The Ab Rant - Endomorph and Ectomorph
Options
peaceout_aly
Posts: 2,018 Member
in Chit-Chat
Little background. I am 5' (barely) and 115-117 lbs. I lift 6 x week for 60 minutes a day and when not in a bulk I do cardio for 15-30 minutes per day. I do the basic heavy lifts, tons of accessory work and have a core circuit that I do 2 x week (trying to up that, build core muscle during the bulk!) I can get skinny and lose almost all fat on my abdomen, but the most I'll get is the oblique definition. My best friend just had a baby about a year ago, and almost instantly lose all the weight, and has a complete 6-pack. This same friend eats an entire roll of cinnabuns, sleeves of cookies and drinks Pepsi like crazy. She never works out.
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?
0
Replies
-
peaceout_aly wrote: »Little background. I am 5' (barely) and 115-117 lbs. I lift 6 x week for 60 minutes a day and when not in a bulk I do cardio for 15-30 minutes per day. I do the basic heavy lifts, tons of accessory work and have a core circuit that I do 2 x week (trying to up that, build core muscle during the bulk!) I can get skinny and lose almost all fat on my abdomen, but the most I'll get is the oblique definition. My best friend just had a baby about a year ago, and almost instantly lose all the weight, and has a complete 6-pack. This same friend eats an entire roll of cinnabuns, sleeves of cookies and drinks Pepsi like crazy. She never works out.
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?[/b[
Yes...
I know a lot of really lean and fit women...only one of them has a six pack and she only has that some of the time...she has to be scary lean to have visible abs...women have more essential BF and thus it's much harder to to have the ab thing going on...it's definitely genetic.
ETA: but I do have a hard time believing that someone who never works out has a six pack...0 -
Good question, you figure that out I want to know too!2
-
cwolfman13 wrote: »peaceout_aly wrote: »Little background. I am 5' (barely) and 115-117 lbs. I lift 6 x week for 60 minutes a day and when not in a bulk I do cardio for 15-30 minutes per day. I do the basic heavy lifts, tons of accessory work and have a core circuit that I do 2 x week (trying to up that, build core muscle during the bulk!) I can get skinny and lose almost all fat on my abdomen, but the most I'll get is the oblique definition. My best friend just had a baby about a year ago, and almost instantly lose all the weight, and has a complete 6-pack. This same friend eats an entire roll of cinnabuns, sleeves of cookies and drinks Pepsi like crazy. She never works out.
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?[/b[
Yes...
I know a lot of really lean and fit women...only one of them has a six pack and she only has that some of the time...she has to be scary lean to have visible abs...women have more essential BF and thus it's much harder to to have the ab thing going on...it's definitely genetic.
ETA: but I do have a hard time believing that someone who never works out has a six pack...
It's not a solid six-pack with protruding muscle definition, but you can absolutely see the top four muscles at all times and the bottom two on occasion. She works out maybe once every 2 months when she comes with me to the gym and she usually comes on my leg day, not upper body. LOL. She is just lucky I guess!0 -
Cutaway_Collar wrote: »I am upset Warren Buffet has more money than me.
...not saying I'm upset about it, just wondering about the endo/ectomorph theory0 -
My last show I was getting ready for, that never happened cause I blew my shoulder out, I only had top 4 of my 6pack showing, could not get the fat on my back to come off. it was ridiculous and my lower abs would not show up. I tried everything.
Then there are guys who lift and train and eat what they want and have veins and all 6 abs all year round. Just how they are.0 -
Anyone think it had anything to do with the distribution of fast versus slow twitch muscle fibers in an individual?0
-
OP, somatotype have been debunked..
But what is relevant is genetics, all people have vast differences in metabolism, how they store fat, how they grow muscle, appetite, etc.... genetic differences manifest themselves such that some people do have a harder or easier time gaining muscle, losing fat, etc..3 -
peaceout_aly wrote: »Cutaway_Collar wrote: »I am upset Warren Buffet has more money than me.
...not saying I'm upset about it, just wondering about the endo/ectomorph theory
Somatotypes were originally supposed to be predictors of your mental temperament based on your body type. If you were an ectomorph, you were thin, flat-chested, lightly-muscled, delicate... And tense, anxious, restrained, and secretive. The idea that someone's physical form dictates their temperament is pretty ludicrous, yeah?
That's not to say that people have different genetics and different builds, of course they do. But people don't fall neatly into ectomorph, mesomorph, and endomorph body types, and anything saying you need to eat or exercise for your somatotype is broscience.
Oh and the original endomorph description was for a short, overweight person... I feel like when I see it described now it's usually talking about big, a super-muscular person, so even the original "science" isn't used "correctly" anymore.1 -
Genetics. Even with competitive body builders who get down to single digits in body fat percentage, their definition may not be as crisp as one who may have 1% or 2% more than them.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
1 -
peaceout_aly wrote: »cwolfman13 wrote: »peaceout_aly wrote: »Little background. I am 5' (barely) and 115-117 lbs. I lift 6 x week for 60 minutes a day and when not in a bulk I do cardio for 15-30 minutes per day. I do the basic heavy lifts, tons of accessory work and have a core circuit that I do 2 x week (trying to up that, build core muscle during the bulk!) I can get skinny and lose almost all fat on my abdomen, but the most I'll get is the oblique definition. My best friend just had a baby about a year ago, and almost instantly lose all the weight, and has a complete 6-pack. This same friend eats an entire roll of cinnabuns, sleeves of cookies and drinks Pepsi like crazy. She never works out.
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?[/b[
Yes...
I know a lot of really lean and fit women...only one of them has a six pack and she only has that some of the time...she has to be scary lean to have visible abs...women have more essential BF and thus it's much harder to to have the ab thing going on...it's definitely genetic.
ETA: but I do have a hard time believing that someone who never works out has a six pack...
It's not a solid six-pack with protruding muscle definition, but you can absolutely see the top four muscles at all times and the bottom two on occasion. She works out maybe once every 2 months when she comes with me to the gym and she usually comes on my leg day, not upper body. LOL. She is just lucky I guess!
Yeah, good genes...I have a buddy from Laos and he works out about the same as me...nothing crazy, a couple days per week in the weight room doing full body stuff...he's pretty jacked...he would be incredibly impressive if he actually trained with some volume for size...he could pretty easily be a body builder I think.
I on the other hand just look fit...I will never be "jacked" even if I trained for that...certainly I would get bigger, but I don't have the genetics to be a body builder.
ETA: genetically, I have really nice legs, calves in particular...and a booty which most guys are lacking. Genetics plays a huge roll...0 -
peaceout_aly wrote: »Little background. I am 5' (barely) and 115-117 lbs. I lift 6 x week for 60 minutes a day and when not in a bulk I do cardio for 15-30 minutes per day. I do the basic heavy lifts, tons of accessory work and have a core circuit that I do 2 x week (trying to up that, build core muscle during the bulk!) I can get skinny and lose almost all fat on my abdomen, but the most I'll get is the oblique definition. My best friend just had a baby about a year ago, and almost instantly lose all the weight, and has a complete 6-pack. This same friend eats an entire roll of cinnabuns, sleeves of cookies and drinks Pepsi like crazy. She never works out.
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?
Could it be that she's busting her *kitten* and keeping it to herself? Early morning or late night workouts? 10 mile jog every morning at 4:30 a.m.? Do you know EVERYTHING she eats? A person could eat 1,000 calories of cinnabuns and cookies and if that's all they eat, they'll lose weight. I don't recommend that, just saying.
I'm curious too.0 -
Bingo.peaceout_aly wrote: »Little background. I am 5' (barely) and 115-117 lbs. I lift 6 x week for 60 minutes a day and when not in a bulk I do cardio for 15-30 minutes per day. I do the basic heavy lifts, tons of accessory work and have a core circuit that I do 2 x week (trying to up that, build core muscle during the bulk!) I can get skinny and lose almost all fat on my abdomen, but the most I'll get is the oblique definition. My best friend just had a baby about a year ago, and almost instantly lose all the weight, and has a complete 6-pack. This same friend eats an entire roll of cinnabuns, sleeves of cookies and drinks Pepsi like crazy. She never works out.
My question is, people say that there is no such thing as an ectomorph and endomorph, but how is it possible that she can eat so much more, not work out and still have the perfect stomach and I watch what I eat, work out daily, and still have little to no definition if those concepts do not exist? Are some people just geneticly predisposed to having good muscle structure?
Could it be that she's busting her *kitten* and keeping it to herself? Early morning or late night workouts? 10 mile jog every morning at 4:30 a.m.? Do you know EVERYTHING she eats? A person could eat 1,000 calories of cinnabuns and cookies and if that's all they eat, they'll lose weight. I don't recommend that, just saying.
I'm curious too.
In high school I was that person that 'ate everything in sight' but still had 7% body fat. I'd have a light breakfast, pizza+gatorade+snickers ice cream bars for lunch, dinner with family and a 2nd dinner around 11pm just for me. I thought I was a devourer of worlds. A little while back I calculated an average day for me back then and it came in around 2,000 calories. Add on 2-3 hours of exercise a day and it was no wonder that I was a skeleton. You don't know what she eats like when she's not around you and unless she's measuring and logging then she will probably over-report what she eats the same way I did.0 -
As others said.. genetics, existing muscle base and ability to build muscle in certain parts. For example I have little to no ab definition even at very low BF%. Why? Probably a mix of genetics and the fact that I don't have a muscle base that shows through. Bulking has helped to build a bit but I don't work on my abs at all so they tend not to show through (personal preference).. so just keep at it and in time you may see some changes. It may take a few bulk/cut cycles. On the other hand you should see my calves! Holy smokes.. I don't work them directly at all and they are so muscular..likely due to genetics plus some track and field and sports I did when I was younger.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 394 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 950 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions