PCOS and weight loss

diwijo13
diwijo13 Posts: 106 Member
edited January 2016 in Health and Weight Loss
I have PCOS and the last time I tried to make a lifestyle change, I quit after a year due to discouragement and personal issues. It was so hard to lose my stomach fat. It took me 1 year to lose 30 lbs and 10 of those lbs were in the first month. For those who have PCOS, what's the most weight you were able to lose in the least amount of time? How did you accomplish that? What were your macro settings, especially carbs, what exercises worked for you, etc?

Replies

  • hlcavalieri
    hlcavalieri Posts: 28 Member
    Hello! I too have PCOS. Unfortunately everyone loses weight at their own pace, and PCOS can sometimes make it a little more tricky! I'm currently down 27lbs, I started my lifestyle change in June, so I'm moving relatively slowly.
    Slow and steady wins the race though! I changed my eating habits, by eating healthier options, and smaller portions. I also try to work out at least 20 minutes a day.Any healthy changes you make is going to be beneficial, and will help with the PCOS symptoms! Good luck to you!
  • seska422
    seska422 Posts: 3,217 Member
    I wouldn't worry about the time it takes to lose weight. It's a marathon, not a sprint.

    If I'm not gaining weight, that's a win.

    If I'm losing weight, that's 2 wins.
  • Mexicanbigfoot
    Mexicanbigfoot Posts: 520 Member
    I have PCOS. I have been at this (seriously) for 8 months now and I have lost 77 pounds. I have not lost all stomach fat, it's impossible to target certain areas but I have gone down 5 pants sizes and 1-2 shirt sizes. I weight and log ALL my food. I cook once a week and package meals for the whole week; breakfast lunch and snacks. I pre-log every day so there is no guess about what I will be eating. I work out with a personal trainer 3 times a week for 1 hour (a mix of cardio and lifting weights) and I do cardio workouts on my own 5-6 days a week. I still have about 110 pounds to go, but it's not impossible. You just have to be dedicated and diligent! Good luck!
  • Nell8i8
    Nell8i8 Posts: 61 Member
    I too have PCOS when I was younger I lost 70 lbs with diet and exercise but unfortunately I let a knee injury keep me from being active and within the last 3 years I've gained 50 of it back. I let myself become lazy and a bit depressed but I'm now fighting it back off. It can be done but there is no short cut. Good luck. Feel free to add me.
  • wkwebby
    wkwebby Posts: 807 Member
    Stomach fat is stubborn for all females, but more so than others (due to genetics). Do the best and don't get down on yourself. A year is a long time, reevaluate your methods after a month at a time (if you're not losing, change something after reevaluating what you're doing). Doing the same thing after a year and getting nowhere would be frustrating for anyone. Good luck!
  • diwijo13
    diwijo13 Posts: 106 Member
    Thanks for the replies. I knew that it would take me longer; it just seemed to take too long. Lol 20 lbs in 11 or so months was crazy (after 10 lbs the first month). I was even lifting weights. I'm in it for the long run now. I just want to make sure that I'm doing everything I can. I bought a scale last time but it wasn't digital. So to Walmart I go today to get me one. Is anyone taking metformin or any other type of PCOS medication? If so, did it help? Thanks again.
  • Deena_Bean
    Deena_Bean Posts: 906 Member
    There really isn't a perfect formula for ladies with PCOS...what each of us responds to may be entirely different from another. There are many variables as well that will make a difference in what your body responds to. My experience and education point to the most effective way of eating is low carb for PCOS. Almost all women who eat that way, to my knowledge, have success. Yes, the rate of loss and success is variable, but because of the many aspects to PCOS, low carb seems to be a thumbs up. It's what I do and I can tell you that the level of feeling hungry has gone SO far down. That's huge for me. I've come across many other benefits while eating this way as well. The weight is coming off fairly slowly, but it's coming off. Yes it's up and down, but the overall is down.

    That aside, the first and largest chunk of weight I lost was after about 9 or so years ago. I lost about 50 pounds in one year doing weight watchers. Some came back, but not a lot. Since that loss I'm down about 10-15 more and this next 15-20 is the end of the loss journey. I feel like it will never happen because it's been 15-20 "more" for like 7 years. Uphill battle...the only way to lose the battle is to quit it, though. So I just keep fighting...
  • KatEmmaMarie
    KatEmmaMarie Posts: 64 Member
    I've only been recently diagnosed with PCOS but have struggled with it and the symptoms of it my entire life. I was very overweight for as long as I can remember, as early as middle school. I finally found the motivation/dedication to make a change about 4 years ago. Within roughly 10-12months I lost a total of 75 pounds by joining weight watchers (to track what I was eating) and working out 6 days a week. The weight came off super fast, I was consistently losing 2-3 pounds a week. This I believe happened because I was super strict about what I was eating and making sure I worked out 6 days a week. My work outs consisted of mainly cardio, running on the treadmill or using the elliptical. I was also a college student living on my own (8 hours from my family) so I controlled any food that I bought/had around my room. I also had a very active job, on my feet walking for the entire shift. That definitely helped.
    Fast forward to 2 years ago when my lifestyle changed a lot (graduated from school, left the really active job for a very much sedentary job) I gained about 15 pounds within the year and have maintained at that 15 pound gain.
    Fast forward to now and I am trying to get that final 15 back off. Within the 2 years I've managed to go down, but then back up always plateauing at the 15pounds gained point. But I finally put my foot down and joined MFP to track my food and have actively gotten back into working out. I now make sure I do cardio 5 days out of the week and cross training the other two. I've lost about 7 pounds and have about 8 pounds left to get back to my "happy" weight.
    It's definitely coming off more slowly than it did 4 years ago, I have been losing around 1lb a week. It can be a bit discouraging when I remember seeing those 3lb weight losses and not understanding why it's taking longer now. But I've come to accept that things are very different now than they were 4 years ago, so I am happy that I am just finally getting back control over my body.
    As far as the stomach issues, I have the same problem. My stomach (and thighs too) is my main trouble area. It definitely doesn't come off that area in ways that I want it to. Don't get my wrong, my stomach is smaller than it ever was 4 years ago, but I definitely have awkward pudge around the belly button that actually causes my belly button to almost get lost in the pudge. My two younger sisters have both always been super skinny and they have that "typical flat stomach" and I've always been jealous of it. I've come to accept the fact that I will most likely never see a naturally flat stomach.
  • LKArgh
    LKArgh Posts: 5,178 Member
    diwijo13 wrote: »
    I have PCOS and the last time I tried to make a lifestyle change, I quit after a year due to discouragement and personal issues. It was so hard to lose my stomach fat. It took me 1 year to lose 30 lbs and 10 of those lbs were in the first month. For those who have PCOS, what's the most weight you were able to lose in the least amount of time? How did you accomplish that? What were your macro settings, especially carbs, what exercises worked for you, etc?

    I have PCOS, diagnosed more than 20 years ago. Never been overweight. It is true that whatever fat I have on my body is in the tummy area. But PCOS does not mean it is impossible to be at a normal weight. Actually it works the opposite: the more overweight you are, the worst PCOS becomes. For me, variations within the normal BMi range make a huge difference in symptoms.
    Limit your calories, increase your physical activity and be patient. Do not have crazy expectations. 20 lbs loss in a year is actually a very good pace, PCOS or not.
  • pineygirl
    pineygirl Posts: 322 Member
    I'm down 19lbs in a little over 3 months. I have never really been overweight as I have lean PCOS, but I put a little too much weight on with my son and kept it on for more than a year. I had another miscarriage (two before my son in 2013 and one in early October of last year), and it made me want to change. So I decided to get healthy and part of that meant getting back in shape and losing the 15lbs of baby weight I was hanging on to.

    I eat about 30% carbs, 35% protein and 35% fat. It varies from day to day but it's pretty close to that.

    I try to eat whole grains and veggies for carbs, and a little bit of fruit. And I always part carbs with protein so they don't raise my blood sugar so much.

    On the day of my miscarriage I was 130lbs. I'm 110.8lbs today. Going to stop losing once I get around 107 to 108lbs...then switch to maintenence and probably put back a couple pounds from getting back my stored glycogen....and hopefully be around 110lbs when I concieve the next one.
  • Gerbsxyng412
    Gerbsxyng412 Posts: 86 Member
    I have lost 70 lbs so far.. hormones are normal again and I am tons healthier... I have another 100 lbs to lose ...before I am at my goal weight !
  • touraymm82
    touraymm82 Posts: 1 Member
    I have pcos as well... I'm wondering what calorie range others go for. Mfp suggests 2620 for me but I do not lose weight at that... Even 2000 seems like too much. The scale does not move
  • 3AAnn3
    3AAnn3 Posts: 3,054 Member
    I have PCOS and hypothyroidism. It's more difficult for us to lose for sure. You need to balance your hormones, which obviously makes things better. Make sure you're getting healthy fats in your diet, like coconut and avocado. Don't cut calories too low. Eat high quality foods like grass-fed or pasture raised meats, organic milk, lots and lots and lots more vegetables and fruits. Cut out the processed crap. Limit any processed sugar or carb. Those are killers for women with PCOS. I have healed my body so much through diet and exercise. I do lots of weight training and a decent amount of cardio. PCOS is pretty much caused by our modern lifestyle and diet and can be reversed (though maybe never eliminated) by changing those things.
  • kshama2001
    kshama2001 Posts: 28,052 Member
    diwijo13 wrote: »
    Thanks for the replies. I knew that it would take me longer; it just seemed to take too long. Lol 20 lbs in 11 or so months was crazy (after 10 lbs the first month). I was even lifting weights. I'm in it for the long run now. I just want to make sure that I'm doing everything I can. I bought a scale last time but it wasn't digital. So to Walmart I go today to get me one. Is anyone taking metformin or any other type of PCOS medication? If so, did it help? Thanks again.

    My girlfriend with PCOS had good success with metformin and eating low carb. She loves her endocrinologist.
  • new_fit_2016
    new_fit_2016 Posts: 9 Member
    I too suffer from PCOS, was diagnosed last year after having suddenly gained 20 pounds in 3-4 months, all while eating healthy and exercising. It's been tough, but I always feel better when eating low carb and exercising, haven't lost much weight though. Any tips??
  • wkwebby
    wkwebby Posts: 807 Member
    The suggestions from MFP are all based on the average person. So there are no adjustments for your medical condition. You need to identify what your baseline TDEE is (what you would normally spend in calories throughout the day or week) and subtract an adequate number of calories to be in deficit to lose weight. From the forums I've heard that women with PCOS will need less calories than an average healthy woman without PCOS. So if 2000 calories is what MFP allowed (without adjustments), then you should shoot for lower than that and figure this number is your maintenance number (at the best case and hope you don't gain on that number). Everyone is different and will expend more or less energy. Please carefully consider these things. You definitely don't want to starve, but try a little of each of the methods. Low carb (so you feel fuller on less calories), exercise a little, and keep strict track of your calories. You should be able to lose the weight. Metformin is one way to go, but it is a crutch that you will have to keep taking if you don't change the other factors in your life.
  • new_fit_2016
    new_fit_2016 Posts: 9 Member
    Great advice, thanks. I was put on metformin as soon as I was diagnosed and it only made me gain more weight. Plus the negative side effects of nausea, headaches and belly ache made me stop taking metformin. I did however manage to lose the 5+ pounds I gained with metformin.
  • srv524
    srv524 Posts: 1,363 Member
  • suz_z_q
    suz_z_q Posts: 3 Member
    My doctor suspects i have pcos as well. This was discovered after a false positive pregnancy test about 3 months ago. I have been working out for about 3 months now and i am down almost 20 pounds. I have not changed much with my eating yet, but i did increase my workouts. I just downloaded the mfp app on my new phone to start tracking my food so that i can better manage my good and exercise.
    I will be starting metformin this week as well. Im not a fan of the idea of medications forever but if it help gets everything back to normal, then i will give it a try!
    I am searching for some friends to motivate me and keep me positive that i can deal with this disease and still be a mommy someday soon!
  • cafeaulait7
    cafeaulait7 Posts: 2,459 Member
    edited January 2016
    Metformin helps balance other hormones than just the insulin, so I don't think it's a crutch even if you do lose weight (when needed), go low carb and exercise. One of the worst effects of PCOS is male-pattern facial hair problems (not to mention infertility), so I wish I'd taken the metformin way, way back when it was first suggested to me. It does help balance the androgens (although I also need Prometrium to further cut down the extra estrogen from PCOS).

    For me, that's also aside from the fact that it might have prevented my worsening IR problem :( I did not have to lose weight (was quite skinny for most of those early years) and my yearly fasting blood glucose didn't show diabetes, so I did not take the metformin back then. Now I definitely do --after the facial hair growth and hyperglycemia, dammit. I never tried to have kids.

    The side effects of Metformin go much, much better if you wean on slowly and take the met with food. Mine does great now. I dropped weight really quickly for no reason for a few months when I first started, too, so that was pretty cool since I was trying to lose the last few lbs of a 30-lb weight gain.

    ETA: Oh, and Metformin made a change in how I finally lost my lower tummy pooch! I never, ever lose this certain amount of pooch, yet I did last year after getting on Metformin and losing those last lbs. I've been at this weight before, often, and the composition was different. The only problem was that I have a teeny bit of loose skin at the bottom because I've had that little pooch since puberty, lol. It's not many inches at all, but I swear I did nothing different except for met and lower carbs (for the hyperglycemia I now have).
  • swall0810
    swall0810 Posts: 148 Member
    I have PCOS also. Was diagnosed 2 years ago and my weight is always up and down. Recently I put on a lot of weight and struggling to lose it. I just started Metformin 2 days ago but it wasn't for weight loss, it is for other reasons. Pcos sucks. Feel free to add me and we can encourage each other.
  • azulvioleta6
    azulvioleta6 Posts: 4,195 Member
    I have PCOS as well as 4 other metabolic diseases.

    I eat a lower-carb diet (75G/day seems to be my sweet spot...100G/day is my upper limit for maintenance) and I exercise a lot--generally 90-120 minutes/day, generally 6 days/week. About half of my exercise is low-intensity (walking) and the rest is higher intensity. I tend to alternate high- and low-impact exercises so that I don't need to take many rest days.

    I've not kept track of speed of weight loss, but I have been able to lose 90 pounds and maintain it. I would like to lose 20 more pounds, but serious medical issues mean that it might not be physically possible for me.

    It's going to take you longer than a healthy person and it will be more difficult. Do it anyhow. You can make a HUGE difference in your A1C and that translates to a lifetime of improved health and feeling better. It is worth it.
  • diwijo13
    diwijo13 Posts: 106 Member
    One of the worst effects of PCOS is male-pattern facial hair problems (not to mention infertility), so I wish I'd taken the metformin way, way back when it was first suggested to me. It does help balance the androgens (although I also need Prometrium to further cut down the extra estrogen from PCOS).

    For me, that's also aside from the fact that it might have prevented my worsening IR problem :( I did not have to lose weight (was quite skinny for most of those early years) and my yearly fasting blood glucose didn't show diabetes, so I did not take the metformin back then. Now I definitely do --after the facial hair growth and hyperglycemia, dammit. I never tried to have kids.

    The side effects of Metformin go much, much better if you wean on slowly and take the met with food. Mine does great now. I dropped weight really quickly for no reason for a few months when I first started, too, so that was pretty cool since I was trying to lose the last few lbs of a 30-lb weight gain.

    ETA: Oh, and Metformin made a change in how I finally lost my lower tummy pooch! I never, ever lose this certain amount of pooch, yet I did last year after getting on Metformin and losing those last lbs. I've been at this weight before, often, and the composition was different. The only problem was that I have a teeny bit of loose skin at the bottom because I've had that little pooch since puberty, lol. It's not many inches at all, but I swear I did nothing different except for met and lower carbs (for the hyperglycemia I now have).

    Yes! The facial hair. I hate it! I've taken spirolactone (sp) to help with that, but it takes a while to work and once you stop taking it the hair just comes back. I've even thought about laser treatments but heard that it's not guaranteed for people with PCOS and that the hair can just come back.

    I've never heard of Prometrium. I'll have to look into that. And I too was very skinny when I was young. Oh how I wish I could get back to those days. Lol

    My next step is to go back to my endocrinologist for the metformin. I hear that the XR pills lessen the side effects.
  • diwijo13
    diwijo13 Posts: 106 Member
    wkwebby wrote: »
    From the forums I've heard that women with PCOS will need less calories than an average healthy woman without PCOS. So if 2000 calories is what MFP allowed (without adjustments), then you should shoot for lower than that and figure this number is your maintenance number (at the best case and hope you don't gain on that number). Everyone is different and will expend more or less energy. Please carefully consider these things. You definitely don't want to starve, but try a little of each of the methods. Low carb (so you feel fuller on less calories), exercise a little, and keep strict track of your calories. You should be able to lose the weight. Metformin is one way to go, but it is a crutch that you will have to keep taking if you don't change the other factors in your life.

    I've never heard about eating fewer calories than MFP recommended, but maybe that's why I gave up last time. Right now MFP has me at 1540 calories to lose 2 lbs a week. I don't think that I can go any lower. I already feel irritated probably due to eating fewer calories. Last time I did too much in the beginning and by the end of the 1st month, I felt tired and run down, not energized even though I had lost 10 lbs. Now only after 6 days I am feeling the same way. I'm really considering metformin so at least I can level the playing field.
  • diwijo13
    diwijo13 Posts: 106 Member
    I have PCOS as well as 4 other metabolic diseases.

    I eat a lower-carb diet (75G/day seems to be my sweet spot...100G/day is my upper limit for maintenance) and I exercise a lot--generally 90-120 minutes/day, generally 6 days/week. About half of my exercise is low-intensity (walking) and the rest is higher intensity. I tend to alternate high- and low-impact exercises so that I don't need to take many rest days.

    I've not kept track of speed of weight loss, but I have been able to lose 90 pounds and maintain it.

    90 lbs is impressive! How long did it take? I have my carbs set at 40% now. My goal is to lower that to 30% by April since I just started on this journey. Now I'm trying to increase my protein, which will help lower my carbs.

    I wish i could exercise 1.5-2 hrs a day but i don't think i could keep that up for long. Lol. I exercised 3 times this week already so I am doing a little something. Last time I did stronglifts and loved it so I'm going to start that soon and take group classes, something I didn't do last time. I have heard that walking is a big help, even low intensity walking so I do Leslie Sansone's Just Walk.
  • diwijo13
    diwijo13 Posts: 106 Member
    suz_z_q wrote: »
    I have been working out for about 3 months now and i am down almost 20 pounds. I have not changed much with my eating yet, but i did increase my workouts. I just downloaded the mfp app on my new phone to start tracking my food so that i can better manage my good and exercise.

    Impressive, especially since you haven't changed your eating habits much. Yesterday, I bought a digital scale so I can log accurately. I'm hoping the scale and Metformin will help tremendously.
  • LKArgh
    LKArgh Posts: 5,178 Member
    diwijo13 wrote: »
    wkwebby wrote: »
    From the forums I've heard that women with PCOS will need less calories than an average healthy woman without PCOS. So if 2000 calories is what MFP allowed (without adjustments), then you should shoot for lower than that and figure this number is your maintenance number (at the best case and hope you don't gain on that number). Everyone is different and will expend more or less energy. Please carefully consider these things. You definitely don't want to starve, but try a little of each of the methods. Low carb (so you feel fuller on less calories), exercise a little, and keep strict track of your calories. You should be able to lose the weight. Metformin is one way to go, but it is a crutch that you will have to keep taking if you don't change the other factors in your life.

    I've never heard about eating fewer calories than MFP recommended, but maybe that's why I gave up last time. Right now MFP has me at 1540 calories to lose 2 lbs a week. I don't think that I can go any lower. I already feel irritated probably due to eating fewer calories. Last time I did too much in the beginning and by the end of the 1st month, I felt tired and run down, not energized even though I had lost 10 lbs. Now only after 6 days I am feeling the same way. I'm really considering metformin so at least I can level the playing field.

    If you not have done so already, you will need to change what you eat, to be happy with less calories. You can e.g. spend 500 calories on something that is low volume calorie-dense or for the same calories eat for example a normal serving of grilled meat/fish, plus a big side dish of vegetables, that will keep you fuller for far longer.
    Also maybe 2 lbs per week is a goal that is just too aggressive? Better slow and steady than giving up.
  • bellaa_x0
    bellaa_x0 Posts: 1,062 Member
    edited January 2016
    diwijo13 wrote: »
    One of the worst effects of PCOS is male-pattern facial hair problems (not to mention infertility), so I wish I'd taken the metformin way, way back when it was first suggested to me. It does help balance the androgens (although I also need Prometrium to further cut down the extra estrogen from PCOS).

    For me, that's also aside from the fact that it might have prevented my worsening IR problem :( I did not have to lose weight (was quite skinny for most of those early years) and my yearly fasting blood glucose didn't show diabetes, so I did not take the metformin back then. Now I definitely do --after the facial hair growth and hyperglycemia, dammit. I never tried to have kids.

    The side effects of Metformin go much, much better if you wean on slowly and take the met with food. Mine does great now. I dropped weight really quickly for no reason for a few months when I first started, too, so that was pretty cool since I was trying to lose the last few lbs of a 30-lb weight gain.

    ETA: Oh, and Metformin made a change in how I finally lost my lower tummy pooch! I never, ever lose this certain amount of pooch, yet I did last year after getting on Metformin and losing those last lbs. I've been at this weight before, often, and the composition was different. The only problem was that I have a teeny bit of loose skin at the bottom because I've had that little pooch since puberty, lol. It's not many inches at all, but I swear I did nothing different except for met and lower carbs (for the hyperglycemia I now have).

    Yes! The facial hair. I hate it! I've taken spirolactone (sp) to help with that, but it takes a while to work and once you stop taking it the hair just comes back. I've even thought about laser treatments but heard that it's not guaranteed for people with PCOS and that the hair can just come back.

    I've never heard of Prometrium. I'll have to look into that. And I too was very skinny when I was young. Oh how I wish I could get back to those days. Lol

    My next step is to go back to my endocrinologist for the metformin. I hear that the XR pills lessen the side effects.

    I started laser treatment about a year ago and it has definitely improved the hair situation for me; however, mine was not super extreme to begin with.. it was mostly my chin area. I still have a few strays that grow back in every now and then but they're not thick and dark like they used to be.
  • cafeaulait7
    cafeaulait7 Posts: 2,459 Member
    I tried several sessions of laser and it didn't do a thing! Not one thing. It was hundreds of dollars and I got zero out of it. Mine's not all that much (on my chin only, too) but the texture is startlingly male-like, so of course I hate it. It's definitely from androgen excess :(

    The Prometrium for me is taken every day, because I also have endometriosis and my doc and I wouldn't mind me not having a period at all. I don't take estrogen products, being in so much excess already from PCOS and being well over 35, etc. But lots of women with PCOS take the progesterone on a schedule that has their periods come back, where they don't take it certain weeks of the month. It works for fertility that way.

    The balance with PCOS is usually too much estrogen, too many androgens, too much insulin and not enough progesterone (of the ones that are commonly medicated for). That's why the symptoms include so many distressing things. It's also why I don't think the pill is nearly the best way to go about things, yet that's what doctors push for so hard. That's what I took for decades for it (and look how far it got me).