How Many People Are Not Increasing Their Activity Level As Part Of Their Weight Loss Plan?

I haven't had time to ramp up activity, but I'm having success just cutting calories and not eating out as much. That said, I do obsess about food and its only been a week, so maybe I should take that advice...

bcalvanese wrote: »

Are you including exercise into your plan in addition to cutting calories, or just cutting calories?

I am doing both, and think it would be much harder to just cut calories. If I sit around all day, I think of eating more, and wind up using up most of my calories too soon in the day. When I increased my activity level with exercise, I think about eating less, and have plenty of calories left over later in the day. In addition, the calories I have burned adds even more calories, so by the end of the day, I may still have calories left over, and am not even really hungry.

I think this is a very important point, because it could mean the difference between succeeding or not.

I think working out is incredibly important to body composition and mental health. I don't do it for weight loss, especially since it makes me hungrier. I've seen enough successful wheelchair users to know that it is not, in fact, "the difference between succeeding or not."

But let me tell you--if you can, you should. When the scale slows down, it helps take inches off. And running NSVs feel as good as scale victories to me.

You can succeed at weight loss without exercise, but the closer you get to a normal weight the tighter your metabolic range becomes. Exercise can help give you more calories to work with, but the biggest differentiator is how well a person manages their intake.

Since exercise calorie burns are very difficult to estimate accurately, even with fitness monitors, it is better to accurately manage intake to reduce the overall error you're working against.

Most definitely increasing activity. Started as a couch potato, now do triathlons.

It's the only way to fly...

bpetrosky wrote: »

You can succeed at weight loss without exercise, but the closer you get to a normal weight the tighter your metabolic range becomes. Exercise can help give you more calories to work with, but the biggest differentiator is how well a person manages their intake.

Since exercise calorie burns are very difficult to estimate accurately, even with fitness monitors, it is better to accurately manage intake to reduce the overall error you're working against.

I should have also said resistance exercise helps retain muscle mass, so even though it may not burn much in the way of calories, the benefits when you get to your goal weight are significant.

I started walking before I joined MFP. I started this whole thing because of a medical diagnosis which is greatly managed with exercise. The lighter I become, the more active I get.

I didn't at first. I always say this, but I didn't start losing weight to lose weigh. I changed my diet so that I could maybe be healthier because I had a new health problem.. I'd just had a thyroid surgery (they found a lot, all at once - good, new doctor!) and got pills that enabled me to lose.

So I was just focusing on my health and the pounds started dropping off. Clothes got bigger. I started fitting into the next size down again. And it went on like that for a good while. No calorie-counting (much less food scale), no weighing myself, no exercise.

I did it, so I know it can be done.

But my bones suck. My body just keeps eating away at them and exercise might help that, so it got added. I tried the gym, but hated it. It is boring as hell for me and I really didn't go because I didn't want to. So, I found things I don't hate doing and do those instead.

It helps with weight loss, for sure. People sometimes say, "Losing weight is done in the kitchen!" but it can be done in the pool, too. You cannot exclude calories burned exercising from the equation. It all works together.

While I'd advise everyone to find something they like and do that, I know that some people are just losing weight to look better and don't care about doing any exercise. It's a valid choice and can work, so I wish them well. But if someone cannot lose and isn't being active in some way, try it!!!

I feel comfortable eating around 1500 calories a day and I want to lose 2 pounds a week so I have to keep my TDEE at 2500 in order to do that. Therefore I have to work out pretty much everyday if I want to keep up the same pace. When I was heavier I didn't have to work out as much but as I get lighter I have to increase it or accept a slower rate of loss.

I haven't really changed my activity, but that's because I was already pretty active. I've tried to be better about exercising instead of just "planning" to, but I already averaged over 12K steps per day and worked out 3-6 times per week before I joined MFP.

But I've kept the extra weight on because I love food, and I love indulging in food, and I eat when I'm bored, and I hate feeling hungry, and I really, really love food. I love whole, organic, balanced meals, and I love potato chips, and I love bell peppers and I love chocolate. I want to eat whatever I want, whenever I want, and that policy keeps me about 20-25 pounds over my body's ideal weight.

So calorie control is the piece I'm missing, and that's the piece I need. More activity might help, but the more active I am the hungrier I feel (over time--on a high-activity day I don't eat much, but a day or two later I'm starving). So I'm focusing on controlling the urge to eat everything in sight, and let my activity take care of itself.

My sister recommended MFP to me in April 2012 when I had a lot of knee pain and was having a difficult time exercising. I did lose weight without exercising much, but then I started swimming and was able to do that. As I lost weight and strengthened my knees, I was able to do more.

When gardening season started this year, it hurt me to squat, but now some combination of losing weight and strengthening my knees has allowed me to squat, just in time for strawberry harvesting