Have You Skipped the Scale?

2»

Replies

  • brb_2013
    brb_2013 Posts: 1,197 Member
    FitnessTim wrote: »
    I try to weigh myself everyday, log the number and just forget about it. What a person weighs on a given day is meaningless. It's progress over time that matters most.

    That's a sweet concept but many people struggle with it, stating it so simply doesn't make it so.

    I have been doing my best to stay off the scale lately. I'm pushing for at least Feb 1 (allowing myself to fully recover from Holiday gain, I hope) and then monthly from there unless I can resist longer. Seeing the number just makes me feel so much anxiety and self loathing, even when it's moving as it should.
  • AdrianChr92
    AdrianChr92 Posts: 567 Member
    No reason to skip it. My weigh will still be the same
  • kirstinlee
    kirstinlee Posts: 152 Member
    I go crazy when I don't weigh in the morning. It's the first part of my day. I used to get discouraged by the numbers fluctuating, but I found an app -- Libra -- that charts your weight over time and shows you the trend instead of just the numbers. That way I can look back over time and see the downward trend instead of just an essentially arbitrary number. Helps put it in perspective.
  • jdhcm2006
    jdhcm2006 Posts: 2,254 Member
    I used to weigh myself weekly. But once I moved to my own place, I didn't own a scale for a while. I recently got the Fitbit Aria scale. So I have started to weigh myself daily bc it syncs automatically. I want to see the trends; especially, during my monthly cycle. I make sure I weigh myself fasted each morning (so the conditions are somewhat the same). However, if you're someone who gets freaked out by seeing tiny fluctuations, I wouldn't recommend a daily weigh in.
  • eviegreen
    eviegreen Posts: 123 Member
    clobern80 wrote: »
    JanetYellen wrote: »
    Everything I read says that you are more successful when you weigh yourself daily.

    I have NEVER heard this. I weigh myself weekly and never touch the scale again. Your weight fluctuates too much with weighing daily due to water, how much food is in your system and various other things.

    *raises hand* I have also read that daily weighing keeps the weight off more successfully.

    Because even though weight fluctuates, the daily weigher will notice when that weight fluctuates higher and starts to creep up, and they'll be able to adjust their calories to bring their weight back down much sooner than those who weigh less frequently.

    The daily weigher also becomes familiar with his/her daily weight fluctuations, what their fluctuations look like after certain meals the day before (I'm usually dead on accurate how much water weight I'll have following a night of drinking, for example), and during certain times of the month.

    The daily weigher, who uses the scale as a tool, takes each morning's scale number as a data point in a trend. The more data points the person puts in, the more accurate the trend, the more accurately they're able to tell whether gains and losses are legitimate or just fluctuations.

    As to the original question: I went from weighing myself sporadically (because I was afraid of the number on the scale) to weighing myself daily. When I weighed myself sporadically, I didn't notice when the weight started creeping back up because using the scale just upset me.

    Then I put on my big girl (fat) panties, stepped on the scale, and decided I would listen to all the advice I read and weigh myself daily. I use the Libra app to track my weight. The things I credit most with finally making it down to a healthy weight are: 1. Weighing my food ; 2. Logging my food ; and 3. Weighing myself every day even when it's after a huge Christmas meal.

    Being honest with yourself (about your food and your weight) is a huge part of a successful weight loss.

  • 88meli88
    88meli88 Posts: 238 Member
    Not weighing myself regularly is what got me into this mess in the first place. Bye bye DENIAL, my good old friend. The scale keeps me accountable. Also, you need to find your sweet spot of losing the optimum amount of weight without feeling deprived and that can take some trial and error on what is the right calorie deficit, how much of it from food and how much from exercise. It can also be super motivating to see the number go down from week to week. Once I understood what can affect weight fluctuations, I obsessed less about it

    If you are worried about daily fluctuations, you can find weight visualization apps that smooth fluctuations in your daily weight. I use Happy Scale for example. It actually makes daily weigh ins fun and reduces the big expectation towards the end of the week weigh in. It evens out big losses and also puts gains from time to time into perspective. Eg if you are out of town for a few days and you gain a bit of weight but it is within a three week period of losing, it will still look like you are losing weight over the longer period of time. So it helps you manage the expectations and your reactions to the number.
  • kommodevaran
    kommodevaran Posts: 17,890 Member
    I'm with the rest of the daily weighing gang. I feared the scale, didn't want to see that I was gaining weight. Weighing daily takes away that fear (I can't possibly have gained three pounds of fat in two days - so, it has to be water weight).

    These fluctuations are natural, everybody has them. If you can't handle them, but still need to keep track of your weight, I suggest getting an old fashioned analog scale that tells you you weight in whole pounds or kilos.
  • crb426
    crb426 Posts: 661 Member
    I weigh everyday. It's great encouragement to keep going, and a reminder to stay in control.
  • kristen6350
    kristen6350 Posts: 1,094 Member
    I lost my first 30lbs without a scale. Just cut back on calories and watched my clothes size decrease. When I got within 20lbs of my goal I got a scale (actually just to see how much I actually did weigh). Now I'm in maintainance I find that I HAVE to get on the scale every 2 weeks to just make sure it's holding somewhat steady. If I don't, I tend to go a bit off the rails.
  • funchords
    funchords Posts: 413 Member
    I weigh every day. You need to try an app called Libra (for Android) or Happy Scale (for iPhone). They smooth out the fluctuations and make it a lot easier emotionally to weigh.
  • sabified
    sabified Posts: 1,035 Member
    The last time I weighed myself was Xmas eve, just because I went to a party and the person had a scale in their bathroom... otherwise, I don't have one so have no idea how I'm doing. I don't know if I'm losing weight or not, but at the same time I don't get negative and down from weight fluctuations. My calories are generally in a deficit (though I'm not very strict on myself this time around, so not "perfect" by any means) and I figure as long as I keep going at this rate, I'll lose. I'm not as intense about losing according to a timeframe as I was when I first started using MFP, though I'm pretty sure if I were to get a scale I would fall right back into that.

    I'm a lot less stressed out this time than I was before, so I'm really resisting getting a scale, though I'm so tempted to.
  • whooRAWRowlbear
    whooRAWRowlbear Posts: 47 Member
    I weigh myself daily because I like seeing how my weight fluctuates from day to day, especially in response to when I eat certain foods. It also helps me keep it as a routine. I only really care about my "official" weigh-in day on Wednesdays when I track all my measurements. It coincides with the day I usually do my biometric screening for work later in the year.
  • 20months
    20months Posts: 62 Member
    crb426 wrote: »
    I weigh everyday. It's great encouragement to keep going, and a reminder to stay in control.

    Exactly the same for me.
  • AdrianChr92
    AdrianChr92 Posts: 567 Member
    edited January 2016
    funchords wrote: »
    I weigh every day. You need to try an app called Libra (for Android) or Happy Scale (for iPhone). They smooth out the fluctuations and make it a lot easier emotionally to weigh.


    Libra is cool. It can get scary when your weight fluctuates this much but what matters is the long time period. Not day to day
    b9wevbb5i35y.jpg
  • chopperchalk
    chopperchalk Posts: 1 Member
    I'm on day 11 and don't intend to weigh until 30 days, 60, 90 etc. I've got 100lbs to lose but I'm more concerned with my BF percentages as that is more important than my actual weight. I'm weighing only so that I can adjust my HR monitor and record calorie burn accurately. My target is 20% and I really don't care what the scale says when I get there.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories