I am going to try something different...
ChantalGG
Posts: 2,404 Member
I have been following MFPs suggestions and havnt really seen too much progress lately. So i am going to change it up. My BRM is 1408 calories a day, I will need to lose from that 500 a day to drop a lb in a week, so I am going to bring my calories per day to 900 not 1200. Just for a week and see what happens. I am still going to eat 1200 calories or more but i am going to start running more and I am doing Zumba so it will be easy to burn those extra calories. Any thoughts? This is really a test because i am bored. I have been doing Jillian 30 day shred all last month She suggest 1400 a day and doesnt mention eating back calories.
I need to change things up.
I need to change things up.
0
Replies
-
Your BMR isn't what you burn in a day before exercise, it's what you'd burn in a day if all you did is breathe and not move or do anything. Even with a sedentary lifestyle, that wont be your calorie burn. 1200 pre exercise sounds dangerous to me.0
-
I have been following MFPs suggestions and havnt really seen too much progress lately. So i am going to change it up. My BRM is 1408 calories a day, I will need to lose from that 500 a day to drop a lb in a week, so I am going to bring my calories per day to 900 not 1200. Just for a week and see what happens. I am still going to eat 1200 calories or more but i am going to start running more and I am doing Zumba so it will be easy to burn those extra calories. Any thoughts? This is really a test because i am bored. I have been doing Jillian 30 day shred all last month She suggest 1400 a day and doesnt mention eating back calories.
I need to change things up.
Judging by your profile picture you don't look like you have much to lose, and you should have a smaller, not a larger caloric deficit. Try setting your goal at 0.5lbs/week instead. When you don't have much to lose you should not eat under BMR calories, so eat between BMR and maintenance for a healthy weightless. if your deficit is larger you risk burning a large % of muscle.
Please read this post from Banks below:the reason why you need to reduce your deficit as you move closer to a healthy weight is many fold. One of the main reasons is the one you stated (I.E. to prepare you for maintenance), and while that may not seem like a big deal, adherence is listed as the number one reason why people yo yo diet. In other words, BECAUSE people treat it like a diet instead of a permanent lifestyle change, is one of the main reasons why it doesn't work. Creating healthy eating habits that you can live with is a main way to lose the weight and keep it off.
Another main reason, (and these are in no particular order of importance), is because the size of the deficit is a direct correlation to the amount of energy in the body available to use to make up the difference.
Without getting to complicated, the goal of a deficit is to force the body to burn adipose fat to make up the difference. But there's a line there, when fat stores shrink, available surface area of fat shrinks, which means less fat for the body to draw on at any one time to use to make up the energy difference. If your deficit is to large, the body will do 2 things, 1 it will try to utilize the third source of energy (protein) which it generally will get from muscle mass (taking the least used muscle first, which is why anaerobic exercise during weight loss is important), and the second thing it will do is (like a dimmer on a light switch) turn down the metabolic activity in the body, reducing certain organ and system functions to reduce energy needs.
It's important to note that there's no "line in the sand" where this all starts happening, it's a constant evaluation based on homeostasis throughout the body and hormone production, and as such you are almost always burning at least a little muscle mass, even if you're perfect, but the percentages go way up if you create too large of a deficit, (either by incorrectly choosing your goals, or by exercising to grow your deficit, or a combination of both), so the idea is to minimize protein burn, while maximizing fat burn by keeping the deficit in the sweet spot, as you lose body fat, that sweet spot deficit becomes smaller.0 -
I have been following MFPs suggestions and havnt really seen too much progress lately. So i am going to change it up. My BRM is 1408 calories a day, I will need to lose from that 500 a day to drop a lb in a week, so I am going to bring my calories per day to 900 not 1200. Just for a week and see what happens. I am still going to eat 1200 calories or more but i am going to start running more and I am doing Zumba so it will be easy to burn those extra calories. Any thoughts? This is really a test because i am bored. I have been doing Jillian 30 day shred all last month She suggest 1400 a day and doesnt mention eating back calories.
I need to change things up.
Judging by your profile picture you don't look like you have much to lose, and you should have a smaller, not a larger caloric deficit. Try setting your goal at 0.5lbs/week instead. When you don't have much to lose you should not eat under BMR calories, so eat between BMR and maintenance for a healthy weightless. if your deficit is larger you risk burning a large % of muscle.
Please read this post from Banks below:the reason why you need to reduce your deficit as you move closer to a healthy weight is many fold. One of the main reasons is the one you stated (I.E. to prepare you for maintenance), and while that may not seem like a big deal, adherence is listed as the number one reason why people yo yo diet. In other words, BECAUSE people treat it like a diet instead of a permanent lifestyle change, is one of the main reasons why it doesn't work. Creating healthy eating habits that you can live with is a main way to lose the weight and keep it off.
Another main reason, (and these are in no particular order of importance), is because the size of the deficit is a direct correlation to the amount of energy in the body available to use to make up the difference.
Without getting to complicated, the goal of a deficit is to force the body to burn adipose fat to make up the difference. But there's a line there, when fat stores shrink, available surface area of fat shrinks, which means less fat for the body to draw on at any one time to use to make up the energy difference. If your deficit is to large, the body will do 2 things, 1 it will try to utilize the third source of energy (protein) which it generally will get from muscle mass (taking the least used muscle first, which is why anaerobic exercise during weight loss is important), and the second thing it will do is (like a dimmer on a light switch) turn down the metabolic activity in the body, reducing certain organ and system functions to reduce energy needs.
It's important to note that there's no "line in the sand" where this all starts happening, it's a constant evaluation based on homeostasis throughout the body and hormone production, and as such you are almost always burning at least a little muscle mass, even if you're perfect, but the percentages go way up if you create too large of a deficit, (either by incorrectly choosing your goals, or by exercising to grow your deficit, or a combination of both), so the idea is to minimize protein burn, while maximizing fat burn by keeping the deficit in the sweet spot, as you lose body fat, that sweet spot deficit becomes smaller.
Totally agree with this.... it can take a bit to get your head around eating more = losing weight.
When I started I was clueless and set MFP to lose 2pounds a week. But I don't have much to lose now so have changed to .5 a week. I've gone from 1200 cals a day to 1530 + eating back 3/4 of my exercise calories. I'm also not weighing myself as often but my husband can definitely see a difference... Please try to eat more rather than less!0 -
Hehe i like that he referred to it as the sweet spot. lol
Oh I see... well my maintenance is 1760 calories a day, I have daily calorie allowance for 1280 calories a day. I dont know where my sweet spot would be.0 -
Hehe i like that he referred to it as the sweet spot. lol
Oh I see... well my maintenance is 1760 calories a day, I have daily calorie allowance for 1280 calories a day. I dont know where my sweet spot would be.
I would guess it would be around your BMR, you can start there and try it for 3-4 weeks and if it is not working adjust up or down, until you find it.0 -
Well I just changed it and it is telling me i can eat 1510 calories, seems kind of high and sometimes i cant even eat back my calories when i consume 1200. I dont know what i am doing anymore. :huh: i am going to go take nap. And figure something out later.
Thanks though!0 -
Just chiming to agree that you may need to lower your weekly goal to .5/lb a week (so, yep, eat more). I had to do that to start losing again.0
-
All very interesting....bump0
-
Well I just changed it and it is telling me i can eat 1510 calories, seems kind of high and sometimes i cant even eat back my calories when i consume 1200. I dont know what i am doing anymore. :huh: i am going to go take nap. And figure something out later.
Thanks though!
What are your numbers, maybe I can help (Height, Weight, Actvity level, what do you do for workouts, what kind of job do you have, what is your body fat % if you know it, what is your age, do you have any medical conditions). By the way, I'm the Banks guy eric posted from before (that was fast E, I just posted that like 1 hour ago)0 -
Your BMR isn't what you burn in a day. BMR multiplied by another number is your base caloric burn. Usually its 1.2 for sedentary, so your daily needs might be 1500*1.2 = 1800 calories per day to maintain. 1800-500 = 1300 net calories per day to lose 1 lb/week.
ALSO, for lean subjects, the nervous system and your body's hormones CONTROL how you lose weight so strongly that weight loss isn't always linear. So -3500 calories doesn't necessarily mean a pound at the end of the day! Be consistent and the weight will come off!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions