I gained weight?
laurenpthomas9510
Posts: 13 Member
So I am coming from a place of absolute anger and frustration. I have been so good this week and came in below my calorie allotment for almost every single day for a week, I weighed myself today, and I have gained. It was only a gain of .4 pounds but I got so angry I almost through the scale across the room. I am on my period (sorry if that's TMI) but I don't feel bloated. The only other thing I can think is that normally I weigh myself every morning and today I weighed in the evening? I don't know what to think or what I am doing wrong. Sorry for the rant, but I would really like some suggestions or ideas. Thanks in advance.
-Lauren.
-Lauren.
0
Replies
-
You've answered your own question
If I want a horrible shock when I step on the scale I'll make sure and weigh in the evening, and as an added crappy bonus I will also do this at that time of the month. Double points 
Pick a day away from your periods. Weigh first thing in the morning, after going to the loo, and before eating to get a more accurate reading.0 -
how does a piece of equipment cause so much anger...if it does it's time to take a step back from it.
if a song comes on the radio you don't like do you beat the radio???
0 -
You weighed in the evening...on your period. I'd probably weigh about 10 lbs more.0
-
If you weigh yourself in the evening, you're also weighing a good portion of what you've eaten and drank throughout the day. Your body has finished digesting some, but not all, so a portion is still in your system. That will make the number different than what you would see in the morning. Don't weigh yourself at night.
Many women also retain water during their period, some up to 5lbs. I know I do, but my physical appearance doesn't change too much anymore. I used to bloat like crazy and it's much less now.
Always, always, ALWAYS weigh yourself under the same conditions - most people here would say that should be first thing in the morning, after going to the bathroom and before getting dressed, having breakfast, etc.
~Lyssa0 -
christinev297 wrote: »You've answered your own question If I want a horrible shock when I step on the scale I'll make sure and weigh in the evening, and as an added crappy bonus I will also do this at that time of the month. Double points
Pick a day away from your periods. Weigh first thing in the morning, after going to the loo, and before eating to get a more accurate reading.
True stuff.
0 -
Yep, it's your period! Don't freak out too much, although I know that's awfully hard to do.
I have gone over my calories once in something like 160 days. I didn't gain that week. I gain every time I drink alcohol (which is rarely). I give out a little scream and then know that the gain isn't real and will resolve itself. Yours will too. 0 -
If I weighed myself in the evening, during shark week, and my weight was only up .4 pound, I'd be doing the happy dance.
0 -
Timorous_Beastie wrote: »If I weighed myself in the evening, during shark week, and my weight was only up .4 pound, I'd be doing the happy dance.
Me too.0 -
Timorous_Beastie wrote: »If I weighed myself in the evening, during shark week, and my weight was only up .4 pound, I'd be doing the happy dance.
That totally made me smile. I guess I just freaked out because I just started getting serious about my dieting again, and I worked SO hard this week.0 -
I think the reason I got so mad was simply because I have been working so hard, seeing some results, and finally doing it the healthy way. I had an eating disorder in high school and so losing weight in a healthy way is difficult for me, and this is my first "setback" so to say. But I certainly do see your point, and will taking a moment to re-evaluate the reason's I am trying to lose weight.how does a piece of equipment cause so much anger...if it does it's time to take a step back from it.
if a song comes on the radio you don't like do you beat the radio???
0 -
I know better than to weigh in the evening. As I said to SezxyStef, I used to have an eating disorder, and even though I am recovered now, scales can still be very upsetting. Usually I only weigh once a week and it is in the morning after I use the bathroom and before I eat or drink anything.0 -
Thank you all for your replies, as they put my thoughts back into perspective. Almost all of you were very helpful, thank you!0
-
laurenpthomas9510 wrote: »
I think the reason I got so mad was simply because I have been working so hard, seeing some results, and finally doing it the healthy way. I had an eating disorder in high school and so losing weight in a healthy way is difficult for me, and this is my first "setback" so to say. But I certainly do see your point, and will taking a moment to re-evaluate the reason's I am trying to lose weight.how does a piece of equipment cause so much anger...if it does it's time to take a step back from it.
if a song comes on the radio you don't like do you beat the radio???
I could have written this post I had similar troubles in high school and still struggle sometimes. It's a tough thing to get past, so kudos to you!
Keep in mind that weight loss is NOT a linear thing. Over time (time being 4-6 weeks and then some) you should have a downward trend. But you won't be constantly losing, especially as a woman. Hormones wreak havoc with water retention, plus excess sodium and working your muscles will cause water retention, too. That retention will easily mask fat loss. If you're accurate with your logging, you could be losing fat but the scale won't show you because you're retaining an equal or higher amount of water.
If you're exercising and you weigh weekly, weigh on the day AFTER you've rested. That should help get an accurate number. Consider taking measurements, too, as those may change even though the scale weight doesn't.
I like to weigh daily so I have the data. If my weight is holding steady for more than a few days, that usually means I'm consuming too much sodium or something similar. It's not something I worry about, but it's nice to have the numbers.
This is my weight loss over the course of a few months. You'll see my weight bobs down and up quite a bit, but goes down overall.
Keep it up! You can do this
~Lyssa0 -
Lauren, i know exactly how you feel because i weigh myself daily and obsess over every lb gained, but the truth is day-to-day you can lose or gain several lbs in waterweight.
Around our period we're particularly prone to water retention, which can see the scale rise significantly (im not just talking 0.4lbs here)..
Also i believe you should try to weigh yourself at the same time, ie, 1st thing in the morning, after the bathroom (TMI) & before you eat/drink anything, wearing the same clothes each time (or naked like i do- i figure its more accurate lol). If you weigh yourself in the evening you've got all that food and drink in your stomach that you wouldnt have early in the morning.
So, if youve been sticking to your correct calories for your deficit, for the reasons above i doubt youve put weight on at all. Hope that makes you feel a little better 0 -
christinev297 wrote: »You've answered your own question If I want a horrible shock when I step on the scale I'll make sure and weigh in the evening, and as an added crappy bonus I will also do this at that time of the month. Double points
Pick a day away from your periods. Weigh first thing in the morning, after going to the loo, and before eating to get a more accurate reading.
Haha, yes, exactly. I can be 5 pounds more on my cycle. Add to that end of the day where I can be up 2 pounds, so that's like a 7 pound gain during "that time of the month. No worries. If you're under goal, you'll lose. Wait a bit longer.
0 -
CoconuttyMummy wrote: »Lauren, i know exactly how you feel because i weigh myself daily and obsess over every lb gained, but the truth is day-to-day you can lose or gain several lbs in waterweight.
Around our period we're particularly prone to water retention, which can see the scale rise significantly (im not just talking 0.4lbs here)..
Also i believe you should try to weigh yourself at the same time, ie, 1st thing in the morning, after the bathroom (TMI) & before you eat/drink anything, wearing the same clothes each time (or naked like i do- i figure its more accurate lol). If you weigh yourself in the evening you've got all that food and drink in your stomach that you wouldnt have early in the morning.
So, if youve been sticking to your correct calories for your deficit, for the reasons above i doubt youve put weight on at all. Hope that makes you feel a little better
That reply was very sweet and thoughtful and I very very much so appreciate it. Normally I weigh at the same time everyday, naked, in the morning, after the bathroom, and before food or water. I weigh almost obsessively but I have been staying with a friend who does not have a scale, so I made the mistake of weighing myself the first thing when I got home instead of waiting like I should have. It definitely helps to hear that weight fluctuates and that that is just part of this. (as infuriating and frustrating as it may be)0 -
macgurlnet wrote: »laurenpthomas9510 wrote: »
I think the reason I got so mad was simply because I have been working so hard, seeing some results, and finally doing it the healthy way. I had an eating disorder in high school and so losing weight in a healthy way is difficult for me, and this is my first "setback" so to say. But I certainly do see your point, and will taking a moment to re-evaluate the reason's I am trying to lose weight.how does a piece of equipment cause so much anger...if it does it's time to take a step back from it.
if a song comes on the radio you don't like do you beat the radio???
I could have written this post I had similar troubles in high school and still struggle sometimes. It's a tough thing to get past, so kudos to you!
Keep in mind that weight loss is NOT a linear thing. Over time (time being 4-6 weeks and then some) you should have a downward trend. But you won't be constantly losing, especially as a woman. Hormones wreak havoc with water retention, plus excess sodium and working your muscles will cause water retention, too. That retention will easily mask fat loss. If you're accurate with your logging, you could be losing fat but the scale won't show you because you're retaining an equal or higher amount of water.
If you're exercising and you weigh weekly, weigh on the day AFTER you've rested. That should help get an accurate number. Consider taking measurements, too, as those may change even though the scale weight doesn't.
I like to weigh daily so I have the data. If my weight is holding steady for more than a few days, that usually means I'm consuming too much sodium or something similar. It's not something I worry about, but it's nice to have the numbers.
This is my weight loss over the course of a few months. You'll see my weight bobs down and up quite a bit, but goes down overall.
Keep it up! You can do this
~Lyssa
This was extraordinarily helpful to see and to think about. Honestly I weigh everyday just so myfitnesspal has the numbers, but I weigh on Monday's as my "did I lose the 2 pounds I was supposed to have lost this week" day. Seeing the chart was a good reminder to both me (and the ED voice in my head I still sometimes hear) that .4 pounds is not that big of a deal (:0 -
laurenpthomas9510 wrote: »macgurlnet wrote: »laurenpthomas9510 wrote: »
I think the reason I got so mad was simply because I have been working so hard, seeing some results, and finally doing it the healthy way. I had an eating disorder in high school and so losing weight in a healthy way is difficult for me, and this is my first "setback" so to say. But I certainly do see your point, and will taking a moment to re-evaluate the reason's I am trying to lose weight.how does a piece of equipment cause so much anger...if it does it's time to take a step back from it.
if a song comes on the radio you don't like do you beat the radio???
I could have written this post I had similar troubles in high school and still struggle sometimes. It's a tough thing to get past, so kudos to you!
Keep in mind that weight loss is NOT a linear thing. Over time (time being 4-6 weeks and then some) you should have a downward trend. But you won't be constantly losing, especially as a woman. Hormones wreak havoc with water retention, plus excess sodium and working your muscles will cause water retention, too. That retention will easily mask fat loss. If you're accurate with your logging, you could be losing fat but the scale won't show you because you're retaining an equal or higher amount of water.
If you're exercising and you weigh weekly, weigh on the day AFTER you've rested. That should help get an accurate number. Consider taking measurements, too, as those may change even though the scale weight doesn't.
I like to weigh daily so I have the data. If my weight is holding steady for more than a few days, that usually means I'm consuming too much sodium or something similar. It's not something I worry about, but it's nice to have the numbers.
This is my weight loss over the course of a few months. You'll see my weight bobs down and up quite a bit, but goes down overall.
Keep it up! You can do this
~Lyssa
This was extraordinarily helpful to see and to think about. Honestly I weigh everyday just so myfitnesspal has the numbers, but I weigh on Monday's as my "did I lose the 2 pounds I was supposed to have lost this week" day. Seeing the chart was a good reminder to both me (and the ED voice in my head I still sometimes hear) that .4 pounds is not that big of a deal (:
The ED voice might quiet some over time - I know mine has
You very likely won't see the 2 pound loss every single week. But you should see an 8 pound loss over the course of 4 weeks. Keep in mind that water weight and TOM will have an affect on that, so maybe it'll only be 3-5 pounds on the scale, but you might see a difference despite the number.
That graph is from trendweight.com - I log my weight in via the Fitbit app, which syncs to MFP and trendweight.com. There are other apps for phones, like Happy Scale, which will do similar graphs. The graph has really, really helped put this in perspective for me, especially since my weight loss is pretty slow now. Even if the trend is just slightly down, it's still going down
~Lyssa
0 -
Rule number one do not look at the scale. Scales are not the best measurements during weight loss; try focusing on body measurements or lose of body fat. Plus, every scale is different. The number can change depending on the surface the scale is on or the calibration.
Because you're on your period, that might be the reason you agains .4 of a pound. Don't give up, a lot people have ups and down during their weight loss journey.
Best wishes!0 -
Why are you weighing yourself so much? You know that your weight can fluctuate +-5 pounds on any given day? Pick 1 day a week, 1 time a week, and even that don't let be the only measure of your success
0 -
A period will make you gain. You need to wait longer than a week to see results.0
-
honkytonks85 wrote: »A period will make you gain. You need to wait longer than a week to see results.
Been doing this for almost two months. Have only had myfitnesspal for like a week.0 -
I really don't understand why people refuse to use one of the many, free, "trendline generating" apps when it comes to weighing themselves.
Your weight goes up and down on a regular basis because of external "noise'. Hormones, salt, random sun-spots.
You should weigh yourself daily at about the same time, preferably in the morning, after you've used the bathroom, and before you've eaten or drank anything,
Then either automatically or manually INPUT THE NUMBER IN THE APP (or spreadsheet, or other magical trendline generating device).
Presto you cut through the crud and figure out whether you're really gaining or really losing weight!
And you avoid all the agony and drama!
www.weightgrapher.com
Scooby's web site also has an excel spreadsheet you can use.0 -
Period causes water retention for most. A 0.4 gain is not much at all ( like 1 cup of water literally ).
0 -
You might not feel bloated, but you still might be. I don't feel bloated right now (my monthly visitor arrived yesterday) but I certainly looked bloated in the dress I wore today! I was going to weigh myself today as I haven't in a couple weeks now, but knew with my visitor here it was the wrong time to weigh myself. Once she's gone I will, first thing in the morning after I've gone to the bathroom.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions