Garden of life Vs Shakeology?
Lola824
Posts: 96 Member
Which do you prefer and why? I am thinking for cost of going with garden of life. Are these meal replacements?
0
Replies
-
Yes, both are meal replacements (as long as you get the Garden of Life RAW Meal, not just the protein powder). I love the RAW Meal and also their RAW Protein! Great quality, great ingredients... Flavor is not as good as Shakeology but I mix mine with tasty things, and make delicious chocolate peanut butter banana smoothies with it. I always have 1/2 of a serving of the RAW Meal and it really fills me up. Tried to have the whole serving once and it was just too much for me.1
-
Wow, the Garden of Life shake looks damn good, thanks for posting!
On the vitamin and nutrients front, it also looks like Garden of Life's offering is better. More fiber. Has what Shakeologys got and more. Not to mention price. I wonder how it tastes?1 -
Wow, the Garden of Life shake looks damn good, thanks for posting!
On the vitamin and nutrients front, it also looks like Garden of Life's offering is better. More fiber. Has what Shakeologys got and more. Not to mention price. I wonder how it tastes?
Yeah it's super healthy! I feel great when I have it. Taste is okay. I recommend making a smoothie with it, not just mixing it with water or milk of choice.0 -
Thanks! I think they sell this at earth fare and whole foods, I was just thinking shakeology seems so darn expensive, so I think I will start with Raw garden of life first!1
-
Just be careful with Garden of life. Do a search on Garden of Life heavy metals. It seems as though they source their brown rice from Asia and in labs have shown to have extremely high levels of Lead, Tungsten, and Cadmium. Not sure if they are going to do a recall on it or not. I've been looking at both for a month or so now and may go ahead and spend the extra money on shakeology to be safe.
Excerpt from one of the websites:
In one lot we tested (E2694A), we found concentrations so high that:
• Lead intake from a single serving exceeds California Prop 65 limits for dietary supplements by 2,700%.
• Cadmium intake from a single serving exceeds California Prop 65 limits for dietary supplements by over 1,000%.
• Tungsten concentrations were so high that they exceeded the lead concentration by nearly 2,000%.0 -
http://m.naturalnews.com/news/043759_Garden_of_Life_RAW_Protein_heavy_metals.html
Update on heavy metals!0 -
Wouldn't it be much more sensible to just learn how to eat correctly rather then depend on a meal replacement?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition2 -
I think the point of a shake (for me) is I'm on the go a lot & it's very quick & portable. I'd like something that's healthy.0
-
Wouldn't it be much more sensible to just learn how to eat correctly rather then depend on a meal replacement?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
yeah I agree. the only garden of life you need is at the farmers market. just make you own shakes. I like smoothies too but I just add in flax seed, oats, chia, vegies, fruit,, almond milk, water, and sometimes squeezed oj. get creative with what you already have.0 -
FindingAmy77 wrote: »Wouldn't it be much more sensible to just learn how to eat correctly rather then depend on a meal replacement?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
yeah I agree. the only garden of life you need is at the farmers market. just make you own shakes. I like smoothies too but I just add in flax seed, oats, chia, vegies, fruit,, almond milk, water, and sometimes squeezed oj. get creative with what you already have.
I agree to a point. There are food deserts. There are single parents with two jobs. I eat whole foods and prepare a lot of my own foods- BUT. having a tub of this around is incredibly convenient when time is short. To get that much nutrition ( go ahead, read the ingredients, I dare you find a way to get that much protein, etc in 10 seconds without choking..lol).
The point here is this thread is for people that use these products, not to shove lifestyles down throats...no pun intended.1 -
Neither.
0 -
FindingAmy77 wrote: »Wouldn't it be much more sensible to just learn how to eat correctly rather then depend on a meal replacement?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
yeah I agree. the only garden of life you need is at the farmers market. just make you own shakes. I like smoothies too but I just add in flax seed, oats, chia, vegies, fruit,, almond milk, water, and sometimes squeezed oj. get creative with what you already have.
Exactly. At the very least save yourself the money and just buy a whey protein and a good multi-vitamin. The per-serving cost of those products is pretty expensive comparatively for marginal value. Supplementation should be a very small piece of the big picture.
0 -
Natural News, the most reliable of all the news sites!ChantelCherie wrote: »http://m.naturalnews.com/news/043759_Garden_of_Life_RAW_Protein_heavy_metals.html
Update on heavy metals!
Seriously, these products are overpriced, taste terrible, and don't actually do anything. Most of the people who espouse their virtues have a vested interest in having other people buy them.
0 -
I actually use shakeology because when I was eating unhealthy, I was spending 5 or more dollars a day for breakfast at fast food chains. so I was spending more then what shakeology cost me per day and its way better than the crap I was eating. not to mention I quit smoking which also saves more 7+ dollars a day0
-
I like Garden of Life. Their ingredients list is just about as clean as they come for protein powders, and they always have coupons. Vanilla chai is the best flavor in the Raw Meal. Just mix it with a little more liquid than the label says and make sure to use a blender bottle since it's pretty thick. It gets even thicker if you chill it after mixing.0
-
Oh boy, someone linked a story from naturalnews.com one if the most unreliable website for actual science backed "facts."0
-
Wouldn't it be much more sensible to just learn how to eat correctly rather then depend on a meal replacement?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
The most sensible foods are the ones that will be eaten. Shake powders and bars are those things you stash in your bag and remember are there that night when everything goes wrong at once. Fast food as a last resort is completely optional.
That being said, I pay for packaging and choose something single serve and a little higher calorie for the sake of having energy to function. I tend to brand hop but never to either of the above brands because they don't fit the bill.0 -
Shakeology
I eat all kinds of prepackaged foods for the specific use.
It is about convenience though, not my normal way of eating
Quest bars, Cliff bars, GU gel packs, Accemeraide mix, Muscle Milk cartons, EAS protein bars.
Any of that stuff is great on a bike ride or in my gym bag as an alternative to a drive thru burger and fries.
I can't always make perfect choices, but I can make better choices.0 -
While meal replacements aren't necessarily a necessity, you might have luck with one. Those heavy metal reports look scary though. I don't know. I mean I've never had either but if you don't mind spending the money, give a few options a try (preferably ones without metal in them) and see what you like. Heck, you might decide that meal replacers aren't for you. It's all about figuring out what's right for you. Good luck!0
-
If you are in Canada check out Vega One.0
-
I like vega one, but some people object to the stevia taste. I just override that sweetness by adding a little additional unsweetened cocoa powder or Italian instant espresso. I really don't see why the shade for an occasional protein shake.0
-
I like Vega as well, but it's pretty expensive. Isn't it about $60 for a tub?
0 -
The medium size can I just bought was on sale for $35/can. Yes, the giant can is about that I imagine. I was trying it out... I usually fund those big purchases (like a big pack of meat at Costco too) by stuffing $5 or $10 in an envelope for a few pay periods & then buying when the remainder feels like a comfortable amount. It really does provide a lot of nutrition though for the money.0
-
I work weekend mornings at a caregiving job where I do a lot of cooking for my client. I had a vega one shake with banana, Greek yogurt, and ice on my drive out around 7:00 am, prepared a full English breakfast for her & spent the rest of the morning cooking several complete meals around some fresh trout her SIL caught and I haven't felt even ONE hunger pang... For me a shake is sometimes the best thing. I'll need to grocery shop for my own family on the way home & the earliest I'll have lunch is 2:00. With some types of work you are just too rushed on your feet to stop for a meal. If a protein shake or bar keeps you comfortable that seems okay.0
-
I've never tried Shakeology, but I did try Garden of Life's Vanilla Raw Fit High Protein Powder (the Vitamin Shoppe sells individual serving packets so I picked one up). Honestly? The stuff was by far the most horrible thing I've ever tried!!! It was the first protein powder I couldn't even finish, it tastes disgusting and has a really chalky texture to it. Do yourself a favor and try a packet of it before committing to an entire tub. It. Was. Gross. I don't see how anyone could like it, but I mean, if they sell it then SOMEONE must like it. You may, who knows. Go for it. Just be warned!0
-
Garden of Life.0
-
I've never tried Shakeology, but I did try Garden of Life's Vanilla Raw Fit High Protein Powder (the Vitamin Shoppe sells individual serving packets so I picked one up). Honestly? The stuff was by far the most horrible thing I've ever tried!!! It was the first protein powder I couldn't even finish, it tastes disgusting and has a really chalky texture to it. Do yourself a favor and try a packet of it before committing to an entire tub. It. Was. Gross. I don't see how anyone could like it, but I mean, if they sell it then SOMEONE must like it. You may, who knows. Go for it. Just be warned!
The trick is to use much more liquid than called for by the package (over 1/2 cup extra) and to ALWAYS use a shaker bottle. Refrigerating it makes it get thicker too.0 -
Wow, I thought MFP was for people who wanted to eat well and embrace a healthy lifestyle. Instead it is flooded with overpriced shakes and propaganda about convenience and food deserts. And the mods allow it. Wow. Just wow.0
-
Oh they let people talk about fast food and Halloween candy too. Oooh the horror!!! ~passes smelling salts~
Maybe you need to go lie down on your fainting couch a spell!2
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions