Do you treat yourself after loosing a certain amount?
AshleighAnn72
Posts: 83 Member
Hi,
If you treat yourself after, what do you have and how much do you lose for a treat?
I was thinking a stone, for a day off of MFP.
If you treat yourself after, what do you have and how much do you lose for a treat?
I was thinking a stone, for a day off of MFP.
0
Replies
-
When losing (maintaining now), part of what I was trying to do was change my mindset about food. So I didn't look at food as a reward for losing weight. Non-food rewards (books, clothes, etc.) made more sense to me.
Taking a day and eating to maintenance now and then can be helpful, but I don't tend to think of them as rewards - more of "life happens" events.15 -
I can pretty much lose weight up until 6th July, which is my first dress fitting for my wedding in August. I'll keep weight loss to a minimum from then, as I don't want to keep paying for alterations!
I will be treating myself to a lovely shopping trip in mid-July. I'll need clothes in my new size for my honeymoon!13 -
For me a treat when you lose a certain amount of weight makes weight loss sound like a punishment or something bad and I don't want to think of it like that. It's more like a lifestyle change that I'm enjoying and when I get to a healthy weight I'll carry on as I am, just adding more calories.2
-
When I was losing weight a treat for me would be to buy a new item of clothing in a smaller size...
Thinking of a treat day in regards to food perhaps means you are denying yourself the things you really like to eat. Fit treats into your daily calories, that way you don't feel deprived.9 -
NO.
Everyday I reward myself.3 -
Seeing the scales move, fitting into new sizes and just seeing my body change is enough of a reward for me. And since I lose slowly and somewhat erratically, I suspect planned rewards would lead to more disappointment than motivation.3
-
Sort of. When the scale started moving I got a fitness tracker to keep me motivated. (It worked!) After 15 lbs. I got some Powerblock dumbbells (like Kelli uses on Fitness Blender). Love those. I guess my next reward will have to be clothes.
1 -
AshleighAnn72 wrote: »Hi,
If you treat yourself after, what do you have and how much do you lose for a treat?
I was thinking a stone, for a day off of MFP.
I see nothing wrong with rewarding yourself for all of your hard work. HOWEVER...I would not use anything food-related (such as a day off MFP) as a reward. A day off can easily turn to two, then three, then a week. At least for me.
Treat yourself to something nice but inexpensive: a manicure, a massage. Sometimes I'll buy myself a book I've been wanting.6 -
I agree with everyone who has posted.
Making food the reward by taking a day to eat what you want when you reach a certain benchmark runs the risk of giving you a mindset that all the other days are burdensome and pale in comparison. There's nothing wrong with taking a day off now and then when life events dictate, but to do it as a reward for having lost a certain amount of weight seems counterproductive to me.
I rewarded myself along the way with special things that I don't do for myself on a regular basis, like buy a piece of clothing that I love in my new size. The bonus is that everytime I wear that new item it reinforces for me that the reason I even *have* it is because of how successful I am being.
On days like Christmas when I know I'll be eating at maintenance or above, I simply log it as best I can and move on. Taking the emphasis off of giving food power over me is one of the best things I managed to accomplish along the way.3 -
I bought myself new clothes and fitness gear as rewards for weight lost, so that I could enjoy my new body and newfound fitness. Buying myself food as a reward would reinforce some dysfunctional thinking and behavior about food. Would make as much sense as an alcoholic having a beer as a reward for sobriety lol. Okay, I realize it isn't exactly the same but my point is that in order to lose over a hundred pounds and keep it off for a year (which I've done) I had to change my way of thinking about food. To celebrate my breaking a bad behavior by engaging in that behavior would not make sense. Mentally associating the binge eating of high calorie/low nutrition food food with reward, comfort, etc. (especially as reward for the "torture" of doing healthy things) is what got me in this mess in the first place. I'm not saying I never have a cookie or anything, but I'm trying to do that in moderation and as part of an overall healthy diet, not some temping thing I'm deprived of.3
-
if you look at a "day off MFP" as a reward, that would suggest that being on MFP is punishment...not a good use of the reward system!3
-
Oh, and about days off MFP as rewards, I would say this is generally a bad idea for me. Over my past year of maintaining I have occasionally stopped logging for a few days, usually because I just wanted to eat freely and enjoy myself, and it results in setbacks. Over the past year I have picked up about 5 pounds of net weight that way ("net" meaning I would gain 3, lose 2, gain 5, lose 4, gain 4, lose 2, etc etc...always gaining a little more than I took back off). I am back here in serious weight loss mode again, trying to shave off 5 pounds that I need to "nip in the bud", plus a few extra that I've decided to lose, plus learn some things that help me break this cycle. Someday I would like to stop tracking, but need to do it not as a "splurge" but as a transition to a more intuitive way of managing my weight.
If you want a break from weight loss, I suggest that you just build that into the plan in a way that won't cause setbacks. I want to lose about 1/2-3/4 pounds per week but I have my tracker set at 1 pound loss per week but then override that on 2 days per week (when I eat to maintain). These aren't treats but just are higher calorie days that are part of my plan. I can use them whenever it makes sense, like if I am especially hungry that day, or taking a rest from exercising and not going to have a lot of calories added for that, or am going out to eat or a party that will have a lot of higher calorie food. This week I'm taking them on Thursday/Friday so I will be better fueled for a 5k race I'm doing on Saturday morning.0 -
When I signed up with MFP and realised that I was actually going to lose weight ... I stuck with it for 16 weeks with no breaks at all, lost 15 kg and thus reached my first goal.
Then I took a 1-month diet break, went on holiday, travelled, ate, and exercised a whole lot more than normal.
Not a reward because I would have done it anyway, but nice that it worked out that I had reached my first goal.0 -
Lots of great advice here- I also think a "day off of MFP" is not a good reward. Like others have said, smaller clothing and benefits of weight loss is a good reward in itself, but if you really want to get yourself something, make it an experience or a non-food-related something.
I haven't officially "rewarded" myself while losing weight yet, but I am getting closer and closer to one of my major goals- to be under 200 lbs. I've decided that when I get there I'm going to get contacts, which is something I've wanted for a long time.0 -
When I get under 200lbs, I'm upgrading one of my motorcycles...3
-
Not losing anymore but for me my treat was clothes and make up, I needed the clothes anyway as I got smaller and it was wonderful being able to buy things I really wanted to wear rather than just things that I had to buy to feel comfortable in, I felt more confident so experimented more with make up.
If I wanted a day off from MFP I would have just had one at any point, I know the odd day here and there doesn't make a difference in the grand scheme of things and although some people do like to log those days to see how their body reacts it's never bothered me, it's usually a birthday or something and I either can't be bothered or it's not practical because it involves meals from places that don't list calories and I wont spend a special occassion trying to guestimate them.
Food treats are already in my life, I have eaten ice cream every day this week within my calorie allowance for example so I don't feel I am lacking them or missing out on yummy things anyway, I eat all the foods but just more moderately than I used to.
But clothes, now I can never have too many of those1 -
Yes! I always treat myself with a lemon poppyseed cookie or a scoop of delicious ice cream after I have lost a few more pounds. No restrictions. Food is not the enemy. And if I go over my calorie allotment that day, no big deal. It doesn't dismantle my diet regime. Plus the beauty of counting calories. We can and should enjoy all the foods we love while dieting.0
-
I don't use food as a reward, choosing healthier options that fit into my days worth works just fine. I like to use material objects for goals; a new outfit, shoes, heavier weights....2
-
I'm getting closer to my goal, so I'm about to treat myself to a lower loss per week and more calories.0
-
Tattoos.. amusement parks.. dance classes. Those are my treats0
-
-
My treat was hopping on the scale this morning and being almost a pound under my goal weight. Some new clothes are in order as I've just been making do with what was in the closet (years of hoarding various sizes with hopes of one day wearing some of it). Now, everything is too big. @CooCooPuff that sounds like a good plan, I did that a few weeks ago and it's amazing how just a few more calories helps.0
-
In order to incorporate important days like birthdays, holiday dinners, etc. into my new way of eating, I already have days where I don't log everything. But that is reserved for very rare and special occasions.
Logging gives me sanity and confidence. Taking a "day off" only helps me get through things like Christmas without losing my mind, it's not a reward.2 -
I have been buying most of my 'new' clothes from a thrift store during my weight loss. When I got to 49lbs down I went out and bought several brand new items. That was a huge treat.3
-
Seeing the changes is my reward.0
-
AshleighAnn72 wrote: »Hi,
If you treat yourself after, what do you have and how much do you lose for a treat?
I was thinking a stone, for a day off of MFP.
I prefer to not reward myself with food. I don't have the best relationship with it so that is counterproductive.
I DO reward myself with a new blouse or dress. Nothing like feeling good in your clothes to stay motivated.2 -
booksandchocolate12 wrote: »AshleighAnn72 wrote: »Hi,
If you treat yourself after, what do you have and how much do you lose for a treat?
I was thinking a stone, for a day off of MFP.
I see nothing wrong with rewarding yourself for all of your hard work. HOWEVER...I would not use anything food-related (such as a day off MFP) as a reward. A day off can easily turn to two, then three, then a week. At least for me.
Treat yourself to something nice but inexpensive: a manicure, a massage. Sometimes I'll buy myself a book I've been wanting.
So much yes to this. I treated myself to a book I'd been wanting to read for the first 15lbs. When I get to the next 15lb I will treat myself to a new sundress.
I agree that the treat should not be food related or MFP related. For me that would feed into the unhealthy relationship I have with food instead of working to improve that relationship.1 -
Rewards are great, although I don't set specific times for them. A frequent reward is clothes, including workout clothes, which I usually buy at Goodwill! I can get so much more for my $$ this way and I don't like to spend retail $$ when I know it will fit me for only a few months. But, I don't get why a day off MFP would be a reward? Is logging a punishment? Logging helps most people be successful, so why would you reward yourself by stopping what makes you successful?2
-
I like to reward myself - nobody else is going to award me any gold stars so I'm going to do it
I don't use food rewards, I buy new clothes (lots of workout clothes) or have a massage. My last reward for meeting my running and weight loss goals was a new Garmin. Hopefully these rewards lead to more success!2 -
I've heard of other splurges such as getting a massage every 10 pounds, etc.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions