We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Beware!

aprilvet
aprilvet Posts: 724 Member
edited September 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
Just wore my new hrm (Polar FT40) for 1st workout. It said I burned 200 cals less than the treadmill calculated!:noway: Although I know the machines tend to over-estimate calories, I had no idea it was this off! So those of you w/o hrm, be careful using the machine cals!

Replies

  • aprilvet
    aprilvet Posts: 724 Member
    Just wore my new hrm (Polar FT40) for 1st workout. It said I burned 200 cals less than the treadmill calculated!:noway: Although I know the machines tend to over-estimate calories, I had no idea it was this off! So those of you w/o hrm, be careful using the machine cals!
  • Julie837
    Julie837 Posts: 84
    Thanks, I've been thinking of getting one, so maybe I'll check it out.
  • TheGuardian
    TheGuardian Posts: 53 Member
    Yup! I got a Polar F6 last week and my elliptical has been overestimating my calories burned by 50%

    Considering I was typically doing close to 800 according to the machine, that's a significant amount 6 days a week!
  • get_fit2009
    get_fit2009 Posts: 827 Member
    I LOVE mine! My hubby and kids got me an F6 for Christmas. I am not only more accurate, I am also more motivated to burn more calories! :happy:
  • pixiestick
    pixiestick Posts: 839 Member
    Yup! I got a Polar F6 last week and my elliptical has been overestimating my calories burned by 50%

    Considering I was typically doing close to 800 according to the machine, that's a significant amount 6 days a week!

    F6 is like a godsend, from heaven to mortal men (and women:laugh: ) I had a problem the other way: my treadmill was underestimating my cals by 100-150 every day, and I already never consumed all of my exorcise cals, so it explains why I was losing SO slowly.

    Starving... Bad. Polar F6... Good.
  • shar140
    shar140 Posts: 1,158 Member
    I had the same situation as pixiestick - I found I was burning MORE than I thought! I :heart: my Polar F6!!!
  • mrsmojo82
    mrsmojo82 Posts: 54 Member
    Thanks for the advice. How accurate is the calorie burn on this website?
  • Winter23
    Winter23 Posts: 142
    How much do those cost and where do I get one.
  • meanness67
    meanness67 Posts: 366 Member
    I just got one from amazon today; can't wait to try it out! :wink:
  • amyalwaysonline6
    amyalwaysonline6 Posts: 101
    Mine is coming tomorrow, I'm stoked!
  • trritchie
    trritchie Posts: 25
    This is freaking me out. Does this website calorie counter go along with what you hrm said? I use the heart rate monitor on the machines, n try to keep in the cardio zone, and always in the fat buring zone.
    i would hate to think im not buring as many calories as i think.
  • get_fit2009
    get_fit2009 Posts: 827 Member
    Thanks for the advice. How accurate is the calorie burn on this website?

    My estimations using this website were pretty darn close to what I have been registering with my HRM. The machines at the gym...not as close.
  • LauraLane42
    LauraLane42 Posts: 6 Member
    Thank you for sharing. I had never even heard of this product before. I will look into ordering one right away. I was leary of what my treadmil was saying also. Especially when I realized that the weight was not set . It thought that I was heavier than I am ,and was reading much higher calories burned than I actually was . Thanks for the insight.

    135308.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Online Calorie Counter
  • aprilvet
    aprilvet Posts: 724 Member
    HRM can be fairly inexpensive or up to around $160. Beware, the less expensive ones don't calculate your calories. I splurged (my bday next week:drinker: ) and bought the new Polar FT40 for $156 from Amazon. Came in 2 days w/ free shipping! As for the accuracy of the exercise cals on the site, I'm trying to figure that out myself! :grumble: Will rely on the hrm, mainly!
  • SHBoss1673
    SHBoss1673 Posts: 7,161 Member
    Any website (or gym equipment) is only going to give you a rough estimate based on averages. Thats why Heart Rate Monitors that have a chest or arm strap are so good.

    go to polarusa website to see their whole line (no I don't work for them, but if they wanted to send me a free RS400sd I wouldn't turn it down:tongue: )

    Polar makes a great HRM for any type of athlete. The F6 and above are all waterproof, all have great features including upload to a computer and file storage.

    There are pleanty of other brands that are good too, I wear a polar so that's the only brand I know in detail.

    Once you know what you want you can usually shave a few bucks off retail by getting them at amazon or ebay.
  • AmyNVegas
    AmyNVegas Posts: 2,215 Member
    This is freaking me out. Does this website calorie counter go along with what you hrm said? I use the heart rate monitor on the machines, n try to keep in the cardio zone, and always in the fat buring zone.
    i would hate to think im not buring as many calories as i think.

    It was off by over 350 calories for me for a 30 min stationary bike ride. It said over 600 for me and the HRM said 250.

    Amy:bigsmile:
    118984.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Food Diary

    My favorite post for answers:
    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/23912-links-in-mfp-you-want-to-read-again-and-again
  • janiebeth
    janiebeth Posts: 2,509 Member
    thanks for the post - just ordered one from overstock.com
  • janiebeth
    janiebeth Posts: 2,509 Member
    thanks for the post - just ordered one from overstock.com

    Quoting myself - :wink: :wink:

    Correction - ordered from Amazon - about $20 cheaper...
  • pixiestick
    pixiestick Posts: 839 Member
    This is freaking me out. Does this website calorie counter go along with what you hrm said? I use the heart rate monitor on the machines, n try to keep in the cardio zone, and always in the fat buring zone.
    i would hate to think im not buring as many calories as i think.

    I found that the MFP was actually fairly accurate for me... always within 100cals. But the machine was off. I got my Polar F6 for $95 directly from a retailer because I am impatient and I didn't want to wait. Anyone in the UK, they sell the F6 at most of the ARGOS EXTRA.
    :flowerforyou:
  • pettmybunny
    pettmybunny Posts: 1,986 Member
    I found that when wearing my HRM, the machines and sites were calculating low.
  • ohthatbambi
    ohthatbambi Posts: 1,098 Member
    This is freaking me out. Does this website calorie counter go along with what you hrm said? I use the heart rate monitor on the machines, n try to keep in the cardio zone, and always in the fat buring zone.
    i would hate to think im not buring as many calories as i think.

    Save up, get a hrm. It is the most accurate way to know what you are burning...everything else, this site and the machines at gym are only an estimate.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories