Does not eating past 7pm help?
rose_lemonade
Posts: 8 Member
I've heard some people swear by this rule but I don't know if there's any science to back it up. My boyfriend also wants to lose weight but he doesn't usually get in from work till 9pm or later and then I either cook or we order in. I wake up feeling bloated and I'm sure this is the cause, but in terms of actual weight loss/gain, does eating late make a difference?
If so then it means we'll only be able to eat together on weekends, which kinda sucks
If so then it means we'll only be able to eat together on weekends, which kinda sucks
6
Replies
-
For weightloss it makes no difference at all when you eat.7
-
If you're prone to overeating to the point of wiping out your calorie deficit before bed, sure.
Otherwise, meal timing has no effect on weight loss.5 -
Nope. It's not true. Eat when you want. Just stay within a calorie deficit, and you'll be fine. I eat right up until bed every night. Dinner usually doesn't happen until 8:30 or so.
I worked night shift for years. Not sure what I would have done if I couldn't eat after 7:00, since I worked 6:00 p.m. to 6 a.m.2 -
It matters not when but how much.7
-
For weight loss, it doesn't matter. But you mention feeling bloated. I know if I eat too late I have heartburn issues, so I don't. But it has no impact on my weight loss.4
-
Nope. A deficit of calorie intake over an extended period of time is what helps.2
-
The rule as I know it is "no eating after dinner". Not a specific time. I've also heard it called the 12 hour daily fast.5
-
It takes up to 3 DAYS to digest food. So it hardly matters if you consume some of them after 7pm.
It's all about calories in, calories out.
So once you meet your calorie intake goal, STOP EATING.
Mindful eating, peeps.
I think where people get into trouble, is the graze in the evening, and go over their DAILY calorie targets.
"Digestion can take anywhere from 24 to 72 hours, during which time the food you've eaten travels down your esophagus to your stomach, then to your small intestine, your large intestine, and out through the *kitten*."6 -
Eating late doesn't matter. People stop eating at a certain time to help limit overall calories. If you are in a caloric deficit, it doesn't matter what time you stop eating for the day2
-
Thanks guys. I will probably try and eat lighter dinners if I'm eating late anyway to stop the bloat in the morning, but glad to know my bf and I can still have dinner together!0
-
To keep from feeling bloated, maybe try to change what you are eating by adjusting your macros; less carbs, more protein and "green" / "alive" things like fresh salad greens with simple homemade dressing of lemon juice, chopped garlic, salt, pepper and olive oil.
One of the most nourishing / alkalizing foods I know of is parsley. People use it as a garnish - blend it in the blender and eat it. Takes the bloat away.
Bloating can also be from yeast. Spit into a glass of distilled water, cover with plastic warp and look at it the next day, if there are "threads" you have yeast over growth. Yeast can be curtailed by cutting out sugar / carbs and taking the correct "live" probiotics - you need more than what is in yogurt.16 -
I think one of the reasons this became a thing is because of the mindless eating people tend to do in the evening hours when they're relaxing in front of the TV or on the computer. It's often not eating out of hunger at that point, but habit or maybe boredom. So, if your boyfriend is one of those folks, being aware of why he's eating can be helpful.
You're right, there is no real research to back it up.
I get home late, too, several nights a week because I workout right after work. I eat when I get home. No impact on weight loss or bloating. If you're feeling bloated after eating later, maybe different foods? If you're ordering food, take outs/aways often have lots of sodium and that could be your bloating culprit. Eating right before bed can cause heartburn as well.1 -
If whatever you eat after 7 consistently takes you out of a calorie deficit, sure it will help. You can also account for whatever you would like to eat late into the night, maintaining a deficit, and you will continue to lose. I eat up until 30 minute before sleep, every single night.0
-
After 7pm doesn't matter. After midnight absolutely does!
24 -
0
-
rose_lemonade wrote: »I've heard some people swear by this rule but I don't know if there's any science to back it up. My boyfriend also wants to lose weight but he doesn't usually get in from work till 9pm or later and then I either cook or we order in. I wake up feeling bloated and I'm sure this is the cause, but in terms of actual weight loss/gain, does eating late make a difference?
If so then it means we'll only be able to eat together on weekends, which kinda sucks
There is no science behind it because it doesn't matter. What you have to realize is that a lot of "rules" like this...don't eat after x o'clock...no carbs at dinner, etc are simply ways of controlling calories. You have to remember that the vast majority of people aren't counting calories and when you're not counting calories you have to employ other methods of controlling calories.
I just finished cutting my winter weight and I'm considering a further cut...when cutting weight, I typically don't eat grains/starches with my evening meal...there's nothing magical about it, it's just an easy way for my to control calories. My wife and I eat dinner around 8:30 most evenings.3 -
I never saw any actual justification for it. IMHO what matters is how you as an individual reacts to it. If you go to bed at 1 am, eating at 6-7 pm sounds like a sure way to midnight snacking, since 5 hours later it's normal to be hungry.
If you feel bloated, perhaps eat a lighter dinner? I'd say it's a matter of trial and error. I do tend to eat early because otherwise I can't sleep early (I'm not wired to sleep before midnight, and eating late postpones my bedtime even more); but that's the way I am, and it's bound to be different for other people.2 -
I eat at 11pm right before bed and snack on Bread and peanut butter around 3am,
Don't think I could cope without my early morning snack2 -
Not eating past 7 PM would be counterproductive for me because I would wake up hungry in the middle of the night and not be able to get back to sleep until I ate. This would mess up the next day.2
-
Debbie_Ferr wrote: »It takes up to 3 DAYS to digest food. So it hardly matters if you consume some of them after 7pm.
It's all about calories in, calories out.
So once you meet your calorie intake goal, STOP EATING.
Mindful eating, peeps.
I think where people get into trouble, is the graze in the evening, and go over their DAILY calorie targets.
"Digestion can take anywhere from 24 to 72 hours, during which time the food you've eaten travels down your esophagus to your stomach, then to your small intestine, your large intestine, and out through the *kitten*."
The bolded is in my opinion is why so many people believe that eating late causes weight gain/stops weight lose. The problem is when people sit and mindlessly eat at night. I eat most of my calories after 6pm and as long as I log it and stay within my calorie goal it haa no effect on my weight.2 -
If I eat late, I don't sleep well (I just toss & turn all night long) which then makes it difficult for me to stay on track with my diet the next day & not binge.0
-
TheWJordinWJordin wrote: »The rule as I know it is "no eating after dinner". Not a specific time. I've also heard it called the 12 hour daily fast.
Whilst I understand what people are saying about pitfalls of mindless evening snacking - there is no actual rule that says 'No eating after dinner' either.
As long as the total is within your calorie allowance this will not matter.
OP, I nearly always eat dinner after 7pm and I nearly always have an evening snack after that too.
It has not stopped me reaching my goal weight.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Around that time of night is when my mindless munchies set in. I can set a cut off time, but unless my guardian angel whacks me over the knuckles when I'm pawing around in the pantry, then setting some random time that I'm well able to ignore will be of no help to me.
My solution. . I go to bed early (between 7-8pm. I get up at 4:30-5:30am), and watch tv or read in there. As once I'm in bed i just don't think about food.0 -
To keep from feeling bloated, maybe try to change what you are eating by adjusting your macros; less carbs, more protein and "green" / "alive" things like fresh salad greens with simple homemade dressing of lemon juice, chopped garlic, salt, pepper and olive oil.
One of the most nourishing / alkalizing foods I know of is parsley. People use it as a garnish - blend it in the blender and eat it. Takes the bloat away.
Bloating can also be from yeast. Spit into a glass of distilled water, cover with plastic warp and look at it the next day, if there are "threads" you have yeast over growth. Yeast can be curtailed by cutting out sugar / carbs and taking the correct "live" probiotics - you need more than what is in yogurt.
Nonsense.
OP, looks like you have a good plan. Eat a bit lighter through the day, and enjoy your meals together. You could eat a bit lighter during your shared meals to see if that helps with the bloated feeling.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions