We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Healthier Snickers Pie

jessmomof3
jessmomof3 Posts: 4,590 Member
edited September 2024 in Recipes
A friend of mine made this and shared her recipe. My kids loved this healthy version!


Healthier Snickers Pie

1/2 gallon fat free Vanilla frozen yogurt

8 oz container of Cool Whip

1/2 cup (or more) of Grapenuts cereal

2/3 cup (or less) natural peanut butter

1 small box sugar free instant chocolate pudding

2 graham cracker crusts (reduced fat)

Soften yogurt. Blend in peanut butter & dry pudding mix. Stir in cool whip and Grapenuts.

Pour into 2 crusts. Freeze until firm and then top with additional cool whip. Freeze another

3-4 hours.

Makes 2 pies: Using fat free vanilla yogurt, sugar free cool whip, sugar free pudding, and reduced fat graham cracker crusts... here is what I figured out for calories for 20 servings (10 servings per pie).

212 calories/ 35g carb/ 2g fiber/ 7g fat/ 6g protein

I think you could even make it without the crusts (or use a different type of crust) and cut back on the carbs/ calories even more.

I added it to the database under Healthier Snickers Pie and submitted the recipe. :bigsmile:

Replies

  • dbendelow
    dbendelow Posts: 27
    ooo this sounds lush, but whats the UK equivalnt of cool whip?? :/:blushing:
  • Melbel85
    Melbel85 Posts: 240 Member
    Bump!
  • brookiemo
    brookiemo Posts: 15 Member
    bump
  • lucky723
    lucky723 Posts: 52
    Bump!!!
  • NanBar
    NanBar Posts: 283 Member
    bump
  • LissaBaby14
    LissaBaby14 Posts: 46
    That is awesome! Thanks so much for sharing!!
  • jessmomof3
    jessmomof3 Posts: 4,590 Member
    I think you could also add in some regular or chocolate PB2 to cut back on calories as well. I just shared the original recipe that my friend gave me. :bigsmile: Lots of possibilities!
  • stephstrege
    stephstrege Posts: 62 Member
    Sounds great! Thanks for sharing!
  • Tzavush
    Tzavush Posts: 389 Member
    Yumm...just yumm...
    i might try replacing the pb with almond butter ...
  • jessmomof3
    jessmomof3 Posts: 4,590 Member
    Yumm...just yumm...
    i might try replacing the pb with almond butter ...

    That would work great too! Also I had thought about using ground up almonds for a crust instead of graham crackers. :wink:
  • runnerdad
    runnerdad Posts: 2,081 Member
    Thanks Jess - sounds great!
  • BrandyH20
    BrandyH20 Posts: 63
    bump
  • Losershawn
    Losershawn Posts: 152
    Sounds great....will definitely have to try it.
  • gp79
    gp79 Posts: 1,799 Member
    No doubt this would taste great...I could even eat the entire pie :) But it's not necessarily low calorie. 1/10th of a pie is not much for 212 calories.

    I think I'd rather eat an entire box of Jello Pudding (big box) made with almond milk and either a crushed graham cracker / reduced fat oreo on top.
  • jessmomof3
    jessmomof3 Posts: 4,590 Member
    Bumping this up w/ a little lower cal version! I made this for a family get together tomorrow.

    Healthier Snickers Pie
    1/2 gallon fat free Vanilla frozen yogurt
    8 oz container of Cool Whip
    1/2 cup (or more) of Grapenuts cereal
    2/3 cup (or less) natural peanut butter (I used crunchy!)
    1 small box sugar free instant chocolate pudding
    4 servings of Keebler mini vanilla wafers (crushed) <this saves a TON of calories rather than using a graham cracker crust!>

    Soften yogurt. Blend in peanut butter & dry pudding mix. Stir in cool whip and Grapenuts.
    Pour into crushed vanilla wafers in a 9 x 13" pan. Freeze until firm and then top with additional cool whip. Freeze another
    3-4 hours.
    I figured it for 24 servings from the 9 x 13" pan.

    134 calories/ 23g carb/ 4g fat/ 4g protein/ 1g fiber/ 141 mg sodium

    Ingredients Calories Carbs Fat Protein Fiber Sodium
    Blue Bunny - Fat Free Frozen Yogurt (Vanilla), 1 container (7 cups ea.) 980 266 0 56 0 840
    Cool Whip - Free, 1 container (50 tbsp ea.) 375 75 0 0 0 125
    Post Cereals - Grapenuts, 1/2 cup (58g) 200 48 1 7 7 290
    Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter - Peanut Butter, 10 tbsp 950 40 80 35 10 400
    Jello Sugar Free Pudding - Chocolate (Mix Only), 1 container (1 package ea.) 140 32 0 4 4 1,240
    Keebler - Mini Vanilla Wafers, 72 cookies 560 84 24 4 4 480

    Add Ingredient
    Total: 3205 545 105 106 25 3375
    Per Serving: 134 23 4 4 1 141
  • SatelliteCrush80
    SatelliteCrush80 Posts: 3,575 Member
    Bump :flowerforyou:
  • h3h8m3
    h3h8m3 Posts: 455 Member
    We have this same recipe. It's really quite good. Doesn't really taste like snickers... but it's still delicious.
  • serabee5
    serabee5 Posts: 89
    I have made this before but used crunchy peanut butter not grape nuts....sounds good :)
  • westbrja
    westbrja Posts: 111 Member
    I have made this before but used crunchy peanut butter not grape nuts....sounds good :)

    I like this idea! I'm not a huge Grapenuts fan plus that would cut out 200 more calories :smile: The recipe sounds great though. Maybe I'll take it to my next work potluck.
  • rkdesmond
    rkdesmond Posts: 23
    Bump!
  • tmarie2715
    tmarie2715 Posts: 1,111 Member
    I think you could also add in some regular or chocolate PB2 to cut back on calories as well. I just shared the original recipe that my friend gave me. :bigsmile: Lots of possibilities!

    And fat free Cool Whip would cut some cals as well, if you are okay with artifical sweetners. :) Thanks for a good summer dessert!
  • kunmingmom
    kunmingmom Posts: 60 Member
    bump!!
This discussion has been closed.

Categories