Menopause tips...
Replies
-
I see a lot of people above saying menopause doesn't affect weight loss or metabolism. Well that is false. It seems to differ depending upon the person. It is a HUGE factor for some women.
In my case I exercising MUCH more than I did in my 30's and eating 200 or more calories LOWER than I did successfully dieting in my 30's and losing about 1/3 a pound a week compared to the 1.5 pounds I could pretty reliably lose on my 30's. (yes I'm keeping tight logging, no don't tell me I'm doing it wrong, I am losing, just very slowly, yes my thyroid levels are normal). What has changed? Mostly I got old and went through menopause.
So, first thing is I just tune out the self-styled authorities who say menopause doesn't make a difference - they don't have a clue, the most they can say truthfully is it may not have made a difference to them. Paying attention to those "authorities" was very destructive to my mind set as all they want to do is tell you it's your fault somehow - you are doing it wrong...
Second- while I find weight loss to be VERY slow, it is steadily coming off for me at around 1100 to 1400 calories per day (1400 on higher exercise days) - and I started moderately low carb but found that wasn't working well for me. That's the thing, it may be slow- and what works for one person doesn't seem to work for the next so try different things.
Third, I found it way too exhausting and frankly awful to continue dieting at the extremely low intake level I need to lose any weight. So I'm changing things up by eating for the next month or two at maintenance level. I'm still keeping up with my exercise so I expect to end the month at the same weight or maybe a small fraction of a pound lighter. This has improved my mental game considerably!
I get very disappointed and discouraged at the extremely slow weight loss - at this rate it will take longer than a full year to go from my 29.9 BMI to a BMI in the normal range. So, what I try to do is keep my eye on the prizes: I'm getting much healthier each day regardless of how slow that scale is moving. And, purportedly, slow weight loss is easier to maintain.
You are awesome to acknowledge the uniqueness in each of us. Yes menopause and other aging contributors are real factors for many women. I have always eaten healthy and exercise...just hoping to lose 20 lbs so I stay as healthy as possibe and hopefully avoid problems associated with being a bit too heavy. TY2 -
DebLaBounty wrote: »I'm 57. I also did the C25K (Couch to 5K) running program this Spring. You just download the app to your phone and follow the voice prompts. You start walking 5 minutes, jogging a minute, walking a few minutes, jogging a minute, etc. You gradually work up to running 10 minutes without stopping, then 20, then 25. I found the challenge of it very motivating. If you're walking a lot, this is a good way to increase your cardio exercise and earn yourself a few more calories to eat.
Is the C25k a MFP program? It sounds like just what I need.0 -
SummerSkier wrote: »Tammi CT5K is a program to get you moving aerobically for 30 min a day. It's an 8 week program but you can take it at your own pace. "Couch to 5K". I am 5'2" also. Doing the additional jogging has really kept me on track. Good luck looks like you are getting a lot of tips. There is another thread you might want to read in the maintenance section call 5'1" gals - what are you maintenance calories.
TY so much. The program is just what I need. I haven't looked at my maintenance calories.0 -
tammienichols316 wrote: »I see a lot of people above saying menopause doesn't affect weight loss or metabolism. Well that is false. It seems to differ depending upon the person. It is a HUGE factor for some women.
In my case I exercising MUCH more than I did in my 30's and eating 200 or more calories LOWER than I did successfully dieting in my 30's and losing about 1/3 a pound a week compared to the 1.5 pounds I could pretty reliably lose on my 30's. (yes I'm keeping tight logging, no don't tell me I'm doing it wrong, I am losing, just very slowly, yes my thyroid levels are normal). What has changed? Mostly I got old and went through menopause.
So, first thing is I just tune out the self-styled authorities who say menopause doesn't make a difference - they don't have a clue, the most they can say truthfully is it may not have made a difference to them. Paying attention to those "authorities" was very destructive to my mind set as all they want to do is tell you it's your fault somehow - you are doing it wrong...
Second- while I find weight loss to be VERY slow, it is steadily coming off for me at around 1100 to 1400 calories per day (1400 on higher exercise days) - and I started moderately low carb but found that wasn't working well for me. That's the thing, it may be slow- and what works for one person doesn't seem to work for the next so try different things.
Third, I found it way too exhausting and frankly awful to continue dieting at the extremely low intake level I need to lose any weight. So I'm changing things up by eating for the next month or two at maintenance level. I'm still keeping up with my exercise so I expect to end the month at the same weight or maybe a small fraction of a pound lighter. This has improved my mental game considerably!
I get very disappointed and discouraged at the extremely slow weight loss - at this rate it will take longer than a full year to go from my 29.9 BMI to a BMI in the normal range. So, what I try to do is keep my eye on the prizes: I'm getting much healthier each day regardless of how slow that scale is moving. And, purportedly, slow weight loss is easier to maintain.
You are awesome to acknowledge the uniqueness in each of us. Yes menopause and other aging contributors are real factors for many women. I have always eaten healthy and exercise...just hoping to lose 20 lbs so I stay as healthy as possibe and hopefully avoid problems associated with being a bit too heavy. TY
Interesting. You're my height and I'm also in the process of losing 20#. It's taken me 9 months to lose 17 pounds. I eat 1200 calories and I exercise and lift weights 4 days a week before work. I eat half my calories back. It's slow, very slow. I've done this twice before on MFP and reached my goal weight, only to pat myself on the back for making it, and eventually stopping logging. Of course, I regained all the weight I'd lost.
This time I've read the maintenance boards daily, and come to realize that it never really ends. So, even a pound every month or two is a success, and better than gaining! Keep tweaking the calories down. I will confess that I stopped alcohol two months ago as I hadn't lost in 6 weeks even tho I was counting the alcohol. I've lost 5 pounds since then.
1 -
tammienichols316 wrote: »DebLaBounty wrote: »I'm 57. I also did the C25K (Couch to 5K) running program this Spring. You just download the app to your phone and follow the voice prompts. You start walking 5 minutes, jogging a minute, walking a few minutes, jogging a minute, etc. You gradually work up to running 10 minutes without stopping, then 20, then 25. I found the challenge of it very motivating. If you're walking a lot, this is a good way to increase your cardio exercise and earn yourself a few more calories to eat.
Is the C25k a MFP program? It sounds like just what I need.
No, it's just a popular phone app with MANY companies having one.
I have downloaded the free version from ZenLabs. I've done a few others, but I really like this one.
I did it last fall and by the time I got to week 4 or 5, my weight started really dropping off. That (for me) VERY SLOW JOGGING made such a difference. Walking doesn't really cut it for me for a good calorie burn. I'm 53 and don't have too many physical issues (besides being incredibly weak and never an athlete!!!) and I got through it.
Oh, I never did eat back any exercise calories so that probably helped.
I've restarted it and am on Week 2 now so hopefully I'll see some action on my weight loss in a few weeks.2 -
I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!0 -
CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Hope you have a smooth transition, and glad you found an approach that works for you.2 -
The Couch to 5K phone app I use is from ZenLabs, and it's free.1
-
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Absolutely!
By weighing myself every day, I've discovered my patterns so weigh gains don't alarm me. I know exactly what's going on.
3 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Hope you have a smooth transition, and glad you found an approach that works for you.
For me it seems as though that, I lost a lot more; than that! I believe that, with the exception; of laws & science, there're no rules; just opinions! So while I've figured what works for me, it might work for others also; therefore my advice was just an opinion! Thank you!0 -
CaloricCountess wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Hope you have a smooth transition, and glad you found an approach that works for you.
For me it seems as though that, I lost a lot more; than that! I believe that, with the exception; of laws & science, there're no rules; just opinions! So while I've figured what works for me, it might work for others also; therefore my advice was just an opinion! Thank you!
Yup. That's why I congratulated you on the approach to weight loss that works for you!
1 -
I am 43, went through early menopause, starting three years ago, 6 months or so after I completed my first sprint triathlon. I am on herbal remedies now for the hot flushes and other symptoms. No HRT. I recently wrote this on my profile feed:
"10 cals over, higher cal day. Gym today. Whoop! 2204 cals. For those curious (as my diary is closed) I eat between 1650 and 2500 cals per day. I weigh in at 79kg/174lbs at the moment. I take 5g creatine daily on a 4 week on, 2 off cycle. My macros are roughly 35% carbs, 35% fat and 30% protein. Yes, I still lose weight. I have been eating this way since June this year and took a two week diet break whilst on holiday in August. 22lbs down in 3 months. 7lbs per month, 1.75lbs per week. I cycle to and from work and other places (30 miles per week average) and do heavy lifting (powerlifting with barbell mostly) in the gym 3 times per week. On rest days, I also walk for an hour, it helps me wind down and gives me time to think. For the last 3 weeks I have been adding an accessory/assistance lift day because I have weak spots and it is in my programming for 6 weeks. I am still in deficit, but want my strength and lean mass to remain..."
I am planning to start a strongman programme in around a month's time and then start a PHUL (hypertrophy) programme after that. I have always lifted heavy (on and off since I was 16). Everyone's goals are going to be different. Mine is to be stronger, fitter and leaner. I also want to try to build some more lean mass towards the end of this year so I can lift even heavier (whilst not in deficit).
I do not avoid carbs, I eat fruit, bread, pasta, rice, icecream, biscuits and even sweets and chocolate as long as it fits my macros. I also do not avoid fat. Again, see my macros above. I have only just started to trial carb back loading. I eat loads of snacks and three main meals, my biggest meal being lunchtime, usually.
0 -
tammienichols316 wrote: »I see a lot of people above saying menopause doesn't affect weight loss or metabolism. Well that is false. It seems to differ depending upon the person. It is a HUGE factor for some women.
In my case I exercising MUCH more than I did in my 30's and eating 200 or more calories LOWER than I did successfully dieting in my 30's and losing about 1/3 a pound a week compared to the 1.5 pounds I could pretty reliably lose on my 30's. (yes I'm keeping tight logging, no don't tell me I'm doing it wrong, I am losing, just very slowly, yes my thyroid levels are normal). What has changed? Mostly I got old and went through menopause.
So, first thing is I just tune out the self-styled authorities who say menopause doesn't make a difference - they don't have a clue, the most they can say truthfully is it may not have made a difference to them. Paying attention to those "authorities" was very destructive to my mind set as all they want to do is tell you it's your fault somehow - you are doing it wrong...
Second- while I find weight loss to be VERY slow, it is steadily coming off for me at around 1100 to 1400 calories per day (1400 on higher exercise days) - and I started moderately low carb but found that wasn't working well for me. That's the thing, it may be slow- and what works for one person doesn't seem to work for the next so try different things.
Third, I found it way too exhausting and frankly awful to continue dieting at the extremely low intake level I need to lose any weight. So I'm changing things up by eating for the next month or two at maintenance level. I'm still keeping up with my exercise so I expect to end the month at the same weight or maybe a small fraction of a pound lighter. This has improved my mental game considerably!
I get very disappointed and discouraged at the extremely slow weight loss - at this rate it will take longer than a full year to go from my 29.9 BMI to a BMI in the normal range. So, what I try to do is keep my eye on the prizes: I'm getting much healthier each day regardless of how slow that scale is moving. And, purportedly, slow weight loss is easier to maintain.
You are awesome to acknowledge the uniqueness in each of us. Yes menopause and other aging contributors are real factors for many women. I have always eaten healthy and exercise...just hoping to lose 20 lbs so I stay as healthy as possibe and hopefully avoid problems associated with being a bit too heavy. TY
With only 20 pounds to lose you should set your weight loss goal to a half pound per week. You are creating too aggressive a deficit with your 1100 calories per day. This is stressful to the body, which can raise your cortisol level and cause you to retain water, which will mask your fat loss. This is especially true when combined with intense cardio.
https://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/why-big-caloric-deficits-and-lots-of-activity-can-hurt-fat-loss.html/6 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Hope you have a smooth transition, and glad you found an approach that works for you.
One ounce. Those were the days. I lost three pints last month. Thanks, fibroids. Come on, menopause, I'm 50, get on with it!1 -
kshama2001 wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Hope you have a smooth transition, and glad you found an approach that works for you.
One ounce. Those were the days. I lost three pints last month. Thanks, fibroids. Come on, menopause, I'm 50, get on with it!
Oh fibroids SUCK!!! So sorry!!!!0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »CaloricCountess wrote: »I am 37 years old & I began going through premature menopause, during April; of 2016! My problem's that the inconsistency of my menstrual cycle, means that I'm unable to gauge my weight riddance; via a scale and/or tape measure with regularity but I am able to with knowing that adherence to my caloric goal & accurate logging, means that I am getting rid of; the weight! To lessen the frustration, I currently only weigh & measure myself monthly, just to see a # but until I'm postmenopausal, the only weights & measurements, that I know'll be consistently accurate's my caloric intake!
So the inaccuracy of the #'s, doesn't mean; that it's a metabolism issue because blood like everything else, that's tangible; has weight & mass to it, as well & how little or much, of it you're producing; for your menstrual cycle & when your body, expels that blood'll determine; your weight & measurements also! For me this fluctuation, also includes extra water; since I become increasingly thirsty & fecal matter, since I cease expelling that waste; as frequently as well but luckily I don't suffer via constipation, so I just let nature run it's course; with that!
Therefore my advice's this:
{1.} Weigh & measure, yourself monthly (every 4 weeks/28 days, not the 1st; of each month etc. because the lengths of the months themselves, aren't always; the same)!
{2.} While you're able to choose how much weight, you desire to get rid of you're unable to choose; where that weight decreases & thus only your starting weight matters for gauging weight riddance, whereas measurements're only to gauge what size; you currently're!
{3.} Log everything, that has calories; including your cheat meals/days (if you've them) because since you're unable to rely upon the scale, to inform you; if your gains and/or losses, were just the result; of extra sodium/water retention and/or how much, they were!
{4.} If you know that you've been as accurate, as realistically plausible; concerning your caloric intake & exercise, then regardless of what the scale actually reads; via your starting weight minus or add how much weight, that you should be; to your 1st month & then continue, with using your 1st month; for subtracting or adding, to your 2nd month etc.!
We don't actually lose very much blood. We lose very very little, like in teaspoon measurements. Like 1ounce.
https://www.bodyform.co.uk/our-expert/expert-advice-chat-to-gill/how-much-blood-do-you-lose-during-a-menstrual-period/
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Periods-heavy/Pages/Introduction.aspx
We DO tend to retain 3-7 pounds of water just before our periods and hang on it until after. And many of us find we're ravenously hungry for a few days. (We also retain 3-7 pounds just before we ovulate).
I also believe we should weigh as often as we'd like. I weigh daily. That helped me know what was real and what was menstrual (or a sushi dinner, or a long airplane flight)...
Hope you have a smooth transition, and glad you found an approach that works for you.
For me it seems as though that, I lost a lot more; than that! I believe that, with the exception; of laws & science, there're no rules; just opinions! So while I've figured what works for me, it might work for others also; therefore my advice was just an opinion! Thank you!
Yup. That's why I congratulated you on the approach to weight loss that works for you!
Thank you, again! 0 -
The only real side effect that I've had is the hot flashes, which suck lol. My doctor put me on estrogen and about a month later I had a period. I had not had one in several years due to non menapause issues. When I had a period, I was like "oh hell no lol". My doctor tried to talk me into just taking half a pill, but I quit them. I'd rather have hot flashes than a period again.0
-
I think *normal* people only lose an ounce. Gosh that would have been so liberating if that had been me. I spent the years of ages 34-50 with very heavy bleeding and large clots (I know, TMI). Those clots themselves were well over an ounce. Granted, this is considered abnormal bleeding but just about every female friend of mind has these issues.0
-
The only real side effect that I've had is the hot flashes, which suck lol. My doctor put me on estrogen and about a month later I had a period. I had not had one in several years due to non menapause issues. When I had a period, I was like "oh hell no lol". My doctor tried to talk me into just taking half a pill, but I quit them. I'd rather have hot flashes than a period again.
FYI...my dr says you have to have progesterone if you take estrogen, or as you experienced you will have a period and no we don't want that...lol.0 -
fiddletime wrote: »tammienichols316 wrote: »I see a lot of people above saying menopause doesn't affect weight loss or metabolism. Well that is false. It seems to differ depending upon the person. It is a HUGE factor for some women.
In my case I exercising MUCH more than I did in my 30's and eating 200 or more calories LOWER than I did successfully dieting in my 30's and losing about 1/3 a pound a week compared to the 1.5 pounds I could pretty reliably lose on my 30's. (yes I'm keeping tight logging, no don't tell me I'm doing it wrong, I am losing, just very slowly, yes my thyroid levels are normal). What has changed? Mostly I got old and went through menopause.
So, first thing is I just tune out the self-styled authorities who say menopause doesn't make a difference - they don't have a clue, the most they can say truthfully is it may not have made a difference to them. Paying attention to those "authorities" was very destructive to my mind set as all they want to do is tell you it's your fault somehow - you are doing it wrong...
Second- while I find weight loss to be VERY slow, it is steadily coming off for me at around 1100 to 1400 calories per day (1400 on higher exercise days) - and I started moderately low carb but found that wasn't working well for me. That's the thing, it may be slow- and what works for one person doesn't seem to work for the next so try different things.
Third, I found it way too exhausting and frankly awful to continue dieting at the extremely low intake level I need to lose any weight. So I'm changing things up by eating for the next month or two at maintenance level. I'm still keeping up with my exercise so I expect to end the month at the same weight or maybe a small fraction of a pound lighter. This has improved my mental game considerably!
I get very disappointed and discouraged at the extremely slow weight loss - at this rate it will take longer than a full year to go from my 29.9 BMI to a BMI in the normal range. So, what I try to do is keep my eye on the prizes: I'm getting much healthier each day regardless of how slow that scale is moving. And, purportedly, slow weight loss is easier to maintain.
You are awesome to acknowledge the uniqueness in each of us. Yes menopause and other aging contributors are real factors for many women. I have always eaten healthy and exercise...just hoping to lose 20 lbs so I stay as healthy as possibe and hopefully avoid problems associated with being a bit too heavy. TY
Interesting. You're my height and I'm also in the process of losing 20#. It's taken me 9 months to lose 17 pounds. I eat 1200 calories and I exercise and lift weights 4 days a week before work. I eat half my calories back. It's slow, very slow. I've done this twice before on MFP and reached my goal weight, only to pat myself on the back for making it, and eventually stopping logging. Of course, I regained all the weight I'd lost.
This time I've read the maintenance boards daily, and come to realize that it never really ends. So, even a pound every month or two is a success, and better than gaining! Keep tweaking the calories down. I will confess that I stopped alcohol two months ago as I hadn't lost in 6 weeks even tho I was counting the alcohol. I've lost 5 pounds since then.
Good stuff! I weighed this morning and the scale finally moved. All of a sudden I am down...4.4 lbs. The encouragement I needed to keep going! I will also have to learn maintenance and make it a lifestye or I will likewise gain it back. My best to you!5 -
tammienichols316 wrote: »The only real side effect that I've had is the hot flashes, which suck lol. My doctor put me on estrogen and about a month later I had a period. I had not had one in several years due to non menapause issues. When I had a period, I was like "oh hell no lol". My doctor tried to talk me into just taking half a pill, but I quit them. I'd rather have hot flashes than a period again.
FYI...my dr says you have to have progesterone if you take estrogen, or as you experienced you will have a period and no we don't want that...lol.tammienichols316 wrote: »The only real side effect that I've had is the hot flashes, which suck lol. My doctor put me on estrogen and about a month later I had a period. I had not had one in several years due to non menapause issues. When I had a period, I was like "oh hell no lol". My doctor tried to talk me into just taking half a pill, but I quit them. I'd rather have hot flashes than a period again.
FYI...my dr says you have to have progesterone if you take estrogen, or as you experienced you will have a period and no we don't want that...lol.tammienichols316 wrote: »The only real side effect that I've had is the hot flashes, which suck lol. My doctor put me on estrogen and about a month later I had a period. I had not had one in several years due to non menapause issues. When I had a period, I was like "oh hell no lol". My doctor tried to talk me into just taking half a pill, but I quit them. I'd rather have hot flashes than a period again.
FYI...my dr says you have to have progesterone if you take estrogen, or as you experienced you will have a period and no we don't want that...lol.
That's really interesting. It's my pregesterone levels that are already super Highbthough so they would probably never prescribe anything for that. I have a benign tumor on my pituitary gland which causes very high pregestorone levels, thus no periods. That's why it was such a surprise to have them on the estrogen.tammienichols316 wrote: »The only real side effect that I've had is the hot flashes, which suck lol. My doctor put me on estrogen and about a month later I had a period. I had not had one in several years due to non menapause issues. When I had a period, I was like "oh hell no lol". My doctor tried to talk me into just taking half a pill, but I quit them. I'd rather have hot flashes than a period again.
FYI...my dr says you have to have progesterone if you take estrogen, or as you experienced you will have a period and no we don't want that...lol.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions