Two questions: coffee and soups
cuerpito
Posts: 65 Member
Hi All,
I have two questions regarding cooking and nutrition:
1. I realized that my weight loss was hindered because I didn't drink enough water. Since I started drinking more, I' ve noticed SLOW but better than non weight loss with less weight fluctuations. However, I am a teacher and all the drinking is very problematic during the day. I need to go to the bathroom VERY frequently. This is difficult, as I can't just leave whenever I please. I can't leave my students on their own, so I have to wait for the three minute breaks we have between classes. This means that I can use the bathroom every 45 minutes or so. With the water and daily coffee I drank every day, this was not enough time to "hold it"! I quit the coffee but I MISS IT A LOT!!! My question is, what ingredient in coffee is dehydrating? Will switching to decaf help? I'm craving a nice iced coffee so badly. Is there another type of coffee that you know of that wouldn't make me go to the bathroom as often as regular? I know I could drink it in the afternoon but it just isn't the same.
2. I often make soups. I don't use any broth. I just use some sort of meat and let it cook with vegetables. Now, when I log this, do I need to add broth to my list or simply adding the meat will be enough? Basically, will adding all the ingredient be enough? Or should I add broth in addition to all the ingredients?
I have two questions regarding cooking and nutrition:
1. I realized that my weight loss was hindered because I didn't drink enough water. Since I started drinking more, I' ve noticed SLOW but better than non weight loss with less weight fluctuations. However, I am a teacher and all the drinking is very problematic during the day. I need to go to the bathroom VERY frequently. This is difficult, as I can't just leave whenever I please. I can't leave my students on their own, so I have to wait for the three minute breaks we have between classes. This means that I can use the bathroom every 45 minutes or so. With the water and daily coffee I drank every day, this was not enough time to "hold it"! I quit the coffee but I MISS IT A LOT!!! My question is, what ingredient in coffee is dehydrating? Will switching to decaf help? I'm craving a nice iced coffee so badly. Is there another type of coffee that you know of that wouldn't make me go to the bathroom as often as regular? I know I could drink it in the afternoon but it just isn't the same.
2. I often make soups. I don't use any broth. I just use some sort of meat and let it cook with vegetables. Now, when I log this, do I need to add broth to my list or simply adding the meat will be enough? Basically, will adding all the ingredient be enough? Or should I add broth in addition to all the ingredients?
0
Replies
-
1: Caffine is a diuretic, so it make you go a lot, and can dehydrate you. decaf may help, but if you are still taking in the same amount of liquid, you will probably still be going often
2. If you are not adding broth to your dish, but it is making its own broth instead, I would not add broth to your food diary, as it is sort of already included in your meat/veg naturally.
Hope that makes sense and helps!0 -
I don't know anything about the soup but caffeine is a diuretic so it will make you have to go to the bathroom more. All diuretics increase the excretion of water from your body so I think that may be what's dehydrating you. Decaf coffee should help although even decaf still has about 2% caffeine lol, but it's a lot less than regular coffee.
I hope this helps.
EDIT: Oops, I guess my post wasn't needed lol.0 -
Thanks for a prompt response. Let me ask another thing then: if it's decaf, do I technically have to "make up" the coffee with additional water? You know, when they say for every cup of coffee you drink, you should drink an additional cup of water to replace the lost hydration. Do you have to do it for decaf, too?0
-
I'm a teacher also & I run into the same thing that you do with the breaks--I have it alittle easier because I have an assistant to help. I think Caffiene (sp) is the ingredient that dehydrates. When you add your recipes--I usually just add the ingredients. Hope this helps!! Enjoy your summer--I have 1 wk left of school.0
-
When you first start drinking alot of water you will have to pee often.... but then your body will adjust. I'm now back to a regular pee schedule, but at first I did have to go about every 30 minutes. Took about 2 weeks to get back to normal urinary habits. Also, I think limiting my sodium helps too.
Try not to take big gulps of water at once, little sips. Or if you are going to tank up - do it 15-20 minutes before your break, so when the break comes your kidneys will have your bladder ready to go about the time your break rolls around and you won't have to hold it and be too uncomfortable for too long. :drinker:0 -
Wow, great info and advice, WideMomDVM. I hope I will adjust because it is driving me crazy.
Aclark6818 - I don't have an assistant available, well, I do, one period per week 17 days left, here But summer will be busy, too.0 -
I can appreciate your problem, because I am being treated for bladder cancer and thus have to go pretty much every 20 minutes. It comes on quickly and I often don't make it in time. The worst thing is when someone stops me on the way to the bathroom to ask a question or chat. I am not a teacher, and can go pretty much whenever I want, but I rarely get there without being stopped on the way. And I almost never make it to the bathroom in time when shopping in a department store or a supermarket. The underpant type of Depends has been very helpful as the maximum absorbency variety will hold a full bladder if I need it. It's not comfortable, but it's better than wetting your pants in the asile in the supermarket, or in the hallway at work!
Personally, cutting out caffeine has not helped this problem, though it has helped me sleep better, and increasing water absolutely MAKES IT WORSE. My oncologist/urologist informs me that the water in food and flavored beverages are JUST AS GOOD as plain water at hydration, and there is no need to drink more than 64 ounces of water from any source in a day, and that includes beverages like coffee and tea, and things like soup and jello unless you are sweating a lot from exercise. Exercise does call for an immediate replacement of water lost to sweating and breathing hard. You should watch the calories in sugar sweetened beverages, but not for hydration reasons. He also says that additional water loss from caffeine is negligible. I know this flies in the face of what we're told, but this doctor is a nationally recognized expert in the urinary system, and he says there is lots of experimental evidence that this is so.
I say do whatever you have to do. If that's getting your doctor to write a note saying you need bathroom breaks more often than every 45 minutes, then do it. This would be an Americans with Disabilities Act Reasonable Accomodation, and there has to be a way for the school to get someone to cover for you twice during each period. My urologist does recommend peeing on a schedule so you never have to go really badly. I try to keep to an every 20 minute schedule, and my employer has a doctor's note that explains that I have a need to do this.0 -
How much coffee are you drinking? Although caffeine is a mild diuretic (makes you pee), one or two cups a day is not enough to have much of a diuretic effect, if any. If you drink too much water this will also result in a diuretic-like effect. Perhaps you are drinking more liquid than you need to. Not every one needs 8 cups a day. I know that most folk tell you not to count tea or coffee but there is no scientific evidence to support that small amounts of caffeine have a significant diuretic effect. If your urine is running clear, or very pale yellow, then you may be over-doing it. Going every 45 minutes throughout the day doesn't sound right to me but like a PP mentioned, you may find that you adapt over time.
If you do decaf, you most certainly won't need to make up for the dehydration effect but I also think it is bogus to make up for the so-called-dehydration effect of one to two coffees a day. If you are drinking 8 cups of water plus 2 coffees and not exerting yourself to any extent with exercise, it isn't surprising you are peeing a lot.0 -
That's a lot of great information, guys. What I've been doing is trying to drink 8 cups at work (before 4 p.m.) and a large (10 oz?) cup of coffee - recently eliminated. Then, I drink a cup of Coke Zero with dinner and then 3 cups after exercise - I do p90x.
I try drinking early during the day because if I drink late, I wake up at night to go to the bathroom and then I have a hard time falling asleep again. I know that I drink 3 cups in the evening but that doesn't make me go - I guess my body just replenishes the water lost during exercise.
You posted some interesting information about that 8 cups is plenty. Not so long ago I read a post here on MFP. Someone said that you should take your weight and divide it by half - that's how many oz of water you need a day.0 -
There are all sorts of formulas as to how much liquid you should drink. If you are only doing one cup of coffee, I can assure you, it isn't the culprit! I'd say the 8 cups before 4 PM is! Like I said in my previous post, if your pee is clear or very light yellow, this is a great sign that you are plenty hydrated. It sounds as though you have your exercise fluids figured out. I suspect you don't need quite as much leading up to your exercise. You are effectively taking in 13 cups of fluid a day. I'd explode if that was me but everyone has different needs. The amount of caffeine in Coke Zero isn't enough to cause a diuretic effect. I don't know if I can explain the physiology, but if you consume a large amount of fluid within a certain amount of time, your kidneys go into overdrive and start excreting the excess fluid. Trying cutting down the volume during the day and see if that helps. Your body won't use excess water so if you are taking in too much, your body is simply getting rid of it.0
-
Thanks for the info. It's good to know. I will start cutting back a little and see what happens!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions