We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Trail running

msfine2328
msfine2328 Posts: 73 Member
edited November 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
Question for runners out here. What do you think of trail running? I had major hip surgery back in 2009. I am trying to do a half this October and have a 5k coming up soon. My friend who is a runner said not to do trail runs because of my hip. What are your opinions?
Let me clarify when I say trail runs they are really just small trails around a lake in my town. And I picked to do it there because it's a change of scenery. TIA

Replies

  • rybo
    rybo Posts: 5,424 Member
    I find trails to be far less impact on my legs than road running. While at times they may be a little more tiring, because of changes in elevation and uneven nature, I'm way less sore after a trail run than a road run.
  • rsclause
    rsclause Posts: 3,103 Member
    I did a trail half marathon and up not liking it. When I was talking to a friend waiting on the start he said just make sure you look down. It was fall and leaves were covering rock & roots. This combined with my bifocals I ended up staring at my blurry feet all race and fell twice. Next time I will need contacts to race one of these again. Re: your question, if it is a track type trail I don't see a problem. If it is a lot of back and forth with ups and downs it may put some stress on your hip.
  • jjpptt2
    jjpptt2 Posts: 5,650 Member
    edited May 2017
    This is a case where it TOTALLY depends on the trail. Terrain will be the most important factor.

    If it's really well groomed and maintained (think: really smooth, flat, clean path) then it can be a great option. If it's rough and technical (think rocks, roots, off-camber, uneven, etc), then trail running can be MUCH harder on the body and your joints than is road running. At least that's been my experience.

  • MobyCarp
    MobyCarp Posts: 2,927 Member
    edited May 2017
    @msfine2328 - I concur with @jjpptt2 on trails. When you start out, or if you have an injury or permanent physical issue with your running chain, you want non-technical trails. Where I live, I'd point you at the Erie Canal Trail, which hardly even qualifies as a trail, the way trail runners understand the term. It's flat, there are miles and miles of crushed stone or stone dust surface that is softer to run on than asphalt, and there are no roots or protruding rocks to worry about. From there, I'd move you to less technical trails that are mostly packed dirt with maybe an occasional protruding tree branch, and hills no steeper than you'd find on the roads anyway.

    Your runner friend may be thinking about the brag-worthy trails with killer steep hills up (not too bad) and down (terrible if you need to be gentle with that hip), rocks, roots, and other stuff that appeals to young male runners with lots of testosterone. As long as your hip remains a concern, I wouldn't have you run trails like that.

    Go ahead and try the trails you have in mind. If they're not very technical and they allow you to be gentle with your hip, you have a winner. If you find a stretch that resembles the highlight reel from an action movie, it's time to turn back and find friendlier terrain. Also be aware that even on non-technical trails, you need to pay more attention to the surface you're running on than you need to while running roads.

    Edit to add: Recreational running on trails can be managed to suit your ability, picking the trails that are friendly to that hip. Trail races are another story. You get whatever the race director set up, which will frequently be designed to appeal to those young male runners with lots of testosterone.
  • Niki_Fitz
    Niki_Fitz Posts: 951 Member
    edited May 2017
    jjpptt2 wrote: »
    This is a case where it TOTALLY depends on the trail. Terrain will be the most important factor.

    If it's really well groomed and maintained (think: really smooth, flat, clean path) then it can be a great option. If it's rough and technical (think rocks, roots, off-camber, uneven, etc), then trail running can be MUCH harder on the body and your joints than is road running. At least that's been my experience.

    This sounds right to me. My physical therapist wanted me off uneven trails when my hip/knee were troubling me but I'm back to the flatter groomed trails and hope I never have to give these up! @MobyCarp useful info!
  • msfine2328
    msfine2328 Posts: 73 Member
    Thank you all. This was all very helpful. My trail I did is around a local lake. The parts that had rocks or what not I did walk because I am not an experienced runner like that. It was my walking part of the couch to 5k. You all rock!! Thank you for all your advice
  • MeanderingMammal
    MeanderingMammal Posts: 7,866 Member
    Personally I'd rather race on trails than road.

    Much easier on my system, but as above for a novice pick an easy route. You don't want technical or fast downhills.
This discussion has been closed.