Lowering calories to offset yesterday's binge?

clariemoo
clariemoo Posts: 34 Member
edited November 2024 in Motivation and Support
Yesterday I ate 2500 calories worth of blueberry tart, ice cream and chocolate (on top of 1000 calories of protein & veggies). My last binge was about a month ago (PMS related cravings) but otherwise I'm on 1200-1400 calories per day (mainly low carb/protein+veggies+dairy).

Would eating 500 calories the next 2 days offset yesterday's binge (bringing my calories to an average of 1500/day)?

Replies

  • WaterBunnie
    WaterBunnie Posts: 1,371 Member
    No, it would more likely bring on another binge due to deprivation. Draw a line and move on at your MFP calorie goal.
  • RuNaRoUnDaFiEld
    RuNaRoUnDaFiEld Posts: 5,864 Member
    Noooo, don't get in to a cycle of punishment. Just go back to eating at a 500 calorie deficit.

    Life isn't perfect and neither are we. When I go to a BBQ or a wedding etc I'll have a blow out. As long as you get back to eating at a slight deficit it won't harm you.
  • GWehsling
    GWehsling Posts: 120 Member
    No. I'd say don't go under about 1200 because you'll end up with all kinds of problems and possibly an eating disorder.

    When I have big days like that, I make an effort to workout a little more over the coming days, but still give myself the nutrition my body requires - a few weeks ago, I had a massive night out, drank a few litres of beer, but it did not puncture my master plan, I have still lost weight, my target is just a little further out, but I can bring it back in with more gym time. I cannot see your diary, so it's a bit hard to see how you work out or how you usually eat but please accept that this happens from time to time and the overall picture is not that bad.

    Rather than starve, I'd say try to work out why you have these huge cravings and just keep moving forward.

    Good luck.
  • livingleanlivingclean
    livingleanlivingclean Posts: 11,751 Member
    You could try 5:2 for the week.... Two "fasting" days but not consecutively.
  • sheppeyescapee
    sheppeyescapee Posts: 329 Member
    Nah I just usually go back to my normal pattern of eating and draw a line under it.
  • 999tigger
    999tigger Posts: 5,235 Member
    Log it and move on, the sky isnt going o fall in. If you wnat to or have to make up the deficit then do it in a healthy sustainable way. Maybe add a 20 min walk each day for a few weeks. Never eat below 1200 (unless long term 5:2) and dont cut calories in the way you are suggesting becayse its too reactionary and an aggressively poor solution.
  • WaterBunnie
    WaterBunnie Posts: 1,371 Member
    If your binge is PMS related it may just be easier to accept that one day a month you are going to be out of control and have that day as a maintenance day - or more - rather than beat yourself up over it. A lot of us get hormone spikes and crave sweet and fatty foods at that time and it's not the end of the world if it helps you through it.
  • clariemoo
    clariemoo Posts: 34 Member
    Thanks everyone! Makes lots of sense (especially about restricting which could be risky and trigger another binge). I made peace (or piece lol) with my dessert blowout, so today had 1100 worth of calories on soupe, toast and fruit.

    @WaterBunnie Yeah the ravenous hunger and intense craving for sweets&carbs usually happens with my PMS, can't wait for the period to come and get it over with! I recently had surgery and can't really do any exercise while the recovery period which kind of sucks and so mainly relying on calorie counting for weightloss. but anyways its good to get perspective, keep in mind the bigger picture and like you said "it's not the end of the world"
  • faithyang
    faithyang Posts: 297 Member
    edited June 2015
    Hi @clariemoo, I've slipped into the binging many times before and trust me if you start lowering your calories down to 500 or something you're going to further feed that binge monster that thrives on deprivation. (Trust me I found it so hard to get off a 4 week binge cycle bandwagon of crazy buffet binges WITH double/TRIPLE doses of dessert at the dessert cart and then dropping my cal to 500-600, including a fast during the week and double the exercise...then got so obsessed with food I ended back at the buffet once again which DECIMATED the torture I had put myself through during the week. Don't get me started on this one time I ended up with a $20 box of assorted baklava and another time it was a box of Indian sweets. Goodness. :| )

    Finally realised what I was doing and stopped the madness, reset the clock and went back to a normal exercise/diet routine of well-portioned healthy choices, healthy dose of exercise and moving around more in the day to lose that weight more sustainably. Lesson learnt.

    Just replace your next few meals of your choice (I usually choose dinner as you need energy for the day and you'll get tempted to binge if you starve yourself during the day and leave things open for dinner!)with a lighter option such as soup, salad, less or no carb. It has to be filling and dense!

    I usually go for a big salad, a bowl of soup (I love minestrone, or Asian beef/chicken soup) and sometimes a 1/2 serve of rice/bread.

    Don't worry about the numbers on the scale for the time being - always use it as a means to positively motivate, not to negatively dismantle. After a week or two, go back straight into your normal diet/fitness routine.
  • Mr_Knight
    Mr_Knight Posts: 9,532 Member
    clariemoo wrote: »
    Yesterday I ate 2500 calories worth of blueberry tart, ice cream and chocolate (on top of 1000 calories of protein & veggies). My last binge was about a month ago (PMS related cravings) but otherwise I'm on 1200-1400 calories per day (mainly low carb/protein+veggies+dairy).

    Would eating 500 calories the next 2 days offset yesterday's binge (bringing my calories to an average of 1500/day)?

    If those 500 calories are basically all protein, it could work. Otherwise you're probably just going to create another deficiency and binge again.
This discussion has been closed.