Pasta confusion
e_curran15
Posts: 8 Member
Ok so this is probably a stupid question but here's the sitch. So last night I made pasta. The serving size on the package said 350 calories per 3.5 dry ounces. After I cooked it I measured out 3.5 ounces to eat..which was like not alot. But as I'm eating some today I'm wondering if I should have measured out like 6 ounces of the cooked pasta to meet the 350 calories of 3.5 ounces dry. ...or maybe I'm just wishing I could eat more lol. Anyone know if I'm right
0
Replies
-
If the nutritional information on the package is for dry pasta, you'll want to weigh it dry and then prepare it. It will weigh more when it is finishes because it absorbs water while cooking.0
-
you weigh and log it dry.
personally, i use entries for cooked versions. yes theres some inaccuracy, but im okay with that lol0 -
Dry ounces means the weight before you cook it. When you cook pasta, it absorbs water so 3.5 ounces dry is not the same as 3.5 ounces boiled.
My suggestion is to measure out 3.5 ounces of dry pasta. Boil it and then weigh it to see how much it weighs. You could also put it in a measuring cup to see how much it is. I did that with spaghetti and found that 2 oz. dry was equal to a slightly rounded 1 cup measuring cup full of boiled pasta. Now I just measure my spaghetti that way (we get the same kind all of the time.)0 -
Pasta is hard to measure after cooking. Weigh it dry then cook. Sometimes I even boil two pots when cooking for my family so I can keep my measured portion separate.0
-
e_curran15 wrote: »Ok so this is probably a stupid question but here's the sitch. So last night I made pasta. The serving size on the package said 350 calories per 3.5 dry ounces. After I cooked it I measured out 3.5 ounces to eat..which was like not alot. But as I'm eating some today I'm wondering if I should have measured out like 6 ounces of the cooked pasta to meet the 350 calories of 3.5 ounces dry. ...or maybe I'm just wishing I could eat more lol. Anyone know if I'm right
If the calories is for dry weight, then you were correct in what you did. Thing is recommended servings are always small, I don't know what 3.5ounces are (I use metric) but I know my pasta recommends 75g as a serving and that little pasta makes me want to cry. I have 100/110g and just allow for that many calories.
EDIT - No, I read your post wrong. You didn't measure it dry. You should have measured out the 3.5 dry. It's been a long day!0 -
Ok so basically I didn't just eat 350 calories of pasta because that was the measurement for dry. To eat the full 350 I should have measured out like 6 ounces of cooked pasta correct? I get confused with uncooked portions0
-
e_curran15 wrote: »Ok so this is probably a stupid question but here's the sitch. So last night I made pasta. The serving size on the package said 350 calories per 3.5 dry ounces. After I cooked it I measured out 3.5 ounces to eat..which was like not alot. But as I'm eating some today I'm wondering if I should have measured out like 6 ounces of the cooked pasta to meet the 350 calories of 3.5 ounces dry. ...or maybe I'm just wishing I could eat more lol. Anyone know if I'm right
Yes, when I cook pasta to al dente 2 ounces dry makes a little more than 4 ounces cooked, so you would have been safe using 7 ounces cooked.
Here's the system entry for cooked spags: "Spaghetti, cooked, enriched, with added salt"0 -
e_curran15 wrote: »Ok so basically I didn't just eat 350 calories of pasta because that was the measurement for dry. To eat the full 350 I should have measured out like 6 ounces of cooked pasta correct? I get confused with uncooked portions
Not necessarily. We don't know how much water your pasta absorbed. Where are you getting the 6 ounce number from?0 -
No, you weigh the 3.5 ounces dry then eat that after it cooks0
-
callsitlikeiseeit wrote: »personally, i use entries for cooked versions. yes theres some inaccuracy, but im okay with that lol
I agree, especially for stuff like pasta. I don't eat it very often, and it's too much trouble to try and measure mine and then cook in two pots to keep my measured portion away from my husband's whatever portion. Sometimes I will weigh dry and just count how many "noodles" are in a dry measured portion. and just kind of use that as a guide, knowing I won't get the exact 25 noodles I weighed earlier, but it's close enough for me. Works well for stuff like penne or farfalle that is easy to count.0 -
e_curran15 wrote: »Ok so basically I didn't just eat 350 calories of pasta because that was the measurement for dry. To eat the full 350 I should have measured out like 6 ounces of cooked pasta correct? I get confused with uncooked portions
You can't assume that the weight will double once it is cooked. The best way to know how much you're eating is to weigh it dry, cook it, and then eat that amount.0 -
weight it before you cook it - that's what it means by "dry". the weight of the water absorbed from cooking doesn't count in the weight of the serving size. You'll be happier about pasta then - it's a bigger serving size than you had - but still not big0
-
your cooked portion will weigh more than the 3.5 dry portion on the package...3.5 cooked is going to be less than 350 calories as you are consuming less than the actual serving on the package.
doubling the weight would be a reasonable way of estimating, but it would be far more accurate to weigh out a dry serving and then weigh it out again cooked...you only have to do that once so you know for future use how much a cooked serving would accurately weigh.0 -
There are no stupid questions, we are all idiots in this business, that's why we're here girl! But yeah, you could have eaten more pasta for sure, but now you know, and like GI Joe says, knowing is half the battle! Good luck0
-
I weigh it cooked, as that is how the nutrition is printed on the pack. If you are cooking for more than one and you want to weigh it raw, you can use something like this to keep your portion separate in the cooking pot http://www.amazon.co.uk/Healthy-Steps-229476-Portion-Control/dp/B003Y3B8RO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1452015160&sr=8-1&keywords=pasta+basket0
-
Thanks everybody!0
-
CurlyCockney wrote: »I weigh it cooked, as that is how the nutrition is printed on the pack. If you are cooking for more than one and you want to weigh it raw, you can use something like this to keep your portion separate in the cooking pot http://www.amazon.co.uk/Healthy-Steps-229476-Portion-Control/dp/B003Y3B8RO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1452015160&sr=8-1&keywords=pasta+basket
That is genius.
0 -
the 3.5oz dry is one serving. so, i would have eating the whole portion you made last night, since you measured out 3.5oz.0
-
-
I just make it all, eat it all, no weigh, and enjoy life!0
-
KANGOOJUMPS wrote: »I just make it all, eat it all, no weigh, and enjoy life!
When i did it that way i found out I was eating 3 servings of pasta (clocking in right around 1,200 calories) in every sitting.0 -
I always weigh out pasta dry because cooked size/portions will vary. You can find some great calories for dry and cooked pasta here though:
http://calorielab.com/foods/pasta-and-noodles/19
I cup of dry pasta is a heckuvah lot cooked to me, and calorie dense.
0 -
callsitlikeiseeit wrote: »personally, i use entries for cooked versions. yes theres some inaccuracy, but im okay with that lol
I agree, especially for stuff like pasta. I don't eat it very often, and it's too much trouble to try and measure mine and then cook in two pots to keep my measured portion away from my husband's whatever portion. Sometimes I will weigh dry and just count how many "noodles" are in a dry measured portion. and just kind of use that as a guide, knowing I won't get the exact 25 noodles I weighed earlier, but it's close enough for me. Works well for stuff like penne or farfalle that is easy to count.
For multiple servings I make, say, 4 servings and then measure the cooked and take 1/4.0 -
rainbowbow wrote: »KANGOOJUMPS wrote: »I just make it all, eat it all, no weigh, and enjoy life!
When i did it that way i found out I was eating 3 servings of pasta (clocking in right around 1,200 calories) in every sitting.
Yeah, my estimate by sight was way off with pasta, mostly because I'd use what seemed normal when dry, get lots more than I expected, and eat it all anyway because it was made and didn't save well. Sigh. Also, lots of Italian restaurants have crazy portion sizes.
What I was surprised to find is that a serving based on the box is typically plenty for me, sometimes I'm happy with less. It was just adjusting my expectations by measuring out the serving rather than trusting to my eye.0 -
You should have weighed the dry pasta, since that is what you had nutrition info for. If you're only adding water then you don't add calories, but the dry gets heavier as it absorbs the water.
If you were making pasta for more than yourself, then weight your total dry amount. Then after draining, weigh your total cooked amount. Then you can convert.e_curran15 wrote: »Ok so this is probably a stupid question but here's the sitch. So last night I made pasta. The serving size on the package said 350 calories per 3.5 dry ounces. After I cooked it I measured out 3.5 ounces to eat..which was like not alot. But as I'm eating some today I'm wondering if I should have measured out like 6 ounces of the cooked pasta to meet the 350 calories of 3.5 ounces dry. ...or maybe I'm just wishing I could eat more lol. Anyone know if I'm right
0 -
[/quote]
For multiple servings I make, say, 4 servings and then measure the cooked and take 1/4.[/quote]
I do the same. It's convenient and then I also have some pasta ready to go
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions