Fitness Trackers
smit7633
Posts: 182 Member
I want to know who's wearing one, which one, what you love about it, what you hate about it, and which features you wish it had?! And GO!
0
Replies
-
Fitbit Charge HR. I love it. I love that it count my steps and activity during day. I can even track a workout to get stats from that individual exercise. It has all the features i need.0
-
Fit Bit Flex ($100)
Pros: counts steps, keeps track of minutes when you're extra active, let's me know how much sleep I'm getting each night and how restless I was, syncs easily with MFP to adjust my calorie allowance, has a count down on the app that tells me how many pounds I have left to loose (which is currently a larger number than pounds I have lost, so I like seeing the bigger number of FitBit go down), has a silent alarm that vibrates on my wrist which is nice for mornings or a reminder during the day for things, it's slim compared to most, the band comes in lots of colors and if you change sizes of bands you don't have to buy a whole new device
Cons: you have to charge it every 5 days (doesn't take long though), it doesn't have a display screen on the device so you have to sync it to the app to see anything (the device just has 5 lights on it so you can see an approximation of what % of steps you have until your goal, it serves no other purpose than as an exercise device (i.e. not a watch), some would say it's not overly attractive, water resistant but not water proof so not really supposed to wear in the pool (although many of my friends do and haven't had an issue).
I've had my Flex for 2 years (it did just start having some issues getting it to charge) and am excited to be upgrading to the new one coming out in March. I think it's called FitBit Blaze. It looks like a watch, has a screen that shows everything, has a built in HR monitor, and some other upgrades0 -
I love my FitBit, too! I'm using the Charge HR and think it's the bees knees. The heart rate function allows for more accurate calorie burn readings which is always helpful! I find it gives me motivation to reach my step goal and reminds me to stay hydrated.0
-
Thanks for your posts ladies. Rebekah I'm also considering the fitbit Blaze, lots of great new features, but I'm so disappointed that fitbit still hasn't come out with a waterproof tracker!0
-
i have a moov now and i wear an FT4 with hrm. thinking on upgrading the ft4 though
moov Now pros: water proof, built in coach, can be used for swimming, running, walking, has built in workouts like boxing or 7 minute work out, maps daily cal burn and activity, tracks sleep.
cons: you can't see how much you've burnt on workouts that are not 'hosted' on the moov. (for example, cize. it wouldn't tell you the burn for it. Does not have a pedometer if that's what you're after0 -
Garmin Vivofit 2. ($80, amazon or best buy)
Pros: water proof to 5atm, 1 year battery life (uses watch batteries ), tracks calories burned, steps, sleep, shows the time. Syncs with mfp. Can customize what data you see on the tracker. Has an optional chest strap hrm for more accurate cardiovascular heart rate tracking (see cons)
Cons: App is only meh. Does not sync on its own, you have to open the app and press a button on the tracker, must also press button to track sleep. HRM isn't great. Could be me but it doesn't track as well as my 10 year old polar hrm. You can get it without the monitor.0 -
I use Paser and it is awesome. 0
-
My friend is letting me borrow her charge hr for a week to see how I like it before I buy one. I do find wearing it more motivating, but I really wish it was waterproof. Also the little screen scratches up easily, she had it for less than a month and it's already scuffed up. I'm leaning toward the activite pop, it's water proof and looks just like a regular watch, and doesn't need to be charged. The downside is that I have heard the app isn't too great, no hr monitoring and the price is a little high considering all the features it doesn't have compared to other trackers in the same price range.0
-
Garmin Vivoactive Watch w/ Chest Strap
Pros:
* gets phone notifications (texts, whatever)
* Different settings for indoor/outdoor exercises
* Great battery life--burns more battery when using chest strap, but only need to charge every couple of weeks.
* Tracks sleep
* Color display
* Can download different watch faces and applications
* Displays can be simple or complicated--my current one shows daily steps taken towards goal, weekly step average, calories burned, time, date, day, Bluetooth connectivity.
* Nudges me to move every 45 minutes. Must actually take steps to appease Garmin, no getting around it by waving your arms.
* Syncs with MFP.
* Good phone app
* Good website
* Pretty fire works display when you hit your steps goal for the day
*
Cons
* no optical (wrist) hrm. This was not a con for me. I only care about hr when training and believe the research I've read saying the chest straps are more accurate.0 -
Amazon sells screen protectors.My friend is letting me borrow her charge hr for a week to see how I like it before I buy one. I do find wearing it more motivating, but I really wish it was waterproof. Also the little screen scratches up easily, she had it for less than a month and it's already scuffed up. I'm leaning toward the activite pop, it's water proof and looks just like a regular watch, and doesn't need to be charged. The downside is that I have heard the app isn't too great, no hr monitoring and the price is a little high considering all the features it doesn't have compared to other trackers in the same price range.
0 -
I have my fitbit one that I wear in my pocket, and I just upgraded my Polar RCX3 HRM to a Polar M400 fitness tracker. It came with a chest strap with blue tooth, it has GPS for when I walk, run, or ride bike. I love it!!! Polar is the best HRM, imo, so when I saw they came out with the fitness tracker and it was time for a new HRM, I just had to get it. I do wish it would keep constant bluetooth connection with my phone, but that is the only qualm I have with it.0
-
basis peak fitness and sleep tracker
love mostly everything about it! it constantly tracks my heart-rate and has only been off by 1-2 beats max on occassion (was dead on when at docs). love that it automatically switches/knows when i walk, run, go to sleep, etc. and i don't have to remember to turn anything on or off.. Battery life is outstanding, i get 6-7 days of battery life when i don't turn on notifications, about 4 days when i keep notifications on. The sleep tracking part is my favorite of all (about 95% accurate) and the calories burned feature is my second favorite part. after first 2-3 days of Basis learning my ways, it started calculating my total burned calories (resting and active) pretty much on the nose, i have not gained a pound since eating at or closer to what it says i burned (which is more than what calculators/mfp says my maintenance cals should be). I also like that it has a notification feature on it so i can see who texts or calls me while working out without having to stop and go check my phone. Also like i can replace band with any non basis 23mm band i want and i like that i will not have to buy another watch when they introduce new updates/features in future (hopefully alarm clock being one soon).
con: no alarm feature yet, it is not great for indoor steps since i don't always swing my arms when i walk around my house but, worse thing about Basis, is they still have not made it useable with mfp!0 -
Sylvie does the basis peak start tracking your activity right away? I have done some research on the basis peak as it definitely has all the things I'm looking for and more. I've read that the app is kind of worthless as far interpreting your data and that it can sometimes take up to 15 minutes to recognize that you are doing an activity. What do you think?0
-
FrugalMom, since I've been test driving the charge hr I'm steadily liking the idea of a wearable that doesn't go on your wrist more and more. The charge hr really irritates my wrist at night, as I do move around a lot during sleep, by morning my wrist is aching. Also I walk on the treadmill a lot and I don't like to swing my arms, I like to hold on and that causes the wrist tracker not to count my steps. How do you like the fitbit one? Does the fitbit app sync with polarbfor HR monitoring or so you have to sync them to each other through MFP?0
-
A different approach would be figure out what data points you want to track, what activities you do (or plan on doing), then seeing which trackers do a good job of meeting those criteria. The question as asked is begging for confirmation bias.0
-
I have had a Fitbit zip, one, flex, and charge hr. I returned both the flex and the charge hr to to the store within a couple of weeks, and my one collects dust on my dresser. All the bells and whistles are fun for a few days, but having to charge the thing is a huge no for me. And I don't like wearing it on my wrist. I have a beautiful watch that I like to wear, and I just think fitness trackers look ugly. They also irritate my wrist- the flex not so much, but the charge hr really did. I like that the zip tells me what I need to know to get more active, but I can just clip it to my bra and forget about it. All IMHO, of course. 0
-
Thanks for your posts ladies. Rebekah I'm also considering the fitbit Blaze, lots of great new features, but I'm so disappointed that fitbit still hasn't come out with a waterproof tracker!
I have a Surge but I'm going to be getting the Blaze (can't wait to get it!). I love tracking the heart rate, sleep patterns, and the ability to just start a workout on it and it will tell me at the end of it how many calories i burned, based on my heartrate. I realize it's approximate, but I love that feature. I enjoy trying to get my daily steps in, that i can participate in challenges with friends on fitbit, and how it syncs to MFP and to WW.
I don't know if it'd be overkill, but i hear that Misfit (which I hear also tracks to WW, but not sure about MFP) has a waterproof tracker, so I suppose on days that you need to go swimming with a tracker, you could put that on instead of fitbit 0 -
FrugalMomsRock75 wrote: »I have my fitbit one that I wear in my pocket, and I just upgraded my Polar RCX3 HRM to a Polar M400 fitness tracker. It came with a chest strap with blue tooth, it has GPS for when I walk, run, or ride bike. I love it!!! Polar is the best HRM, imo, so when I saw they came out with the fitness tracker and it was time for a new HRM, I just had to get it. I do wish it would keep constant bluetooth connection with my phone, but that is the only qualm I have with it.
I just bought the Polar M400 too...I've had it about three weeks and I. Love. It. The little bar at the bottom of the watch face motivates me each day because I can't stand the idea of not seeing my goal met, haha! I've only ever owned Polar and even my friends with Fitbits like the look and functionality of this one better. My one annoyance is that the Polar Flow app doesn't sync with MFP if you have Android. Aside from that, it's great!0 -
Sylvie does the basis peak start tracking your activity right away? I have done some research on the basis peak as it definitely has all the things I'm looking for and more. I've read that the app is kind of worthless as far interpreting your data and that it can sometimes take up to 15 minutes to recognize that you are doing an activity. What do you think?
the app itself is pretty basic in info/data, i only use it to sync watch and do a quick look at basic info. The website is where the data is broken down for you really well IMO. you can see each activity you did on there and see what your heart rate/temps/perspiration/calories burned were during each activity.
i have never had watch take more than 5mins max to recoginzed i am doing an activity. 1 1/2 mins is about the average it usually takes on me. the up to 15min thing happens to some with certain activities that don't involve much arm movement. Personally i strap it a little above my ankle with certain activities (step aerobics/threadmill), it recognizes these activities well this way although the heartrate readings are not that accurate on ankle and it can be off on steps a tad bit (lower end).
It can take up to 15mins before the sleep tracking part will officially consider you awake when you wake up though, i wake up in slow mode so at first it did take about 10-15mins for it to log me as awake, after i realized this, i automatically started turning watch light on and swiping between screens and making sure to move my arm when i walked down to kitchen after i get out of bed.
two things you may not like about watch btw, is how tightly you may have to wear it to get accurate sleep data. it bothered me at first but, not so much after i got a $20 non peak watch band that was softer. the second thing you may not like is the bulkiness look of the watch if you are a on the low medium or smaller frame female.
Also other than its great sleep tracker, the basis peak is made more for walking, running and outdoor biking activities (more if you can get a band to fit on your ankle though).. And it is indeed waterproof but, if you don't take it off and dry it off, you can end up with a yuck rash on your wrist!
0 -
Thanks for your reply Sylvie and everyone else who posted a comment. I love getting all his in depth information about all the different trackers! It's all going to help me a lot going forward!0
-
The charge hr really irritates my wrist at night, as I do move around a lot during sleep, by morning my wrist is aching. Also I walk on the treadmill a lot and I don't like to swing my arms, I like to hold on and that causes the wrist tracker not to count my steps.
Try wearing the band looser at night? Mine never bothers me at night.
For your treadmill steps, tuck it into your pants. When I'm doing a lot with my hands, and don't want am movements counted as steps, I put my Charge HR on my hip, tucked into my underwear. This way, it's still on my skin so my heart rate is still tracked, and tracks just my steps.
0 -
It never occurred to me that it would work I'd I didn't have it on my wrist. Good to know Laura!laurainottawa wrote: »The charge hr really irritates my wrist at night, as I do move around a lot during sleep, by morning my wrist is aching. Also I walk on the treadmill a lot and I don't like to swing my arms, I like to hold on and that causes the wrist tracker not to count my steps.
Try wearing the band looser at night? Mine never bothers me at night.
For your treadmill steps, tuck it into your pants. When I'm doing a lot with my hands, and don't want am movements counted as steps, I put my Charge HR on my hip, tucked into my underwear. This way, it's still on my skin so my heart rate is still tracked, and tracks just my steps.
0 -
I am wearing a Garmin Vivofit HR and it is awesome.
PROS - waterproof, alerts, accurate heart rate monitoring that quickly picks up spikes (so it registers High Intensity activities and weightlifting, and is not affected much by arm swings), accurate pedometer even though I use my hands a lot at work, decent app, syncs seamlessly with MFP and a few other apps, can tell when I am sleeping without starting a session, allows me to edit sleep and activity sessions (in case it makes a mistake), relatively inexpensive ($150), perfect screen size for alerts, able to customize the info that shows on the device, comfy (I only take it off to charge it), compatible with my apple phone and my windows phone, motivational messages on my least active day...there is not much I don't like about it
CONS - needs recharging about every five days, the app stores no info on your phone, so you cannot see anything when you're not connected...0 -
I have a Misfit Shine/Swarovski crystal tracker. It does everything my Fitbit used to do but my Fitbit died four times in one year - one only lasted three weeks! To be fair, the Fitbit company replaced every one of the dead trackers without complaint. The Misfit uses a disposable battery, so no charging, and it's pretty enough to wear even if it wasn't a tracker.
0 -
Misfit's swarovski crystal tracker certainly is attractive, it's new right? I'd love to hear from you in a few months about how well it's held up for you! It's gorgeous!0
-
I just pre-ordered the Under Armour UA Band. It's waterproof and does everything except for help you find your phone, which the Garmin does and I ALMOST went for that one. I have to have waterproof as I'm a Barista and we're constantly spilling stuff. Lol0
-
Can't wait to hear how you like it. Keep us updated once you receive it and had a chance to test drive it!BigSouthsWifey wrote: »I just pre-ordered the Under Armour UA Band. It's waterproof and does everything except for help you find your phone, which the Garmin does and I ALMOST went for that one. I have to have waterproof as I'm a Barista and we're constantly spilling stuff. Lol
0 -
i heard the basis Peak is meant to be quite an accurate wrist monitor, but you can't beat a chest monitor 0
-
Fitbit Charge HR.
Not having any problems with the battery, as I don't have it on all day sync.
Definitely gets me moving more, I like seeing what I'm burning everyday.
I like the weekly email progress report....so far my projected weight loss on it has been spot on.0 -
Hello everyone. My VivoFit is getting here this week. I was just wondering what y'all set your daily activities at on your profiles. Seems if I'm going to use my Fit for all my calories burned it should be at Sedentary, but I just wanted to see what others were doing. Thanks.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions