confused about fruit and sugar
maryzcontrary
Posts: 70
I am new to MFP. When I set up my food diary, I did not use the "sugar" counter. I have been eating lots of fruit for snack time -- watermelon and grapes, mostly, as they are "in season" and quite refreshing! I have a banana in my smoothie in the morning as well....I have lost 2 lbs already....well, as I am poking around in the forums I see lots of stuff about not eating fruit because of the sugar. So I add the counter, and WOW! I am over on my sugar big-time --- I thought that my goal was to not eat over 1200 calories, and usually I don't, but do I have to give up my fruit, too??? I am very confused. The fruit is very satisfying, and helps me to not binge on carby-starchy stuff. I'd rather have it than some other kind of snack...
Advice? Warnings? Input?
Advice? Warnings? Input?
0
Replies
-
Eat your fruit and be blissful. It's good for you.0
-
My opinion, and it is just an opinion is to eat your fruits. I hear from some that they have natural sugars. If they fill you up and keep you from bingeing then I would not give them up.0
-
eat the fruit! The fruit is much better for you then simple sugar "sweets" like cookies and candy. Some fruits are higher than sugar than others.. If you are not choosy, you might want to go with the lower glycemic index fruits.. In general I say if it isnt broke.. dont fix it! You are losing and eating healthy. Keep up the good work!0
-
Fruit is fine!! Are you eating fruit instead of the bad carbs you used to eat? If so, you are fine.....I do usually eat 3 to 4 svg of fruit a day, and I do watch my "bready" carbs....so I might not have as much of the pasta, rice, bagels, cereal, like I used to, but instead I eat fruit, veggies and yogurt. You will ready too some people are saying do not eat a lot of dairy, but again, if you are eating that instead of the bad carbs, you will be fine. I watch my carbs, protein, fat and fiber really close. Carbs are carbs, whether they come from bready carbs, fruit, or yogurt....they all turn to sugar once they hit the blood stream. Some carbs are just better b/c they have fiber in them and it digests slower than the other carbs. As long as you are losing weight, you are fine!! Good luck!! That is the nice thing about this site, you do what works for you and what works for your life style.0
-
Eat fruit. You have excellent reasons to continue eating them, including proven weight loss. I believe the worst thing you can do is to limit yourself from entire food groups. So-called "diets" that cut out important groups also cut out the important nutritional benefits they provide.
That said, if you have issues with your blood sugar, or with other sugar-related things, then it would be good to start tracking it. I have had problems with PVCs that I successfully can treat by being aware of carbs and sugars. Your mileage may vary.0 -
Eat your fruit--it's a good source of various nutrients, and usually has some fiber in there, to boot. I'm diabetic and I eat my fruit--even my doc tells me to. I avoid fruit juices, however, except for artificially sweetened cranberry once a day. I've been told by two docs and two nutritionists now that fruit juice isn't much to write home about unless you do your own juicing at home.
Kris0 -
as long as you are losing good i would not worry about it0
-
I agree! Eat your fruit! The "sugar" in fruit is not added sugar. Also, fructose (the type of sugar that is found in fruits) is thought to have less of an impact on the glycemic index scale than refined sugar. Fruits are too good for you to give up!0
-
I am having this problem, too... Fruit is my go-to snack. When I voiced some concerns about going over my MFP "recommended" sugar intake, a lot of people pointed out that MFP goals are just an estimate when it comes to specific components of food. When you plug a food into the MFP calculator, it just sees sugar as sugar... Not natural sugar from fruits that have many, many health benefits VS. sugar from a giant chocolate chip cookie. I have reached a peace about eating as much fruit as I want, over MFP sugar standards or not.0
-
Stick with the fruits and just get rid of processed sugars. Your body will thank you for it.0
-
Also, keep in mind, the MFP goals for proteins, fats, and carbs are all a little tweeked. Look up the percentage of calories for each by the American Heart Association if you want something healthier.0
-
Eat the seasonal fruit! I'd just watch your macros (carbs, protein, fat) and make sure you try to stick to those.
There have been a LOT of threads about "fruit sugar" and it's gotten pretty nasty, so I just figure that sugar in a natural proportion, that my body recognizes, is always a good option. Given the choice between "low sugar" cookies and an apple, with the same amount of calories, I'd take the apple.0 -
Eat your fruit. I am over on my sugar every day and all my sugar is from fruit. Snacking on fruit helps to keep the blood sugar just high enough so that you are not famished at a meal. When I snack on fruit, I tend to eat less calories at the next meal.0
-
Also - eat proteins with fruit (a few nuts, for example, or healthy cheese) to keep your blood sugar balanced!0
-
My opinion based on my own individual experience (everyone is different). Regard fruit as a treat and stick to the ones that are lower on the glycemic index. There isn't anything you can't get from vegetables that you can get from fruit -- minus the sugar.0
-
Well! I am convinced! All of you Wise Folk who are so inspirational with your great weight losses whilst consuming mass quantities of fruit have made me decide that I will simply continue on!!
Thank you all for your encouragements
Wishing you prosperity0 -
Thanks Mary for your great question.
It was actually the same question I had on my mind this morning. I was glad to see all th great advice! I still feel that raspberries are so much better for me than cookies! I am glad to see that alot of people that responded have lost alot of weight so they must know what they are talking about:smile0 -
Fruits contain natural sugar which doesn't break down and get stored as fat as easily as processed sugar (corn syrup and it's many derivatives). In my opinion, eat your fruit. I don't agree with these people that say it's bad for you. Fruit contains a plethora of vitamins that -are- good for you, especially being female and we have that lovely problem of expelling a lot of nutrients from our body during that time of the month.
Now, I will ask what else you are eating because in a lot of American foods, sugar is an added ingredient. Pasta sauce, pickles, salad dressings... a lot of them contain sugar and you'd never know because you eat it and don't taste any sweetness. Check your cupboard for things you're eating regularly that have sugar where they don't belong. Bread is another issue, and watch your intake of high fructose corn syrup which has cropped up in everything. I stress that I don't think fruit is what's causing your sugar overage.0 -
Don't worry about too much fruit. It's a natural unprocessed source of nutrition without added sugar.
That being said, don't forget your vegetables! They are just as important and do not contain as much sugar in any form. They are also easy to sneak into other foods if you don't like the salad approach.
And cydonian has a good point about sneaky forms of sugar in our food. I love how the corn grower's association talks about high fructose corn syrup being fine in moderation, but it's hard to get it in moderation -- that *kitten*'s in everything unless you really pay attention.:huh:0 -
And cydonian has a good point about sneaky forms of sugar in our food. I love how the corn grower's association talks about high fructose corn syrup being fine in moderation, but it's hard to get it in moderation -- that *kitten*'s in everything unless you really pay attention.:huh:
It's sick, isn't it? My husband is from Britain and they don't have that crap in their food, so he came here and was astonished by reading the labels on food. We've 100% cut it from our diet; if we do buy soda, we buy Throwback so that it has actual sugar instead of HFCS. We've struggled to find bread locally that didn't have the HFCS, and finally have found 2 brands that don't (one has sugar unfortunately, though). Also... my current quest: relish! I want a sweet relish with no HFCS, dangit.
/steps off of soapbox0 -
If you're really watching your carbs, you will have to watch your fruits. Acquaint yourself with the idea of glycemic load - how fast the sugars are released into your bloodstream.
Wanna eat fruit but don't want all the sugars? Here are a couple of fruits that we normally think of as vegetables: Tomatoes, bell peppers (all peppers, actually), eggplant, squash, beans, peas and pea pods, cucumber, okra - even corn! So now you can eat your fruits without doing in your sugars!
Cheers...
T0 -
Tomatoes, bell peppers (all peppers, actually), eggplant, squash, beans, peas and pea pods, cucumber, okra - even corn! So now you can eat your fruits without doing in your sugars!
The only problem with bell peppers, cucumber and corn is that they're mostly water. She also won't be getting the same nutrients from many of those as she would get eating a pomegranate or an apple. Even tomatoes contain mostly water... but have lycopene which has been studied to have some positive effects on the body. You actually need BOTH in your diet. You can't substitute a tomato for an orange. Just throwing that out there.0 -
Just adding this--both sugar snap peas (fresh in the pod) and (especially) corn raise my blood sugar markedly--more than a couple of plums, as much as an orange. Because I count carbs as carbs, I make allowances so my blood sugar doesn't go above where I want it. However, sweeter veggies hit me just the same as fruits. It's the carbs in general rather than just sugar, and my corn on the cob is as carb-y as my nectarine. Luckily, keeping my meals fiber-y keeps my blood sugar from going crazy.
Eat the fruit. It's good for you, and veggies aren't the same--you need fruits and veggies, not veggies instead of fruits.
Kris0 -
Eat your fruit and enjoy the natural sugar. I wouldn't worry about it.0
-
Nearly everything contains some kind of sugar: you can't avoid it, so stop worrying about that.
If you're trying to eat a low glycemic index diet, then yes, you need to limit your intake of low-fiber, high fructose fruits, like oranges. Notice I said "LIMIT" not eliminate. Replacing chocolate and pretzels with whole fruit and vegetables is almost always good plan.
This is because when you eat whole fruit, you also eat fruit fibers, good vitamins, minerals and stored plant water, besides fructose. The fiber is what keeps you feeling full and satisfied so you don't binge out on empty calories. Fiber also has the benefit of making your food take longer to digest - when this happens, it sits in your stomach longer. The sugars aren't absorbed as quickly and as readily as say, refined white sugar, so you don't spike your sugar levels quickly and suffer from being hungry 5 minutes later. As a result, the fiber in your fruit can be viewed as 'reducing' your carbohydrate intake, because it spreads it out over a longer period of time.
If you would like to remain eating fresh foods as snacks, while reducing your sugar intake, try eating fruits that have less sugar and more plant fibers, but still taste good raw. Sugar snap peas, tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, mushrooms (wiped clean of course). These all taste great and don't need any dressings or toppings to be edible.
Fruits high in fiber and relatively lower in sugar would be bananas, plums, peaches, pears, grapefruit, apples. Limit your intake of oranges, tangerines and the like, they are notorious for having very little fiber and lots of fructose in the sweet juice. You can get more vitamin C from a red bell pepper than you need in a full day, anyways, so it's a great substitute.
Should you worry about your sugar intake? If you're drinking lots of fruit juices and iced tea mixes, then yes. If you're only getting sugar (carbohydrates) from whole foods, like whole fruit and vegetables and meats, then no. Sugar is found in everything... yes, everything, and you can't stop eating food because you want to stop eating sugar.
Best of luck!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions