Sugar substitutes-Stevia Experiences?

fitgirldrw81
fitgirldrw81 Posts: 11 Member
edited November 26 in Health and Weight Loss
So my Kroger ran a deal a few weeks back for a free box of Pure Via (stevia packets). I picked them up thinking I would give them a try. I didn't have high expectations because any other artificial sweeteners I've tried left a nasty aftertaste and actually left me wanting more sweets. Surprisingly, this stuff isn't that bad. I just tried dumping 1 packet in with 8 ozs water and 2 Tbsp lemon juice just to change things up a bit. Not a bad lemonade if I do say so myself. I used to only drink sodas...no water, no milk, nothing else. Since starting back on MFP I have only been drinking water or green tea. This sweet lemonade drink is helping break up the monotony a bit.

So my questions are...Does anyone else use Stevia as a sweetener? Has anyone experienced any side effects of it? I feel like it is a good pick as a sugar substitute but I don't know enough about it to commit 100%. Any suggestions or personal experiences?
«1

Replies

  • soapsandropes
    soapsandropes Posts: 269 Member
    I don't like stevia it has a strange bitter flavor to it. If you like it then use it.
  • earlnabby
    earlnabby Posts: 8,171 Member
    I prefer sucralose (Splenda). Stevia has a really bitter taste and I don't like it. The only affect I have seen with sucralose is, if I have too much (like several diet sodas in a day), I get a little extra flatulence.
  • ms_smartypants
    ms_smartypants Posts: 8,278 Member
    I just used stevia for the 1st time a few days ago and it gave me a sour stomach
  • LadyLallybroch
    LadyLallybroch Posts: 36 Member
    First of all, stevia is not artificial. That makes it a lot less... weird.

    To me, it has a fruity flavor. My mom likes to do lemonade like you mentioned. I've used stevia in anything fruity. I think it'd be odd with chocolate and those stevia sodas are not very good. It's really good on grapefruit. I've also made margaritas with it. I made some baked apples with cinnamon and stevia that were very tasty.

    I've never had any "side effects" or negative experiences with it.
  • misterdale67
    misterdale67 Posts: 171 Member
    I don't like stevia it has a strange bitter flavor to it. If you like it then use it.

    I agree completely with this!
  • fitgirldrw81
    fitgirldrw81 Posts: 11 Member
    First of all, stevia is not artificial. That makes it a lot less... weird.

    To me, it has a fruity flavor. My mom likes to do lemonade like you mentioned. I've used stevia in anything fruity. I think it'd be odd with chocolate and those stevia sodas are not very good. It's really good on grapefruit. I've also made margaritas with it. I made some baked apples with cinnamon and stevia that were very tasty.

    I've never had any "side effects" or negative experiences with it.

    Correct, stevia is not artificial. Sorry, I didn't word that very clearly in my original post. That was one of the reasons I thought I'd give it a try because other artificial sweeteners were total yuck! I figured if I'm going to eat healthy I might as well try to eat things more natural and maybe they wouldn't taste so weird. I'll have to give it a try on other fruity things. Thanks for the suggestions!
  • nvmomketo
    nvmomketo Posts: 12,019 Member
    edited November 2015
    I use only the stevia drops, which are incredibly sweet. To sweeten a large coffee it just takes 1 drop. I made pumpkin coconut flour muffins this morning and only added 3 droppers full for 20 muffins.

    I find the best thing to do with stevia is to err on the side of undersweetening foods. When too much stevia is added it can sometimes get that funny, bitter aftertaste.

    I've never had any side effects, like I would with sugar alcohols.

    I prefer the drops because there is no starchy, or sugar filler added, such as maltodextrin. There aren't many recipes that require a bulk filler (off sugar crystals or maltodextrin powder) that I can't alter to fit stevia drops.
  • Mongo5918
    Mongo5918 Posts: 27 Member
    If you're getting a bitterness from Stevia you're using too much or a lousy brand. Wisdom Natural SweetLeaf Stevia Clear Liquid has no alcohol, some other brands do. I have never had a bitterness from the Sweet Leaf unless I use way too much. The liquid is generally less bitter than the powders.
  • jgnatca
    jgnatca Posts: 14,464 Member
    I think sweeteners of all kinds are an acquired taste. I've been using artificial sweeteners for so long it's no big deal any more. I find Stevia tickles my tastebuds very much like cinnamon, so it can linger. I like it. I like them all.

    I find my Chai tea much more enjoyable with a sweetener packet, and perhaps the cinnamon masks the sweetener aftertaste a bit.

    Now, peppermint, that can be overdone.
  • jgnatca
    jgnatca Posts: 14,464 Member
    edited November 2015
    Oh, and about all the "artificial" moniker. Stevia approved for food consumption is the highly refined active ingredient from the Stevia leaf, Rebaudioside A.

    Just as white sugar (glucose/sucrose) is the highly refined active ingredient from Sugar Cane or Sugar Beet.
  • fitgirldrw81
    fitgirldrw81 Posts: 11 Member
    Mongo5918 wrote: »
    If you're getting a bitterness from Stevia you're using too much or a lousy brand. Wisdom Natural SweetLeaf Stevia Clear Liquid has no alcohol, some other brands do. I have never had a bitterness from the Sweet Leaf unless I use way too much. The liquid is generally less bitter than the powders.

    I had no idea there were liquid versions. Hmmm...might have to give that a try too. I did notice when I emptied my package into my ice water it took a while to dissolve all of it. It kink of clumped up on my ice and chunks floated around for a bit (ick!). Liquid might be where it's at! TY!
  • yarwell
    yarwell Posts: 10,477 Member
  • CoffeeNCardio
    CoffeeNCardio Posts: 1,847 Member
    I can't stand any of the artificial sweeteners. The nasty aftertaste and the weird smell....yes I smell them in my coffee. I just cannot take them. It's less that they taste bad to me, and more that the flavor feels like it's coating every square inch of the inside of my mouth and throat. I don't want to have to chase my coffee with water to avoid that. On the up-side, using sugar means I'm that much more motivated to get off my butt and work out (high calorie count in sugar). So, if soda isn't a trigger for you, and you can manage to have one once or twice a week or whatever without going way overboard, then consider planning them into your count by planning a work out. If you don't mind the stevia/splenda/equal whatever, that's cool too, I'm sure it makes it easier to come in under count:)
  • Whitezombiegirl
    Whitezombiegirl Posts: 1,042 Member
    edited November 2015
    I love truvia the granulated stevia. Its heavily vanilla flavoured and expensive but worth it imo. It tastes lovely and smells like cotton candy.

    I prefer sweeteners to sugar and i can only drink diet coke. Regular tastes nasty to me.




    I
  • segacs
    segacs Posts: 4,599 Member
    Natural versus artificial isn't really a health issue. And the use of "natural" in foods is mostly a marketing term that plays upon people's misunderstanding of basic chemistry.

    I don't add sugar to very much (e.g. I mostly drink water, not soda, and I take my coffee with milk only), so no, I don't really use packets of sweetener. Of course, some foods I eat are sweetened with Stevia or similar, such as yogurts or whatnot. That's fine by me. If I'm baking a cake, though, I'll use regular sugar.

    There are a lot of conflicting studies out there. But the evidence seems to conclude that artificial sweeteners do help with weight loss if you're using them to replace higher-calorie sugary foods like sodas. But the main reason isn't any net benefit from the sweeteners in particular; it's simply CICO -- if you cut calories, you'll lose weight faster. If, on the other hand, you fool yourself into thinking that this means you can replace those calories with others (the compensatory effect), then you'll probably see little to no effect.

    Bottom line: Sure, eat them if you want. IIFYM and all.
  • JustMissTracy
    JustMissTracy Posts: 6,338 Member
    I tried Stevia, hated it...it gave me wicked belly aches...someone said "Oh, that's just your body getting used to it.". No thanx, If I have to have tummy trouble just for a cup of tea, I'd rather the 20 calories of the real stuff please.
  • MommyL2015
    MommyL2015 Posts: 1,411 Member
    I like stevia better than all the other non-sugar sweeteners (obviously, sugar is tastiest!) but for some reason, my digestive system doesn't like it, at least not the liquid stevia drops. I haven't tried Truvia or anything like that.

    I just use sucralose for when I don't want sugar. It's cheap-ish and good enough.
  • VykkDraygoVPR
    VykkDraygoVPR Posts: 465 Member
    I like stevia in my smoothies. I don't really use it for anything else. My sister made a cake with stevia last weekend for our grandmother's birthday. It was tasty.

    It makes coffee taste stale. Like, how the hell can coffee taste stale? Weirdest thing ever. Would not recommend. I just use sugar in the raw if I sweeten my coffee. I'll sometimes use agave nectar, but that's really only nice with cream and a bit of tequila.
  • kristen6350
    kristen6350 Posts: 1,094 Member
    Gave them all up. I use sugar VERY sparingly. I'd rather use honey to sweeten things now if I need to.
  • JustMissTracy
    JustMissTracy Posts: 6,338 Member
    So my questions are...Does anyone else use Stevia as a sweetener? Has anyone experienced any side effects of it? I feel like it is a good pick as a sugar substitute but I don't know enough about it to commit 100%. Any suggestions or personal experiences?

    I get severe cramps in my legs and back from Stevia. I've had it twice and it happened both times. The first time it was listed as stevia extract on the label of water additive. Within a half-hour I could hardly walk. I googled and discovered it's a known side effect. Apparently, it's not many people that get it though. I tried to avoid it after that.

    When I bought my first protein powder, I read the label and saw Reb-A. I asked the salesclerk if he knew what that was. He incorrectly told me it was a preservative. I drank it, only to cramp again, although not as badly because I'd only had a bit. I was actually googling the Reb-A while I was drinking it, so I stopped when I found out.

    Since my side effect is so instantaneous, I'd assume if it were going to bother you, you'd already know. So, I wouldn't worry about it. I really wanted to be able to have it. :neutral:

    Could you save me the time of googling (supposed to be working here!) and advise what exactly Reb-A is?
  • Francl27
    Francl27 Posts: 26,371 Member
    Truvia is nasty. I use stevia in the raw and I like that one (I don't put a lot).

    I didn't mind splenda when I tried it, but all the products that use it use SO MUCH OF IT that it's sickeningly sweet to me so I avoid it...
  • christyg74
    christyg74 Posts: 87 Member
    I like Stevia in The Raw or Now brand stevia.
  • Alluminati
    Alluminati Posts: 6,208 Member
    I like the pink packet. Don't like the blue or the yellow packet.
  • sunandmoons
    sunandmoons Posts: 415 Member
    edited November 2015
    I gave up drinking Pepsi. 25 years of drinking at least 4-24 ounce bottles a day.

    Switched to vitamin water O as a substitute and have been drinking it for over 8 yrs.

    Truvia (Stevia leaf extract) is the sugar substutue. Never had a problem.

    It's not a substitute for regular water by no means, but it sure beats chugging all that sugar.
  • Yi5hedr3
    Yi5hedr3 Posts: 2,696 Member
    Stevia is best. Use liquid form to prevent any bitter taste
  • Unknown
    edited November 2015
    This content has been removed.
  • vegmebuff
    vegmebuff Posts: 31,389 Member
    I use pure Stevia everyday. It is important that it not be 'cut' with anything though. Not only because of the taste but because of health concerns as well. I like the taste of Organika pure Stevia powder and Herbal Selects pure Stevia powder or liquid. However the Herbal Select's Stevia in individual packets do cut it with Maltodextrin so I most definitely do not use those.

    'Stevia in the Raw' and many other companies uses maltodextrin as the primary ingredient in their baking products. Maltodextrin, derived from corn, spikes blood sugar even worse than refined glucose sugars and is used in thousands of products manufactured in the US and elsewhere because since it has about 3.75 calories/gram, and thus can be labelled as having “zero calories” (in the US if it is under 5 calories/serving it can legally be labeled calorie free).

    Maltodextrin has a high glycemic index, digests quickly and thus both spikes blood sugar, sometimes worse than refined glucose or white bread, and can increase insulin problems and promote fat gain.

    I think Maltodextrin is not a good choice when one is trying to go “sugar free” or avoid products that spike blood sugar and insulin.

    Not only that, but maltodextrin is made from corn - which usually means a GMO product - if that is a concern for anyone.


  • stevencloser
    stevencloser Posts: 8,911 Member
    vegmebuff wrote: »
    I use pure Stevia everyday. It is important that it not be 'cut' with anything though. Not only because of the taste but because of health concerns as well. I like the taste of Organika pure Stevia powder and Herbal Selects pure Stevia powder or liquid. However the Herbal Select's Stevia in individual packets do cut it with Maltodextrin so I most definitely do not use those.

    'Stevia in the Raw' and many other companies uses maltodextrin as the primary ingredient in their baking products. Maltodextrin, derived from corn, spikes blood sugar even worse than refined glucose sugars and is used in thousands of products manufactured in the US and elsewhere because since it has about 3.75 calories/gram, and thus can be labelled as having “zero calories” (in the US if it is under 5 calories/serving it can legally be labeled calorie free).

    Maltodextrin has a high glycemic index, digests quickly and thus both spikes blood sugar, sometimes worse than refined glucose or white bread, and can increase insulin problems and promote fat gain.

    I think Maltodextrin is not a good choice when one is trying to go “sugar free” or avoid products that spike blood sugar and insulin.

    Not only that, but maltodextrin is made from corn - which usually means a GMO product - if that is a concern for anyone.


    A single gram of sugar, or maltodextrin or anything isn't going to spike your blood sugar and insulin.
  • sunandmoons
    sunandmoons Posts: 415 Member
    edited November 2015
    Might google Stevia dangers

    1% of the product contains Truvia/Stevia. The benefits outweigh drinking 40 plus teaspoons of sugar. So I could careless. Your comments was worthless.

    We could sit here all day and talk about the dangers of most any consumer good. Pffft
  • ridge4mfp
    ridge4mfp Posts: 301 Member
    Tried Stevia, absolutely hated it. And yes, this was the pure, liquid version, still nasty. The other options such as aspertame and sucralose seem to irritate my urinary tract if I use it in drinks on a regular basis. I use sweeteners with cyclamates, which I order from the U.K. By far the best tasting sweetener in my opinion, and I have experienced no side effects. I drink a ton of iced tea, and this has been a huge factor in my success in cutting sugar.
This discussion has been closed.