1200 calorie diet
NickAmrine
Posts: 34
So I am starting a 1200 calorie diet were I am eating 45% carbs 10% fats and 45% proteins.
I am also burning 1000 calories in cardio exercise per day.
Should I eat all those 1000 calories back making my diet 2200 calories or just eat 1200 calories while burning an extra 1000 per day?
I am also burning 1000 calories in cardio exercise per day.
Should I eat all those 1000 calories back making my diet 2200 calories or just eat 1200 calories while burning an extra 1000 per day?
0
Replies
-
eat them back. or at least as much as you can0
-
You are gonna get a lot of different ops on this; some say eat, others say don't. I say eat half for a week and see how it goes for you. DO NOT depend on MFP for accurate calories burn. It's best to have a HRM or Body Bugg. MFP, says I burn close to 900 calories in a 50 minute spin class. Although spin is a high calorie burn, I only eat back half or 500 of those calories. I don't have a HRM yet, but will be getting one because I am curious to see how much I actually burn in that class.0
-
If I were you, I'd make sure to eat back at least half of those calories you're burning.0
-
You are gonna get a lot of different ops on this; some say eat, others say don't. I say eat half for a week and see how it goes for you. DO NOT depend on MFP for accurate calories burn. It's best to have a HRM or Body Bugg. MFP, says I burn close to 900 calories in a 50 minute spin class. Although spin is a high calorie burn, I only eat back half or 500 of those calories. I don't have a HRM yet, but will be getting one because I am curious to see how much I actually burn in that class.
My thoughts exactly!!0 -
My understanding is if you eat back all you burn you will maintain your weight. If you want to lose you wouldn't eat all of them back, but you are able to eat over the 1200 you are allowing yourself. That is my take on things anyway!!0
-
Try it both ways. At first I was eating most of my calories back... Then I realized I wasn't losing any weight. Then I would only eat 100 or so if any back and began dropping. I think a lot of it has to do with how much weight you have to lose.0
-
I'd say eat back half, also. That's generally what I do. I don't entirely trust the amounts from MFP and I haven't yet replaced my broken HRM. Better to be a little under on calories than over, IMHO.0
-
I agree, you need to eat at least half of them. But your body will let you know if you listen to it!!0
-
You should eat back your calories, but burning 1000 calories per day in exercise is extremely hard to do...I would eat back at the most 500....That's like 2+ hours of cardio for me...0
-
1) How are you burning 1000 calories per day? I would also recommend, if that is the number, to have a proper heart rate monitor to determine whether it's accurate. (If you are basing it on a heart rate monitor then disregard).
2) Why are you starting a 1200 calorie diet?
3) I don't think your math is correct. Quoting my earlier post:
"There are three ways to go about hitting your calorie goals. For the sake of the hypothetical, we will assume that your total daily calorie expenditure (i.e., metabolic rate x activity level) = 1800 calories per day. If your goal is to lose 1 lb/week -- which is a safe and reasonable goal, notwithstanding that it doesn't sound like very much, you should be eating approximately 1300 calories per day.
(1) Diet only. This is pretty self-explanatory, to hit your target goal you simply reduce your food intake to 1300. The downside to this is that you'll likely be losing fat AND muscle.
(2) Exercise only. This one is pretty self-explanatory too. To hit your target goal, you still eat 1800 calories per day. But then you exercise away 500 calories, so you net 1300. There's no real downside to this except eating 1800 calories per day might be difficult for you, and burning away 500 calories EXTRA by exercising may be a problem as well.
(3) Exercise + diet. A combination of the two. To hit your goal you eat slightly less than you would normally... say, 1600. Then you exercise away 300 calories. Both are reasonable goals: you aren't reducing what you eat by that much so you are more likely to avoid hunger pangs and binges, and you aren't wasting a ton of time at the gym."
So, if you're total daily energy expenditure is 1700 (which is startling low, by the way), then your target would be 1200 total calories in per day. To achieve that number, you can do it a number of ways but if you're doing it via exercise + diet and you ARE burning 1000 calories per day, then you should be eating 2200 calories or so. But please confirm that you are burning that many calories (additional) through exercise first...0 -
mfp doesnt have an accurate calorie burned chart... the best way to know for sure how many calories you burn is with a HRM, but as far as eating your calories back i would have at least half! otherwise you net calorie deficit will be really low (like 200 or so) and that CAN put your body in starvation mode. personally for me i find that when i DONT eat my workout calories, i dont lose. its when i do that i see a pound lost or so the next time i weigh in (which is everyday).
but try the eating half calories for a week, see how your body reacts to it and then adjust from there. if you gain after the week then dont eat your calories.:flowerforyou:0 -
Hi,
I say eat back as many as possible, you want to stay at 1200 calories, so if you burn 1000 of those up
you're actually only eaing 200, that will nearly stop your metabolism in it's tracks and put your body in starvation mode!
I hope this helped, good luck to you with meeting all of your weight loss goals!
Please feel free to add me0 -
another vote here to eat atleast half of it back!0
-
Thanks everyone for the help! I think I'm gonna try eating back 600 of the 1000 calories burned since I don't have an HRM and hopefully that will work.0
-
I would agree with everyone above in eating back some of the calories...if you are hungry, eat healthy options and see how it goes! I rarely eat all my exercise calories, and I have been consistently losing weight...less now that I am closer to my goal...0
-
What does your daily intake need to be to maintain weight? Is your goal to lose or maintain? No matter what, if your body requires, let's say 1700 calories to maintain weight, and you are limiting yourself to 1200 - you already have a deficit that is allowing you to lose weight before the exercise. So, technically, you "could" eat back all 1000 and still be losing weight - if that is your scenario. However, I would say that if it's a weight loss goal, you should definitely eat some of them back to put more wood in the fire to keep burning. A 1200 calorie intake with 1000 calories burned = 200 net, and you're going to get exhausted. Just make sure you track whatever you eat, and if you're still below your requirement - you're golden... just don't starve yourself..0
-
WOW. what are you doing to burn that many calories?0
-
Eat at least most of them back up to at least 2000 depending if you are a man or a woman. I usually stick to eating 1780-1880 calories on strict days and 2000 on my up day. I try to have two up days a week to keep my body guessing.
Note though: Please do not eat your calories back in junk and expect results. Keep all your food pretty clean to see the results you want. Base your meals around 1800 so if you have to add it's easy and most of the extra calories should be in the AM up until 2pm.
Hope this helps.....0 -
Thanks everyone for the help! I think I'm gonna try eating back 600 of the 1000 calories burned since I don't have an HRM and hopefully that will work.
Seems fair. Most of the calculators are just estimates anyway. You want to keep track of several things (in no particular order):
- Your rate of weight loss
- Your strength
- Your measurements (e.g., waist size, arm size)
And then adjust your exercise (output) or diet (input) accordingly! Best of luck!0 -
oh I burn about 500 calories doing 2 hours of workout with my football team and then I usually go to the gym and do some cardio such as running, elliptical, or stair machine to burn the other 5000
-
My understanding is if you eat back all you burn you will maintain your weight. If you want to lose you wouldn't eat all of them back, but you are able to eat over the 1200 you are allowing yourself. That is my take on things anyway!!
MFP starts you off with a deficit to begin with. If she were to eat 1200 calories a day, and not workout at all, she would lose weight. That is how the site is created.
In saying that...If she eats 1200 + 1000 in workout calories= Her 2200 calories will be be eating at a deficit because the 1000 extra calories has already been depleted.
In saying this....Do whatever the heck it is you want to do. You are going to get 100 people who say they gained 38973459873457435 pounds from doing it, you're going to get 2324349237459732745 other people saying eat them all back.
Personally, when I was eating 1200 calories and not eating my exercise calories, I made myself ungodly ill for the first few weeks. The scale also wasn't moving an ounce.
After much reading (fitness and health literature...NOT diet literature), I figured out it was because my body wasn't necessarily in starvation mode, but it was holding onto every ounce of food I was putting into my system because I wasn't eating enough to function properly as well as workout as hard as I was.
I'm guessing you can figure out what side of the road I stand. I've been zig zagging and eating back exercise calories (to the best of my ability....when I have a high cal day + major cardio, its hard to eat 3000+ calories of good food with feeling sick from too much food) and have lost five pounds in three and a half weeks, 4 1/2 inches of fat, added 1 in of muscle in my arms, and I feel amazing.0 -
You are an 18 year old male, eat some food but make good food choices. Build those muscles with heavy weights, the fat will fall off don't do just cardio.0
-
If you're playing football, I would highly suggest you make sure what your body actually needs. 1200 calories for a male seems REALLY low.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions