Strength training newbie question.

Yisrael1981
Yisrael1981 Posts: 132 Member
edited November 22 in Fitness and Exercise
I have lost about 70 pounds and I am looking to get strong now however I don't want to add weight. I am going to eat at maintenance level. Can I get really strong without putting in muscle mass?
Secondly what type of weight lifting is best for my goal?
Thanks in advance for your advice

Replies

  • Karen_can_do_this
    Karen_can_do_this Posts: 1,150 Member
    Hire a personal trainer for a few sessions to get your form correct. Otherwise make friends with youtube.
    Start of with a beginners program like stronglifts, or new rules of lifting or ice cream fitness.

    I'm not sure about gaining muscle, I can feel myself getting stronger and I'm not bulking up thank goodness. However I'm female and eating at a deficit.

    I'm not an expert though. Lots of others can help you.
    Check out the lifting stickies at the top of the fitness section
  • BalletAndBarbells
    BalletAndBarbells Posts: 334 Member
    Try something like circuits workouts - this will increase strength but because there is cardio in there too you won't "bulk up"/gain weight.
  • TR0berts
    TR0berts Posts: 7,739 Member
    debsbiggs wrote: »
    Try something like circuits workouts - this will increase strength but because there is cardio in there too you won't "bulk up"/gain weight.


    That really isn't a great idea, for OP's goal. Circuit training is very inefficient at getting someone "strong," like OP wants.

    mrsfitzy gave you a few good programs. Pretty much any reasonable beginner training program will be good.

    Yes, you can (probably, depending upon current strength levels) get strong without gaining weight. I'm going to differentiate weight and muscle mass. "Recomp" is where you maintain your weight by (slowly, most likely) putting on muscle while losing body fat.

    Below are two links. One is a thread here on recomp. It's long, but you hopefully won't need to read all of it (unless you want to, of course), while the other one has a couple more routines, in addition to what mrsfitzy said above. The beginner workout and the muscle building workout there are probably pretty good ones. If you do one of those, start with the empty bar and add 5-10 lbs when you can.

    http://www.aworkoutroutine.com/the-muscle-building-workout-routine/
    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10177803/recomposition-maintaining-weight-while-losing-fat/p1
  • Barbados1965
    Barbados1965 Posts: 33 Member
    Strength and muscle mass are directly proportional because muscle is what give you strength. What you are really trying to achieve is to gain muscle and not fat. Too many people think of weight which is aggregate of fat, muscle bone and water. With that out of the way, determine if you want the large, medium, or slim muscular look. If you are into long distance running you would probably be going for the slim look; sprinter/quick burst of energy for short duration, medium look; Power: being able to lift heavy, large look. Get with a trainer to give you some one on one attention and take it from there good luck.
  • Cave_Goose
    Cave_Goose Posts: 156 Member
    I have been lifting for strength, without bulking up. Lift no more than 2-3x per week. Use lighter weights and higher reps (Guys looking to bulk do heavier weights and lower reps.). The personal trainer who put me on my plan said I should be looking at 15-25 reps per set, doing 2 sets. Do one exercise per major muscle group.

    You should feel a little sore the next day, and the last reps should be hard to finish, or the weight is too low.

    So on my chest, I do 2 sets of 20 reps with 35lb dumbbells. By the time I hit that 20th press, my body is screaming at me that I can't finish it. (3 months ago, I could only do 10 dumbbell presses at this weight)

  • VanillaGorillaUK
    VanillaGorillaUK Posts: 342 Member
    Yes you can get strong without putting on too much size - It comes down to the rep ranges.

    Bodybuilders typically use higher rep ranges (6+) because it forces the muscle to have endurance. Their muscles will store glycogen and water in order to perform. This give the bodybuilder appearance.

    For pure strength without weight gain, you'll want to stick with less than 5 reps. This type of training forces the actual muscle fiber to grow and develops your CNS.

    Take a look at powerlifting programs
  • Cave_Goose
    Cave_Goose Posts: 156 Member
    And now that I think more about it, there are a bunch of phone apps called "30 Challenge." They have them for all the major muscle groups, and they rely on body weight. Before I ever went to the gym, I started with 30-Day push up, 30-Day squat, 30-day Abs, and 30-Day Back. I could tell a significant difference after a couple of weeks.

    The con is the more days into it, the more reps you are doing. The ab workout alone was up to 30 minutes, and I was running out of time. Still, it's a good place to start, without paying a gym fee or buying weights.
  • Capt_Apollo
    Capt_Apollo Posts: 9,026 Member
    edited July 2015
    I have lost about 70 pounds and I am looking to get strong now however I don't want to add weight. I am going to eat at maintenance level. Can I get really strong without putting in muscle mass?
    Secondly what type of weight lifting is best for my goal?
    Thanks in advance for your advice


    you can get very strong without building mass. this is typically called "newbie gains" and this lasts about a year. mass is typically more of a result of the amount and type of food you eat.

    you can do any and every type of weight lifting. personally, i recommend full body circuits, as they get the best bang for your buck if you are only able to get to the gym three times a week. isolating body parts into a 4 day a week schedule is for a more experienced lifter.
  • JayTE83
    JayTE83 Posts: 11 Member
    Interesting subject from the OP and one that I'm sure many people have asked in some form or another. Firstly I'd say well done on dropping so much weight its a great achievement. Secondly to truly get strong you need to build thicker more resilient muscle fibres. Utilising mid range repetitions and between 55-75% of your 1rm, also work with good quality resistance bands. Obviously muscle lb for lb weighs more than fat in terms of size, and adding muscle mass to your frame will make you initially slighty heavier depending on your nutrition program. But doing high intensity, shorter rests and maintaining a measured amount of calories, your body will adapt to your exercise regime and level out. So in answer to what you said. You will probably put on a small amount of weight as you add muscle but it doesn't have to be to much if you focus on the look and size you want, just takes time for endocrinatic and sympathetic nervous systems to engage and adapt to new routines. Keep at it
  • labohn91
    labohn91 Posts: 113 Member
    It is hard to answer your question because you did not define really strong. But you can get strong without gaining weight it depends on a lot of factors. Genetics (Muscle insertions, limb lengths, height and Antony), stress, time you are willing to put in and effort.

    Here is a 15 year old girl benching 330
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RgVfkTyjNKI

    Here is a 123 pound man snatching 303lb
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQ-ke6ouvK4

    Richard Hawthorn 130lbs picking up almost 5x his body weight
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FkRkPigvO9Y
This discussion has been closed.