How often do you eat?
oat_bran
Posts: 370 Member
How many meals and snacks per day do you have and how soon do you get hungry after a meal/snack?
I find that I almost always get hungry 3-3,5 hours after a meal, even after a big one (450-500 cals) with 25-30g protein, a decent amount of fat and fiber. Is it normal? It seems like many people around me go hours and hours without food.
I try to make it work with my deficit. And have somewhat smaller meals and leave room for snacks. But it's not always easy. I still need to postpone my first meal as much as possible so that my last meal is just before bed (otherwise I won't be able to fall asleep and if I don't get enough sleep I can't really function and di my job the next day). So I end up eating 3 meals and 3 snacks sometimes and on days I am less active and my TDEE is lower it's so hard to fit it into my allowed calories.
Basically I was wondering if maybe my snacking is counterproductive? Maybe it's just a question of habit and if I eliminate snacks and would only have meals after a week my body would adjust and I won't feel as hungry in between meals? I'm somewhat afraid to just test it because I'm afraid to end up being too hungry and overeat.
Tell me about your experience with changing meal frequency and meal times?
I find that I almost always get hungry 3-3,5 hours after a meal, even after a big one (450-500 cals) with 25-30g protein, a decent amount of fat and fiber. Is it normal? It seems like many people around me go hours and hours without food.
I try to make it work with my deficit. And have somewhat smaller meals and leave room for snacks. But it's not always easy. I still need to postpone my first meal as much as possible so that my last meal is just before bed (otherwise I won't be able to fall asleep and if I don't get enough sleep I can't really function and di my job the next day). So I end up eating 3 meals and 3 snacks sometimes and on days I am less active and my TDEE is lower it's so hard to fit it into my allowed calories.
Basically I was wondering if maybe my snacking is counterproductive? Maybe it's just a question of habit and if I eliminate snacks and would only have meals after a week my body would adjust and I won't feel as hungry in between meals? I'm somewhat afraid to just test it because I'm afraid to end up being too hungry and overeat.
Tell me about your experience with changing meal frequency and meal times?
0
Replies
-
Currently I'm pretty much eating all the time. MFP set me up with 2,080 cals per day. That was nothing to me before because when you live off of junk food and candy, you reach that pretty quickly.
Now that I'm watching what I eat, I find that I'm pretty much snacking all the time and still not reach my goal. I try to have three somewhat more substantial meals (300+ cals) per day but that still leaves me with around 1,000 cals to spare, so I also have 2-3 snacks.2 -
I eat 3 meals a day consisting of breakfast, lunch and dinner. That is quite tricky as my daily allowance is 1200 calories . So I usually eat a medium breakfast, light lunch and a heavy dinner so that I can sleep well.2
-
I usually eat 3 meals and no snacks. I split my daily intake into roughly 1/4 for breakfast, 1/4 for lunch, 1/2 for dinner and eat them 3-4 hours apart. Breakfast is the easiest meal to postpone, so I'm usually up for a few hours before I eat anything, and I feel fine for several hours after dinner, and then it's bedtime anyway. I will feel empty between meals, but I don't worry about hunger as long as I know I'm eating enough, both quantity and quality.
I have had all kinds of meal timings and schedules, while losing and gaining and maintaining weight, without noticing any difference in hunger. Several meals was fine, grazing was ambivalent, four meals was nice, three meals is tidy and practical.0 -
i go for the following on weekdays:
7am (getting ready for work) pint of water
8.30am breakfast (250-350 cals of protein enriched cereal or fat free greek yoghurt with granola)
12-12.30 lunch (300-500 cals salad/sandwich/wraps/protein thins/bagels etc and a portion of fruit)
3pm snack (100-200 cals nut bar/protein flapjack/popcorn/jerky)
4.30pm pre workout snack (100-200 cals peanut butter/cheese)
6.30-7pm dinner (600-800 cals depending what it is)
i pre log breakfast lunch and dinner and then fit in my snacks around how many cals i have left (also depends if i am working out that day). these days my calorie goal is net 1600 or net 17003 -
longstocking wrote: »How many meals and snacks per day do you have and how soon do you get hungry after a meal/snack?
I find that I almost always get hungry 3-3,5 hours after a meal, even after a big one (450-500 cals) with 25-30g protein, a decent amount of fat and fiber. Is it normal? It seems like many people around me go hours and hours without food.
.....snip...
Basically I was wondering if maybe my snacking is counterproductive? Maybe it's just a question of habit and if I eliminate snacks and would only have meals after a week my body would adjust and I won't feel as hungry in between meals? I'm somewhat afraid to just test it because I'm afraid to end up being too hungry and overeat.
Maybe it's just me, but being hungry 3 to 3.5 hours after a meal seems pretty normal! If I eat breakfast at 7:00, I'm ready for a snack at 10ish and then lunch around noon. If I'm hungry mid-afternoon, I take a break at work and have a snack around 3, and then we typically eat dinner at 7 or 8pm.
I don't think snacking is counterproductive unless it causes you to exceed your calorie budget for the day.
I prefer not to be too regimented in when I eat. I do pre-log my meals in the morning or sometimes the night before. But I'm flexible too! I eat when I'm hungry and adjust things as I go throughout my day. I do plan ahead to have a variety of snacks with me, though, and that helps me avoid eating something at work that will put me over my calorie budget.
Hope that helps!
Karen4 -
I tend to eat two or three meals and a few snacks. Depends on the day and the shift (are there enough staff on the floor to let me take a break and eat something.) I have always gone a good amount of time between actual meals though normally 5 to 7 hours. If I've been grazing then around 3 or so.
It might sound counterproductive but maybe try increasing the fat's you have with your meals I, personally, find it helps when I know I'll need to go a long time between meals (nine or ten hours). But of course everyone is different.0 -
2 meals, 2 snacks.
I dont eat in the morning simply because im not hungry
Lunch i love a good salad, tends to be about 300cals
Quick afternoon snack less than 200
Dinner is typically 400 - 500
Evening snack is all the rest of my calories so i can eat a fair amount of stuff and be under my goal
Extra calories are banked for a meal out
Works for me0 -
I vary greatly depending on the day. If I'm home or idle I tend to graze and not really have a meal. If I'm busy I might have two meals and maybe one snack.
I hear you in feeling like you're the only one that wants to eat so often. I ALWAYS felt this way in college especially, and around the BF and his friends. Now I realize that it's just that I'm always so aware of food so it's on my mind more. Either I've pre-logged- so I'm already thinking about lunch in a more detailed way than the casual way most people are; or I'm thinking about what to get to fit my calories. The guy in the next cubicle feels a rumble, thinks "I'm hungry" and spends five seconds determining what he wants for lunch....
Plus, a lot of us are pretty good at creating satiating meals for 300-500 calories, right? Well that can't compete with the 500-1000 calorie fast food or restaurant meals that exist. I realized this with my BF. I thought he was never hungry, ate so little. No, he just ate BIG HEAVY meals that kept him full for hours. My calorie controlled portions could never compete.1 -
During the week I typically eat a bigger late morning breakfast, a mid-sized mid-afternoon lunch and a bigger evening dinner.
I plan my meals out ahead of time and they are balanced - I try to include fruit, veggies, fiber, fats, proteins and carbs.
I can go long time in between meals. Usually about 4 - 5 hours and in between dinner and breakfast the next day I don't have hunger pangs.
In my experience snacking didn't work for me. I would be thinking about my next mini-meal or snack and I was rarely satisfied.
Once I started listening to my hunger cues and ate larger meals less frequently I started having a better relationship with food. There was a bit of an adjustment period as my body was expecting food all day, but the transition wasn't hard.
This eating pattern works so well for me and I've been able to lose and keep a lot of weight off.4 -
I don't really have a schedule but usually something like this...
wake up- eat immediately
1-2 hours later- large snack
11am-2pm a big lunch
3-5pm dinner (which some days I skip)
and nothing after 3-5pm.0 -
3 meals, 1-2 snacks, about every 3-5 hours.
Typically I will eat these amounts at these times:
8 AM Breakfast about 300 calories
Noon Lunch about 400 calories
3-4 PM snack
6 PM Dinner about 500 calories
8-9PM snack
Snacks are 100-300 calories total for both.0 -
3 main meals and 3 snacks. Little and often seems to work well for me as I fill up quickly. I maintain on 1800 cals.0
-
2 meals, rarely a snack. Lunch & dinner. Occasionally a snack after dinner if it was light or my workout for the day was a long and difficult one.0
-
I don't eat during the day at all. I haven't eaten breakfast or dinner since i was around 12 years old so I just eat lunch. I normally eat lunch at around 11pm which isnt healthy at all as I end up being starving at the point and just eat lots of bread with my meal to help fill me up and then I go to bed and maintain the calories i just ate0
-
This content has been removed.
-
During the week-
7-8a: two boiled eggs, 1 oz cheddar chz
930-1030a: 1c greek yogurt, walnuts, strawberries
12-1p: 4-6oz protein, .75-1c carbs, 1.5c veggies
3-4p (preworkout): oats with flax, banana
630-730p: 4-6oz protein, 2c veggies
Weekend is always variable and a little less prescribed, but tends to be a later, bigger breakfast and no morning snack, smaller lunch, grazing afternoon snack, bigger dinner.
Maybe-
930-1030a: 2 eggs (poached, scrambled, fried, sometimes omelette with veggies that need to be used), bacon, 1 red potato hash
1230-130p: lettuce wraps with leftover protein or salad with leftover protein and oil and vinegar
230-330p: grazing crackers/cheese/fruit/veggies of some sort that need using
630-730p: 4-6 oz protein (usually some kind of beef or seafood), 1c carbs, 1.5c veggies0 -
I eat 3 meals, no snacks. Current goal is 1500, and I split them somewhat evenly (usually around 350-450 for breakfast, not always, whether lunch or dinner is biggest varies). I eat at 6:30-ish (depends on whether I run in the morning, as I eat after I run), noon-ish, and when I get home and make dinner, which is quite late, usually 9-10. I don't generally get hungry until it's my normal eating time, because I am a creature of habit. I almost always end up doing a workout right before a meal -- if I don't run/swim before breakfast I do it before dinner, and I usually lift at lunchtime (before lunch) or before dinner.0
-
through the week anywhere from 3-6x a day.
I have breakfast and if needed I have a small snack about 1 hour before lunch...then I have lunch...a snack about 4pm then my dinner...
sometimes if I have the calories or if I am hungry I eat at night too...keep in mind most of my meals are 500-600 calories each and my snacks are yogurt or fruit...sometimes in the evening I eat chips and chocolate too.1 -
longstocking wrote: »Basically I was wondering if maybe my snacking is counterproductive? Maybe it's just a question of habit and if I eliminate snacks and would only have meals after a week my body would adjust and I won't feel as hungry in between meals? I'm somewhat afraid to just test it because I'm afraid to end up being too hungry and overeat.
When I was younger I used to skip breakfast and often lunch. I wasn't hungry early in the day. I did get pretty hungry, tired, not feeling 100% by afternoon though. I started eating lunch more and that was better. As I got older I decided to eat something small for breakfast and my energy for the whole day got better. I get hungry in the morning at that meal time now where I did not before it was a regular habit.
I get hungry every 3-5 hours and I think that is pretty average. I'm sure if I changed my eating schedule and split up my calories into fewer meals I would eventually get used to it and get hungry around those times. I don't have to do that though. It is convenient for me to eat on my current schedule.
The only way you will find out if a different way of splitting your calories or different meal timing works better for you is to try it.
If you are going to cut snacks you need to eat some bigger meals and maybe change habits. Like if you always eat a snack while watching tv change to a different activity during that time. It could take more than a week to change a habit.
1 -
Three meals (1,700ish cals) and two or three snacks (300ish cals) for me. I usually eat every two or three hours, otherwise I'm starving. Most of my snacks are fruits and veggies though, so it evens out the heavier meals
0 -
Because I'm an insulin-dependent diabetic, I try to eat 5 meals a day (9am-9pm) spaced exactly 3 hours apart. This keeps my insulin dosage lower & consistent and basically I'm "not really hungry" by the time the next meal comes around which helps with eating smaller meals. I try to have all my meals at about the same size as far as calories, carbs & protein (but that's still a work in progress).0
-
I have one protein shake in the afternoon and eat one large meal around 6pm.0
-
Usually (it's a habit, not a rule) I eat twice a day. A small lunch or large snack (about 300 cal) around 2:00 p.m. and a large dinner around 8:30 p.m. On these days I start getting hungry about an hour or so before the meal.
On the weekends we typically work outside most of the day so I eat around 10:00 a.m. instead of 2:00, and then dinner around 8:30 - 9:00. On these days I'm usually not hungry before the first meal and I'm ravenous by dinner.0 -
For about a year, I ate 6 (7 if including what I consumed before/during workouts) evenly spaced 300 calorie "meals." Goal was 2200-2500 cals. I was hungry every 2-3 hours and looked forward to my "feeding times." 5am, 7am, 10am, 1pm, 4pm, 7pm.
The last 3-6 months, I've been doing just three 500-600 calorie meals, which after eating tiny meals at a high frequency, makes me feel SO FULL and holds me over 4-5 hours. Training days, it's 500cal Pre/IntraWO, 600cal Breakfast, 500cal Lunch, 600cal dinner.
Maybe consider trying out smaller meals with a higher frequency and see if your body likes that better. 0 -
3 meals, 3 snacks. I eat every 2-3 hours0
-
I'll have a small breakfast (approx 100 calories) at roughly 7:30am. I'll then have another small breakfast or snack (again, approx 100 calories) while I'm at work between 9:30-10:30 ish.
I'll have lunch between 12:00-1:00pm which is normally between 400-500 calories. I rarely have a snack between lunch and dinner but if I'm hungry enough I will.
My dinner tends to be my biggest meal of the day at 500-700 calories and I will sometimes have a dessert (approx 200 calories or less).
I'm never that hungry anymore after meals or snacks, I suppose I've just got used to it (also it does help eating little and often).1 -
I only eat breakfast, lunch & dinner. I don't find the need for snacks.. and I'm only "allowed" 1200 calories per day, my 3 meals usually get me pretty close to that 1200. I eat breakfast around 9:30, lunch at 12:30 and dinner around 6. I also drink around 90oz of water a day, I think that REALLY helps curb any hunger pains I may get.0
-
I skip breakfast and just eat lunch and dinner, with occasionally one snack between the two.0
-
Breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a couple snacks in the late afternoon/early evening as I don't eat dinner until around 8:30 PM0
-
Small meals and snack throughout the day. Sometimes, I even ignore mealtime and eat small healthy meals, snacks. Sometimes indulging in a snickers or cookie.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions