Is it true it's best to change up calories?
PoppyFlower1
Posts: 62 Member
Someone told me recently that it's best if you change up your calories daily, while maintaining a deficit. For example eating 2000 calories one day, then 500 the next, then 1200 after that. So overall 3700 over 3 days so remaining in deficit but he said this way your body/metabolism doesn't get used to lower calories and it helps you lose weight quicker. Is this true?
8
Replies
-
little to no science that supports this to my knowledge5
-
No, if anything, as little calorie variance as possible from day to day is best - but many people bank calories for the weekend, and that works great, too. Your body or metabolism doesn't get used to anything, it takes what you give it and stores or uses it.11
-
Yes!! If your trying to lose weight and you hit a plateau you need to confuse the body to keep the pounds dropping. I heard some people have cheat days x1 A week just to kinda restart the metabolism.55
-
Why would that help? Just eat less than you burn, and theres nothing extra to store.3
-
But there is no reason to eat 500 caps a day
0 -
*Cals0
-
I calorie cycle in a deficit.. but I do it for adherence and better workout performance.4
-
nope. you can't "confuse" your body lol. your body does the same thing everyday regardless of what you're gonna eat.
eat in a deficit and youll lose weight. look at your calories for a week instead of a day. i "bank" calories during the week to eat/drink more on the weekends and i still lose weight.4 -
You can eat different calorie amounts on different days and average it over the week but dropping down to 500 seems silly. You will only be really hungry that day and possibly overeat so seems to me to be a bit pointless.
Slow, Steady and sustainable wins in the end.
9 -
I like to have a variable goal for adherence, to support my exercise routine and to fit my diet into my lifestyle - but weight loss is down to calorie deficit averaged over an extended period of time.5
-
lizzyleveille wrote: »Yes!! If your trying to lose weight and you hit a plateau you need to confuse the body to keep the pounds dropping. I heard some people have cheat days x1 A week just to kinda restart the metabolism.
Your body does not get confused, and if your metabolism needs restarted then you're no longer living.
The only thing that ends a plateau is lowering your calorie intake, which most of the time happens through more accurate logging.7 -
I have not had any luck with changing up caloric intake like that. This is my third time to go down in weight to 170, and I have tremendous success on calorie counting and being a creature of habit. That's why I love this app. I count, and I do a strict diet, and lose weight. But I love fruits and vegetables. So I'm lucky.5
-
Even when I was severely anorexic, I rarely ate 500 calories a day. That is so little food it's not a good plan (which is why I'm glad to see the 5:2 diet doesn't seem as trendy anymore...)
Consistency is fine! Sometimes there's variation--appetites can cycle a bit, or exercise calories may change intake. Just follow MFP guidelines and you'll be groovy.10 -
staticsplit wrote: »Even when I was severely anorexic, I rarely ate 500 calories a day. That is so little food it's not a good plan (which is why I'm glad to see the 5:2 diet doesn't seem as trendy anymore...)
Consistency is fine! Sometimes there's variation--appetites can cycle a bit, or exercise calories may change intake. Just follow MFP guidelines and you'll be groovy.
Aww congrats on beating anorexia that's amazing x2 -
Other names for it are "calorie shifting" or "calorie cycling". Too complicated for my taste (and not a regime I'd want to do for the rest of my life), and the research results are less than convincing to me:
http://www.berkeleywellness.com/healthy-eating/diet-weight-loss/article/hype-calorie-shifting-diets1 -
You can bank calories for an expected large meal or holiday but changing up daily amounts for any other reason than that seems pointless. Whatever benefit you would gain would be so minimum as not worth the effort. Your metabolic rate isn't like a muscle that benefits from changing and shock.1
-
Yeah, I think your are referencing the 5:2 intermittent fasting. 5 days regular healthy calories, 2 days low 500 calories intake.
I just started this, and am at a healthy weight and fitness level. Just wanted to get beach ready for a trip. Now I understand that Basal Metabolic Rate may not change/ change easily. But here is what my first anecdotal experience:
I have been doing Orange Theory Fitness classes for 4 months and my cardio is decent and my strength was increasing, but I still want to drop into the 19.5 BMI range before our vacation. So I did one day 500 cals, and the next day regular breakfast, and then workout.
I never worked that hard in a workout before. I was barely hitting my cardio rate and weight lifting milestones I would regularly do. But my heart rate and calorie burn rate (which OTF measures) was the highest it had ever been.
So I think my body did respond to this diet. It made my regular fuel less available and my body had to work harder to do the same things.
But it would take a few more sessions to see if this trend continues.
I do like the feeling of really understanding hunger though. A lot of the times I graze at the slightest hint of a feeling towards hunger. Versus a day later, and my body felt the urgent need to eat that it work me up early. So I fed it and it was satisfying!0 -
IMO, the only reason to stagger calories is to accommodate workouts. I get ridiculously hungry on lifting days, so I eat more. I shave extra calories from non-lifting days to stay at goal.2
-
what you are saying sounds like intermittent fasting (to me it sounds like your referencing alternate day fasting) and yes, it works for many people.
0 -
I think it just matters what works better for you mentally. There’s definitely a value in looking at the net calories of the week instead of the day if you find yourself to be more hungry on some days than others. But yeah, for some people I think that’s easier mentally because they have varying appetites or triggers on different days and it just works for their life where as some people, like myself, prefer consistency2
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.7K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.8K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 415 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.6K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions