Calories/Sodium Intake-Help

aocheltree75
aocheltree75 Posts: 2 Member
edited November 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
Would appreciate some positive advise on my issue. I'm 6'4, 319lbs ex-collegiate football player who has been trying to slim down to at least my old high school weight of 260lbs (I know that will take awhile but I have started this weight loss journey at 325lbs so im getting there). The thing is my recommended calorie intake to help reach my goal per my fitness pal is 2346 calories. The past 2 weeks i've been doing average about 16 to 1800 calories. But some how some way i keep going over the sodium intake or really close to it (less than 2300mg is recommended). Can someone please give me food ideas for increasing my calories a little while reducing sodium? I know my main problem is probably eating lean cuisine lunches which have a lot of sodium. But it seems like anything anymore has a ton of sodium and i've been told that too much sodium causes water weight to increase.

Thank you in advance!!

Replies

  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    I have no medical reason to limit sodium so I don't pay any attention to it.

    That said, I think you've hit the nail on the head -- many pre-made foods like frozen meals or canned soups do tend to have more sodium than the equivalent we'd make at home. If you don't want to prepare more of your own meals, you can find lower sodium versions of many of these foods.
  • psuLemon
    psuLemon Posts: 38,442 MFP Moderator
    If you don't have hypertension or high blood pressure, it probably doesn't matter. But if you are afraid of sodium, increase whole foods (limit packaged foods) and increase potassium/magnesium, as it will balance out sodium.
  • estherdragonbat
    estherdragonbat Posts: 5,283 Member
    Water weight fades pretty quickly. If you're not medically required to restrict sodium, it's not a major concern. And if it helps...

    hp3iozcqon61.png
    znkpaakzbsja.png

    Just my n=1

  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    In regards to sodium, eat less processed foods and eat out less and eat more whole foods and cook from scratch. Highly processed foods like lean cuisine, etc are going to be sodium bombs...

  • Maxxitt
    Maxxitt Posts: 1,281 Member
    Water weight, in and of itself, is not a problem - just a # that has nothing to do with excess fat. If you need to cut down on sodium for medical reasons, or just want to "just because," then the way to do it is to prepare your own food from scratch. Get into the habit of looking at food labels and given an option, choose a lower sodium item. All prepared meals - most soups (unless they explicitly say low sodium - and imho are then tasteless), frozen complete meals, and lots of pasta sauces will be prepared with more sodium than you'd use making it yourself.

    Vegetables and fruits are naturally low in sodium. Nut roasted without salt are low in sodium. Some meats and poultry can be injected with a solution that is high in sodium so you need to check the labels there. Yogurt is another good low-sodium option.
  • RoxieDawn
    RoxieDawn Posts: 15,486 Member
    edited September 2017
    Unless you have a medical reason going over sodium is okay. Sodium does and will cause water weight gain, but this is temporary weight gain. Higher carb foods also cause water weight gain as well.

    Is it a convenience for you to eat frozen prepackage food? I would stay away from pre-packaged/frozen/processed foods as much as possible. Depending on what you like to eat, there are many ways to counteract higher sodium as there are a lot of lower sodium options on the market.
  • Smaya29
    Smaya29 Posts: 106 Member
    edited September 2017
    I am not an expert on this and my calorie goal is less than yours but i never hit my recommended sodium intake.
    I guess i can advise you to eat more fresh veggies and some fruit. Avoid canned or frozen/processed meals. Chicken/ turkey beasts without skin, and shellfish are not high in sodium.
    If you want to eat canned beans just buy the ones that have 'no added salt' or 'low sodium' label on them.
    1% milk, less than 3% Greek yogurt or any low fat yogurt doesn't have much sodium. I add a mixture of chia and flax seeds to make up for the absence of fat in it.
    Instead of using salt to taste in your food, you can slowly start to substitute it with lemon/lime juice.
    Read the labels.
    Especially watch out for high sodium in these foods:

    Breads, rolls, bagels, flour tortillas, and wraps
    Cold cuts and cured meats
    Pizza
    Poultry (much poultry and other meats are injected with sodium. Check the Nutrition Facts for sodium content or read package for a description of a solution, for example, “Fresh chicken in a 15% solution.”)
    Canned Soup
    Ready to eat sandwiches

    Good luck :)
  • aocheltree75
    aocheltree75 Posts: 2 Member
    I don't have a general medical reason for staying away from sodium but I was always told too much as not good. The convenience of the frozen pre-packaged foods are what get me because I can be a little bit lazy and not meal prep for the week, which I know I need to fix. So going under my recommended calorie intake---is that okay?
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    I don't have a general medical reason for staying away from sodium but I was always told too much as not good. The convenience of the frozen pre-packaged foods are what get me because I can be a little bit lazy and not meal prep for the week, which I know I need to fix. So going under my recommended calorie intake---is that okay?

    Being a bit under or being under occasionally is no big deal. But if you're consistently under and creating a deficit that is too large, it can potentially compromise your health and energy.

  • BusyRaeNOTBusty
    BusyRaeNOTBusty Posts: 7,166 Member
    I don't have a general medical reason for staying away from sodium but I was always told too much as not good. The convenience of the frozen pre-packaged foods are what get me because I can be a little bit lazy and not meal prep for the week, which I know I need to fix. So going under my recommended calorie intake---is that okay?

    You might lose too quickly, you might also lose more muscle than is desirable (and I assume as a former football player that you have a lot of muscle and don't want to lose that).

    Some ideas for increasing calories without too much effort:
    protein shakes with whole milk,
    oatmeal with nuts for breakfast,
    salads with cheese and full fat dressing,
    hole fat greek yogurt,
    scrambled eggs, etc.
  • RoxieDawn
    RoxieDawn Posts: 15,486 Member
    edited September 2017
    I don't have a general medical reason for staying away from sodium but I was always told too much as not good. The convenience of the frozen pre-packaged foods are what get me because I can be a little bit lazy and not meal prep for the week, which I know I need to fix. So going under my recommended calorie intake---is that okay?

    The difference between 2346 calories and 1600-1800 a day (you in mentioned in your OP) is 546-750 calories. This increases your calorie deficit per day quite a bit, If you only go under occasionally this is fine, but sustaining this large of deficit for longer periods of time could be quite unhealthy.

    I would look into moderating the processed foods at much as possible, looking into lower sodium options, meal prepping as much as you can, and eat calorie dense foods if you need to to reach your calorie goal.
  • Moxie42
    Moxie42 Posts: 1,400 Member
    Everyone has already mentioned you don't necessarily need to worry about sodium, and that packaged foods tend to be sodium bombs, etc. I just wanted to add that I actually try to hit 2,000mg sodium/day, even if it means adding a little extra salt to my food (which I've had to do recently because I've been home-cooking everything, all fresh stuff, and I don't usually use a ton of salt). If my sodium is too low for too long, I get charley horses, even if my magnesium and potassium levels are okay. If I'm way over on sodium, I just drink a lot of extra water to prevent bloating. Works for me! :)
This discussion has been closed.