Fitbit? Are they worth it?
kentalanwilson
Posts: 2 Member
Looking to purchase a Fitbit (Charge HR). Do they work/help or is it just a gadget to waste $ on? I am doing CrossFit and want to know heart rate, calories burned etc.
Thanks!
Thanks!
0
Replies
-
I have a FitBit Charge HR and I never take it off (well, except to shower). I think it was worth it, for sure. Even if it's just to get to my 10,000 steps. You don't get a reward (besides a little buzz on your wrist) and yet I am still motivated to get there every day. So much to the point that i will walk in place for 10 minutes if I have to. It also helps if you have "friends" who have one too, that way you can add a little competition.0
-
I am not an expert on these gadgets, but from what I've read, there are several choices with different price ranges, and I'm sure functionality. Might be good to do research before buying to ensure you get what you want for the best price / functionality.0
-
Will_Run_for_Food wrote: »I have a FitBit Charge HR and I never take it off (well, except to shower). I think it was worth it, for sure. Even if it's just to get to my 10,000 steps. You don't get a reward (besides a little buzz on your wrist) and yet I am still motivated to get there every day. So much to the point that i will walk in place for 10 minutes if I have to. It also helps if you have "friends" who have one too, that way you can add a little competition.
This is me too. I love just asking sure I'm up and active and at the end of the day if I haven't hit my goal of 10,000 steps I like to get up and get moving. I have the charge hr and I like to see my heart rate when I'm working out and after just to see where I stand am I getting better etc.
0 -
It's worth it for me. I can't let that annoying girl from work get more steps than me. I'll walk circles around my kitchen island if I have to. It's also been nice to track sleep.0
-
Personally, I'm disappointed in my Charge HR. The heartrate isn't at all accurate, nor is the step count. I was at 300 before getting out of bed this morning. That said, it does encourage me to be more active.
If I could go back, I'd opt for a pedometer that goes around my ankle instead.0 -
kdcomstock89 wrote: »It's worth it for me. I can't let that annoying girl from work get more steps than me. I'll walk circles around my kitchen island if I have to. It's also been nice to track sleep.
OMG your comment is hilarious!!!! I love my fitbit though and have done challenges with my friend which have kept me motivated to keep MOVING. As a user said above, I like to see my heart rate changes. When I was hitting the gym regularly, my resting heart rate dropped from the low 90s to high 70s in a few weeks. I was so proud of myself (before the holidays stole my motivation for a few weeks :-( )
0 -
kentalanwilson wrote: »Looking to purchase a Fitbit (Charge HR). Do they work/help or is it just a gadget to waste $ on? I am doing CrossFit and want to know heart rate, calories burned etc.
Thanks!
So I think there are three parts to the answer.
Is an activity tracker useful? That's a very personal point and depends how you're motivated and what you hope to gain from it? Personally I find mine interesting, but it doesn't tell me much I didn't know.
Is the Charge HR a good device? It does two things, the accelerometer counts steps and the optical HRM can track HR data. The two different things can give you a range of data. The step tracker can be useful, the HR data has very limited utility to most users.
Is it useful for Crossfit? No, not even remotely. Neither of the two data sets give yyou anything meaningful with respect to your training or fitness. The calorie count will not be accurate and HR is meaningless in the context.0 -
I like the fitbit surge, step track and competition with my girlfriend is great (although she almost always wins, the wily little minx) the hr is consistent with my treadmill monitor and my recumbent bike, I can see messages in meeting (link to phone) and I can control music levels. oh and it tells time and date.......0
-
I've had a Zip for less than a week. So far, I'd say that it has pushed me to move more. I am super sedentary at work. Seeing the really low step number when I get home has encouraged me to go walk for a bit after dinner each night. Right now, I feel like its calorie count isn't really matching up with what I expect, based on logging my food/weight for the past couple of years, but I am being patient to see if that improves.0
-
I have the Force and love it. They had a recall due to a rash it was causing so I started moving it to my other wrist and back again, no more rash. I have worn it every day for more than two years, even in the shower! I like to run in the mornings and often get 10k steps before the sun comes up. I bought my mother in-law one and when she saw mine she asked "how many step you got?" I had had a busy day and had run 10 miles already so I looked and replied 22,000 She said go to hell!0
-
kentalanwilson wrote: »Looking to purchase a Fitbit (Charge HR). Do they work/help or is it just a gadget to waste $ on? I am doing CrossFit and want to know heart rate, calories burned etc.
Thanks!
They are definitely worth it! I currently have the Charge HR but I just pre-ordered the new Blaze. They will be out in March
0 -
I have had a fit bit for 3 years. First a One, then a Force (no longer available) and I got a ChargeHR last June.
To me, they are the best invention ever. I love Fit Bit. I am seriously thinking about up grading to their new Blaze. It is the perfect device to motivate me to move more.0 -
kentalanwilson wrote: »Looking to purchase a Fitbit (Charge HR). Do they work/help or is it just a gadget to waste $ on? I am doing CrossFit and want to know heart rate, calories burned etc.
Thanks!
At the start of your workout you can put the device in "exercise mode" by holding down the button (it will vibrate) This will track steps, distance, cals burned & heart rate" So YES this will be beneficial to use during crossfit. You just probably won't be getting a lot of steps. But it will determine calories burned based off your heartrate.
I use this when on my elliptical and stationary bike. Works great. Love seeing how many calories I burn.0 -
i just replaced my outdated 4 year old bodymedia band with a fitbit HR, and i'm totally happy. Its accurate for me so far, and already motivated me to increase my daily activity. My syncs up bluetooth with my phone, so if my phone screen is on, it shows me real time activity like my steps or calorie burn. i love that feature0
-
Will_Run_for_Food wrote: »I have a FitBit Charge HR and I never take it off (well, except to shower). I think it was worth it, for sure. Even if it's just to get to my 10,000 steps. You don't get a reward (besides a little buzz on your wrist) and yet I am still motivated to get there every day. So much to the point that i will walk in place for 10 minutes if I have to. It also helps if you have "friends" who have one too, that way you can add a little competition.
I am the exact same way. Just got mine on Sunday and I love it!0 -
I've been using mine (Charge HR) for about 6 months. My reasons for getting it were pretty simple - I wanted to automate the process of entering exercise calories into MFP, and give me a little extra motivation to keep moving during the day (e.g., to get to the magical 10K steps). It has definitely done both in spades.
To be fair, there are other fitness trackers out there that do more than the FitBit for less money.... but I'm pretty happy with the product.0 -
300 calories or steps? I'd talk to their customer support if the step count is that high in the morning.Personally, I'm disappointed in my Charge HR. The heartrate isn't at all accurate, nor is the step count. I was at 300 before getting out of bed this morning. That said, it does encourage me to be more active.
If I could go back, I'd opt for a pedometer that goes around my ankle instead.
As for calories, it gives an estimate of your total calories burned not just from purposeful exercise. You burn calories just by being alive.
I suggest reading this if you haven't.
0 -
It works for me, but probably wouldn't work for my husband. I am incredibly competitive and goal oriented. I am like the other posters who will "get my steps in"because not hitting that number would bug me. There are days that without it I would probably just watch tv.
0 -
Only if you like wasting your money on a product with customer service that treats you like crap.0
-
I just got a Charge HR about a week ago and I'm in love with it! It totally keeps me motivated to move more and it syncs with MFP too.0
-
craziedani wrote: »Will_Run_for_Food wrote: »I have a FitBit Charge HR and I never take it off (well, except to shower). I think it was worth it, for sure. Even if it's just to get to my 10,000 steps. You don't get a reward (besides a little buzz on your wrist) and yet I am still motivated to get there every day. So much to the point that i will walk in place for 10 minutes if I have to. It also helps if you have "friends" who have one too, that way you can add a little competition.
This is me too. I love just asking sure I'm up and active and at the end of the day if I haven't hit my goal of 10,000 steps I like to get up and get moving. I have the charge hr and I like to see my heart rate when I'm working out and after just to see where I stand am I getting better etc.
YES! My bf got me one and its really cool. Simple enough & just makes you want to put it to work.0 -
EleanorLynn1989 wrote: »Only if you like wasting your money on a product with customer service that treats you like crap.
I haven't had any problems with their service. In fact, I lost my Flex shortly after getting one, and when I finally contacted them months later, they asked for my receipt and sent me a brand new one. I was floored.0 -
EleanorLynn1989 wrote: »Only if you like wasting your money on a product with customer service that treats you like crap.
they have always been great to me since I had mine.0 -
whoisfriend wrote: »EleanorLynn1989 wrote: »Only if you like wasting your money on a product with customer service that treats you like crap.
I haven't had any problems with their service. In fact, I lost my Flex shortly after getting one, and when I finally contacted them months later, they asked for my receipt and sent me a brand new one. I was floored.
I as well as many other Fitbit users haven't been able to use ours for a week now because of a software glitch with Fitbit Connect and syncing issues. I'm about to throw mine in the trash.0 -
go to their forums and they will help you. I had that issue with updates and nothing they suggested worked. so they tried and tried and nothing. they sent me a replace because mine would not update to the new version. since then I dont have problems with it. the only thing that is wonky is the app not syncing info with the fitbit and it says tracker not found. but I think its their app software right now. if you go to the forums it will tell you if that is whats going on or not
0 -
I got the Charge a few weeks ago. I already have a Polar HRM, and wasn't really interested in the HR feature on the FitBit. So far I absolutely love it. I can sit at the computer for longer than I care to admit, and have actually had to delete a few sleep logs because it thought I was sleeping even though it was just me sitting at the computer not moving. That is eye opening actually seeing those chunks of time I should be doing something like moving! The challenges with friends (or even just by yourself to reach your daily goals) are motivating and seeing how everyone else is doing, getting cheered on or cheering on your friends is also fun. I always want to get my steps in and find myself chasing my dog around the living room in circles playing to get a few more in each night, just to see that higher number.
I also can't believe how much I missed wearing a watch. I haven't worn one regularly in nearly a decade, but find myself relying on the time (and date!) from it more and more in just these few weeks I've had it. Also, getting the vibrate and caller ID means I don't miss as many calls, and can make a quick decision on whether or not to stop what I'm doing and go get the phone depending on who's name shows up!0 -
I love mine. It keeps me motivated to get my steps in everyday.0
-
At the start of your workout you can put the device in "exercise mode" by holding down the button (it will vibrate) This will track steps, distance, cals burned & heart rate" So YES this will be beneficial to use during crossfit. You just probably won't be getting a lot of steps. But it will determine calories burned based off your heartrate.
So I'd assume you don't know much about crossfit?
The step count will be overestimate because it'll assume arm movements are steps, so that contribution fo calories expended will be wrong.
Basing calorie ehxpendirure estimates on HR assumes that HR is broadly constant and aerobic range. Crossfit sessions are rarely constant HR or consistently aerobic range.
Neither approach to approximating calorie expenditure will give an accurate figure.0 -
CharlieBeansmomTracey wrote: »go to their forums and they will help you. I had that issue with updates and nothing they suggested worked. so they tried and tried and nothing. they sent me a replace because mine would not update to the new version. since then I dont have problems with it. the only thing that is wonky is the app not syncing info with the fitbit and it says tracker not found. but I think its their app software right now. if you go to the forums it will tell you if that is whats going on or not
I did last week. I went to the Fitbit Flex Help Forums last week and they started moving threads around and no one was responding to the issue. I went to their facebook page hoping there'd be something there about it and there wasn't. I waited 2 days for a response and we never got one. Now I keep going back there and there still isn't anyone telling anybody what's going on with the glitch. It's been a week now. I'm really disappointed because these things aren't cheap. I got mine as a Christmas gift and I feel like I should pay my family back for something that isn't working before I get another tracker. Other than that, the product was great and it was an awesome motivator and I had even thought about getting other Fitbit models before this syncing issue happened.0 -
i really love my HR Charge... and now got upgraded to Surge... so far loving both and kinda making my obsessed over it...
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions