Calorie Counting hasnt worked for me....so counting carbs in
Candice73
Posts: 19 Member
HI there,
Since April 2010 I made it my mission to lose the additional stone I have carried for a while, I began bootcamp training, zumba and a whole host of other exercise sessions to decrease my weight, as well as counting calories. Including a bootcamp weekend which ended with a run up a mountain.
Now from the generic tool I used I should be eating 1200 calories a day to lose weight uping them a bit when training....i did this for a year and did not lose weight and did not tone, I also became very tired and in December 2010 came down with the flu and have been ill on and off ever since (I used to never be ill). I became obsessed and could not figure out why I could not lose this weight...surely if it is all about calories in/calories out I should have lost my stone and more!!!!
SO at my wits end one day I decided to go for some metabolic testing....the best thing I could have done....it confirmed my body does not burn fat at rest. I burn 85% Carbs/15% protein..also my body fat was 25%, and very little lean muscle (the rest is water) I also had a fitness test and I am not that fit either so for a year of training and calorie counting I have nothing to show for it!!!!!!!
The testing also showed for me to function on a daily basis I need at least 1500 calories a day so I need more than that to do my normal daily activities and even more before training...has my body shut down and gone into starvation mode, is my body clinging on to every bit of fat I eat (which is little as been on low fat diet) and storing instead of burning?? How do I fix it??? Does anyone else have this problem??
After the testing I decided not calorie count and stop training. I put on a few pounds and felt much healthier for it, however the additional pounds obviously started to get me down.
I started to read books on hormones/insulin and carbs and read tons of research and it seems for some people carbs are really evil and I think I am proof of this as I have cut my carb intake and my weight is beginning to drop quite easily, I have also increased my fat and protien (mentally that is really hard as surely Fat make you Fat !!)
I still eat fruit and lots of veg and I am lovin it... before I ate because I loved eating and food was constantly on my mind ..now I am only eating when I feel hungry and only feel it is a necessity sometimes I am forcing myself to eat even though I dont feel like it and I have energy again..I will over time find my own magic carb number i,e how many carbs can i eat before I gain weight and I look forward to getting to that stage too.
I hope to lose this last stone by autumn..but I am in no rush, this will be my life from now on and my body will be a fat burning machine not carb burning machine even at rest...
Any comments welcome as would love to hear peoples thoughts and opinions. I know this goes against the grain,,,,but it is working for me and thought I would share my experience.
Since April 2010 I made it my mission to lose the additional stone I have carried for a while, I began bootcamp training, zumba and a whole host of other exercise sessions to decrease my weight, as well as counting calories. Including a bootcamp weekend which ended with a run up a mountain.
Now from the generic tool I used I should be eating 1200 calories a day to lose weight uping them a bit when training....i did this for a year and did not lose weight and did not tone, I also became very tired and in December 2010 came down with the flu and have been ill on and off ever since (I used to never be ill). I became obsessed and could not figure out why I could not lose this weight...surely if it is all about calories in/calories out I should have lost my stone and more!!!!
SO at my wits end one day I decided to go for some metabolic testing....the best thing I could have done....it confirmed my body does not burn fat at rest. I burn 85% Carbs/15% protein..also my body fat was 25%, and very little lean muscle (the rest is water) I also had a fitness test and I am not that fit either so for a year of training and calorie counting I have nothing to show for it!!!!!!!
The testing also showed for me to function on a daily basis I need at least 1500 calories a day so I need more than that to do my normal daily activities and even more before training...has my body shut down and gone into starvation mode, is my body clinging on to every bit of fat I eat (which is little as been on low fat diet) and storing instead of burning?? How do I fix it??? Does anyone else have this problem??
After the testing I decided not calorie count and stop training. I put on a few pounds and felt much healthier for it, however the additional pounds obviously started to get me down.
I started to read books on hormones/insulin and carbs and read tons of research and it seems for some people carbs are really evil and I think I am proof of this as I have cut my carb intake and my weight is beginning to drop quite easily, I have also increased my fat and protien (mentally that is really hard as surely Fat make you Fat !!)
I still eat fruit and lots of veg and I am lovin it... before I ate because I loved eating and food was constantly on my mind ..now I am only eating when I feel hungry and only feel it is a necessity sometimes I am forcing myself to eat even though I dont feel like it and I have energy again..I will over time find my own magic carb number i,e how many carbs can i eat before I gain weight and I look forward to getting to that stage too.
I hope to lose this last stone by autumn..but I am in no rush, this will be my life from now on and my body will be a fat burning machine not carb burning machine even at rest...
Any comments welcome as would love to hear peoples thoughts and opinions. I know this goes against the grain,,,,but it is working for me and thought I would share my experience.
0
Replies
-
what is important is that you have found what works for you. reading and investigating nutrition is a boring subject and most people just want someone else to tell them what they need to do. good luck with your journey.0
-
how did you have metabolic testing done? i am interested in learning more about this. i have been stuck at my current weight and cannot seem to take off these last 6lbs.0
-
Great job you have found, The Primal lifestyle. Come on over to our support group, here, http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/249784-palelo-support-group
if you want support and to learn more about eating clean, low or no processed crappy carbs. As you already know eating like this is life changing.0 -
Hi Masongirl9,
I searched for on google and only 2 testing centres came up in London..google search in the area you are and you may find one. I had mine done privately and cost around £200. Hope you find one it was well worth it for me!
Candice0 -
This sounds just like me. I have lowered my carbs as well and it has totally changed my binge eating and I dont feel as hungry all the time. I keep my carbs under 100 and really most of my carbs are from my morning oatmeal after I workout. I have been training HARD for 2 years and also dont have the body I think my training should have given me. I was so focused on calories in/out that I let myself eat whatever as long as I stayed within those limits. Now I focus mostly on lower carbs, fat and protein and not so much on calories. My midsection really looks better than a few weeks ago! Good Job and Good Luck!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions