goal...which should be at least maintenance as you don't need to lose weight, and should in fact gain.

And lastly, speak with your physician to address any of your health/weight concerns.

Just cherry picking from your previous posts (ALL of which are to do with your eating disorder), this one stands out:

Hello so I am anorexic. 5'6 and 96lbs. I saw a dietician yesterday she said to eat whatever and doesn't matter the amount. Does that mean go to mcdonalds and supersize it? Lol what do yu think I should do? Where should I start that won't terrify me?

So yes. You're anorexic. You know you are, you've had multiple threads discussing it. Your husband is worried about you, you have a nutritionist telling you to eat. You need to stop trying to run from a diagnosis and stop seeking reassurance that you don't have a problem because you do. You know you do. Please keep seeking help. Lean on your supportive and worried husband. Concentrate on getting better rather than trying to deny that you have this problem. Acceptance of an issue is the first vital step to recovery.

Just cherry picking from your previous posts (ALL of which are to do with your eating disorder), this one stands out:

Hello so I am anorexic. 5'6 and 96lbs. I saw a dietician yesterday she said to eat whatever and doesn't matter the amount. Does that mean go to mcdonalds and supersize it? Lol what do yu think I should do? Where should I start that won't terrify me?

So yes. You're anorexic. You know you are, you've had multiple threads discussing it. Your husband is worried about you, you have a nutritionist telling you to eat. You need to stop trying to run from a diagnosis and stop seeking reassurance that you don't have a problem because you do. You know you do. Please keep seeking help. Lean on your supportive and worried husband. Concentrate on getting better rather than trying to deny that you have this problem. Acceptance of an issue is the first vital step to recovery.

But why do I gain off of so little calories compared to other recoveries?

Because you aren't gaining fat, your just experiencing the rapid gain of fluid and glycogen stores which people see after restricting for so long and having their stores depleted. You aren't giving yourself a chance to stabilise, you're seeing a gain and panicking. You need to be getting proper treatment from a proper ED therapist. You need to stop comparing yourself to other recoveries and decide that your recovery is more important that that number on the scale ESPECIALLY in the short term. Please get help. Real help.

Just cherry picking from your previous posts (ALL of which are to do with your eating disorder), this one stands out:

Hello so I am anorexic. 5'6 and 96lbs. I saw a dietician yesterday she said to eat whatever and doesn't matter the amount. Does that mean go to mcdonalds and supersize it? Lol what do yu think I should do? Where should I start that won't terrify me?

So yes. You're anorexic. You know you are, you've had multiple threads discussing it. Your husband is worried about you, you have a nutritionist telling you to eat. You need to stop trying to run from a diagnosis and stop seeking reassurance that you don't have a problem because you do. You know you do. Please keep seeking help. Lean on your supportive and worried husband. Concentrate on getting better rather than trying to deny that you have this problem. Acceptance of an issue is the first vital step to recovery.

But why do I gain off of so little calories compared to other recoveries?

As stated before, your gains are due to glycogen stores replenishing in your muscles. This is not a gain of fat. If your body is gaining any mass at all, it is the result of your body panic-storing everything it possibly can, as a result of you starving it for so long. Most people see rapid gain when entering recovery from a restrictive eating disorder. The gains slow down, level off, and redistribute. The actual gain is irrelevant, as the entire goal of anorexia recovery is for you to become health-restored, whatever that means. This extreme obsession with very small weight gains (4 pounds in a month? really?) is very unhealthy and disordered, and you know fully well that the rest of it is disordered as hell.

I have seen your multiple threads asking if you have an eating disorder. Why are you wasting your time asking these questions? We cannot give you reassurance that you don't. We cannot lie and tell you that you are healthy. Regardless of your state of body health (which I gather is suffering badly), your extreme fixation on weight and calorie restriction is a strong enough indicator alone that the state of your mental and emotional health is in a bad place.

As someone who is also recovering from a restrictive eating disorder, I advise you to speak with your husband or another trusted support person. Your health can improve. Your fear can be conquered. But you will not achieve these things sitting around on a calorie counting website asking for people to lie to you and tell you you're fine. You already know the answer to that.

A BMI of less than 16 is underweight.
Trying to lose weight at a BMI of less than 16 is indicative of anorexia.

Anorexia is not a state of being, or a given condition--it's not like being anemic. Anorexia is an emotional disorder characterized by an "obsessive desire to lose weight by refusing to eat."

So what you definitely are is underweight. Pretty significantly. Only you know if it is due to an obsession for weight loss or fear of food. I would speak to a doctor, rather than a message board community about this. This is a serious health discussion that will require a serious professional's opinion. Good luck, and I hope everything works out well for you.

Anorexia is a disease, not a weight.

Speaking as someone who batted Anorexia and won. What you describe is no way near Anorexia. As someone already posted it is a physiological problem mainly and not just being underweight. If you are forcing yourself to throw up, starving yourself and hiding it from people I suggest you go see your doctor. However if you are not doing the above I still suggest you see your doctor for advise on how to gain weight. Maybe you have a thyroid problem. Anyway good luck whatever the result.

This topic is a year old... not sure why it got resurrected?