Running on treadmill when overweight advice?!

Lucy_Clare_x
Lucy_Clare_x Posts: 7 Member
edited November 14 in Fitness and Exercise
Hello!

Just wondered if anyone had any advice on running on a treadmill when overweight/obese. Obviously running is a great way to lose weight but when the impact hurts your knees that doesn't help! Any advice on how to go about this? Thanks!

Replies

  • shadowloss
    shadowloss Posts: 293 Member
    If you can't run, walk. If that is still causing pain, move to an elliptical machine that is much easier on the joints. I do both because of injuries that causes walking to be painful sometimes. If the elliptical is still causing problems, jump on a bike. If you don't have access to this equipment, then simply walking in place.

    The beauty is that as long as you are doing something and sticking to your goals, you won't be obese for long and your body will adjust to where the treadmill might not hurt after a while? Good luck. I know I'm only stating the obvious, but since I deal with the same issue I thought it might help.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Start with c25k to ease your knees in to it.

    Weight loss is all about calorie deficit, but running is a good way of burning calories.
  • SonyaCele
    SonyaCele Posts: 2,841 Member
    edited January 2017
    running really isn't a good way to lose weight, its a good way to burn some calories but your best safest way to lose weight is to eat less - eat the right amounts of the right foods. I dont think running while obese is a good idea, do the eliptical or something less impact. As your weight drops and your fitness improves, start adding in a little running if you want. starting out slowly is always a good idea
  • mgalovic01
    mgalovic01 Posts: 388 Member
    edited January 2017
    Initially strike the ground more- so towards the front of your foot, not with your heel. It'll take the stress off your knees. Ease into it, because it takes your calves some time to get used to it. Also, a faster pace walk on a higher incline is great for burning calories. Increasing the incline also increases the likelihood you'll strike the ground with the front part of your foot, along with increasing difficulty and results.
  • Supawilkins
    Supawilkins Posts: 10 Member
    You dont want to be running on treadmill for distance if you are over weight. You want to be doing interval training and run sprints for 15-30 seconds each set.
  • rosebarnalice
    rosebarnalice Posts: 3,488 Member
    I'm not a runner-- my boobs and joints don't like all that bouncing one bit! Walk at a brisk pace (3.5-3.7 mph) and that gets my heart rate up and burns calories just fine.
  • emdeesea
    emdeesea Posts: 1,823 Member
    Running isn't the reason people lose weight, it's the eating less food part where people lose weight.

    If you have bad knees, just walk.
  • Tacklewasher
    Tacklewasher Posts: 7,122 Member
    I started @ 330 lbs on the treadmill. I started walking and walking. ~30 mins every morning and then some evenings up to 50 mins. I decided if I'm going to watch a hockey game, I need to walk for 2 of the 3 periods.

    I'm down under 275 now and just now starting a C25K program. Pretty sure it would have been too hard on me to start, and I still have to be conscious of one knee that sometimes flairs up. But I had already started doing some intervals and some jogging on it.

    My opinion is that the C25K might be a bit much to start with. Walk for a month first and see how that goes with your knees etc.
  • jennybearlv
    jennybearlv Posts: 1,519 Member
    As someone who is morbidly obese and runs, I don't believe all this don't run when you are heavy nonsense. The important thing for people of any weight is to go slow and ease into it. If something is sore go slower or do less. I am doing C25K for the third winter and I think it is a fantastic program to get into running. If running still hurts try walking instead. Walking for a longer period of time is just as good and easier on the body.
  • SkinnyGirlCarrie
    SkinnyGirlCarrie Posts: 259 Member
    Walking briskly can be just as good, especially if your treadmill can incline. Boost the incline and not go quite so fast and you'll be burning quite a bit. My knees and hips don't like to run consecutive days in a row, so I find this alternative can burn almost as much as a run (per my HRM).

    Make sure you have good, supportive shoes that fit you well. For my sneakers that I run in I often have to go 1/2 - 1 size up because your foot will swell and it is not pleasant to be hitting the front of your shoe!

    If you're new to running - Don't go flat out. Start with run/walk intervals. And run slow! I used to think I needed to be speeding or I wasn't running, so not true :lol: Work yourself into it.
  • kenyonhaff
    kenyonhaff Posts: 1,377 Member
    My advice is to:

    * Be sure to have good quality running shoes. Preferably new and purchased from a quality running shoe store (not a chain like Foot Locker). New Balance has a good reputation for shoes with a lot of support for "heavy strikers" and/or overweight people.
    * Get a good running bra. It makes a big difference in comfort, and the girls will thank you. Heavier women tend to have more bust, and with more bust comes more bouncing which you don't want!
    * Start off with run/walk intervals. Many treadmills have programs that have pre-programmed intervals like this.
    * Start a little lower than you think you need. It's better to start off a little too low than too high.
    * Don't compare your efforts to anyone else.
    * Running is actually one of the best exercise for weight loss, but it can be one of the most difficult for a heavier person to do. The strain on your lower body will be more than someone lighter. Honor this.
  • joemac1988
    joemac1988 Posts: 1,021 Member
    Lucy_Clare_x wrote: »
    Hello!

    Just wondered if anyone had any advice on running on a treadmill when overweight/obese. Obviously running is a great way to lose weight but when the impact hurts your knees that doesn't help! Any advice on how to go about this? Thanks!

    15 seconds at a jog/run, 45 seconds walk and repeat.
  • cerise_noir
    cerise_noir Posts: 5,468 Member
    SonyaCele wrote: »
    running really isn't a good way to lose weight, its a good way to burn some calories but your best safest way to lose weight is to eat less - eat the right amounts of the right foods. I dont think running while obese is a good idea, do the eliptical or something less impact. As your weight drops and your fitness improves, start adding in a little running if you want. starting out slowly is always a good idea

    Agreed. The best way to lose is via calorie deficit.

    I am around 40lbs overweight, but when I was 100lbs more than I am now, I started off by walking on the treadmill or outside. Last May, I started c25k...then hurt my foot. Now I am hoping to get back into it again.

    I would not jump right into running. Fast walks are better, then a very slow jog, then progress through the jogging speeds until you can run. Walk-fast walk-walk intervals and walk-jog-walk intervals are good, too.
  • lorrpb
    lorrpb Posts: 11,463 Member
    Running does not make you lose weight. I agree with the other good advice here. Use MFP to establish a calorie goal to eat within. Then start walking to improve your fitness. Unless someone is already quite fit, I don't recommend running until you are within 25 lbs of your goal weight.
  • bagge72
    bagge72 Posts: 1,377 Member
    If you really want to run take it slow, try something like C25K, you can't feel it at first, but going to fast to quickly can really hurt your joints and your feet, so work up to it. But just know, running isn't what is going to make you lose weight, being at a calorie deficit is. so if you burn and extra 200 calories from running, and then go eat an extra 500 because you are hungry because of it, then it doesn't really matter.
  • MeanderingMammal
    MeanderingMammal Posts: 7,866 Member
    Lucy_Clare_x wrote: »
    Just wondered if anyone had any advice on running on a treadmill when overweight/obese. Obviously running is a great way to lose weight but when the impact hurts your knees that doesn't help! Any advice on how to go about this? Thanks!

    There is no reason not to run, although as observed upthread it's something that helps contribute to losing weight as long as you're in calorie deficit.

    As far as running technique is concerned there are a number of things that can contribute to knee pain, so without knowing a lot more about what you're experiencing it's not something that you can get reliable advice on.

    C25K is a good way to get up to running a reasonable distance while minimising your injury risk.

    It's worth getting dedicated shoes for running. Some people advocate gait analysis, although personally I'm not as sold on the idea.

    When you're building up, leave your pace at a manageable level, the main thing is getting used to running by time, not so much by distance initially. So if you do use something like C25K then in the run periods try to limit yourself to a pace that you can still talk at.

    You build endurance over time, so just take it easy. I used C25K about 4 years ago, and remember the challenges. Nowadays I'm comfortable running for long periods, 3-4 hours routinely.

    The final point I'd make is a common mistake new runners make is overstriding, tied to a fear of going too slowly. It's worse on a treadmill. As you run, aim to keep your leading foot as close to landing under your centre of mass as possible. You make progress by pushing off, rather than pulling yourself forward with your leg.

    Hope some of that helps a bit, but if you are experiencing pain rest until it eases.

  • spiriteagle99
    spiriteagle99 Posts: 3,743 Member
    Keep your pace slow, think jog, not run.
    If running is too difficult, walk until you can walk easily.
    When you do start running, don't do it every day. You can get some form of exercise every day, but mix it up: walking, running, biking, dancing, yoga, etc.
  • MeanderingMammal
    MeanderingMammal Posts: 7,866 Member
    spiriteagle99 wrote: »
    Keep your pace slow, think jog, not run.

    Run, or walk. Never jog unless you fancy being the one that finds dead bodies in the woods.
  • Azdak
    Azdak Posts: 8,281 Member
    Lucy_Clare_x wrote: »
    Hello!

    Just wondered if anyone had any advice on running on a treadmill when overweight/obese. Obviously running is a great way to lose weight but when the impact hurts your knees that doesn't help! Any advice on how to go about this? Thanks!

    Any activity that helps burn extra calories and contributes to a calorie deficit is a great way to lose weight. The one benefit of running is that it burns calories at a higher rate than many other types of exercise.

    The main detriment of running is the higher impact--it can increase the risk of injury, esp if one is significantly overweight. It can also fatigue your legs more quickly which might limit the duration of your workout. For an unfit beginner, the fact that running burns calories at a 35% higher rate might not be that helpful if it means your workout duration is only 1/3 the duration.

    Personally, unless the desire to run is a major motivator, I would recommend starting with something like incline walking. You will likely be able to go longer and burn more total calories. If you want to run, you can then try it out in smaller chunks which will allow you to adapt at your own pace.
  • riffraff2112
    riffraff2112 Posts: 1,756 Member
    If it hurts, do not do it. Walk or use elliptical or a bike.
    Walking when combined with calorie deficit can be super effective and hundreds of people here can attest to that.
  • stubbysticks
    stubbysticks Posts: 1,275 Member
    I think the answer you're looking for depends on why you want to run specifically, vs. other activities.
    • If you want to run to lose weight faster, it can help but as others have said, good nutrition/calorie deficit is really the key. You want to choose activities that will improve your conditioning & that can be running, walking, cycling, elliptical, swimming, etc.
    • Be aware of your own limitations. This has less to do with your weight than your overall physical condition: do you have bad knees, arthritis, or some other medical issue that could be exacerbated by running? Assuming you're in good health, you should be fine to run - just keep in mind that as a high impact exercise, it's rougher on your joints than many others. My knees are pretty crackly from running (not painful, but noisy).
    • If you want to run because you just like it, then do it!!! Exercise is supposed to be fun. No matter what size you are, if you want to be a runner, then screw what everyone else says and just do it.

    All that aside, you didn't mention how overweight you are, but I started running @ 300 lbs so I can only speak from my perspective. A few tips:
    • Buy good quality running shoes (not cross-trainers, or whatever's on sale at the closest store). Your joints will thank you for it, & it will make running much more enjoyable. You can get some decent shoes for around $50-60, but know that there's a significant difference in quality when you spend $100. (It's a good investment.)
    • Wear compression gear - Old Navy's compression workout pants are really good for the price. I've even worn a belly binder for extra support at times. Wear good sports bras designed for high impact & you're good to go.
    • Don't be surprised if you feel INVINCIBLE at the end of your run. It's a known side effect & there's a risk of you wanting to run farther & faster next time.
    • Set a goal. Many others mentioned Couch to 5k (C25K) which is a great beginner program. Having a plan to follow really helps with motivation & gives you an easy way to track your progress.
    • Mix it up with other activities. The elliptical is a great substitute for running, so if your knees or back are a little sore but you still want to work out, you can run on the elliptical to keep your conditioning up. Same motion & mileage without the impact. Strength training/crosstraining will help improve your running too.

    Have fun!
This discussion has been closed.

Categories