Rice cooked and uncooked calories?
JKardeno
Posts: 24 Member
Sorry if this is a stupid question which has been asked 1000 times, but this is really confusing me.
Is there any difference between uncooked and cooked rice? I didn't think so but after doing some reasearch,
I'm confused. I read this:http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_calories_in_100g_of_rice and the calories
seem to be much higher raw. Could anybody explain this to me? Once again, sorry if it's a stupid question.
Haha
Is there any difference between uncooked and cooked rice? I didn't think so but after doing some reasearch,
I'm confused. I read this:http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_calories_in_100g_of_rice and the calories
seem to be much higher raw. Could anybody explain this to me? Once again, sorry if it's a stupid question.
Haha
0
Replies
-
Uncooked rice is dried, and takes up very little space per serving, which is 1/4 Cup of Dry rice. Once this rice is cooked with 1/2-3/4 Cup of water that the rice grains absorb, it swells and softens to One full cup of cooked, edible rice. The caloric value doesn't change, the volume of the rice does (if you cook with butter or oil, yes this changes the calories but cooking rice only takes water).6
-
Sorry if this is a stupid question which has been asked 1000 times, but this is really confusing me.
Is there any difference between uncooked and cooked rice? I didn't think so but after doing some reasearch,
I'm confused. I read this:http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_calories_in_100g_of_rice and the calories
seem to be much higher raw. Could anybody explain this to me? Once again, sorry if it's a stupid question.
Haha
Once the rice has been cooked, it absorbs the cooking liquid...3 -
Uncooked rice is dried, and takes up very little space per serving, which is 1/4 Cup of Dry rice. Once this rice is cooked with 1/2-3/4 Cup of water that the rice grains absorb, it swells and softens to One full cup of cooked, edible rice. The caloric value doesn't change, the volume of the rice does (if you cook with butter or oil, yes this changes the calories but cooking rice only takes water).
I understand that, but usually on the back of the packet of rice I use it would say something like '100g uncooked rice - 356 calories' and '100g cooked rice - 130 calories' If I'm not adding anything why would the calories change?
Oops, double post. Still learning how to use this thing. :S0 -
50g of uncooked rice makes about 170-200g cooked rice. It near quadruples in amount, so if you had 100g of uncooked rice at 356 calories, that would make around 340-400g cooked rice. If you took 100g cooked rice, then it's only a third-quarter of the original uncooked amount.
Hopefully that makes sense, I got a little lost as I was typing it3 -
It's the water absorbed while cooking that adds volume and weight, so 100 grams of cooked rice is the rice & water weight:
100 grams of uncooked rice + water weight = more than 100 grams of cooked rice = 356 calories
100 grams of cooked rice = a much smaller amount of uncooked rice + water weight = 130 calories
You'll eat a lot more rice if you eat the entire 100 grams of uncooked rice and get more calories.
Hope that helps.6 -
Good advice. I don't know why they include the calories for uncooked; not as if you'd ever eat it that way!1
-
Oh wow, I get it now. Thank you. I weighed out 100g uncooked and it was around 170g cooked. How would I log it then?0
-
Good advice. I don't know why they include the calories for uncooked; not as if you'd ever eat it that way!
Yes you're unlikely to eat raw rice, but if you know the calories for uncooked you can weigh your raw rice and use that value - then if you use it to make a risotto, paella or similar you can easily calculate the total calories for your recipe. The uncooked value is the most accurate one to use as it isn't affected by cooking method. I also find weighing dry rice a lot easier than trying to weigh some hot cooked rice as I'm serving it.7 -
The only thing you add to rice to cook it is water which is calorie free. What they're referring to is that the actual quantity will end up being different before cooking vs. after cooking because of how dried rice is smaller and lighter due to the absence of water.0
-
Oh wow, I get it now. Thank you. I weighed out 100g uncooked and it was around 170g cooked. How would I log it then?
It depends how you cooked it - if you just boiled in water or steamed it then the calorific value of the rice hasn't changed just the volume and weight has because it's absorbed water. If you know you cooked 100g of rice then this is the most accurate value to use, however if say you have some leftover cooked rice that you then want use you would need to weigh it and use the cooked calorie value.0 -
Oh wow, I get it now. Thank you. I weighed out 100g uncooked and it was around 170g cooked. How would I log it then?
I always log the uncooked amount + anything I add. That way i don't have to weigh it after it's cooked and get some looser amount for the caloric value. This is true of brown/white rice, quinoa and lots of other grains/pastas that change how much they weigh when cooked in liquid.
When in doubt get all the dry measurements and log that way.1 -
100gr of cooked rice is less rice when dry then 100gr of uncooked rice. Usually 100gr of uncooked rice weighs around 200 - 250gr when cooked (makes sense cos it absorbed the water) hence the extra calories which come from the volume rather then the weight. The same goes for pasta.0
-
This is a good question. I was wondering about this also... the reason I came across your post LOL! Anyway, I've decided (mostly because we cook a lot and I can't just cook for myself) to add the colories of my dirty rice (the whole box) and the colories of my hamburger meat (all of it) together and it's 1390 for the whole dish. When I get finished cooking it, I'm going to re-weigh it all together and get the total ounces. Lets just say its 70 ounces. (about what my spaghetti weighed the other day) Then I'm going to divide and see how many calories per ounce. (19.85 calories/ounce) When I get ready to eat, my family can eat what they want and I can weigh mine out by however much I allow myself to eat for that meal. Just thought I would share.0
-
Thanks for the explanation. Great topic !0
-
I weigh everything dry, so I'm very glad they put it on the back of the packet!1
-
Well I am fairly new to My Fitness Pal. But I selected "Tesco easy cook brown rice (dry) at 100g and then selected Tesco easy cook brown rice (cooked) and the dry came out at 355 and the cooked came out at 353 calories
So either this is wrong info, or else it means that if you boil 75g of dry rice which turns out to be over 100g of cooked rice you are still looking at 350 ish calories of food?0 -
I'm struggling to work out what 150g and 100g of brown easy cook (tesco) rice is too?
I put 150g o cooked in and it comes out with over 500cals but then if you do the 75g = 195 cooked, it's less that 300? odd.0 -
I only cook my rice in water and when I am trying to log it on MyFitnessPal I search for "cooked brown rice" or brown rice cooked that way I know that when it says a half a cup its a half a cup cooked brown rice.0
-
ok simple way of doing this is:
Measure weight of a pan or microwave dish while empty on scales, make note of it.
Put in desired amount of uncooked rice plus liquid.
If you like it lovely and soft then put in a good pint of water, for those who like it more aldente then use less water.
once you get it way you want it, drain off the liquid from the rice
get scales again, measure pan/bowl.
new figure minus 1st figure = weight of cooked rice.
then go by the value of the cooked quanity on packet.
So if say on packet it says 100cal per 75g serving cooked, and you have 350g of cooked rice.
can do this on google spreadsheets or excell etc save using calculator.
=sum(100/75)*350
for calculators: 100/75 = answer then answer times by 350
It worth getting into habit of that then if any foods in MFP database show up a value that doesnt look quite right, you wil spot it straight away.0 -
I only cook my rice in water and when I am trying to log it on MyFitnessPal I search for "cooked brown rice" or brown rice cooked that way I know that when it says a half a cup its a half a cup cooked brown rice.
The problem there is how long it's cooked for then becomes a factor. It gets puffier and heavier because it absorbs more water the longer it cooks. Foods like this should only be measured dry.4 -
ok simple way of doing this is:
Measure weight of a pan or microwave dish while empty on scales, make note of it.
Put in desired amount of uncooked rice plus liquid.
If you like it lovely and soft then put in a good pint of water, for those who like it more aldente then use less water.
once you get it way you want it, drain off the liquid from the rice
get scales again, measure pan/bowl.
new figure minus 1st figure = weight of cooked rice.
then go by the value of the cooked quanity on packet.
So if say on packet it says 100cal per 75g serving cooked, and you have 350g of cooked rice.
can do this on google spreadsheets or excell etc save using calculator.
=sum(100/75)*350
for calculators: 100/75 = answer then answer times by 350
It worth getting into habit of that then if any foods in MFP database show up a value that doesnt look quite right, you wil spot it straight away.
Simpler way of doing this:
Put bowl on scale and hit tare. Pour in the amount of dry rice you want. Log that weight (or put it in a recipe). Boxes will have the dry weight and calories or if you just use plain rice find the USDA value (no asterisk) for the type of rice, dry.
Add water and cook.
If you add anything besides water when cooking (oil, butter, other ingredients) weigh and log those too.
I usually just divvy up the rice into equal portions if making more than one serving, and divide up the total calories that way.1 -
Oh wow, I get it now. Thank you. I weighed out 100g uncooked and it was around 170g cooked. How would I log it then?
1 serving.If you add anything besides water when cooking (oil, butter, other ingredients) weigh and log those too.
I usually just divvy up the rice into equal portions if making more than one serving, and divide up the total calories that way.
@lemurcat12 is giving you good advice here.
FWIW, I'll weigh the pot before cooking and write that down. Then I weigh it again with the cooked rice. Take the delta, divide by the number of servings I cooked and then I know how much to weigh out per serving.
If you're lazy, like me, then you can use your phone to take a photo of the empty pot on the scale so you don't have to write it down.The problem there is how long it's cooked for then becomes a factor. It gets puffier and heavier because it absorbs more water the longer it cooks. Foods like this should only be measured dry.
Agreed on dry measurement for rice, and I do see a lot of weight variances in cooked rice. Rice is a little dense-ish on the calorie side, so I always weigh it out dry and cooked. When it comes to lower calorie foods like asparagus, for instance, I don't worry about it so much.
Sam1 -
It makes mathematical sense. 100 g of raw, long-grain rice = 350 calories approx. After cooking, straining excess starch and rinsing with boiling water to make it nice and fluffy, as rice should be, allowed to sit in the strainer for a minute or two to allow any excess water to strain off, the 100 g of raw rice has become approx 270 g. 100 g of cooked rice = 130 calories, which = 1.3 calories per gramme; thus 270 g x 1.3 cal = 351 cal. Close enough for me. I'll eat easily 270 g of cooked rice per serving with a curry. The only time I would eat only 100 g of cooked rice would be when I'm having a sushi snack.0
-
The reason the give a dry weight is because rice can be cooked in different ways, similar to pasta. In some recipes it is cooked for a longer time, so it absorbs more water. Therefore, if you have more water absorbed in 100gms of cooked rice/pasta, it has less calories than rice cooked for a shorter cooking time. Imagine a dry sponge and a wet sponge, it's still the same sponge but the water makes it weigh much more the wetter it is.0
-
I know this is a really really old post buuuuut....what must be taken into account when logging calories for any starch foods e.g. rice, pasta, potatoes is that if boiled/steamed the cooking process removes a huuuuge amount of the starch which has a significant calorific value that matter! You should always log the cooked values, they should be very different and are for a reason....more so with white rice!2
-
I cook and serve rice - and oatmeal - in the same water it was prepared in, so no starch is removed by cooking.
I do discard the starchy pasta water.0 -
I boil a stick of Butter (800 calories) in a cup of rice every week for the extra calories so make sure you add the oil or butter calories to the rice total if you use it to cook the rice.0
-
right or wrong for calorie accuracy, I weigh everything as Im cutting/ prepping.. cant be trying to do it all hot. All pasta, rice, quinoa etc all dry weight... been working for me so unless i'm drastically getting it wrong, I'll carry on with dry/raw1
-
this whole concept still confuses me, no matter how many times I read it. All I want to know is how many grams of COOKED brown rice equals how many grams of carbohydrates.1
-
So would rinsing the rice (to get rid of excess starch, which a lot of ricecooker instructions recommend) effect the caloric value?0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions