We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Calories, Fitbit, and exercise

cc3833
cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
edited November 2024 in Health and Weight Loss
Okay so I'm sure everyone is sick of these questions but I just need a little assistance. I've been on here actually logging since about July. I've played around with some things and I just want to know what I am doing right and what I'm doing wrong.

So my current situation:

5'0, 28 yrs old, 180 lbs
MFP set to sedentary, syncing with my fitbit (I do have negative adjustments enabled)
Calories from MFP is 1360 for 1 lb a week weight loss
Eating back at least 50% of exercise calories
I try and use my food scale as much as possible but I do eat out here and there and have to guess what I am eating
I use Libra to trend my weight

I have been progressively gaining weight (prior to September) so I decided to get the Libra app and well last month I didn't lose and I didn't gain. A win for me since I have been gaining about a pound a month. This month I would like to see a loss. I have a desk job and I try to get up as much as I can and just walk around the office. As far as my activity level goes I get between 10.5k-15k steps a day, I ride my horse 5-6 days a week, and I try and get to the gym 2-3 times a week, not exactly sedentary but I sync my fitbit and only use the steps I don't add in any of the other exercise I do (I don't log the gym or horseback riding). But when I sync my fitbit my calories go from 1360 up to about 2000 or more. I have been lifting weights with my friend at the gym for about a month now and I can tell I am getting stronger, and since I have been using my food scale and trying to be as diligent as I can with my logging my stomach and body feel significantly less bloated (I'm guessing my salt intake is much less than before and I have been a lot better about drinking more water).

Any advice on what I should do? Should I just stop syncing my fitbit so I don't think I have as many calories to eat as it says? Should I just use the fitbit to count my steps to make sure I'm moving as much as I should but then manually log my workouts in MFP so that the number isn't so inflated? I'm glad I stopped the trend of gaining but I am trying to figure out how to fix the calorie situation.

If there is any other information that I could provide to give more insight just let me know. Thank you!

Replies

  • Unknown
    Unknown
    This content has been removed.
  • malibu927
    malibu927 Posts: 17,562 Member
    Just keep at it. Introducing weights has most likely caused you to retain more water weight. You should begin seeing a drop again soon.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    You're basically starting with estimates and your real-life results are going to be your best guide to what you need to do. Since you know -- from your results -- that you're eating more than you need to lose weight, that's what I would address.

    It sounds like you're eating back around 600 calories a day from your activity adjustments. I would cut that in half and only eat half of the calories I was getting from my Fitbit, evaluate your results, and go from there.

    (This is based on the assumption that your logging is good. I can't see your diary, but if you open it up we may be able to help troubleshoot there too).
  • cc3833
    cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
    As scary as that is for me, I set my dairy to public. (Note: I am only eating Nutrisystem at the moment because my sister was on it decided to go for WLS and gave me the leftovers... I live on my own so it saves me on grocery money! But once it's gone I'm going back to cooking... which I love and makes measuring even that much easier) As far as the foods I scan the package and then put the amount on my food scale. I'm thinking I am just eating too many of my exercise calories back.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    cc3833 wrote: »
    As scary as that is for me, I set my dairy to public. (Note: I am only eating Nutrisystem at the moment because my sister was on it decided to go for WLS and gave me the leftovers... I live on my own so it saves me on grocery money! But once it's gone I'm going back to cooking... which I love and makes measuring even that much easier) As far as the foods I scan the package and then put the amount on my food scale. I'm thinking I am just eating too many of my exercise calories back.

    I took a look at your diary. Since you are double-checking the weight of your packaged foods, I do think it is your exercise calories. There is also the possibility that you're underestimating when you're eating out, but that's something that you already acknowledged above. I would say keep up with the logging and eat about half of your exercise calories.
  • cc3833
    cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
    Okay, thanks for taking the time! I guess what I'll do it is try to eat only 25% of the exercise calories back instead of 50%. I'll try that this month and see where to go from there. I mean I am happy to stop gaining! Which was an eye opener. But I'll try this out. Thanks again!
  • MegaMooseEsq
    MegaMooseEsq Posts: 3,118 Member
    I was using a fitbit for the last couple of years, and my experience was that it overestimated calories burned. I ended up unsynching it and manually adding in intentional exercise where I could be pretty confident of the actual calorie burn, like walking and running (generally 0.3 or 0.6 times your body-weight in lbs). But as others have said, you're starting out with a really firm foundation - I think a lot of people jump into a deficit without a real sense of their maintenance calories, then get thrown off because they don't actually have a good sense of the size of their deficit or how accurate their logging is. I spent about three months around maintenance when I first started cutting calories, and although it was frustrating not to be losing right away, it actually put me in a really good place understanding my body and portion sizes. And as you said, not gaining is still a win!
  • cc3833
    cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
    MegaMooseEsq wrote: »
    I was using a fitbit for the last couple of years, and my experience was that it overestimated calories burned. I ended up unsynching it and manually adding in intentional exercise where I could be pretty confident of the actual calorie burn, like walking and running (generally 0.3 or 0.6 times your body-weight in lbs). But as others have said, you're starting out with a really firm foundation - I think a lot of people jump into a deficit without a real sense of their maintenance calories, then get thrown off because they don't actually have a good sense of the size of their deficit or how accurate their logging is. I spent about three months around maintenance when I first started cutting calories, and although it was frustrating not to be losing right away, it actually put me in a really good place understanding my body and portion sizes. And as you said, not gaining is still a win!

    Thanks for your insight. Think I am going to try to eat 25% of my exercise calories back this month and then if that doesn't work then I am going to unsync my fitbit. I agree it is really frustrating but I've lost 40 lbs before and gained it all back so if it is going to take me twice the amount of time well... I guess I'll just have to live with it! It can be discouraging so I'm just trying to concentrate on how I am feeling physically along with trying to lose the weight. I can actually do real push-ups now, and I don't get as sore as easily and it has helped my riding a whole lot. So one step at a time... as frustrating as it may be LOL
  • RAinWA
    RAinWA Posts: 1,980 Member
    You might check your settings in Fitbit since that does seem like a really large adjustment if you aren't logging your riding or gym time.

    Make both Fitbit & MFP have your age, sex, height and weight correct. I started getting very strange adjustments and realized that Fitbit had switched me to male for some reason. (Or I did it while playing with the settings - it could happen!)
  • cc3833
    cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
    RAinWA wrote: »
    You might check your settings in Fitbit since that does seem like a really large adjustment if you aren't logging your riding or gym time.

    Make both Fitbit & MFP have your age, sex, height and weight correct. I started getting very strange adjustments and realized that Fitbit had switched me to male for some reason. (Or I did it while playing with the settings - it could happen!)

    Okay, thanks. I'm going to check that now! That would make a huge difference!
  • cc3833
    cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
    Okay thanks for the advice on the fitbit! I realized that my weight loss goals were different from MFP and Fitbit. Fitbit was set to 0.5lbs a week and MFP was set to 1lb a week. And so the calorie deficit will be a lot different! Hopefully this will be helpful along with eating less exercise calories back!
  • RAinWA
    RAinWA Posts: 1,980 Member
    cc3833 wrote: »
    Okay thanks for the advice on the fitbit! I realized that my weight loss goals were different from MFP and Fitbit. Fitbit was set to 0.5lbs a week and MFP was set to 1lb a week. And so the calorie deficit will be a lot different! Hopefully this will be helpful along with eating less exercise calories back!

    Great! Let us know how it goes.
  • cc3833
    cc3833 Posts: 80 Member
    Thank you everyone for your advice! Just an update. I did struggle around the holidays and did gain around that time. But I said enough is enough, on Jan 2nd I started again...... And I joined a dietbet (money is a huge motivator for me). I followed all of your guys advice on the exercise calories. I have also noticed how certain foods effect my body so I try to account for that. I really appreciate all the advice and going through the forums which also helps. I started with a personal trainer at the gym to help keep me accountable and they were having a promotion for 3 months of training. I am also married to my food scale. I wish it was socially acceptable to bring it out with me!!!! LOL! So far in Jan I started at 191.6 and as of today I am currently down to 173.2.

    I seriously could not have done this without MFP. Yes dietbet gave me the monetary motivation to lose weight but without MFP it would be useless. I know I started trying back in July 2017. Its been a long journey of not losing weight. But I have learned so much about my body and what works for me. And all the tips and tricks everyone gave me with weighing my food has been a life changer! Thanks everyone!!
This discussion has been closed.

Categories