Having a super difficult time right now and need advice.
Altagracia220
Posts: 876 Member
So I've gained back most of the weight I've lost. 40lbs to be exact. I feel like one day I have tons of willpower and confidence in myself, other days I go out and order multiple drinks appetizers and entrees. It's a rollercoaster for me and I'm sick of it. I can barely fit into my clothing and when I do I hate how I look.
For those who have failed countless times and have issues with overeating and bingeing, what is one solid piece of advice that has helped you get back up and stay up ?
For those who have failed countless times and have issues with overeating and bingeing, what is one solid piece of advice that has helped you get back up and stay up ?
4
Replies
-
I was on here a few years ago. Lost around 35 pounds and felt great. It was awesome. Then one thing led to another, and I left MFP, and then things happened in my life that made me not give a crap about my health anymore, and I've regained all of those pounds. It sucks, and it's discouraging.
But I don't look at it as a failure. I succeeded in losing those 35 pounds. I did it. I didn't fail at that. I just got off the rails. I'm a real human person who is inconsistent and can be lazy and who really, really likes cake. So I gave in to that nature for a while, and that's unfortunate, but it still doesn't make me a failure.
Our weight is not a statement of who we are as a person. You have excess pounds that you don't want on you, but that doesn't mean you're a bad person or a failure or anything like that. It just means that you have excess pounds, end of story. And you have removed those pounds before, and you can do it again.14 -
This content has been removed.
-
I don't think there is one piece of advice which will magically stop you from bingeing. Perhaps you could try counselling to help you see why you do it? For myself, my main motivation not to binge is that I'm determined NEVER to end the day with my calories in the red. I spoke with a surgeon once who performs gastric bypass surgery, he told me that most people who are chronic overeaters have suffered trauma at a young age, a large proportion of them were sexually abused as a child. Overeating is not about being hungry, it is a coping mechanism; find out what it is you are coping with and sort that out first. Good luck.13
-
Three things helped me to keep the weight off this time.
My doctor said my cholesterol was so high I was at risk of a heart attack or stroke. He also talked about putting me on high blood pressure meds. That conversation woke me up fast.
I'm aware of the "I don't care" attitude that led to weight creep in the past -- when you lose the weight and have a healthier lifestyle and gradually go back to bad habits like eating trigger foods and mindless eating. That don't care attitude often happens when I get really busy (I went back to college). Each time seems like a one time thing, but they add up.
I really like fitting in my clothes.4 -
What is currently working for me is changing one part of my lifestyle at a time. Make whatever it is you are doing a habit. Right now, I'm trying to just focus on my eating. I've been slowly incorporating more exercise, but drastic changes always push me away. I also think it's important not to deprive yourself. I still order pizza, but I'm more conscious of what I put on it, and how much of it I eat. Finally, if you have a bad day today, write it off as a bad day and get up tomorrow and go at it again (some super motivational MFP folks have helped me with that one).5
-
@jazmin220 Willpower is known to be a diminishing resource. That is, the more you use it, the less useful it becomes. Another way of saying that is, "If you use it, you will lose it." What you have described is exactly that. Willpower works briefly, then fails. Try to figure out ways of enjoying your life in a calorie deficit. Do you enjoy cooking? You should. Do you enjoy the foods you eat? You should. You should look forward with anticipation to the delicious food you lovingly prepare for yourself, confident in the knowledge that the food and the portions you are preparing for yourself are going to be delicious and beneficial to you. What I see you doing is going out with one or more friends to places you don't choose and ordering drinks and foods that you don't want and eating them knowing that they are harmful to you. All of those steps are done in response to social pressure. Take charge of your life and make decisions for you. When you care to enjoy and benefit from your calorie deficit, you will not be using willpower. You will be powerful.10
-
Youve done it before so know you can do it, you have to be in the right mindset as we all know its not an easy ride. Small goals and steps, don't let one bad meal/day derail you and be an excuse to throw in the towel.
Logging bad days helps motivate me to do better the next day.4 -
Advice - this has got to become a lifestyle / habits change. It's not a short term diet, you have to develop habits you can sustain for life.4
-
The approach I'm taking is that I'm trying to make incremental adjustments to my lifestyle that I feel are sustainable. I don't want what I eat to feel like I'm going without. Im trying to exercise in a way that feels like a chore. I have gone through the same thing as you so let's lose the weight once and for all and never go back eh.1
-
Set a date in stone. That is the date you will start over. No excuses. Make a workout schedule and meet it, no matter what. Developing a routine is important to staying on track. Have a cheat day, but cheat on moderation. Know you limits and don't let others sway you. Stagger your down time. I find that I cannot take more than 1-2 days off or I have a hard time starting again. Hope this helps.5
-
The advice for myself would be finding a sustainable way to do this for rest of my life instead of telling myself this is just to get to my goal. Don't feel bad for drinking n eating junk unless you plan to divorce them for rest of your life. The more you restrict yourself, greater the rebound will be.3
-
That solid piece of advice is many small, seemingly unimportant, pieces, of common sense, solid habits and self-awareness, among other things.
- I stopped relying on willpower and started to be kind to myself. Being kind means that I will sometimes say no, and other times say yes.
- I created a better food environment for myself. I plan meals, shop for the foods and ingredients I need, and don't buy anything else.
- I aim for variety and only eat food I like.
- I eat regular, balanced meals and aim to not eat between meals.
- I don't demonize any foods, food groups or nutrients.
- I enjoy everything I eat and allow myself that pleasure.
- I move just as much and as often as I like, which isn't a lot, but enough for good health and fitness.
- I differenciate between normal days and special occasions.
- My goal is health and normal weight, not to get as thin and/or athletic as possible.
9 -
As they say in my yoga class, "not to judge but to learn."1
-
As they say in my yoga class, "not to judge but to learn."
First, the past does not control the future. In fact, the past no longer exists. All that's left are our ideas about what it was.
Agree with the above discussion of willpower. Start a food journal, track everything, good, bad and ugly. Never quit tracking. There's a learning curve, it gets easier. But track everything every day. Anyone can track the good days. You're tracking everything.
Tracking is easier with a menu or plan.
If you plan and track you will soon be working mostly by habit. When motivated you can work harder. But motivation is fleeting. Turn to willpower only when absolutely necessary. Try to plan your way away from using it. Willpower is a limited resource. When all else fails, turn to determination. There is no one answer.
Weight loss is a skill set. It is problem solving over and over again. It is very complex, because our lives are complex. As noted above find a calorie deficit you can live with. You need enough enjoyment to get you past the parts you merely tolerate. Good luck.
2 -
Im at this point, add me if you want daily messages helps me feel accountable for my food intake!0
-
I think just about the only thing that seems to work for me is portioning. I'm a recovering binge eater and I still struggle sometimes, but mostly when there's a bufet style food. I will eat whatever is in front of me so portioning is a big deal and I make sure that if I make more food than I should eat I put it out of sight.
One more thing that helped, I tried keto for 2 weeks. I have to admit that my appetite has significantly decreased after that but maybe that's just me.2 -
Every single time you make a better choice is a step in the right direction.
Every.
Single.
Time.
It adds up.
Whether that decision is to take the stairs rather than the lift, putting a handful of the pasta you were going to cook back into the packet, choosing the tomato based sauce with your fish at a restaurant rather than the cream-based or deciding to put on your gym clothes on Saturday morning when you were thinking of staying in bed. ESPECIALLY when it comes to overeating - every time you decide to minimise the impact vs. what your were originally GOING to do - you've won. Rather than a whole bar of chocolate, I will eat half. Instead of buying a Starbucks Pumpkin Latte, I'll have a skinny latte. I'll have a glass of water rather than a cookie and only if I still want one in an hour will I eat one.
Small improvements and every single one is a win.
It ALL goes into the pot. It ALL counts.
In the past I have been guilty of the all or nothing approach to losing weight. It means that I am actually pretty good at losing weight, but then, when I switch things off, it creeps back on and I feel all the feelings you have described.
But I think I have finally learned to appreciate the small wins which means that I can maintain my weight long term. And you know what...small wins are easier to achieve and more frequent which means that not only do you get to feel proud more often but with such regular decisionmaking, it becomes habit to make the right choice rather than needing willpower.
You can do this! Good luck!2 -
So I've gained back most of the weight I've lost. 40lbs to be exact. I feel like one day I have tons of willpower and confidence in myself, other days I go out and order multiple drinks appetizers and entrees. It's a rollercoaster for me and I'm sick of it. I can barely fit into my clothing and when I do I hate how I look.
For those who have failed countless times and have issues with overeating and bingeing, what is one solid piece of advice that has helped you get back up and stay up ?
Best thing I ever did was to reevaluate my goals and my approach to getting there. I was way too strict, way too all or nothing to ever be successful. Backing off, allowing some leeway, allowing some treats, increasing my calories and taking it a bit more slowly, and giving myself permission to be human and not perfect. These were the best things I've done.0 -
other days I go out and order multiple drinks appetizers and entrees.
Well - you're not going to be able to do that anymore, if you want to stay in a deficit, lose weight, and then keep the weight off. Or at least you aren't going to be able to do it in the same way, with the same frequency.
There is not ever going to be a time in your life when you will be able to eat the way that made you gain weight in the past, and not gain weight. It's not a diet, it's a permanent condition of reality.
So what do you want to do? Going out and having drinks, appetizers, and entrees all the time sounds fun. Hating yourself and the way you look sounds terrible. Is it terrible enough to make it worth changing your old way of life?
Reality is math. Add up the calories from your nights out and figure out what you want to do about them. Do you want to go out and have a big blow out once a month, averaging that with your deficit the rest of the time? Do you want to have less indulgent nights out more frequently? Could you have higher quality nights out, less often - maybe instead of a steakhouse with okay food go to a gourmet restaurant with delicious food half as often? Do you want to substitute fun activities which don't involve food? Maybe you would like to go out dancing, or to the theater, instead of to a restaurant?
Try to figure out the math. You need to have a certain amount of fun in your life and you need to have a certain number of calories in your life. Once you have your math, plan ahead how to stick to it. No one has any willpower after two drinks. It's also very hard to go to a familiar place and not do the same thing you always do there. But you can change the places you go. I changed the way I drive home so I wouldn't be tempted to stop at the corner for junk food. What you don't do is do the same thing you have always done in the past and then act all surprised when your "willpower failed."2 -
It isn't all about will power it does help a little. I live a very busy life and I don't get to plan my meals ahead of time and my family doesn't like what I like. I have gone up and down on my weight for the past 11 years. I'm at my biggest right now and I'm okay with it. You need to love you the way you are so that you can make your self into a better healthier person. I love food and I love to cook and bake. I still do all of that but now I do my best to not over indulge. It's very hard not to do it but it can be done. If want to live a long life either for yourself or your family you need to watch what and how much you eat. Good luck and God bless3
-
New t the Keto Diet here but I don't look a it as a diet, it is more a redirection in eating. I can eat many tasted items but iPo low calorie now I'm looking at low carb...it's just different..so I'm hopeful I can stay on it...plus for me, my knees at 51 years old hurt and the added weight is not helping. So, I want to be lighter, in better shape and feeling better. As they say, when the student is ready, the teacher will come....you need to change your mindset for lasting success and you need to focus on it daily, map makes thst happen. Good luck all.1
-
1. You are not fat, you HAVE fat. You also have fingernails but you are not fingernails.
2. Don't take it out on your body.
3. Food is the most abused anxiety drug. Exercise is the most underutilized antidepressant.
4. Do it for the holy *kitten*, you got hot.
5. Imagine the weight you are losing is going to the person you hate.
6. One pound at a time.
7. I already know what giving up feels like; I want to see what happens if I don't.
8. Losing weight is hard; maintaining weight is hard; staying overweight is hard; CHOOSE YOUR HARD.
9. It took more than a day to put it on; it will take more than a day to take it off. MOVE.
10. The worst promise you can break is the one thing make to yourself.
Credit goes to Pinterest...these are my favorites!3
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions