Influence of parents
spyro88
Posts: 472 Member
I was just wondering whether anybody on here would partially or wholly attribute their weight problems to how they were brought up, or their parents' attitude to food?
I know it's a pretty sensitive subject, but when I was a kid I was pretty much allowed to eat what I want, and I took full advantage of it... I feel if the adults in my life hadn't given me this freedom I might not be in this mess now (I was an overweight child as well).
What do you guys think?
I know it's a pretty sensitive subject, but when I was a kid I was pretty much allowed to eat what I want, and I took full advantage of it... I feel if the adults in my life hadn't given me this freedom I might not be in this mess now (I was an overweight child as well).
What do you guys think?
0
Replies
-
MY PARENTS RESTRICTED EVERYTHING AND I AM OVERWEIGHT AND A MESS
idk who to blame but i think its more about taking personal responsibility at this point0 -
I think it's a tough thing to blame everything on parents. Yeah, they could have been better role models when I was younger and instilled the healthy mind set, but when I got to high school, I could have changed things. Instead, I wasn't strong enough (or wasn't educated enough) to go healthy.
You can blame your parents, but in the end, I think it's really you that has to answer for all the decisions. It took me a while to come to grips with that and make the change.0 -
Hello,
My mom used to watch everything I ate. She would serve my plate and it would always be a littler portion that my brothers. I would sneak to the frig at night when everyone was asleep bc i was still hungry and snack on junk food. Then when I moved out on my own, i went even more crazy!! I ate anything i wanted, fast food, cooked unheathly dinners and got seconds sometimes thirds. So i wouldnt put it all on your parents. If they watched everything you ate you might be like me. Now im 300 pounds and wish my mom would watch me like she did then =(0 -
it definately does!!!!
we were not allowed to leave the table till our plates were clean.
my ex-husband too. made me eat all the extra food, cuz he hated leftovers.
its so drilled in my head now that i can not waste food. that i will force it down till its gone.:sick:
its so hard to break that brain washing!!!0 -
Parent's play a huge role, we are going to do what we see and what they allow us. I was always a chubby kid and my mom was constantly buying fast food. I even asked her to stop and she didn't! She hates to cook....so I always hated to cook ( didn't know how) but I have very recently started cooking and I LOVE it! My mom and dad are very overweight, they both realize it and say they want to lose weight but they aren't willing to do what it takes! I have 2 small children now and I am trying my best to set the standard for them, I eat healthy very often and even if I do get fast food it's usually a salad or just the burger no fries, stuff like that. and whenever I get them fast food I opt for the fruit instead of fries, they don't mind! If you want your kids to eat healthy you have to eat healthy.
I don't blame them for me being overweight, and I see how it goes both ways, my husband ate whatever he wanted and still does (he's skinny tho) but I've heard from people who weren't allowed to so they ate everything when noone was looking. Seems like there is no way to win but as a parent now I still think it's my responsibility to feed my kids and myself healthy food, what they do when they are adults is on them! I explain to them why we eat healthy though and I will continue to until they are older and understand the benefits!0 -
I think there are lots of things that influence that part of ourselves. Our families, our friends, the area we live in, your mindset on food, etc... We're all here, because we're taking responsibility for ourselves & making a healthy change no matter what caused us to become overweight.0
-
The forcing to eat everything on your plate dates back to the Great Depression. You never knew when you were getting your next meal. That mindset unfortunately, has been passed down the generations.
You shouldn't play the blame game anyway. It's not going to help you get healthy. Only you can do that. And when (if) you have your own kids, you can teach them the healthy way to eat that you're learning now.0 -
I definitely developed a weird relationship to food as a result of my parents' attitude toward food and eating. In my very early life, we were very, very poor and my brother and I were told to eat everything on our plates, no matter what it tasted like. As I grew older, my brothers and I were very competitive and if I didn't grab food it would disappear, with all the teasing and one-up-manship you find in bitter sibling rivalries.
Top that off with my parents dispassionately telling me I *couldn't* have as much as my brothers--because I was a girl (and girls need to eat less)--with all of the gender resentment and double standards attached, then throw in a healthy dose of unhealthy lifestyle and it's really absolutely no surprise that became overweight.
But here I am now. The real challenge is for me to really take ownership of my life and my body, take responsibility for my past choices, then get on with the business of reversing as much damage as I can before I get too old to enjoy myself fully!
Glad to be here, looking forward to getting healthier!0 -
I was never restricted on food, and could go to the fridge when ever I wanted. I could have ice cream whenever I wanted. Chips. Chocolate...anything we had. We DID NOT have sugary candy or soda at our house, and always had balanced meals and dinner together as well as fruit and vegetables, and I was very active. The processed foods I had at home growing up were very limited, and if you look in my fridge it is the same way now.
My step dad loved to cook, and taught me a lot of what I know about food. I associate cooking/feeding people with showing love. That probably isn't too healthy for my husband So, yeah, a tiny touch of a reason I am overweight is psychological, but I have known for years about portion control and needing exercise...so it isn't like I didn't know any better.
I think our parents and the way we grow up has about a 35% impact overall on how we eat as adults...when you are younger what your parents have at home become your main sources of nutrition and I think creates a predisposition to craving certain things...for me it is fruit and veggies fresh from the farm fields because we went picking often. However, once you are an adult you are in control of what you do with your body and what you put in your mouth. As far as being overweight when you were younger...was it medically related? or were you sedentary? If you were watching TV and playing video games or sitting around 75% of the time, well then it was choice then, too. At some point we all take health and learn how we can take better care of ourselves. I think we can only blame our environment/parents for our bodies/weight/life up until the point where we start making our own choices and decisions.0 -
I had an eye opening moment recently. My parents came to visit for a few days and I planned meals to accomodate their tastes rather than my own. DH and I have been eating home-cooked, less processed food and less meat in the last several months and I'm down about 40#. This visit with my folks was the first time I had eaten the way I was raised since I started logging on MFP. The eye opening thing for me was that I logged the food before I ate it and as a result ate much less than I would have as a child but still struggled to stay under my calorie goals.
For example, we had one meal that was casing hot dogs with vegetable beef soup. When I logged the meal, I decided to eat one hot dog and one bowl of soup. It wasn't very filling or satisfying, even though it was like 600 calories. When I was a kid, I'd have eaten 2-3 hot dogs and 2 bowls of soup, plus "sides" like cheese, jello, canned fruit, milk, etc. My typical meal now is a big bowl of bean chili or a huge salad with tofu, runs about 350 calories, and keeps me satisfied for about 3 hours. It's no wonder I was a fat kid (before kids were fat) and am still struggling with my weight into my 40's, when the way I learned to eat was filled with high calorie, low nutrition, salty, processed foods and caloric beverages.
All that being said, I DO NOT blame my parents for "failing" to teach me about nutrition. They became parents in the early years of convenience food, before we learned how bad it is for you. They learned the lessons that the food industry taught at that time. Mom worked full time, raised two kids, and the whole family ate breakfast and supper together every day. They did a great job. I've learned that, in order to grow, I have to let go of blaming my parents for what's "wrong" in my life. They may have made all the decisions for me for the first 18 years, but they did the best they could, and I'm in control of who I am and what I do now. Not that this personal responsibility thing is easy. It's not. But, it's the person I've decided I want to be.
*jumps off of soap box and goes to make a bowl of oatmeal*0 -
You make a good point Kimbie... it all depends on what the world/ food industry is like at the time. When I was growing up I could go to the chip shop whenever I wanted for example... sometimes I went 2-3 times a week with money left over on the way back from school. That was acceptable then - loadsa kids did it - but if I knew of parents allowing their kids 3 portions of chips a week now, or mcdonalds, etc. I would be pretty horrified. I think attitudes to what we should be feeding kids have changed a lot!
I was pretty much brought up on stuff like fishfingers, chicken nuggets, baked beans, frozen chips as meals at home, but then so were most of the people I knew in a working class neighbourhood at that time.
I remember being shocked when I went to a friend's house and we had to have strawberries *without* sugar, and to me his mum seemed like some sort of health freak, because nobody normally batted an eyelid back then!0 -
I volunteer at an elementary school on the weekends and its funny to sometimes see how "the apple usually doesn't fall far from the tree." When you look at the bigger children in the class, and then meet their parents, you can usually see why. Sometimes its genetic.. sometimes not. I know it's mean to say but it happens to happen that way.
It made me realize that as a child I was accustomed to big meals because I grew up with 3 brothers, and while they were active, they expected me to "be a girl" and play with dolls and not come out to play basketball and soccer and whatever other sports with them. My parents weren't all that into health & fitness either. "Girls don't wear gym shorts and play with balls." So I was eating and eating and not working anything off. I was never overweight but I didn't have the nicest body. I was petite and the upper edge of a healthy weight. In high school I joined the softball and lacrosse teams even though my mother wasn't a "soccer mom" and didnt really come watch me play or even acknowledge that I was doing anything good for myself. Eating didn't change either. Pizza and mcdonalds it was. As soon as I moved to college and started running with my roommate and eating healthier, everyone saw that I was losing weight and it felt great. My roommate used to have an eating disorder so she was working on starting to look healthier... eating right and exercising.. which definitely helped me.
That being said.. we're all adults now and know better. I wouldn't blame it all on them. With 4 children and not being educated about health it was hard for our parents too. Our environment is a large part of who we are but now that I'm back home I do my own grocery shopping and hit the gym pretty hard. You can't work on the new you if you're still holding onto the old one...0 -
Hubby and I were just talking about this last night...in a convoluted way. We were looking at the grocery ads and 90% of the items are processed...and with kids and both parents working, I can see how it seems easier and cheaper to go with something pre-made or processed.
The funniest convenience food I saw was a 'microwave ready potato.' Seriously? It is less convenient because you have to unwrap each potato, rather than open a bag and wash them....but the were 10 for $10 -- such a gimmick to make it look like a good deal! Most of the 10 for $10 items were super processed -- potato and rice sides, mac and cheese...I think one would end up actually spending more on groceries because the processed stuff is less filling than whole foods.
And Kimbie -- there are sooo many comfort foods from growing up that I really need to watch my portions on, too....like any italian food! IMO it is really about portion control. I won't make it in the long haul if I can't have ice cream, cheeseburgers, beer, wine, and steak in moderation :happy:0 -
my mother NEVER restricted what i ate as a child.
i used to eat alot, and have always been a good eater. as a child, i was very active. i would never sit in front of the tv or anything like that, i was always encouraged to go out and play.
but as a teenager, i started eating fast food, and unhealthy options, that is why i am over weight. i cannot blame my mother what so ever, she never told me i must eat something, nor did she tell me i couldn't. she just gave me lots of great options, like fruits and veggies, and i made the choice of what to eat and when. i would say i was very fit and healthy until i was around 15. and by then, i couldn't blame my mother.
my personal belif is that i am overweight, not due to bad teachings, but due to lack of self control on my part.0 -
The only thing I can really "blame" on my parents is genetics - both of them are predisposed to being heavy. But I grew up with my grandparents, and my gram cooked every night - it was rare that we went out to eat - so I ate fairly healthy balanced meals. She also packed my lunch for school and cooked my breakfast. But, she also baked a lot - cookies, and brownies, and cakes - and kept sweet treats in the house, and perhaps let me indulge in those more often than I should have. But if I'm really honest here, while I was maybe 20 lbs overweight when I graduated HS, my weight problems took off in college, when I had a crazy class schedule and I ate whatever was convenient, and snacked a LOT. Ultimately, it comes back to personal responsibility - and the only person I can blame for my weight is myself.0
-
And Kimbie -- there are sooo many comfort foods from growing up that I really need to watch my portions on, too....like any italian food! IMO it is really about portion control. I won't make it in the long haul if I can't have ice cream, cheeseburgers, beer, wine, and steak in moderation :happy:
Oh, girl, I eat me some comfort food, too. :bigsmile: Like you, I watch my portions and make deliberate decisions about what goes in my mouth. My weaknesses are potato chips with dip and pizza. Soft serve ice cream in the summer. But, I'm happy to report my tastes are changing and I don't crave these foods as much as I used to. Chocolate, now, that's a daily event....
That reminds me, there's a Lindt bar here somewhere.....0 -
There are parts about my relationship with food that I attribute to watching my parents (especially my mom) growing up. I don't really think it has anything to do with what I eat, but actually how I eat and "diet".
Throughout my life my mom has been on a diet. She is a serial yo-yo dieter. She's done the shakes, Weight Watchers (a few times), Atkins, pills, Jenny Craig.... She always goes far up in her weight and then very low, which I am always proud of her for her weight loss and achieving a healthier life without all that extra weight.
But she always seems to go back up but "never can figure out why" the weight keeps coming back up. To her, the food and lifestyle changes would always be temporary, not a REAL and long term change. When she was on the low carb diet, she found a type of flax chips at Trader Joes that only had a very small amount of carbs per serving. In her mind this meant that she could sit down and eat the whole bag, yet the pounds kept coming on and she didn't know why.
I admit that I fell into those same traps, doing unhealthy things to lose weight like crash dieting or even an eating disorder, but now I'm working on breaking that "diet" mentality and actually making this my lifestyle.
I almost think my moms addicted to the praise that you get when you lose lots of weight. Hmm. thoughts to ponder.0 -
My mother was very harsh with me. I had some childhood trama that caused me to eat eat eat eat eat. When i was 9 years old i first saw that i had stretch marks and i was SOOO embarrassed to wear a bathing suit. Instead of telling me im beautiful the way i am, my mother would tell me im fat, tell me im going to be big as a house if i continued to eat the way i eat, everytime food went missing i was blamed.. i really had a huge problem. When my mom would take me to the doctor she has NEVER EVER stood there as watched me get weighed. She always had to "go to the bathroom" when i was getting weighed. It was like she was ashamed of me so that added more and more to my issue. my dad never told me i was fat. He would tell me i should do more walking around but he never told me i would be unhappy for the rest of my life if im fat. I dont want to blame her, but i really wish she would have been my support instead of the person i hid food from. It was like a rush hiding food under my pillow, by the washer or dryer, and now that i think about i was alone. Even at 22 she told me i was getting too big. But now i know when i have kids and they gain weight or dont look like what everyone else looks like, i know how to react and what to say because i wish it was said to me. Because my mother way that way towards me it motivates me everyday to be that daughter she always wanted me to look like, but at the same time ill be the person i've wanted to look like since iw as a little girl. :-)0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions