We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
More vs less meals each day
ldwatene
Posts: 150 Member
So I get that weight loss is all about calories in, calories out but are there additional benefits to how often you eat each day either health or body wise?
I was told that it's better for your body to eat smaller meals more often when it comes to better digestion, metabolism and getting the most nutrition out of what you eat.
What are your thoughts on this?
I was told that it's better for your body to eat smaller meals more often when it comes to better digestion, metabolism and getting the most nutrition out of what you eat.
What are your thoughts on this?
1
Replies
-
The general consensus seems to be do what works best for you.
I'm personally great with 5-6 smaller intakes on non-cycling days. Cycling days that might jump to 7 to 10 depending on how far I go.
Some people do great with 1-2.
The science seems to suggest that neither way, nor any in between method, greatly affects your metabolism.
So do what's comfortable to you.
(
Those once a day eaters are just nuts though... 
) 1 -
Do what works best for you....
I prefer less meals. I feel more satisfied with bigger meals, I don't have time to prep multiple meals, I don't have time to eat multiple meals properly (as in sitting down, eating mindfully, and enjoying my food... Not shoving it in because it's 2.5 hours since I last ate)2 -
Derf_Smeggle wrote: »The general consensus seems to be do what works best for you.
I'm personally great with 5-6 smaller intakes on non-cycling days. Cycling days that might jump to 7 to 10 depending on how far I go.
Some people do great with 1-2.
The science seems to suggest that neither way, nor any in between method, greatly affects your metabolism.
So do what's comfortable to you.
( Those once a day eaters are just nuts though... )
Oh my gosh. I use to be one of those once a day eaters.
I could never imagine eating 10 times a day0 -
It's not better, but it's not worse. Meal timing and frequency are personal preference, unless you have a medical reason to watch when you eat. I do three meals and dessert. Others eat more often, others eat less often.1
-
Like others have said it's a personal preference. I do better with less bigger meals, it fits my schedule and it's better for my mental health:-). I do one or two meals with minimal snacking.1
-
I was told exactly what you say - small frequent meals improves metabolism. And then I was told that fasting for extended periods improves fat burning. Much confuse. Reason to the rescue! Eat in a way that makes you feel good, satisfied, energized and not with an increased desire to eat too much. Then don't eat too much.
My body doesn't care whether I eat many small meals or a few large. It just wants food. And I like to eat. More meals means more variety, but fewer meals means less planning and freeing up time. I don't feel obligated to eat just to avoid bingeing or ruining my metabolism, or fainting or getting arrested for assault, I feel free to eat whenever suits me, and I can wait a couple of hours for a meal, no big deal.2 -
So I get that weight loss is all about calories in, calories out but are there additional benefits to how often you eat each day either health or body wise?
I was told that it's better for your body to eat smaller meals more often when it comes to better digestion, metabolism and getting the most nutrition out of what you eat.
What are your thoughts on this?
IMO, personal preference wins the day. Eat in a way that fits your goals and preferences so you can sustain it for a lifetime...1 -
At the end of the day it is what works for your lifestyle. For me I enjoy spreading out the meals throughout the day.
It shouldn't matter how many meals you spread it over as long at you hit your calorie or macro goals by the end of the day.1 -
kommodevaran wrote: »I was told exactly what you say - small frequent meals improves metabolism. And then I was told that fasting for extended periods improves fat burning. Much confuse. Reason to the rescue! Eat in a way that makes you feel good, satisfied, energized and not with an increased desire to eat too much. Then don't eat too much.
My body doesn't care whether I eat many small meals or a few large. It just wants food. And I like to eat. More meals means more variety, but fewer meals means less planning and freeing up time. I don't feel obligated to eat just to avoid bingeing or ruining my metabolism, or fainting or getting arrested for assault, I feel free to eat whenever suits me, and I can wait a couple of hours for a meal, no big deal.
Isn't it funny how if you keep looking, almost all nutrition advice that "they say" cancels out with advice that's mutually exclusive?4 -
So I get that weight loss is all about calories in, calories out but are there additional benefits to how often you eat each day either health or body wise?
I was told that it's better for your body to eat smaller meals more often when it comes to better digestion, metabolism and getting the most nutrition out of what you eat.
What are your thoughts on this?
For the majority of people, it makes no difference whatsoever.
Timing some meals or macros may give elite athletes a performance advantage but most people need to only be aware of comfort: if you feel better working out on a full or empty stomach or somewhere in between.
The number of meals eaten during the day seems to affect diabetics more than anyone, especially those on insulin or medications. Eating frequent small meals can keep blood sugars more level so there is less of a chance of extremely high or low blood sugar events.1 -
Personal preference. I work bestow multiple meals/snacks1
-
Although occasional studies show up that find small differences in time-of-day or number-of-meals food consumption and digestion, there's little consensus that it makes much difference at all. Do what works best for you.1
-
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »Do what works best for you....
I prefer less meals. I feel more satisfied with bigger meals, I don't have time to prep multiple meals, I don't have time to eat multiple meals properly (as in sitting down, eating mindfully, and enjoying my food... Not shoving it in because it's 2.5 hours since I last ate)
Personal perference/do what works for your lifestyle.
Above is exactly how I personally feel about it.1 -
I defensively agree with you.Small meals daily keep your metabolism more consisten.Have been on ww. For 10 years.Lost 120 pounds.Now have neuromuscular disease which recommends same thing.I also don't crave as much.1
-
1958lysmith wrote: »I defensively agree with you.Small meals daily keep your metabolism more consisten.Have been on ww. For 10 years.Lost 120 pounds.Now have neuromuscular disease which recommends same thing.I also don't crave as much.
How can you tell?1 -
kommodevaran wrote: »1958lysmith wrote: »I defensively agree with you.Small meals daily keep your metabolism more consisten.Have been on ww. For 10 years.Lost 120 pounds.Now have neuromuscular disease which recommends same thing.I also don't crave as much.
How can you tell?
Yeah this.
I prefer less larger meals than small, unsatisfying teaser meals which just make me more hungry and therefore eat more in the end!3 -
I think it depends on personal preference...how much you like to eat at one time. I'd much rather eat a double steak dinner, Big Mac meal, or medium pizza in one sitting than nibble on snacks throughout the day.2
-
Do what works for you and helps you keep the calories within your goal.
Week days, at work, I usually eat multiple small meals. My schedule is hectic and I don't have. Lot of time to sit down and eat. I pack my food at home and take it to work in a wheelie cooler which also holds my bottles of ice tea.
Weekends, I tend to eat fewer, larger meals. I have more time to cook and can have things that don't reheat as well (egg whites).0 -
1958lysmith wrote: »I defensively agree with you.Small meals daily keep your metabolism more consisten.Have been on ww. For 10 years.Lost 120 pounds.Now have neuromuscular disease which recommends same thing.I also don't crave as much.
Really? How? Studies?0 -
some people say too many meals does not allow your digestive system proper time to rest and others say many small meals digest better. I think it is individual and we each should see which works better for how our body functions.1
-
More meals works for me! I have 3 meals and one or two snacks. I can't make it so many hours without eating. Snacks are things like bananas, granola bars, string cheese, peanut butter crackers. Just something 200 calories or less to help me make it to the next meal. I get headaches and stomach pains if I go too long without eating. That's just me though.
Best of luck to you on your weight loss journey!1 -
some people say too many meals does not allow your digestive system proper time to rest and others say many small meals digest better. I think it is individual and we each should see which works better for how our body functions.
^^^This. And also see what the individual prefers.
Some people find spreading out their meals prevents them from getting hungry making it easier to eat less. Others find it stimulates there appetite making it harder to eat less...2 -
I kind do a little of both. I eat about half my calories split over breakfast (~70kcal)/morning snack(~270kcal)/lunch (~340kcal)/afternoon snack (~140kcal). I work a desk job so I just pack it all up each day and save the rest of my calories for a big dinner. At work I have some more temptations (snacks/treats) and I have personally found that making sure I have a little something to eat whenever I start to feel a little hungry to prevent me from grazing. Then I have the other half of my calories (800-900kcal) for a big dinner. I have a protein shake in the afternoon in addition to all of this when I am lifting that day. On the weekends, I tend to eat 2-3 bigger meals with minimal snacking.
I recently had to change my process a little more to accommodate my new workout schedule, but I am happy with where it ended up. I will change it again as I need to. This is what works very well for my body and my schedule. Experiment and find what works well for you, OP. That's part of the whole process here- finding out what is helpful for each individual.1 -
i was at my lowest weight eating one meal a day, and my mom is at her lowest weight eating 6 times a day. i would rather eat big meals than to eat small throughout the day because, more often than not, i'm still hungry after the snack.
and then there went 200 calories i could have used at dinner...
2 -
I would kill someone if I had to eat small meals and snacks throughout the day.
I eat two meals between 6:00 p.m. and 10:30 p.m.
Eat whenever you like.
2
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.5K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.5K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 444 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.1K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.8K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions