Carbs?

sdolan91
sdolan91 Posts: 250 Member
edited November 28 in Food and Nutrition
Question. I've read about people going on low carb diets, because carbs have a lot of calories?
Should I stay away from carbs? But I'm watching my calories anyway... So why does it matter? I'm so confused.

Replies

  • zoeysasha37
    zoeysasha37 Posts: 7,088 Member
    Protein and carbohydrates have 4 calories per gram and fat has 9 calories per gram. Not sure if that was your question though.

    For me I don't worry about carbs. Carbs don't cause people to gain weight. A calorie surplus causes weight gain. A calorie deficit causes weight loss.

    Some people with medical conditions must watch their carbs closer .

  • sdolan91
    sdolan91 Posts: 250 Member
    thorsmom01 wrote: »
    Protein and carbohydrates have 4 calories per gram and fat has 9 calories per gram. Not sure if that was your question though.

    For me I don't worry about carbs. Carbs don't cause people to gain weight. A calorie surplus causes weight gain. A calorie deficit causes weight loss.

    Some people with medical conditions must watch their carbs closer .

    Okay thanks!
    Yeah I always stay under my calorie goal.. and my cab goal. I was just wondering if I should stay way under for cabs or if it mattered or not
  • Slimdownmb
    Slimdownmb Posts: 130 Member
    I eat low carb every day, its what works best for me to see results and get the loss each week i want.
    But i do have a medical condition which slows down the whole carb, burning, digesting, blah blah thing... If you love carbs and are having good ones and you can still get results defo keep them. I wish i could have them, its the one thing i miss the most.

    x
  • Spook_Nuke_Em
    Spook_Nuke_Em Posts: 408 Member
    Low carb diets can be good if you're just starting to lose weight and want to get a fast 10lbs off, then you can start adding them back into your diet. Regardless of what type of meal plan you're on, I would stay away from carb loading on your last meal of the day. I usually eat most of my carbs in the morning and lunch and then try to have protein, veggies & minimal carbs during dinner.

    Don't know if this helps.
  • livingleanlivingclean
    livingleanlivingclean Posts: 11,751 Member
    Low carb diets can be good if you're just starting to lose weight and want to get a fast 10lbs off, then you can start adding them back into your diet. Regardless of what type of meal plan you're on, I would stay away from carb loading on your last meal of the day. I usually eat most of my carbs in the morning and lunch and then try to have protein, veggies & minimal carbs during dinner.

    Don't know if this helps.

    Get a fast 10lbs off =losing a lot of water weight, as carbs hold water. Which will come back on when you start eating a normal amount of carbs

    Nutrient timing is largely irrelevant. Eating carbs at night will not effect your weight loss efforts. Eat your carbs when you like (I say as I eat a bowl of frozen yoghurt mixed with protein, frozen berries and banana and half a mars bar... Before bed).
  • cecsav1
    cecsav1 Posts: 714 Member
    Protein satiates longer than carbs and promotes muscle building, so for me, it's not eating low carb but high protein that's important. That's within the same calorie range though, so in order to stay at 1674 calories per day, I sacrifice some carbs for higher protein. A gram of protein and a gram of carbs each has 4 calories. Hope that helps. :)
  • kcoty001
    kcoty001 Posts: 15 Member
    I'm a low carb/Paleo person because that is what works for me. It is easy for me to find a balance on and I feel good. I found I was eating and cooking overall better quality foods. I like that I cook most of my own foods now, know what is in it and have cut out the processed grub. I track calories and carbs and I don't feel deprived. I have three meals and 2 snacks everyday and love meal prepping because I actually save a lot of time and money =) I'm lactose intolerant and I've been hypothyroid almost 14 years and have had digestion issues/indigestion with gluten and some other foods. Its not for everyone though and it is science if you cut calories you will loose weight!
  • PiSquared
    PiSquared Posts: 148 Member
    I think at its core, the low carb diet fad does have a point. A lot of what we eat for carbs, especially heavily processed foods, tends to be 'empty calories', calorie dense foods without much nutrition. I do try to limit my intake of processed foods, but let's be honest. I like chips, and bread, and cookies, and pasta, and a lot of other carb heavy foods.

    I do not feel the need to eliminate carbs. I have no health conditions requiring me to do so, so I still eat them. I would be sad without carbs. They are yummy. Like any food, I think the secret is moderation. Eat carbs, but also eat proteins, fats, and vegetables. Have a treat every now and again. I will never give up cake completely, but I also don't eat it every day.

    I have found that if I eat too many carbs, I feel off. This came into play over Christmas, where it seemed like every time I turned around there were sweets and cookies and all sorts of carby goodness.
  • MelaniaTrump
    MelaniaTrump Posts: 2,694 Member
    edited January 2016
    I am high carb.
    I often eat quinoa, fiber cereal, brown rice, lots of beans, sweet potatos, skim milk, plain oatmeal, whole wheat pasta.
    Don't fear carbs too much? Ok? Often they provide lots of fiber which can make you feel full. Just stay within your calories.
  • lancelyell
    lancelyell Posts: 60 Member
    Do what you can sustain and make a lifestyle. Otherwise you will just be wasting your time. Personally I love carbs and you need them to help you push harder in your workouts. The key is finding the right percentage for your specific metabolism. I lost all my weight by eating 30-40% carbs. Hope that helps!
  • lemurcat12
    lemurcat12 Posts: 30,886 Member
    Low carb can help if you have trouble staying satiated or happen to overeat carbs for some reason (often people who claim this are talking about foods that are high fat as well as high carb and ignoring the numerous other carbs, like vegetables, fruits, and legumes, among many others). It's also important to get enough protein and healthy fats, and can be counterproductive to cut very low on fat, like people used to think they should back in the '90s.

    Also, if someone has a medical condition like diabetes they may have to watch their carbs in a particular way (which does not mean they need low carb in most cases).

    Beyond that, it does not matter what your macros are, and low carb is unlikely to be beneficial (or harmful, if you enjoy it).

    As others have already pointed out, the claim that "carbs" are high cal is false and irritating, but I know it's something lots of people say, because they don't understand. And as you figured out, since you are counting calories anyway, it's not like you'd be going over from the carbs without knowing it.

    Being carb-phobic is just our ages' repeat of the silly fat-phobia that we did before.
  • TeaBea
    TeaBea Posts: 14,517 Member
    lemurcat12 wrote: »
    Low carb can help if you have trouble staying satiated or happen to overeat carbs for some reason (often people who claim this are talking about foods that are high fat as well as high carb and ignoring the numerous other carbs, like vegetables, fruits, and legumes, among many others). It's also important to get enough protein and healthy fats, and can be counterproductive to cut very low on fat, like people used to think they should back in the '90s.

    Also, if someone has a medical condition like diabetes they may have to watch their carbs in a particular way (which does not mean they need low carb in most cases).

    Beyond that, it does not matter what your macros are, and low carb is unlikely to be beneficial (or harmful, if you enjoy it).

    As others have already pointed out, the claim that "carbs" are high cal is false and irritating, but I know it's something lots of people say, because they don't understand. And as you figured out, since you are counting calories anyway, it's not like you'd be going over from the carbs without knowing it.

    Being carb-phobic is just our ages' repeat of the silly fat-phobia that we did before.

    So this^

    I was out the other night with some friends. They asked if I wanted to join them in a low-carb meal replacement diet....Um no! I was polite and said no thanks.

    One went on to say that low carb is the only thing that works for her (she's 5 pounds overweight....10 tops) give me a break. I wanted to point out that low carb is the only that works QUICKLY (water weight)....not that it's the only thing that works. Clueless.

    OP - it's just an old fad coming back. What's old is new again (and again, and again).
  • Sued0nim
    Sued0nim Posts: 17,456 Member
    What going carb does do of course is play with your natural water weight so you can get a great emotional boost of seeing scale weight drop heavily in the first couple of weeks ...this helps bolster the erroneous belief that it is the most effective diet ...however over time all types of eating even out really (oh and that water weight comes back when you increase carbs and replenish your glycogen)

    That said if you find it easy to stick to a lower carb way of eating and it helps you hit your calorie goal, why not?

    It was never for me, I crashed and burned, over and over, each time losing and then gaining even more
  • Yi5hedr3
    Yi5hedr3 Posts: 2,696 Member
    There ARE no essential carbs (unlike Proteins & Fats), however they are great right before, and right after, a good workout!!! :)
  • sdolan91
    sdolan91 Posts: 250 Member
    edited January 2016
    Thanks so much for the replies.
    Yeah, I noticed some of my friends that cut the carbs gained it back quickly, because they started eating carbs again!
    I was really scared because I LOVE bread omg.
    So I'll just try to keep my carbs where MFP tells me to. :) Thanks everyone
This discussion has been closed.