STILLLL... Hungry alll the time..

Your snacks and lunches seem high in calorie, which is fine, but they are more calorically dense than other snack options. ie Instead of peanut butter, substitute grilled chicken strips. They are more filling for the amount of calories you eat. Instead of steak, have turkey meatballs, chicken, or turkey sausage... Also, try drinking more water and trying to distract yourself from hunger. Worst case, add super filling low cal options like broccoli or brussels sprouts...

It was hard when I first started dieting-- I had the same problem. Until your stomach shrinks, I think the best way is to drink tons of water and try to think about something else. Chew gum, read a book, etc.

I think you're smart to try to keep protein high, but too much fatty protein (nuts, nut butter, even certain protein shakes) isn't good, either. I'd do one protein shake when you are hungriest during the day and try something low cal, lots of water or fiber, like strawberries or celery.

What really helped me was avoiding the "mealtime" trap. If I am not as hungry in the morning, I save part of whatever I am having for breakfast for when I am actually hungry (or hungrier).

Good luck!

Your body will get used to eating less first of all. After several days you should see less hunger pains though Mentally craving food is another deal entirely. I use broccoli and water to keep me full but try eating more foods that pack more substance for calories like sweet potatoes and grilled chicken. Try eating 8 oz of chicken at 340 calories and a cup of broccoli for lunch and still be hungry! Avoid nuts (and berries too), more calories than chocolate per volume! Caution with fruits and such for the same reason. Avoid higher calorie meats like steak etc so that you get more volume. You can eat a lot more chicken or turkey (or ground turkey, tuna etc) than steak. I suggested these things to my fiance, she now finds it difficult to eat enough calories by eating these leaner foods! Rice, pasta with little sauce are good options for carbs. Good Luck!

I understand always feeling hungry! (PS - you CAN drink too much water, so don't try and drink every time you want food)

One thing that jumped out at me on what you posted was protein shakes - one per day is probably ok, but instead of a second one, try a glass of skim milk, or some yogurt.

A second thing is that you are having two "freezer meals" today. Instead, can you make your own food? For example, instead of the "steak tips", what about 3 oz chicken, 1/2 cup sauce, 1 oz whole wheat pasta, 3 mushrooms, 3 black olives (chopped), and a small side salad? I know it will take a LITTLE more time to prepare, but honestly it's still doable within 20 minutes and will be much more filling and healthier.

Finally, you may be a grazer, meaning you would feel better eating smaller amounts throughout the day instead of chunky meals. I don't know if you live with anyone else, it's easier alone, but why don't you try that for a week? For example, if you are up for 16 hours and you eat 1600 calories a day - that's 100 calories per hour. You can do a banana for breakfast, a protein shake an hour later, an apple and 1/2 tbsp pb an hour later, 1/2 oz almonds an hour later, a small salad an hour later, etc...so basically you are always eating (every hour) so your body is constantly getting what it wants. And if you want more before the hour is up, just get some gum or water or hard candy - something to occupy your mouth. With this idea, you can also "Save" a few hours if you want a bigger meal (ie, don't eat from 3-6 and then eat 400 calories for the 6-7 hour).

Good luck!

I know for me if I eat processed foods I am hungry all the time. I don't know if it is something in them or they are not filling enough?
I cook or plan my meals so I only eat fresh homemade foods 99% of the time. I find it really helped me.

ALSO, if you eat all the calories you burn through working out then i dont get the purpose of working out?

the deficit you need to lose weight is already factored in in the base calories allocated to you by mfp.
that is why you NEED to eat back most of the exercise calories otherwise you will always be way under in the amount of calories you need to stay healthy and have your body functioning well. *S*

it is confusing at first as that is not the way most diet plans work things.
most other plans give you a set number of calories and then REQUIRE that you work out/exercise in order to get the full deficit you need to lose weight. not so with mfp *S*
trust me.. it works here hun *S* i am living proof.

as to why you still want to work out though, you want to develop healthy, toned muscles, and lower your resting heart rate etc etc so your body becomes fit and your metabolism works efficiently.

here's some REALLY helpful info in these:

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/61706-guide-to-calorie-deficits

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/186814-some-mfp-basics

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/3047-700-calories-a-day-and-not-losing

http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/175241-a-personal-view-on-exercise-cals-and-underfeeding

You sound a lot like me when I first started...

I thought I was eating healthy and I was , I was just either eating too much of a good thing or not the right foods for my meals. I was also not fulfilling my daily calorie goals. I thought eating less calories, I lose more weight.. How wrong I was .. you eat less.. in calories.. your body goes into starvation mode and you gain weight as well as stay hungry.

I know your drinking water.. , I had to re-evaluate what I was eating. I was eating almonds and they are healthy , it just seemed they are not fulfilling my tummy..it took so long for me to get acclimated to eating less but healthy. You have to be careful with almonds because , though they are good for you they are not filling , so one tends to eat more of them, you can actually gain weight from over eating almonds. So now I eat small salads.. also there are these cute little lunch boxes that have the ice tray in them. They keep your salads and fruits cold. So you can snack on your favorite fruits and salads and they taste fresh. I would not suggest hunger pills. Not healthy for your kidneys.

Working out is like detoxifying your body. Your providing your body with oxygen and working building stronger and leaner muscles. Water is like an enzyme and help start the burning process, helps wash out all the toxins in the body, give your body a healthy glow, it also feeds your muscles. Good luck.. I know its hard..but don't give up.. I was once 302 lbs. lost over 100 lbs , but when my father passed away.. I fell into a depression and just let things be and ate.. whatever and gain lots of weight back.. Now I'm at 222 lbs and starting over. Today is my first day at myfitnesspal.

So don't give up.. good luck to you.

I was having the same problem and I am still working with foods to figure out what fills me up the longest. I drink more than enough water. I have found that fiber bars help. I usually eat a kellogs fiber bar alittle while after lunch and that actually keeps my stomach from growling until I come home and cook dinner. They are pretty low in calories and don't taste bad either

Look at your sugar and artificial sweetener intake. Sugar can cause your insulin to spike and make you hungry. Studies have been done with artificial sweeteners and all the studies I have read have the same results; The rats that ate the artificial stuff ate more.