We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Scale that measures more than weight

jonipecson
jonipecson Posts: 29 Member
edited November 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
The scales that measure not only weight, but BMI, Body Water, Body Fat and Bone Mass; is that truly better than a scale that measures weight alone? I want to get healthy, I don't have to be ripped...lol. I just wanted to seek out some ideas on this.

Thanks.

Replies

  • concordancia
    concordancia Posts: 5,320 Member
    I don't think a scale can measure bone mass, and as I understand it, the ones that measure body fat are easily interfered with by water retention. But then, I don't think I have ever heard of measuring body water, so perhaps there is some miracle technology out there...but probably not.
  • seska422
    seska422 Posts: 3,217 Member
    edited October 2015
    All a scale can reliably measure is weight.

    You don't need a special scale for BMI. BMI is based on height and weight so you can look it up on a chart or use an online calculator once you know your height and weight.

    The other things you listed can't be accurately determined by a home scale. They will just be estimates and may not even be good estimates.
  • TeaBea
    TeaBea Posts: 14,517 Member
    seska422 wrote: »
    All a scale can reliably measure is weight.

    The things you listed can't be accurately determined by a home scale. They will just be estimates and may not even be good estimates.

    This^

    If you look at all the criteria that need to be "managed" to keep the numbers as accurate as possible.....no way am I going thru 12 steps (or whatever)....just to weigh myself.

  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    seska422 wrote: »
    All a scale can reliably measure is weight.

    You don't need a special scale for BMI. BMI is based on height and weight so you can look it up on a chart or use an online calculator once you know your height and weight.

    The other things you listed can't be accurately determined by a home scale. They will just be estimates and may not even be good estimates.

    pretty much this...scales that give BF% aren't accurate...they can't tell the difference between fat and water.
  • spiritlevel9
    spiritlevel9 Posts: 48 Member
    I had a go on some scales in town that measure body fat and although my BMI is 21, it said my fat mass was 29 percent which is still high according to the machine! I am not even getting into an argument with a machine. I can see my ribs and when I was measured for a bra, I was directed towards the vests! I am a typical pear and lay down fat on my hips and thighs. I am 5 ft 7 and a UK 10. That is good enough for me.
    If I took it too seriously, I may be feeling under pressure to lose more pounds and that may start messing with my head. I don't think it is worth my while trying to bulk up. I get totally fed up with repetitive exercise and wouldn't keep it up. I walk everywhere and do a little yoga. That is good enough for me. I poked my tongue out at the mocking scale and will never feed it another 50p as long as I live!
  • jonipecson
    jonipecson Posts: 29 Member
    Thanks for the feedback everyone. So basically I'll just take it as an estimate and I know that when I feel healthy and I no longer need blood pressure meds I've truly succeeded on the weight loss front :smile:
  • ElPasoMark
    ElPasoMark Posts: 47 Member
    Depends on what you want to spend and what functions you want/need. Some can get spendy. I've been looking at Tanita body composition monitors for a while. Maybe something like the BC-1000 though the higher priced models look good too-

    http://www.tanita.com/en/products/184-catId.520093811.html

    Good review on the BC-100 here-

    http://www.dcrainmaker.com/2010/02/tanita-bc-1000-scale-review-in-depth.html

    And lo, when I went to the above website to get the URL I found this, an initial write up on a new Garmin scale-

    http://www.dcrainmaker.com/2015/10/garmins-weight-scale.html

    And then there's the Withings-

    http://www.withings.com/us/en/products/smart-body-analyzer

    Cheers



  • cnbbnc
    cnbbnc Posts: 1,267 Member
    My digital scale that also measured body fat was so inaccurate that I gave up and just bought a plain ole analog scale.
  • Sued0nim
    Sued0nim Posts: 17,456 Member
    jonipecson wrote: »
    The scales that measure not only weight, but BMI, Body Water, Body Fat and Bone Mass; is that truly better than a scale that measures weight alone? I want to get healthy, I don't have to be ripped...lol. I just wanted to seek out some ideas on this.

    Thanks.

    No it's crap and innaccurate to the point of pointless

    But it's hard to buy a decent scale that doesn't

    So if you get one just ignore the numbers

    (Mine tells me my BF is 32% ...laughs)
  • lkpducky
    lkpducky Posts: 18,028 Member
    And mine claims I have gained a pound or two of fat even after one night where I ate 500 calories more than usual for that day, and much more sodium (shouldn't that have been mainly water weight, so my body fat % should have decreased)? I finally said "bugger it for a game of soldiers" and only tracked weight trends and measurements, and I'll get a DEXA after losing a few more pounds.
  • MostlyWater
    MostlyWater Posts: 4,294 Member
    I got one on Amazon, the same that gyms use. I think it was $38 with tax
  • Yi5hedr3
    Yi5hedr3 Posts: 2,696 Member
    Yes, they are much better. Not super accurate, but very consistent
This discussion has been closed.

Categories