Frustrated with lack of consistency of Calorie counts for foods on MFP
Bshmerlie
Posts: 1,026 Member
The calorie counts for just about all items are all over the board. Today I was putting in simple 8 ounces of chicken breast skinless. The calorie counts for that same 8 ounces can be anywhere from 360 to over 900. Check out my diary as I entered in all the different options when it came to choosing chicken. Descrepencies can be found on most items. Everyone is always telling people to make sure they are weighing their food but the calorie counts could be off by several hundred per day depending upon which items they select from the drop down list on MFP. Is there a website that has true calories counts for basic protiens, fruits and vegetables? Ya know....things that don't come in packages.
0
Replies
-
I use http://ndb.nal.usda.gov/ndb/foods for stuff that doesn't have nutrition on the package.0
-
208 grams of protein...I wonder what that person was thinking when they entered it.
Definitely compare to USDA's nutritional information. This thread will also help you weed those kinds of things out: community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide0 -
I usually weigh in grams and put "usda" after my search (For example, search, "Boneless skinless chicken breasts USDA") ... there are still variations, but I look through to see which ones have member confirmations, or I compare different ones. Like, if a few entries say 150 calories, a couple say 155 calories, one says 200 calories and one says 900 calories, I'll probably pick the 155 calorie one, as it's close to the most popular one, but I'm estimating just a little more to be safe. That's just me though. Any other suggestions?0
-
208 grams of protein...I wonder what that person was thinking when they entered it.
Definitely compare to USDA's nutritional information. This thread will also help you weed those kinds of things out: community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide
I was going to link this if it wasn't already. I found this extremely helpful.
For whole foods use the non-asterisk entries where possible, and make sure you use the one for the state of the food when weighed (i.e., if you weigh chicken after cooking, don't use the raw entry). Compare with the USDA site if you are unsure, and avoid user-entered recipes and foods where possible. If it's a packaged food, compare with the package information you have.0 -
It is annoying, I wish they had someone to cull it a bit. But yeah, I usually check the FDA website and that link @malibu927 posted before I add food to my food diary.0
-
I looked at canned chicken.
The serving size for a 12 oz can was 2 ounces, the label said 6 servings per can. Ok, then I drained off the water and weighed the chicken---8 ounces.
Did I pour off two whole servings? Hmm...
So I looked up the calories in chicken broth. Figured that would give a decent estimate for the water I poured out of the can.
Very low calories per ounce. Seriously, around 7 calories per ounce. 60 calories per serving multiplied by 6 servings in the can comes to 360 calories. But I poured off 4 ounces, and those took with them ~28 calories. So now the chicken left over is 360-28= 332 calories.
8 ounces of the canned chicken would be 4 servings. Divide 332 by 4 and you get 83 calories per serving, not 60 like on the label.
That doesn't seem like an enormous discrepancy, but it's over 20% higher. Extrapolate that out over 2000 calories and you could be 400 calories higher than you thought. That could be rather significant.
Edit:
My math ain't so good...
As I look on Swanson's website, their chicken broth is about 1.2 calories per ounce. That means 360 (total can's calories) minus only 5, and divided by 4 servings. That means 89 calories per serving. 29 calories more than the listed serving. That is 48% higher than the label.
If you are on a 1600-calorie-par-day limit and are off in measuring by 48%, you are actually eating close to 2400 calories.0 -
I try to use the system generated listing, and get irked at so many people's need to put in their own listing. I can't even find the system's listing for chicken breast any more. Fortunately, it was in Frequent for lunch so I was able to copy it into breakfast.
I do wish the database would get cleaned of duplicate entries.0 -
So according to the USA website my 8 oz of boneless skinless chicken breast is only 272 calories? Am I reading that right.0
-
-
So basically on days that I eat chicken I've been shorting myself about 200 calories. And thats just on the chicken....
0 -
Assuming you weighed it raw, yes.
If you weighed it cooked, it was more.0 -
But keep in mind, that is meat only, and RAW.
8oz of COOKED will be a lot higher.0 -
0 -
-
So basically on days that I eat chicken I've been shorting myself about 200 calories. And thats just on the chicken....
Yup hence the reason I made the post about "logging accurately" and I often mention "are you choosing the correct entries"
If MFP premium came with only USDA calorie entries and from the manufacturer I would pay...
0 -
TheLegendaryBrandonHarris wrote: »I looked at canned chicken.
The serving size for a 12 oz can was 2 ounces, the label said 6 servings per can. Ok, then I drained off the water and weighed the chicken---8 ounces.
Did I pour off two whole servings? Hmm...
So I looked up the calories in chicken broth. Figured that would give a decent estimate for the water I poured out of the can.
Very low calories per ounce. Seriously, around 7 calories per ounce. 60 calories per serving multiplied by 6 servings in the can comes to 360 calories. But I poured off 4 ounces, and those took with them ~28 calories. So now the chicken left over is 360-28= 332 calories.
8 ounces of the canned chicken would be 4 servings. Divide 332 by 4 and you get 83 calories per serving, not 60 like on the label.
That doesn't seem like an enormous discrepancy, but it's over 20% higher. Extrapolate that out over 2000 calories and you could be 400 calories higher than you thought. That could be rather significant.
Edit:
My math ain't so good...
As I look on Swanson's website, their chicken broth is about 1.2 calories per ounce. That means 360 (total can's calories) minus only 5, and divided by 4 servings. That means 89 calories per serving. 29 calories more than the listed serving. That is 48% higher than the label.
If you are on a 1600-calorie-par-day limit and are off in measuring by 48%, you are actually eating close to 2400 calories.
That's exactly my point. Some people wonder why they are not losing weight sometimes. Sometimes it doesn't matter if your're weighing all your food correctly you could still be off by hundreds of calories a day depending upon what you eat.0 -
Sorry, not breast, but I plugged that in and got 370 calories for 8 ounces cooked.0 -
So basically on days that I eat chicken I've been shorting myself about 200 calories. And thats just on the chicken....
Yup hence the reason I made the post about "logging accurately" and I often mention "are you choosing the correct entries"
If MFP premium came with only USDA calorie entries and from the manufacturer I would pay...
Ditto.
0 -
That USDA page is handy.0
-
Thanx for the tip on that nutrition website. When you get several thousand people adding info on the data base, there are bound to be discrepancies. That's why when I add something to the database, I add "from label" in the description. If nothing else, to be able to find my own submission instead of some of the others.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
flamingblades wrote: »Thanx for the tip on that nutrition website. When you get several thousand people adding info on the data base, there are bound to be discrepancies. That's why when I add something to the database, I add "from label" in the description. If nothing else, to be able to find my own submission instead of some of the others.
I just wished MFP didn't force us to share it..which they do. I have tried to uncheck "add to database" but it "rechecks" when I hit submit.0 -
TheLegendaryBrandonHarris wrote: »
Sorry, not breast, but I plugged that in and got 370 calories for 8 ounces cooked.
I looked up chicken breast skinless raw 8 oz and it was 272 calories on the USDA website. I don't think its going to increase in calories simply because it is thrown on a BBQ. How would they know what kind of seasoning I'm using? How does it go from 272 calories raw to 370 cooked?0 -
Since there no way to request corrections to obviously erroneous nutrition information found in the database, it's no surprise that it is so full of discrepancies. I realize this service is free, but in order for it to be useful, it needs to be somewhat accurate. It's too bad they don't have a mechanism for corrections.0
-
If you use the app the items with green ticks have been verified and therefore should be correct. If you're on the website look for the ones without stars. A star means user submitted.0
-
Chicken, broilers or fryers, breast, meat only, cooked, roasted: 100g = 165 calories
Chicken, broiler or fryers, breast, skinless, boneless, meat only, raw: 100g = 120 calories
Off by almost 38%.
Think about that...for every 1000 calories you THINK you are consuming, it's actually 1380.
On a 2000-calorie diet, you're consuming 2,760.0 -
I looked up chicken breast skinless raw 8 oz and it was 272 calories on the USDA website. I don't think its going to increase in calories simply because it is thrown on a BBQ. How would they know what kind of seasoning I'm using? How does it go from 272 calories raw to 370 cooked?
Because 8 ounces raw becomes lighter after you cook away the water and fats inside it. Your 8-ounce piece of raw breast meat would only be ~5 ounces cooked.
So, if you cook your chicken breast and then measure out 8 ounces, you are eating what started out as a raw 11-ounce piece.0 -
If you start with an 8-ounce piece of raw chicken, cook it and eat it, then yes, you'll still be at 272 calories. However, the weight of your chicken was less than 8 ounces at the time you ate it.0
-
So how does meat gain calories by roasting it? I'm assuming thats a rotisserie? Doesn't make sense.0
-
Now...wait a second....your top one (roasted) doesn't say skinless.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions