Losing 4 pounds/week. Is this good?
DarkHorse8765
Posts: 8 Member
Hi. I've lost roughly 8.5 lbs in 15 days through just calorie counting (consuming 1400 cals per day). My BMI is 23.7 (180 lbs,6'). Is this advisable? How can I ensure that I lose only fat and no muscle?
0
Replies
-
You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.8
-
You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
This, though I would add that, as I understand it, there isn't really a way to guarantee that you will lose 0% muscle and 100% fat. As you lose weight, you lose both, unfortunately. The adequate protein, reasonable deficit, and lifting help preserve as much muscle as possible, though.4 -
No, it's bad. It's bad because you're massively undereating especially when you're already at a healthy weight for your height.4
-
You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
You say he is seriously under eating. But he said he is consuming 1400 calories a day. That's correct for weight loss with someone of his size. MFP tells me to consume 1200 a day. He isn't under eating unless he is highly active.
OP: what is your activity level like? Are you working out? Doing a lot of cardio? If you are, it's considered healthy to make sure you eat those calories back. 1400 is already a deficit. So be sure you aren't going below that by working out and not eating those calories back.
If you're not working out and are still losing that, consider seeing your doctor. Or go over your food log with a nutritionist. You may have a metabolism that requires more than 1400 calories a day.
It's also important WHAT you're eating. So, that's why I suggest seeing a doctor or nutritionist. They can help you determine the appropriate nutrition requirements for your body type, health status and activity level.
Regardless congrats on the weight loss.1 -
nicolepburgess91 wrote: »You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
You say he is seriously under eating. But he said he is consuming 1400 calories a day. That's correct for weight loss with someone of his size. MFP tells me to consume 1200 a day. He isn't under eating unless he is highly active.
OP: what is your activity level like? Are you working out? Doing a lot of cardio? If you are, it's considered healthy to make sure you eat those calories back. 1400 is already a deficit. So be sure you aren't going below that by working out and not eating those calories back.
If you're not working out and are still losing that, consider seeing your doctor. Or go over your food log with a nutritionist. You may have a metabolism that requires more than 1400 calories a day.
It's also important WHAT you're eating. So, that's why I suggest seeing a doctor or nutritionist. They can help you determine the appropriate nutrition requirements for your body type, health status and activity level.
Regardless congrats on the weight loss.
He is a 21 year old male, males need more calories. The lowest MFP will set a male's calories is 1600, but for his height, weight, and age he could easily be at 1800 while still losing at a relatively fast pace.10 -
nicolepburgess91 wrote: »You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
You say he is seriously under eating. But he said he is consuming 1400 calories a day. That's correct for weight loss with someone of his size. MFP tells me to consume 1200 a day. He isn't under eating unless he is highly active.
OP: what is your activity level like? Are you working out? Doing a lot of cardio? If you are, it's considered healthy to make sure you eat those calories back. 1400 is already a deficit. So be sure you aren't going below that by working out and not eating those calories back.
If you're not working out and are still losing that, consider seeing your doctor. Or go over your food log with a nutritionist. You may have a metabolism that requires more than 1400 calories a day.
It's also important WHAT you're eating. So, that's why I suggest seeing a doctor or nutritionist. They can help you determine the appropriate nutrition requirements for your body type, health status and activity level.
Regardless congrats on the weight loss.
She's right though. The recommended amount for a male is no less than 1500 calories. I eat more than that and lose.2 -
I would think most of that weight along with some fat may just be water weight. I easily lose 10-12 lbs of water weight initially when I restart cutting after a long bulk. Water weight is especially lost during a keto style diet. I'm 6'0
Lift weights and get plenty of protein to minimize muscle loss.1 -
nicolepburgess91 wrote: »You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
You say he is seriously under eating. But he said he is consuming 1400 calories a day. That's correct for weight loss with someone of his size. MFP tells me to consume 1200 a day. He isn't under eating unless he is highly active.
OP: what is your activity level like? Are you working out? Doing a lot of cardio? If you are, it's considered healthy to make sure you eat those calories back. 1400 is already a deficit. So be sure you aren't going below that by working out and not eating those calories back.
If you're not working out and are still losing that, consider seeing your doctor. Or go over your food log with a nutritionist. You may have a metabolism that requires more than 1400 calories a day.
It's also important WHAT you're eating. So, that's why I suggest seeing a doctor or nutritionist. They can help you determine the appropriate nutrition requirements for your body type, health status and activity level.
Regardless congrats on the weight loss.
A 6ft 180lb man should not be eating 1400 calories. I'm a 5ft5 woman, 145lbs, eating more than that to lose weight.
The recommended minimum for men is 1500, and he likely can eat way more than that. I'm not sure he'd have a lot of weight to lose.... Putting on muscle would probably be a better idea, doing recomp if he thinks he has fat to lose.4 -
dragon_girl26 wrote: »You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
This, though I would add that, as I understand it, there isn't really a way to guarantee that you will lose 0% muscle and 100% fat. As you lose weight, you lose both, unfortunately. The adequate protein, reasonable deficit, and lifting help preserve as much muscle as possible, though.
At his age and if he's new to lifting he may gain muscle. You're right though, nobody can guarantee that weight loss will be 100% fat.3 -
nicolepburgess91 wrote: »You aren't eating nearly enough. You can ensure you aren't losing muscle and only fat by eating at a small deficit, getting adequate protein, and lifting. It's normal to lose rapidly the first few weeks, but yours is far more than normal due to you seriously under eating.
You say he is seriously under eating. But he said he is consuming 1400 calories a day. That's correct for weight loss with someone of his size. MFP tells me to consume 1200 a day. He isn't under eating unless he is highly active.
OP: what is your activity level like? Are you working out? Doing a lot of cardio? If you are, it's considered healthy to make sure you eat those calories back. 1400 is already a deficit. So be sure you aren't going below that by working out and not eating those calories back.
If you're not working out and are still losing that, consider seeing your doctor. Or go over your food log with a nutritionist. You may have a metabolism that requires more than 1400 calories a day.
It's also important WHAT you're eating. So, that's why I suggest seeing a doctor or nutritionist. They can help you determine the appropriate nutrition requirements for your body type, health status and activity level.
Regardless congrats on the weight loss.
Activity level is nil currently due to exams. Since MFP was recommending 1580 calories a day for 1kg/week with a target of 165lbs. I was following that with a bit of additional margin. Probably I should reduce the targeted loss rate and start lifting/other strength based exercises. Thanks for the insight.1 -
Daddy78230 wrote: »I would think most of that weight along with some fat may just be water weight. I easily lose 10-12 lbs of water weight initially when I restart cutting after a long bulk. Water weight is especially lost during a keto style diet. I'm 6'0
Lift weights and get plenty of protein to minimize muscle loss.
Yeah I think that may be the case.0 -
It's not uncommon to lose a lot when you first start. It will taper off eventually.
Definitely get enough protein and lift weight as you go.1 -
Thanks for the guidance everyone. Will take it into account and refocus.1
-
Agree with dialing back the targeted rate, with a small amount to lose you should be shooting for a half-pound per week loss.0
-
Since you're already at a healthy weight, yes that's too much. You should be aiming to lose at most a pound a week, and more likely half a pound a week.1
-
I would recommend aiming to lose 0.5 pounds a week since you're at a healthy weight. I agree with the users who also mentioned mentioned adding strength training.0
-
I stand corrected. I wasnt considering the fact that he is male. I get stuck in feminine calorie goals and often forget that men have to eat more. Sorry about that y'all3
-
nicolepburgess91 wrote: »I stand corrected. I wasnt considering the fact that he is male. I get stuck in feminine calorie goals and often forget that men have to eat more. Sorry about that y'all
No worries. Even for women, that rate of loss is dangerous. It can cause long term health issues.0 -
If you're studying for exams OP, the last thing you should be is under nourished.1
-
Why are you trying to lose weight at all? Let alone at such an aggressive pace? Your BMI is well within the "normal" range and at 6' it isn't a bad thing to be on the higher portion of the normal range. Your post reads like someone who is trying to go against every weight loss guideline there is. At this point, there is nothing to be gained by calorie restriction without exercise.0
-
Eat at maintenance and focus on your exams. You are a healthy weight (wish I was you) and no need for such a drastic weight loss.
When the exams are done, start a fitness regime. I bet you can probably keep your calories at 2000, lift 3 x a week, do some cardio and get the body you want, maybe without dropping a pound.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions