I have had some success but now struggling should I up my calories?
TrueAsGod
Posts: 15 Member
So I am about 4 weeks into calorie counting and I have had some success but it has been really rough. I started off at 1200 calories and felt like I was going to die so I upped my calories to 1500 and did well for like a week. Everyday is becoming harder so I was thinking about going up to 1700 but I'm not sure if this is the right thing to do.
Also I am male 5'6 and 300+ pounds so I can't give up
Also I am male 5'6 and 300+ pounds so I can't give up
0
Replies
-
Hey there, I would definitely try it on 1700 cals and maybe some light workout - walking or swimming are always the best and easiest ones to start off with ☺1
-
Hey , I may not be the best person to help u. But I am in a similar position as you. I am 5,6 and I am 350 pounds. I have recently lost some weight. I feel that diet is all about what u eat and how u exercise . I started on a low carbohydrates diet at roughly 100 carbohydrates max per day . It may sound harsh but what this diet gives is that it allows u to eat loads of meat and veggie in 1 day so much that probably u will be full at 1k calories . Not only that as ur body get used to it u will get better at managing hunger and eat lesser over time. Lesser food means lesser exercise needed. Start off the exercise really really slow but just try to stay active everyday and build up over time at ur own pace . Doing this u won't have to push urself to exercise 1.2k calories per day and feel full and still lose weight slowly ! But be strict with the carbohydrates.0
-
Hey! As a male you have 2500cals a day so by having a deficiency of 800cals a day so you'd still definitely be losing! Good luck & listen to your body1
-
I really appreciate you all replying to me, thank you.0
-
My husband had the same problem. Stay low on carbs high on protien. Since you're a guy you really need 1700-2000 calories a day or you'll go into starvation mode and not loose a thing. Slowly ease back. Do light cardio or something you feel comfortable with to boost metabolism. Good luck!!0
-
What does MFP give you for losing 1# a week?1
-
My husband had the same problem. Stay low on carbs high on protien. Since you're a guy you really need 1700-2000 calories a day or you'll go into starvation mode and not loose a thing. Slowly ease back. Do light cardio or something you feel comfortable with to boost metabolism. Good luck!!
Low carb, arbitrary numbers, starvation mode and metabolism boosting. A full house of MFP BS words.
OP I highly urge you to set up MFP and use the calories calculated for you. At 300lbs I would expect your maintenance to be over 3000 calories so by eating 1500 you aren't doing yourself any favours.17 -
I highly urge you to set up MFP and use the calories calculated for you.
Ok so I let MFP do the calculation for me and it gave me 1760 calories per day. This would have been higher if I were active but I don't do much exercise because of pain. As I lose more weight I will increase my exercise but atm all I can handle a light kettle bell routine and about 20 minutes of walking before my back and knees go tight. So I guess it wasn't far off what I was thinking anyways, thank you for the advice.3 -
I highly urge you to set up MFP and use the calories calculated for you.
Ok so I let MFP do the calculation for me and it gave me 1760 calories per day. This would have been higher if I were active but I don't do much exercise because of pain. As I lose more weight I will increase my exercise but atm all I can handle a light kettle bell routine and about 20 minutes of walking before my back and knees go tight. So I guess it wasn't far off what I was thinking anyways, thank you for the advice.
That is a great plan. Don't go all out with diet and exercise straight away as you will burn out and are likely to injure yourself with all the excess weight on your joints. I assume you have set your goal to lose 2lbs a week which is fine whilst you have a lot to lose but when you are nearer your goal, you may want to reduce this.9 -
im 5'10 and 200 lbs. At my weight, I eat 2100 cals a day and lose about 1.5 lbs a week. I would highly recommend uping your cals to around 2k. With your weight, your body will naturally burn a bit more as moving in general is somewhat of a workout on your body. Definitely would not go below 1500 though or you will be starving your body. If you add in walking or exercise in general, this will provide more cals to eat. typically you can eat back about half your exercise cals.3
-
How much did you set it to lose per week? At your weight you can get away with losing 2lb per week but best not to try and lose any more than that.
Good luck!0 -
CattOfTheGarage wrote: »How much did you set it to lose per week? At your weight you can get away with losing 2lb per week but best not to try and lose any more than that.
Good luck!
I set it to 2lb yes0 -
It's absolutely insane to eat that little u should be at least at 1800 and pushing 2000 unless ure dead sedentary2
-
If you are having trouble keeping to your deficit, take a step back.
Start by logging what you generally eat, without any deficit. Once you have that data look through it and see what you can cut out to give you a deficit of 250 cals a day. Once you are comfortable with that drop another 250 cals a day. Continue doing this until you are at the number MFP gives you to lose 2lbs a week, or a deficit you are comfortable with for the long term even if you will lose less than 2 lbs a week.
Low carb has been mentioned a couple of times, this may or may not be your eating preference. A calorie deficit eating the food you prefer will give you the greatest chance of success.
Spend your first weeks getting really good at weighing and logging your food consistently. You are in this long term so developing good habits that will see you through will be good to develop from the start.
The above goes for exercise too. Log it and eat back a portion of those calories. That isn't too important now, but as you get close to your goal, or for some reason can't exercise, you will need to be able to adjust those calories and if they aren't accounted for long term it is hard to adjust for them later. You will be best served, in my view, to get used to eating them back right from the beginning. (MFP is set up expecting you to eat them back. Your deficit is in your base calories.)
Exercise is good for your health but it will not be the major contributor to your weight loss.
Take baby steps.
Cheers, h.
6 -
lemonychild wrote: »It's absolutely insane to eat that little u should be at least at 1800 and pushing 2000 unless ure dead sedentary
That depends if he is quoting total calories, or if he's talking about net calories and adding exercise on top of that.
OP, are you logging exercise and eating the extra calories? If you're using the default myfitnesspal method, that's an important piece of the puzzle.0 -
CattOfTheGarage wrote: »lemonychild wrote: »It's absolutely insane to eat that little u should be at least at 1800 and pushing 2000 unless ure dead sedentary
That depends if he is quoting total calories, or if he's talking about net calories and adding exercise on top of that.
OP, are you logging exercise and eating the extra calories? If you're using the default myfitnesspal method, that's an important piece of the puzzle.
At present I am not logging exercise because I am doing so little because of pain. most of the day I am just sitting but I have started doing a light full body kettle bell routine every day. But honestly for me just being alive is exercise as bad as it sounds.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions