Do you eat your workout calories ?
uleano
Posts: 1 Member
If am shooting for 2 pounds a week and 1,200 calories a day. When I plug in my workouts,
I " get" more calories. Can use them or am a sabotaging my weight loss?
I " get" more calories. Can use them or am a sabotaging my weight loss?
0
Replies
-
Eat them, exercise calories taste the best.16
-
Absolutely!!
I log my exercise in MFP manually, and select the light/low/slow options even if I feel like I've done a fairly strenuous workout.
Then ...
I eat about half my exercise calories back if I've done just a little bit of exercise, like maybe a 1-hour walk.
I eat about 75% of my exercise calories back if I've done a moderate amount of exercise, like perhaps a 3 hour bicycle ride.
I eat about 90% of my exercise calories back if I've done a lot of exercise, like say an 8 hour 100 mile bicycle ride.
That's all approximate, of course and may vary somewhat.6 -
-
TavistockToad wrote: »Eat them, exercise calories taste the best.
Perfectly said.1 -
This content has been removed.
-
Yes! As long as your average "net" calories remain at or below your daily calorie goal set by MFP you will lose weight (if you are honest about your activity level when first setting up your account:)). I find the weekly calorie view under the nutrition section helpful to ensure I'm on track for the week. It's especially helpful when I've had a not so great eating day because it tells you how many calories you are below your weekly calorie goal too!2
-
For sure, it's half the reason I exercise.6
-
Great informative discussion about it here from a knowledgeable trainer: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10503681/exercise-calories-do-i-eat-these-a-video-explanation/p11
-
Yes. But be careful. Mfp has some ridiculously high calorie burns in the database.10
-
Asher_Ethan wrote: »Yes. But be careful. Mfp has some ridiculously high calorie burns in the database.
Yes indeed. I only give myself partial credit for what the database wants to award me. Maybe 65%
1 -
You can. I choose not to because I don't totally trust the database numbers and I have a lot of weight to lose so I eat my 1200 and I am golden.1
-
Surprised to see so many yes's on here! My understanding was that the going is wisdom states MFP's exercise databases heavily overestimate how many calories you burn exercising, and that activity trackers are also frequently way off. As a result, I personally don't eat back exercise calories except on rare occasions, and on those rare occasions I try not to eat back more than 30% of those exercise calories.0
-
Great informative discussion about it here from a knowledgeable trainer: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10503681/exercise-calories-do-i-eat-these-a-video-explanation/p1
Insightful video ^^
I have eating all or a part of my exercise calories and have been steadily losing weight. Some calorie burn rates seem way high and I don't trust them, so I would either not eat them back or eat part of them back after doing some research online.
0 -
Surprised to see so many yes's on here! My understanding was that the going is wisdom states MFP's exercise databases heavily overestimate how many calories you burn exercising, and that activity trackers are also frequently way off. As a result, I personally don't eat back exercise calories except on rare occasions, and on those rare occasions I try not to eat back more than 30% of those exercise calories.
You shouldn't be surprised, MFP was designed for people to eat back their exercise calories to lose weight - that's how the math is set up.
It's true that the database here is very generous. People have different strategies for estimating what they've burned, but over time you figure out what works. Extreme precision isn't required, we all have a record of what we ate, what we think we burned, and our weight over time, so we can adjust things as we go.3 -
Surprised to see so many yes's on here! My understanding was that the going is wisdom states MFP's exercise databases heavily overestimate how many calories you burn exercising, and that activity trackers are also frequently way off.
Only if you select higher exercise intensities. For example, I always select Bicycling 16-19 km/h. Yesterday's 50 km ride averaged about 20 km/h, but nevertheless, I went with the 16-19 km/h choice as always.
Same with my walking intensity ... I walk one level faster than what I record.
But that's why I go with a percentage ... 50% for less exercise and nearly 100% when I do a lot of exercise. I need fuel for the longer rides, but can get away with less fuel for a short walk.
2 -
In general I'm not hungry enough to eat back my exercise calories.0
-
No.1
-
Asher_Ethan wrote: »Yes. But be careful. Mfp has some ridiculously high calorie burns in the database.
Pick up a heart rate monitor to avoid all these inexact measurements. Been using the polar ft7 for years and now don't work out with it0 -
@sadmaker A heart rate monitor will give you exact measurements of your heart rate and does not measure calories at all. If you want to know how many calories you've burned, a pair of dice is as good as an HRM.3
-
If am shooting for 2 pounds a week and 1,200 calories a day. When I plug in my workouts,
I " get" more calories. Can use them or am a sabotaging my weight loss?
Why do you think MFP would be trying to trick you?Surprised to see so many yes's on here! My understanding was that the going is wisdom states MFP's exercise databases heavily overestimate how many calories you burn exercising, and that activity trackers are also frequently way off. As a result, I personally don't eat back exercise calories except on rare occasions, and on those rare occasions I try not to eat back more than 30% of those exercise calories.
It's the way the tool is designed, so not sure why it would be a surprise. Your calorie target doesn't include any exercise in your activity level...exercise is unaccounted for activity...obviously, the more active you are, the higher you energy (calorie) requirements would be.
Personally, I wouldn't and never have used the exercise data base...but there are numerous ways to determine a somewhat accurate calorie expenditure if one is willing to pursue them. My Garmin 500 is close enough for my cycling.
MFP would give me around 1900 calories to lose about 1 Lb per week (before exercise)...I ride quite a bit and usually do a 30 mile ride on the weekends...I burn over 1,000 calories on a 30 mile ride...if I just ate the 1900, I'd basically be starving my body by only essentially feeding it 900 calories after my exercise...no bueno!0 -
I eat back between 25-50% of my exercise calories- I make that adjustment as I log them in the system.
On Friday, my exercise calories tasted like a margarita
6 -
I use the TDEE method because I prefer to have more stable and humane daily numbers vs the crazy burns MFP sometimes gives.1
-
You can. I choose not to because I don't totally trust the database numbers and I have a lot of weight to lose so I eat my 1200 and I am golden.
Obese people can keep larger deficits without penalty, but sooner or later you likely want to test the database. Your food logging and activity level are also estimates.
OP- eating exercise calories back is how MFP is designed. That's because larger deficits make it harder for your body to support existing lean muscle mass. Most people want a lower body fat %......eating back calories helps you do that. But you need to tweak the numbers a bit because everything is estimates.0 -
No, but I'm trying to lose weight.0
-
-
NorthCascades wrote: »
Me too. Eating exercise calories incentivized exercise for me.2 -
-
Some days I do, others I don't. I prefer to bank my calories for the weekends
1 -
Absolutely, Im on the same calorie count as you, i generally stay close to the 1200 each day regardless how much i exercise, but if i feel hungry or have an event its there for me that day and i can still stay on track.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions