Question....PLEASE Help!
downtome
Posts: 529 Member
Hi All,
I have been eating healthier and exercisng for an hour a day since last year Nov.26th and have lost 86lbs so far with about 64lbs to go. My question is this, WHY THE HECK am I so hungry ALL the time? I thought your stomache was suppose to shrink and you don't feel as hungry, my gosh, it's been 8 months and I am still always feeling like I am starving. I try to keep my calories at around 1450 but lately they have been more like about 1700-1900, and thats the bottom line after I exercise for an hour and eat them back! My diet consist of lots of protein, tons of fruits and veggies and some protein bars and other things. Whats going on has anyone else experienced feeling of hunger like this after losing a bunch of weight and what can I do to keep on track as I still have a ways to go and want to stay focused? I have been exercising more now that I was before as I just joined a gym and NO its not my time of the month either. Please help?! Thanks so much
Denise
I have been eating healthier and exercisng for an hour a day since last year Nov.26th and have lost 86lbs so far with about 64lbs to go. My question is this, WHY THE HECK am I so hungry ALL the time? I thought your stomache was suppose to shrink and you don't feel as hungry, my gosh, it's been 8 months and I am still always feeling like I am starving. I try to keep my calories at around 1450 but lately they have been more like about 1700-1900, and thats the bottom line after I exercise for an hour and eat them back! My diet consist of lots of protein, tons of fruits and veggies and some protein bars and other things. Whats going on has anyone else experienced feeling of hunger like this after losing a bunch of weight and what can I do to keep on track as I still have a ways to go and want to stay focused? I have been exercising more now that I was before as I just joined a gym and NO its not my time of the month either. Please help?! Thanks so much
Denise
0
Replies
-
Are you getting enough water? I was told early on our body sometimes gives off the hunger signal and what we need is water.0
-
Whenever you are hungry just eat vegetables and fruits and also one thing that causes hunger is sugar, just try to stay away from any granulated sugar at all and keep having proteins. You'll be fine. Great job so far. Be proud of yourself and you'll rich you goal. Happy Sunday :-).....
Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Calorie Counter0 -
Denise-
You're exercising more so there's a really good chance your body is telling you it needs the nourishment to keep it up. I have those days too, so I eat some extra good calories to keep my energy up.
Sometimes if I'm starving but don't have many calories to give up, I have a salad. That satisfaction of eating, chewing, flavor, but very few calories.
That's just my humble guestimate as to what is going on.
Keep up the GREAT work!
Sandi0 -
OK - here is my secret - and I swear by it..... Protein and vegetables in every meal, breakfast, lunch and dinnner....
Your diary looks reasonably good - but if I was you I would bulk up with more vegetables - Brocolli, Carrots, Cauliflower, Zuchinni, Mushrooms, Baby Spinach....... Corn on the cob is nice - but high calorie - you can eat a lot more of the veges I just listed for the same calories......
And eat as much as you like of the vegetables (some days I will eat an entire head of brocolli) - I promise you the hunger will go away!! When I do get hungry (3:30itis) I make sure I eat protein - low fat cottage cheese with some carrot or sweet pepper, yoghurt with some berries, 50 grams of lean ham - the trick is protein - you eat a reasonable amount, but I would spread it more evenly in your day....
A dietician I saw recons if you exercise quite a bit you can eat 1.5 to 2 grams of protein for each kg of body weight...0 -
Hmmm, if you are eating enough calories, feeling that hungry might mean that there's something missing in your diet. I note that you say you eat lots of protein and fruit and veg. Do you need some complex carbs (wholegrain bread, brown rice, oatmeal)?
It might be worth seeing a doctor to see if your bloodwork is normal and you're not deficient in some vitamin or mineral.0 -
Im hungry too0
-
OK - here is my secret - and I swear by it..... Protein and vegetables in every meal, breakfast, lunch and dinnner....
Your diary looks reasonably good - but if I was you I would bulk up with more vegetables - Brocolli, Carrots, Cauliflower, Zuchinni, Mushrooms, Baby Spinach....... Corn on the cob is nice - but high calorie - you can eat a lot more of the veges I just listed for the same calories......
And eat as much as you like of the vegetables (some days I will eat an entire head of brocolli) - I promise you the hunger will go away!! When I do get hungry (3:30itis) I make sure I eat protein - low fat cottage cheese with some carrot or sweet pepper, yoghurt with some berries, 50 grams of lean ham - the trick is protein - you eat a reasonable amount, but I would spread it more evenly in your day....
A dietician I saw recons if you exercise quite a bit you can eat 1.5 to 2 grams of protein for each kg of body weight...
Awesome suggestion. 100% agree.0 -
I would suggest checking your fiber intake. Though if you do increase it make sure you drink lots of water too. Fiber and whole grains help your insulin levels and that should regulate your blood sugar which in turn should help your hunger.0
-
Thanks so much everyone, I really appreciate the feedback! Yes, I do have a love affair with corn on the cob lately with spray butter...lol. I am drinking plenty of water and I think I'm already over dosing on the fruit..I might try as one reply mentioned to gear more towards a higher protien diet as I know it curbs the hunger, i just hate not being able to eat my breads and fruits. I might just do the low carb thing and more low cal veggies for a few days and try to get back on track calories wise as I want to lose weight not stay the same. Thanks again for the input, you guys are great, i can always count on your help and feedback! Have a great day and a fun 4th!
Denise0 -
Had to laugh at the NO its not that time of the month!
I have same issue, always hungry, I had gastro last week and thought i was in heaven because then last few days i havent been hungry when i woulda been at my 3rd meal! Wake up call today it came back today Still not as bad though but we cant win!0 -
Firstly, congratulations on that amazing progress! That's nearly 3 lbs per week since November 26th, if I did the math right! Great job!
Often when we first start out losing weight, we start out at with a very large calorie deficit and the pounds start melting away fast. Over time, the closer we get to our goal weight, the smaller the deficit should get, until eventually we reach the goal, and our deficit becomes 0 - back to maintenance level.
I think you can afford to make your deficit a little smaller at this point. You've been losing 3 lbs per week. You should consider changing that to 2 lbs/week now. Then a couple months later, 1 lb/week, then half a lb, then finally change to maintenance calories when you get to your goal. With each increase, you will feel less and less hungry until you are finally at your goal weight and eating the same amount of calories that you're burning - equilibrium.
You've must have been amazingly disciplined up until this point. Keep up the terrific hard work and know that it's perfectly valid to make small incremental changes along the way.
Best of luck!0 -
i just hate not being able to eat my breads and fruits. I might just do the low carb thing and more low cal veggies for a few days and try to get back on track calories wise as I want to lose weight not stay the same.
The other thing I have done is replaced most of the "white carbs" with lentils, beans (cannellini, garbanzo, broad beans) - again much more fibre - and low gi...... bread is now really one of my "treats"
With fruits I eat a lot of berries (nearly 2 bags of frozen berries a week) - again high fibre - and lower sugar....0 -
I looked at your weight goals and it seems that you're hungry all the time because you simply need more calories! I'm in your weight range and I eat 1800 calories to lose. The bare minimum that an adult woman over 18 should eat is 1500, and it's higher if you're younger than that. You're trying to feed your body less than that, and it thinks it's starving and isn't happy. Plus you're burning more calories since you're working out. Try eating a goal of 1700-1800 calories for a week or two and see how you feel. It sounds weird, but you really need to eat to lose. It can also help prevent plateaus from happening.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions